Ask HN: Are the trades a safe career transition?
I am a software guy. Engineering degree but not PEng. Im thinking of jumping ship because i dont see much of a future in the career. Ai has me a little discouraged
I need a few decades of at least mild security to get to retirement...
Are the trades safe?
Im worried about homeowners and companies ending up with robots that do all those tasks. Not next year obviously, but it could happen before the career change fully pays off
And if not the trades, then what is a better bet?
AI is definitely changing things a lot in the field, but don't discount the massive change in how cheap money was during ZIRP and how expensive it became after ZIRP finally ended. This was coincidentally around the same time the layoffs in big tech started, which was before AI really had any meaningful impact. When money is cheap it is a lot easier for companies to hire, and when money suddenly stops being cheap it is a lot harder.
In particular, large discontinuities in economic conditions, which we just experienced recently post-covid, always produce downturns in affected industries (which is distinct from the first order aspect of how expensive money is). So I think even ignoring AI we could expect several years of down-ness and reorganization followed by a recovery.
I don't think we can even tell this point if AI will reduce demand for developers. The economy for software might be even worse right now if the AI developments hadn't happened when they did, there was an insane hiring spree during COVID and even before that the industry employment-side was growing at a probably unsustainable pace.
Trades are boom bust even more so than software engineering. There is a shortage, people run to the field, but by the time they are trained up (end of apprenticeship) there is probably a bust because there are too many people in them. You need to be prepared to sweat out at least one bust at the beginning of your career, and stay in it so you can reap a boom or two.
It’s definitely an exciting time to be in robotics, though it looks like the Chinese are pushing more aggressively into it thsn western developed nations. AI is also a huge risk to the trades (the joke about the plumber just needing to know hit im a call means those quick calls are at risk because that knowledge is easy to get with a chat bot).
They're making pretty good progress on hands[1,2], I don't have a good sense of how quickly these things will become cheap enough to become ubiquitous, I'd imagine > 5 years but < 10 years. One Policy and Zero Prior Learning are making very good progress[3,4,5].
Plummer is probably the safest of the trades if I had to guess. That said, I'd encourage you to think more about other things humans are likely to always want/need - see if any of the other options are interesting to you? For example, lots of people are and will continue to be lonely, having a bar to sit at with someone friendly/interesting is a tool we use for this (I wrote a blog post about this idea: https://b.h4x.zip/finale/) - but there are also things like undertakers, kids activities centers/camp councilor, etc. Not all of these things will be equally financially rewarding, but you're able to think about rewarding in other ways. :)
[1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4whgw2gLBS8
[2]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C5MsqzQW8X4
[3]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhK28R9J-DQ
[4]https://nico-bohlinger.github.io/one_policy_to_run_them_all_...
[5]https://www.pi.website/blog/api-beta
They're nowhere near close with those blocky, slow, and confused hands. The ChatGPT moment for robotics will occur when you see a robot with the hand dexterity of a 6 year old.
Trades are very cyclical and offer little in the way of a safety net. You'll have fat and lean years. The lean years will wipe you out unless you're a phenomenal saver and can keep your lifestyle monk like during the fat years.
You will probably be safe from the sort of automation around the corner as the boom is largely contained in the virtual world. There is no such thing as job security in a dynamic economy like ours. The ones who are the most successful are the ones who can stick and move and are unsentimental about what work they are doing.
In our world of hammers, the nail gun was invented and we can now simply build faster. If your plan was to keep typing code yourself, its definitly coming to an end, but your skills can be transformed to take advantage of those new tools and accomplish so much more than you could before.
Not sure if this applies to many others, at least for me I started using llm a lot for thing that you would normally call a handyman. Obviously this doesn't apply to places where you need a license but I expect automation there to increase a lot.
Check the trades subreddits (hvac, plumbing, electric) - lots of people not being able to find jobs or get into apprenticeships. Words like "oversaturated". My feeling is that we're 5-10 years too late but it might vary by region.
I guess safe is a relative term.
I've met a lot more 9 fingered mechanics than software developers.
>jumping ship
that sure seems unwise to throw away a position in a time of pre-supposed insecurity.
The only careers where you can have certainty about what will happen to your job after the robots are better than you are chess grandmaster and marathon runner.
That's it! I just need to become a chess grandmaster now, whew. Wish me luck!
I'd wait a bit before jumping ships, the future is always different from what people think it will be. If you are really worried, you can get some training in a different job right now and keep it as a plan B.
I'm starting a new business called handjobs for billionaires. Gotta get with the K-shaped economy. We all just create luxury products for the ruling class now. Bend the knee or be left behind.