Ask HN: Do you agree with Jeremie Harris's prepper guidance?
I’ve been a listener to the Last Week in AI podcast for years, and come to trust and respect Jeremie and Andrey’s judgment and takes. Jeremie started a new newsletter at AIEndGame.com, and the most recent post is a long prepper article based on his belief that a large scale AI-related attack is very possible. He is much more knowledgeable than I am, and has far more contacts in the AI space at labs and in government, and I’m inclined to trust his take. And the last 6 months of AI developments (HuggingFace hack, various outages in the last two weeks, AI solving Millenium Prize math problems, etc.) have me a bit nervous. On a similar note, the Dwarkesh podcast had a guest this past week that was adamant that we will have AIs in the next 12 months capable of overthrowing governments— which feels hyperbolic, but still.
All to say: is this doomed stuff overwrought and safe to ignore? Or is following this prepper advice a good idea?
What is his actual guidance? Can you summarize it?
Can't say I agree or not if I don't know what it is...
Here’s the post [1]. It’s basically a long list of things to do (e.g., separate email addresses for bank accounts, Yubikeys, having a computer that has never been connected to the web; having significant water and food rations; a generator and comms; etc.).
Some of it is reasonable, some of it seems extreme.
I guess what I’m really wondering is: is his level of concern reasonable?
[1] https://aiendgame.com/p/personal-resilience-for-the-ai-age
> is his level of concern reasonable?
You answered it in your previous sentence ("extreme").
He is falling in the trap of overestimating the short-term and underestimating the long-term. I do not think any of the list of things he recommends are likely to have a meaningful effect for the AI age (which is a long-term concept), even if it might lighten some short-term bumps.
I mean, how much water and food rations does he think you should store? If you are 25yo, should you buy and store 50 years' worth?