Conscious being is not about ability to enjoy music. Joy can exist in Ai world that is different from biological beings; we won't know what they will experience as joy till we get there. I say that Ai can eventually appreciate success or achievement or experience failure at minimum. Not every entity that is conscious is human or has human senses or sensuality.
Humans have become more conscious over period of 1000s of year via record keeping be it through oral, written or recorded history and that includes music. No recorded history = no music. In my opinion humans were not extra ordinarily conscious from the onset. They developed consciousness though language, oral, written and recorded history and knowledge.
There is no basis to think that biological brains are the only substrate that can host conscious minds. It's also important to actually define what people mean when they talk about consciousness since there's no accepted definition that everyone agrees on.
Personally, I'm a fan of the higher-order theories of consciousness which postulate that a mental state becomes conscious when a higher-order mental state , such as a thought or perception, represents a lower-order state. Effectively, it's the mind creating a model of itself and observing patterns which arise within itself along with the patterns that are triggered by the sensory inputs.
Given that definition, it's pretty clear that it would be possible to model an artificial neural network that would exhibit such properties. In fact, it is almost certain that even LLMs create higher level abstractions within the network as a form of compression as the data moves to higher layers of the network.
Conscious being is not about ability to enjoy music. Joy can exist in Ai world that is different from biological beings; we won't know what they will experience as joy till we get there. I say that Ai can eventually appreciate success or achievement or experience failure at minimum. Not every entity that is conscious is human or has human senses or sensuality.
Humans have become more conscious over period of 1000s of year via record keeping be it through oral, written or recorded history and that includes music. No recorded history = no music. In my opinion humans were not extra ordinarily conscious from the onset. They developed consciousness though language, oral, written and recorded history and knowledge.
> A COMPUTER CANNOT BE HORNY OR SAD
> THEREFORE A COMPUTER MUST NEVER MAKE AN ARTISTIC DECISION
There is no basis to think that biological brains are the only substrate that can host conscious minds. It's also important to actually define what people mean when they talk about consciousness since there's no accepted definition that everyone agrees on.
Personally, I'm a fan of the higher-order theories of consciousness which postulate that a mental state becomes conscious when a higher-order mental state , such as a thought or perception, represents a lower-order state. Effectively, it's the mind creating a model of itself and observing patterns which arise within itself along with the patterns that are triggered by the sensory inputs.
Given that definition, it's pretty clear that it would be possible to model an artificial neural network that would exhibit such properties. In fact, it is almost certain that even LLMs create higher level abstractions within the network as a form of compression as the data moves to higher layers of the network.