And of course the Trump 1 COVID lockdown which cut emissions dramatically. (I support the lockdowns, there was no other option with the information at the time.)
In that sense it isn't clear that Trump is greener than Putin, who has also significantly reduced the population carbon footprint in Russia and Ukraine, and taken actions that resulted in a ~30% reduction in Russian oil refinery capacity.
It almost seems that incompetent rulers with their crappy chaotic actions force others into exact opposite compared to what they want. poo tin forcing Sweden and Finland into Nato, orange man making sure China will be #1 country in many ways in near future and starting the end of oil-for-fuel cycle that helped create US global hegemony in the past.
Oil has really special place, nobody ain't talking about some copperdollars. Time for a slow and steady change.
Well, he did it in a way that makes nuclear proliferation in an already volatile region more likely.
30 or 50 years from now, oil prices may be way less important than today and most of the current fuel use may be long electrified, but Turkey, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, UAE and Azerbaijan could still be pointing hundreds of nuclear warheads at one another.
People like to portray it as a problem of big greedy petroleum companies. In reality the heart of the issue is that we're all addicted to cheap fossil fuels for food, housing, transport. Without them we currently couldn't support our global population levels and we'd have mass famine.
Replacing them is hard and expensive. Easy for us wealthy westerners for whom expensive gas is an annoyance more than anything.
It's a dependency, but not an addiction. We would gladly switch to other energy sources with similar cost for obtaining and less environmental impact. Giving up the dependency on energy is not a realistic option.
Exactly. Trump will go down in history as the greatest president for renewable energy. More than AOC. By waging the wars he has made fossil fuels more expensive. This 5.7D chess is what we needed to finally get off the cheap combustibles!
Let me get this right: the country has become morally and financially bankrupt in order to get us off fossil fuels? That the wars were started explicitly to raise fuel prices?
> Actually recent events has made cheap oil and gas a thing of the past.
It's still incredibly cheap for what it allows us to do, we just got used to having it cheaper for a bit. Once it's gone there will be nothing remotely close in term of price/convenience/utility
Food is mostly a solved issue, we just waste way too much of it, to the trash and for meat production
Recent events were only recent, and we'll (perhaps unfortunately) return to cheap fossil fuels shortly.
For one, natural gas is still cheap, and never went down. And natural gas is pretty bad for the climate.
For two, while I don't know what's going on in the US, petrol at the pump has already dropped back to its pre-Iran prices here in Canada since the midterms. Per barrel costs are also dropping slowly.
Diesel prices are still stupid though.
The unpredictable nature of petroleum prices are really a huge problem for the economies that depend on them. And the temptation to juice their prices for profit (which is what really happend with the Iran conflict) too great.
plenty of coal in the ground in Europe and good part of power mix, and the EU climate legislation massively increases price of power thanks to that.
We're in situation where we have expensive power (and I will remind that expensive power = expensive industry) to "save" on CO2 by sacrificing our own industrial competitiveness while paying for products from China that DGAF about that and despise building renewables chose to not sacrifice their industry on pedestal of ecology.
> If gas in the US was 10$ a gallon you’d see a lot of folks figuring out alternatives. Public transportation, cycling, and of course EVs.
How about reasonably sized cars with a decent fuel consumption for a start? I have a Volkswagen Up! which is great for inner city traffic and would probably fit into the glove box of a standard US sized SUV.
Sad because collectively none of us benefit from this. High gas prices, polluted air, geopolitical risk, wars, and increased risk of floods and devastating fires. Plus, it doesn't even scale. We cannot scale AI without cheap energy and fossil fuels will never be as cheap as we need them to be.
In that context these climate talks are irrelevant. If a country wants to have cheap energy, and thinks clean energy can deliver, then whatever the UN decides is not relevant to its strategy. It’s not like you have to ask the gulf states for permission to deploy nuclear or solar.
One might point out WHO invited Gazprom in, in Germany. Who built NordStream? You don't build something like that without long term government guarantees. Who gave those guarantees?
It was SPD (socialists) and the Greens, who did it. Putin even hired their leaders
I think the CDU deserves getting added to the list (although it was a condition of the SPD to form a government so, I'd say 60% SPD 30% Greens 10% CDU).
This decision was a choice, an unforced error, they had other options. And by my estimate this choice is now costing every European about 3000 euros per year, or over 6000 if you include the Ukraine war.
Strangely we keep hearing from the SPD and the Greens about restitution being owed by industry for mistake they made, everything from famous pharma mistakes (that medicine was also approved by an SPD-led government department, in fact it was arguably caused by them, btw) to climate warming ... yet I've never seen any offers by these parties when it comes to restitution for the mistakes they made.
What I've seen a lot of the growth in "AI datacentre" creation is actually full-on fossil-fuel industry projects proposed around somewhat stranded natural gas assets (in placed like northern Alberta, etc) ; burning natural gas at point of extraction. It's not necessarily meeting actual AI demand, but instead turning purported AI demand into a way to prop up what should be a declining industry.
Kevin O'Leary in particular has his hands all over this shit.
Even if we all suspended disbelief and somehow came to a unanimous agreement on climate science, solar prices, and how we should wean ourselves off oil, the negotiators would still have a fight on their hands.
You still have some remaining oil business. Who does it go to? Whoever can pump it the cheapest? Whoever has the fewest alternatives for export income? Who’s the most dependable to produce during a war? Each one of these puts a different country out of a ton of jobs.
These rounds of speeches mean nothing. Ask the participants for two numbers: 1. How much oil do you expect the world to buy? 2. How much oil do you expect to sell? I’d learn more from adding up the second column than 20 rounds of hot air.
Anywho, I think market forces will take care of this even if governments want to drag their feet. As the price of clean energy drops (and rival countries like China gain might by continuing to fully invest), everyone else will have no choice but to follow.
At this point fossil fuels are economically uncompetitive with solar energy except in fairly polar climates. I just did the math with respect to simple-cycle gas turbines in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50599997 an hour ago.
Yes, transport in particular (and especially, as inglor_cz points out, jets) will be the last part of the energy ecosystem to switch over. But cargo ships are about 3% of world marketed energy consumption, so they don't matter very much.
I don't think we can replace big jets by electric flight quite yet.
Smaller commuter planes that can take a dozen or two of people on a 150 mile trip yes, but not the huge Boeings and Airbuses that can cross entire continents and oceans.
As of now, yes, but if fossil fuels are replaced by electricity on large scale, it will make sense for the oil states to lobby for more flying, in order to grow at least one part of the market. Like "hey, Vietnam, why build a high-speed rail through the jungle if you can fly the same distance in half the time".
So it is possible that consumption of fossil fuels by aviation will rise. I'd expect the oil producers not to give up their business easily.
They can't drop their prices unless they shut down the most expensive oil wells. Even though that would reduce the cost, I'm not confident that it would result in a dramatic increase in aviation, which is largely limited by the number of airplanes.
Depends on the terrain. Where high mountains or sea is in the way, the costs of bridging/tunneling through them might be prohibitive.
I don't think I will ever see a competitive train connection between, say, Krakow and Budapest. The Slovak terrain in between is just unforgiving, and the lowland route around it through Ostrava too long.
Also the NIMBY problem. England would be perfect for high-speed rail, but local NIMBYs weaponized environmental legislation to the degree that a super-expensive structure must be built to protect bats that may not even live in that location. [1] Add several things like that and the project is no longer feasible.
Can you price in the transition costs too? And then show us a transitioning timeline for the next decades? That would be cool.
Or maybe someone actually knowledgeable and who actually works in the relevant industries (e.g. electric power infrastructure construction) can give us some estimates regarding scale -> timeline.
I've done back-of-the-envelope estimates of that kind of thing, but I'm not confident that I know enough for them to be good first-order approximations. I'm more confident about the kinds of costs I'm talking about in the linked comment.
when you ignore energy density then it can appear that way similar to when you just create equations while ignoring reality that would greatly weaken your arrival
There are no political solutions. There never were, because nations that "cheat" and take advantage of cheap fossil fuels gain Geopolitical power in turn (See: Russia). Paris 2016 was a joke and the succeeding decade has proven that.
There are only technical solutions. Let's ignite a fusion reactor. Find a way to get grid-scale storage working (stacking up current-gen batteries won't). Drive enough innovation in Fission that it can be safe and cheap. Maybe harness the tides idk
Human nature being what it is, we will not simply walk backwards away from the Energy Sources we can harness. The only way is forwards, into a cleaner and more sustainable way to get more of it.
I think future generations will look back and think it insane that we coupled our entire economy to a substance run by a cartel that is so price-volatile that the price has to be listed on electronic billboards outside gas stations. That one country can start a war across the other side of the world and prices go up for everyone worldwide. And that we chose a fuel that the West has very little of and is controlled by countries mostly hostile to us.
We had warnings in the 70s and still chose to go all-in on oil. We’re now at a point where the technology exists to displace oil but oil is so entrenched in our culture and politics that it’s difficult. I hope that simple ROI will eventually win where political action has failed, but we should have done all of that a few decades ago.
These are the people that represent the rest of us on the world stage.
If they cannot compromise on something that seems to be central to the survival of our species (and possibly all the others), what chance do the rest of us have?
- Being green from a political posture never brought jobs to the table. Actually investing in energy, recycling and making people do things works, when the politicians jobs are to launder money than invest in real people, who'd listen?
- Many people have actually cheap access to oil and can trade in whatever currencies they want, so they have an option to quickly produce and consume their own oil, leaving all these old energy companies in the dust. Whenever someone blocks it, they are likely to be lobbyists of these old energy companies.
With China's solar boost, this sort of nonsense is going to not shock the world any longer and the people dependent on this gas sector are going to feel the impact of it sooner than later. Wisdom would dictate throwing out these lobbies and investing in local production and consumption of energy. Who's going to do the sane thing though? Not a science issue here, clearly.
The COP 21 conference in 2016 did have credibility. However, Trump walked away from the deal and cancelled US involvement in 2017. Biden rejoined in 2021. Trump then cancelled involvement again in 2025.
The US involvement needs to be codified by the newly enacted Congress in 2027. This will help prevent future inconsistencies. Given the likelihood there will be others like the US current president, who value self interest in preserving the status quo over the long term best interest of constituents and the continuity of human existence.
If congress is smart, every bill for the next 2 years they pass will be the "Donald Trump X act". For example "The Donald Trump clean air act".
Trump is not an ideologue and he is vain enough to sign bills simply because they have his name on them. Democrats can also praise him for being such a smart boy for signing it into law.
It might work for some things, but not a climate change treaty. That requires a dozen Republican votes to pass, and even putting his name on it won't cause them to do a complete 180 on the climate. Especially a treaty, since that will be seen as a violation of sovereignty.
But only 4 republican flips are needed for legislation to get through. They could still send in climate change legislation which complies with but doesn't lock in a treaty.
It's also possible for dems to do a filibuster carve-out. They don't need to fully eliminate it, just in the cases where legislation aligns with their agenda and Trump seems on board (and Trump's influence isn't enough to flip 4 republicans).
There's also budget reconciliation which they can ram through climate change spending. Republicans have already paved the way to do that by just overruling when the parliamentarian says "that doesn't count".
The entire reason Democrats swept the elections is because Republicans caused high fossil fuel prices. Any effective bill to reduce fossil fuel consumption in a a relevant timeframe will need to cause fossil fuel prices to go much higher, which will again cause Americans to vote for the other party.
People do not want to slow climate change, they want their houses in the suburbs, their big cars, their electronics, their out-of-season foods, and their cheap flights.
> Any effective bill to reduce fossil fuel consumption in a a relevant timeframe will need to cause fossil fuel prices to go much higher
Arguably if the bill is effective then it will end up doing the opposite and end up causing fossil fuel prices to tumble (because fewer entities are consuming them).
It's also possible to use the revenue from taxes/fines to help fund social programs which decrease the costs. Even something as simple as a fossil fuel rebate check would go a long way towards buying good will.
For examples of what could be done which would reduce fossil fuel consumption without negatively impacting (most) people. Public transport funds for states. Building out amtrak and high speed rail (dedicated lines rather than shared lines). Heavy heavy taxes on private jets... or better yet simply outlaw them all together, everyone that flies should do it commercially.
> they want their houses in the suburbs
The majority of people want affordable housing. That means cheap apartments ideally within walking distance of their work.
> their big cars
There's not much of an option in the american market, cheaper sedans have a place but fewer manufacturers are offering them. Making big cars more expensive and sedans/minivans/station wagons cheaper would shift market preferences. As of now, those vehicles are practically specialty vehicles and aren't significantly discounted over a monster truck or SUV.
> their electronics
Consumer electronics are not a major driver of climate change. Heating and cooling and transport still dominate in terms of what the average american is emitting.
> their out-of-season foods
This one might seem pretty surprising, but that's not actually a climate change driver. In terms of emissions, shipping by water (which is how most people get those out-of-season foods) emits relatively little CO2 for the amount of goods moved. The bigger issue is the semi-trucks moving the banana instead of the boat moving the banana. Boats are more efficient than trains and trains are freakishly efficient.
> and their cheap flights.
As I mentioned above, eliminating private jet flights would go a LONG way in cutting down flight emissions. Commercial flights are about twice as bad as a car driving the same distance. The way you make less people fly is by making trains better and cheaper. As of right now, trains are MUCH slower than even driving and as expensive or more expensive than flying. In the US they are also plagued with delay because they share lines with private shipping companies.
I don’t see why promoting solar & sustainability has to make fossil fuels worse. Solar is already cheaper, and we need more incentives to make electric everything else cheaper than gas. We don’t necessarily need to disincentivize automobile gas and diesel though. We need to make the other options more compelling.
Even the senate voting to enter a treaty might not be of much help, as there's precedent for the president to withdraw from treaties without congressional approval.
The senate can codify fossil fuel reductions and transitions to renewable energy. They can also renew incentives that drive renewable energy innovations.
They do have a defense: impeachment and conviction. The Republican senators are just cowards who think that groveling to Trump is the only option they really have.
But consider these people literally said Trump would be a disaster for the country — like JD Vance and Lindsey Graham. Given their clear compromise of personal values for personal gain, I have to wonder if their self-flagellating decision to support a felonious president actually makes them happy.
Like, they presumably support Trump because betraying him would mean the end of their political career. And I guess having that power makes them happy? But they bend over backwards to be yes-men and to betray their own beliefs, just for Trump to rake them over the coal anyways. So it can’t be about happiness; I have to imagine this is a distressing situation to be in.
So why not grow a pair and convict? Seems like it’d be happier for everyone. If fear of losing an election is all it takes to self-compromise to this degree, they must be cowards.
Congress has most powers, it's just that it delegates that to the presidency.
The reasons for this are a bit complicated, and it didn't used to be that way, but starting with the Great Depression, lawmakers saw it was easier to accomplish their goals by passing the buck to the president.
The idea is that lawmakers had to do a lot of horsetrading to get bills passed some states got disadvantaged so their congressmen got voted out. If, instead, you authorize the president to do this and that, then it's the president's fault and he will be out in 8 years maximum while congress men get re-elected indefinitely until they die in office.
This is why Congress has an abysmal approval rating, but not individual congressmen. Constituents consistently re-elect "their" congressman while hating congress as a whole.
The biggest issue here I'd say is lack of term limits. If they had a 8 year term limit they wouldn't enable the president so much.
We’re talking here about an agreement that nobody other than the head executive ratified. As an opponent of what US political theorists call the “imperial presidency”, I think the correct story is that the United States never validly joined the Paris Agreement in the first place because the Senate did not consent to do so.
> Even the senate voting to enter a treaty might not be of much help, as there's precedent for the president to withdraw from treaties without congressional approval.
There's some complication here that's often elided. Per the US Constitution, all treaties have to be ratified by the Senate, and it's generally held that such treaties have to be abrogated by act of Congress (SCOTUS has never actually heard a case, since treaty abrogation is generally something they dodge as nonjusticiable in the first place).
However, a lot of "treaties" these days signed by the US are actually "executive agreements," which bypass the need for ⅔ majority vote in the Senate. Since they're made under the (potentially delegated) authority of the executive alone, they're able to be abrogated by that same authority of the executive alone.
I guess it only needs enough credibility to keep the frog in the water.
Change is uncomfortable and the frog so desperately wants to believe that someone else is handling the water temperature issue or at least that it will happen too slowly for it to personally be impacted.
At the end of the day, the frog needs a reason to take the easy way out; a cop out. I doubt that these summits being named COP is really a coincidence.
Governments aren't dragging their feet. Governments simply don't work for the people. The ruling class has figured out that people are best controlled via proxy and controlled opposition.
It's a silly urban legend. Frogs absolutely jump out of water when it gets uncomfortable. Unfortunately, humans as a civilization aren't as smart as frogs.
Also, with climate change "when it gets uncomfortable" is way way too late. We're definitely not smart enough to have jumped out when it was still possible to reverse the course towards future discomfort.
We can sense from what's happening that this 'I am smart (by implication) and can see impending disaster while you don't because you're not smart' does not go down well with some rather distinguished academics intimately acquainted with the data. Since you and many others believe this is an existential crisis (and those other folk simply do not accept it as such) why not organize a truly independently hosted public forum with a massive PR buildup where the arguments can really see the light and people on your side can show everyone just how wrong the demurring folk are? But it has to be independently-hosted to have any traction with folk who say "OK show me the arguments".
"Jump" in this analogy means to stop emitting greenhouse gasses, an action that only works when coordinated throughout the species and is useless for the individual when carried out individually. Frogs can't do anything like that at all.
If by personally ceasing to emit one could obtain a personal bubble of comfortable climate, everybody would do it and the problem would be solved.
At this point, we know it is really over and we are probably on the way to maybe +5C. I thought I read somewhere in reality scientists are hoping we can keep it below +3.5C, but they are very worried, who listens to them anyway :(
In the US, both political parties have been trying for years to keep gas and diesel fuel prices low. They know they will loose their cushy jobs if fossil fuel prices reach a certain level. A good example of this is the US midterms, the GOP got hammered due to fossil fuel prices.
Yes you can argue it was Trump and other reasons, but I have been around for while and gas prices in the US is the # 1 reason for political change and has been since the 70s.
What should happen ? Fossil Fuel prices need to raise a lot to force a very quick move to alternate sources. Otherwise, off to +5C we go. Yes people will suffer, but suffering, even at +3.5C will be far worse than high fuel prices. Instead we keep prices low by oil subsidies and other incentives.
> both political parties have been trying for years to keep gas and diesel fuel prices low
There's no real alternative for a political party. If you push through green energy that ends up increasing the cost of living, your party will inevitably lose power. So instead you get performative green energy, which is just politicians bragging about how great their renewable program is going, while it does next to nothing. I've seen 30 years of this.
I think you just continue to burn oil and coal while heavily incentivizing alternatives, kind of like China's been doing. Without a planned economy though, the vested interests and political power in dirty energy are a pretty huge obstacle.
This is not true, we are not on our way to over +5C , we are slightly below the emissions of the track of IPCC6 scenario SSP2-4.5 , which predicts warming from 2.1 to 3.5 C .
Daily reminder that earth is 70% oceans and that these don't warm anywhere close to as fast as land. +3c globally will be a death sentence for a lot of places.
Does anyone actually believe that these talks will achieve anything concrete? As another commenter has mentioned, only the cost of fossil fuels has any teeth in influencing our behavior. The other factor that will help is the declining birthrate world wide which reduces consumption.
Of course, it’s not all rainbows and butterflies. Higher energy costs results in higher costs in nearly everything including food, heating & cooling costs. Collapsing birthrates mean collapsing economic systems since both socialism and capitalism rely on constantly growing populations.
Actually recent events has made cheap oil and gas a thing of the past.
This is the only thing that will stop people from emitting as much CO2 as they want.
If gas in the US was 10$ a gallon you’d see a lot of folks figuring out alternatives. Public transportation, cycling, and of course EVs.
However, this could also lead to famines in lower income countries. The cost of food production surging isn’t a good thing.
Best thing POTUS did for the world is raise fuel prices. In a very empirical sense he is the most green POTUS, maybe ever.
Love the take. Actions speak louder than words.
And yet they didn't give him the peace Nobel price, corrupt as they are. :)
And of course the Trump 1 COVID lockdown which cut emissions dramatically. (I support the lockdowns, there was no other option with the information at the time.)
He makes a hell of a good case for renewables. Cost, energy independence, national security...
In that sense it isn't clear that Trump is greener than Putin, who has also significantly reduced the population carbon footprint in Russia and Ukraine, and taken actions that resulted in a ~30% reduction in Russian oil refinery capacity.
It almost seems that incompetent rulers with their crappy chaotic actions force others into exact opposite compared to what they want. poo tin forcing Sweden and Finland into Nato, orange man making sure China will be #1 country in many ways in near future and starting the end of oil-for-fuel cycle that helped create US global hegemony in the past.
Oil has really special place, nobody ain't talking about some copperdollars. Time for a slow and steady change.
Getting off oil is not the same as going clean. Australia has plenty of coal they could use instead.
Well, he did it in a way that makes nuclear proliferation in an already volatile region more likely.
30 or 50 years from now, oil prices may be way less important than today and most of the current fuel use may be long electrified, but Turkey, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, UAE and Azerbaijan could still be pointing hundreds of nuclear warheads at one another.
No, it's in fact only led to expansion of the sector.
New pipelines, new extraction, new shipping routes, etc.
Yes in some countries it led to a burst in EV purchases, but not everywhere.
After paying to not have several wind farms completed, of course.
Glad you acknowledged the food production costs.
People like to portray it as a problem of big greedy petroleum companies. In reality the heart of the issue is that we're all addicted to cheap fossil fuels for food, housing, transport. Without them we currently couldn't support our global population levels and we'd have mass famine.
Replacing them is hard and expensive. Easy for us wealthy westerners for whom expensive gas is an annoyance more than anything.
Yes, but its also important when people say that to reiterate that we don't have a choice to phase it out, and that it's dire and urgent.
If it's that urgent and dire then actual war is going to be necessary to stop extraction and consumption.
It's a dependency, but not an addiction. We would gladly switch to other energy sources with similar cost for obtaining and less environmental impact. Giving up the dependency on energy is not a realistic option.
Okay great so then let's make fossil fuels even cheaper by building out sustainable alternative energy infrastructure.
Not a good thing, but at this point probably necessary.
Exactly. Trump will go down in history as the greatest president for renewable energy. More than AOC. By waging the wars he has made fossil fuels more expensive. This 5.7D chess is what we needed to finally get off the cheap combustibles!
Let me get this right: the country has become morally and financially bankrupt in order to get us off fossil fuels? That the wars were started explicitly to raise fuel prices?
That an impressive line of facetious reasoning.
> Actually recent events has made cheap oil and gas a thing of the past.
It's still incredibly cheap for what it allows us to do, we just got used to having it cheaper for a bit. Once it's gone there will be nothing remotely close in term of price/convenience/utility
Food is mostly a solved issue, we just waste way too much of it, to the trash and for meat production
Recent events were only recent, and we'll (perhaps unfortunately) return to cheap fossil fuels shortly.
For one, natural gas is still cheap, and never went down. And natural gas is pretty bad for the climate.
For two, while I don't know what's going on in the US, petrol at the pump has already dropped back to its pre-Iran prices here in Canada since the midterms. Per barrel costs are also dropping slowly.
Diesel prices are still stupid though.
The unpredictable nature of petroleum prices are really a huge problem for the economies that depend on them. And the temptation to juice their prices for profit (which is what really happend with the Iran conflict) too great.
It being unpredictable means you might not want to hop onto a 7 year car loan.
You might reconsider buying a car at all depending on your other options.
plenty of coal in the ground in Europe and good part of power mix, and the EU climate legislation massively increases price of power thanks to that.
We're in situation where we have expensive power (and I will remind that expensive power = expensive industry) to "save" on CO2 by sacrificing our own industrial competitiveness while paying for products from China that DGAF about that and despise building renewables chose to not sacrifice their industry on pedestal of ecology.
> If gas in the US was 10$ a gallon you’d see a lot of folks figuring out alternatives. Public transportation, cycling, and of course EVs.
How about reasonably sized cars with a decent fuel consumption for a start? I have a Volkswagen Up! which is great for inner city traffic and would probably fit into the glove box of a standard US sized SUV.
Sad because collectively none of us benefit from this. High gas prices, polluted air, geopolitical risk, wars, and increased risk of floods and devastating fires. Plus, it doesn't even scale. We cannot scale AI without cheap energy and fossil fuels will never be as cheap as we need them to be.
I'm quite sure that there's a significant number of trust fund kids in this forum who directly benefit from it.
In that context these climate talks are irrelevant. If a country wants to have cheap energy, and thinks clean energy can deliver, then whatever the UN decides is not relevant to its strategy. It’s not like you have to ask the gulf states for permission to deploy nuclear or solar.
oooh you have. heard about people lobbying for oil industry? you can even get "democratised" if your agenda is out of line too much.
example german anti nuclear movement with ears of gasprom sticking out in the background
Voting for the greens is never going to lead to any sensible policies. That’s more of a self-inflicted wound.
One might point out WHO invited Gazprom in, in Germany. Who built NordStream? You don't build something like that without long term government guarantees. Who gave those guarantees?
It was SPD (socialists) and the Greens, who did it. Putin even hired their leaders
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerhard_Schr%C3%B6der
I think the CDU deserves getting added to the list (although it was a condition of the SPD to form a government so, I'd say 60% SPD 30% Greens 10% CDU).
This decision was a choice, an unforced error, they had other options. And by my estimate this choice is now costing every European about 3000 euros per year, or over 6000 if you include the Ukraine war.
Strangely we keep hearing from the SPD and the Greens about restitution being owed by industry for mistake they made, everything from famous pharma mistakes (that medicine was also approved by an SPD-led government department, in fact it was arguably caused by them, btw) to climate warming ... yet I've never seen any offers by these parties when it comes to restitution for the mistakes they made.
What I've seen a lot of the growth in "AI datacentre" creation is actually full-on fossil-fuel industry projects proposed around somewhat stranded natural gas assets (in placed like northern Alberta, etc) ; burning natural gas at point of extraction. It's not necessarily meeting actual AI demand, but instead turning purported AI demand into a way to prop up what should be a declining industry.
Kevin O'Leary in particular has his hands all over this shit.
Even if we all suspended disbelief and somehow came to a unanimous agreement on climate science, solar prices, and how we should wean ourselves off oil, the negotiators would still have a fight on their hands.
You still have some remaining oil business. Who does it go to? Whoever can pump it the cheapest? Whoever has the fewest alternatives for export income? Who’s the most dependable to produce during a war? Each one of these puts a different country out of a ton of jobs.
These rounds of speeches mean nothing. Ask the participants for two numbers: 1. How much oil do you expect the world to buy? 2. How much oil do you expect to sell? I’d learn more from adding up the second column than 20 rounds of hot air.
Gift link: https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/climate/cop31-climate-sum...
Anywho, I think market forces will take care of this even if governments want to drag their feet. As the price of clean energy drops (and rival countries like China gain might by continuing to fully invest), everyone else will have no choice but to follow.
At this point fossil fuels are economically uncompetitive with solar energy except in fairly polar climates. I just did the math with respect to simple-cycle gas turbines in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50599997 an hour ago.
I think that's certainly true for energy, but even so a lot of cases like cargo ships are slow to catch up and still very fossil fuel heavy.
Yes, transport in particular (and especially, as inglor_cz points out, jets) will be the last part of the energy ecosystem to switch over. But cargo ships are about 3% of world marketed energy consumption, so they don't matter very much.
Also half of cargo ships would disappear if we weren’t shipping fossil fuels around the globe.
I don't think we can replace big jets by electric flight quite yet.
Smaller commuter planes that can take a dozen or two of people on a 150 mile trip yes, but not the huge Boeings and Airbuses that can cross entire continents and oceans.
Thats ok, aviation accounts for roughly 5-8% of global oil consumption, and 13% goes towards non-energy use. Global shipping uses roughly 4-5%.
Most of the petroleum is used for things where electricity is a perfectly reasonable substitute, if we can produce and store it cheaply.
As of now, yes, but if fossil fuels are replaced by electricity on large scale, it will make sense for the oil states to lobby for more flying, in order to grow at least one part of the market. Like "hey, Vietnam, why build a high-speed rail through the jungle if you can fly the same distance in half the time".
So it is possible that consumption of fossil fuels by aviation will rise. I'd expect the oil producers not to give up their business easily.
They can't drop their prices unless they shut down the most expensive oil wells. Even though that would reduce the cost, I'm not confident that it would result in a dramatic increase in aviation, which is largely limited by the number of airplanes.
We can build more electrified trains.
Depends on the terrain. Where high mountains or sea is in the way, the costs of bridging/tunneling through them might be prohibitive.
I don't think I will ever see a competitive train connection between, say, Krakow and Budapest. The Slovak terrain in between is just unforgiving, and the lowland route around it through Ostrava too long.
Also the NIMBY problem. England would be perfect for high-speed rail, but local NIMBYs weaponized environmental legislation to the degree that a super-expensive structure must be built to protect bats that may not even live in that location. [1] Add several things like that and the project is no longer feasible.
[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c9wryxyljglo
Can you price in the transition costs too? And then show us a transitioning timeline for the next decades? That would be cool.
Or maybe someone actually knowledgeable and who actually works in the relevant industries (e.g. electric power infrastructure construction) can give us some estimates regarding scale -> timeline.
I've done back-of-the-envelope estimates of that kind of thing, but I'm not confident that I know enough for them to be good first-order approximations. I'm more confident about the kinds of costs I'm talking about in the linked comment.
when you ignore energy density then it can appear that way similar to when you just create equations while ignoring reality that would greatly weaken your arrival
There are no political solutions. There never were, because nations that "cheat" and take advantage of cheap fossil fuels gain Geopolitical power in turn (See: Russia). Paris 2016 was a joke and the succeeding decade has proven that.
There are only technical solutions. Let's ignite a fusion reactor. Find a way to get grid-scale storage working (stacking up current-gen batteries won't). Drive enough innovation in Fission that it can be safe and cheap. Maybe harness the tides idk
Human nature being what it is, we will not simply walk backwards away from the Energy Sources we can harness. The only way is forwards, into a cleaner and more sustainable way to get more of it.
I think future generations will look back and think it insane that we coupled our entire economy to a substance run by a cartel that is so price-volatile that the price has to be listed on electronic billboards outside gas stations. That one country can start a war across the other side of the world and prices go up for everyone worldwide. And that we chose a fuel that the West has very little of and is controlled by countries mostly hostile to us.
We had warnings in the 70s and still chose to go all-in on oil. We’re now at a point where the technology exists to displace oil but oil is so entrenched in our culture and politics that it’s difficult. I hope that simple ROI will eventually win where political action has failed, but we should have done all of that a few decades ago.
These are the people that represent the rest of us on the world stage.
If they cannot compromise on something that seems to be central to the survival of our species (and possibly all the others), what chance do the rest of us have?
There are two aspects to these things:
- Being green from a political posture never brought jobs to the table. Actually investing in energy, recycling and making people do things works, when the politicians jobs are to launder money than invest in real people, who'd listen?
- Many people have actually cheap access to oil and can trade in whatever currencies they want, so they have an option to quickly produce and consume their own oil, leaving all these old energy companies in the dust. Whenever someone blocks it, they are likely to be lobbyists of these old energy companies.
With China's solar boost, this sort of nonsense is going to not shock the world any longer and the people dependent on this gas sector are going to feel the impact of it sooner than later. Wisdom would dictate throwing out these lobbies and investing in local production and consumption of energy. Who's going to do the sane thing though? Not a science issue here, clearly.
Nobody needs the Middle East to solve the climate crisis: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/primary-energy-source-bar...
https://archive.is/EnXFj
There's an interesting correlation with COP talks failing and financial crises.
2000
2009
2019
Now
> Some diplomats said the conference’s credibility would depend on
Does that conference still have any kind of credibility at this point?
The COP 21 conference in 2016 did have credibility. However, Trump walked away from the deal and cancelled US involvement in 2017. Biden rejoined in 2021. Trump then cancelled involvement again in 2025.
The US involvement needs to be codified by the newly enacted Congress in 2027. This will help prevent future inconsistencies. Given the likelihood there will be others like the US current president, who value self interest in preserving the status quo over the long term best interest of constituents and the continuity of human existence.
Congress can’t pass anything without presidents signature. We are just going to have two years of no government.
Congress can override vetos. We'll see if this Congress can.
They need a two-thirds majority to override a veto, and you aren't getting 10 republican senators to defect. Not a chance.
Enough will if dear leader orders them to. Maybe 1 or 2 will refuse. The last ones who refused got voted out in their primary.
They would need 11 Republican senators. That is not going to happen, certainly not on climate issues.
They might override a veto on something less core to the party's principles, where they can all vote for it rather than hang a few out to dry.
If congress is smart, every bill for the next 2 years they pass will be the "Donald Trump X act". For example "The Donald Trump clean air act".
Trump is not an ideologue and he is vain enough to sign bills simply because they have his name on them. Democrats can also praise him for being such a smart boy for signing it into law.
It's basically the Mamdami move with Trump.
It might work for some things, but not a climate change treaty. That requires a dozen Republican votes to pass, and even putting his name on it won't cause them to do a complete 180 on the climate. Especially a treaty, since that will be seen as a violation of sovereignty.
But only 4 republican flips are needed for legislation to get through. They could still send in climate change legislation which complies with but doesn't lock in a treaty.
It's also possible for dems to do a filibuster carve-out. They don't need to fully eliminate it, just in the cases where legislation aligns with their agenda and Trump seems on board (and Trump's influence isn't enough to flip 4 republicans).
There's also budget reconciliation which they can ram through climate change spending. Republicans have already paved the way to do that by just overruling when the parliamentarian says "that doesn't count".
The entire reason Democrats swept the elections is because Republicans caused high fossil fuel prices. Any effective bill to reduce fossil fuel consumption in a a relevant timeframe will need to cause fossil fuel prices to go much higher, which will again cause Americans to vote for the other party.
People do not want to slow climate change, they want their houses in the suburbs, their big cars, their electronics, their out-of-season foods, and their cheap flights.
> Any effective bill to reduce fossil fuel consumption in a a relevant timeframe will need to cause fossil fuel prices to go much higher
Arguably if the bill is effective then it will end up doing the opposite and end up causing fossil fuel prices to tumble (because fewer entities are consuming them).
It's also possible to use the revenue from taxes/fines to help fund social programs which decrease the costs. Even something as simple as a fossil fuel rebate check would go a long way towards buying good will.
For examples of what could be done which would reduce fossil fuel consumption without negatively impacting (most) people. Public transport funds for states. Building out amtrak and high speed rail (dedicated lines rather than shared lines). Heavy heavy taxes on private jets... or better yet simply outlaw them all together, everyone that flies should do it commercially.
> they want their houses in the suburbs
The majority of people want affordable housing. That means cheap apartments ideally within walking distance of their work.
> their big cars
There's not much of an option in the american market, cheaper sedans have a place but fewer manufacturers are offering them. Making big cars more expensive and sedans/minivans/station wagons cheaper would shift market preferences. As of now, those vehicles are practically specialty vehicles and aren't significantly discounted over a monster truck or SUV.
> their electronics
Consumer electronics are not a major driver of climate change. Heating and cooling and transport still dominate in terms of what the average american is emitting.
> their out-of-season foods
This one might seem pretty surprising, but that's not actually a climate change driver. In terms of emissions, shipping by water (which is how most people get those out-of-season foods) emits relatively little CO2 for the amount of goods moved. The bigger issue is the semi-trucks moving the banana instead of the boat moving the banana. Boats are more efficient than trains and trains are freakishly efficient.
> and their cheap flights.
As I mentioned above, eliminating private jet flights would go a LONG way in cutting down flight emissions. Commercial flights are about twice as bad as a car driving the same distance. The way you make less people fly is by making trains better and cheaper. As of right now, trains are MUCH slower than even driving and as expensive or more expensive than flying. In the US they are also plagued with delay because they share lines with private shipping companies.
Replying to the sibling comment by lotsofpulp.
I don’t see why promoting solar & sustainability has to make fossil fuels worse. Solar is already cheaper, and we need more incentives to make electric everything else cheaper than gas. We don’t necessarily need to disincentivize automobile gas and diesel though. We need to make the other options more compelling.
That's a hilarious idea that might genuinely be effective in some cases
Even the senate voting to enter a treaty might not be of much help, as there's precedent for the president to withdraw from treaties without congressional approval.
The senate can codify fossil fuel reductions and transitions to renewable energy. They can also renew incentives that drive renewable energy innovations.
I absolutely cannot understand the US conception of "democracy". In what other republic does the head executive have such autocratic powers?
France?
It's a local privilege escalation bug. Congress people have no defense against threats of violence from the executive.
They do have a defense: impeachment and conviction. The Republican senators are just cowards who think that groveling to Trump is the only option they really have.
But consider these people literally said Trump would be a disaster for the country — like JD Vance and Lindsey Graham. Given their clear compromise of personal values for personal gain, I have to wonder if their self-flagellating decision to support a felonious president actually makes them happy.
Like, they presumably support Trump because betraying him would mean the end of their political career. And I guess having that power makes them happy? But they bend over backwards to be yes-men and to betray their own beliefs, just for Trump to rake them over the coal anyways. So it can’t be about happiness; I have to imagine this is a distressing situation to be in.
So why not grow a pair and convict? Seems like it’d be happier for everyone. If fear of losing an election is all it takes to self-compromise to this degree, they must be cowards.
Congress has most powers, it's just that it delegates that to the presidency.
The reasons for this are a bit complicated, and it didn't used to be that way, but starting with the Great Depression, lawmakers saw it was easier to accomplish their goals by passing the buck to the president.
The idea is that lawmakers had to do a lot of horsetrading to get bills passed some states got disadvantaged so their congressmen got voted out. If, instead, you authorize the president to do this and that, then it's the president's fault and he will be out in 8 years maximum while congress men get re-elected indefinitely until they die in office.
This is why Congress has an abysmal approval rating, but not individual congressmen. Constituents consistently re-elect "their" congressman while hating congress as a whole.
The biggest issue here I'd say is lack of term limits. If they had a 8 year term limit they wouldn't enable the president so much.
We’re talking here about an agreement that nobody other than the head executive ratified. As an opponent of what US political theorists call the “imperial presidency”, I think the correct story is that the United States never validly joined the Paris Agreement in the first place because the Senate did not consent to do so.
> Even the senate voting to enter a treaty might not be of much help, as there's precedent for the president to withdraw from treaties without congressional approval.
There's some complication here that's often elided. Per the US Constitution, all treaties have to be ratified by the Senate, and it's generally held that such treaties have to be abrogated by act of Congress (SCOTUS has never actually heard a case, since treaty abrogation is generally something they dodge as nonjusticiable in the first place).
However, a lot of "treaties" these days signed by the US are actually "executive agreements," which bypass the need for ⅔ majority vote in the Senate. Since they're made under the (potentially delegated) authority of the executive alone, they're able to be abrogated by that same authority of the executive alone.
Is it the fault of the US that a group of countries not involving the US can't come to an agreement?
I guess it only needs enough credibility to keep the frog in the water.
Change is uncomfortable and the frog so desperately wants to believe that someone else is handling the water temperature issue or at least that it will happen too slowly for it to personally be impacted.
At the end of the day, the frog needs a reason to take the easy way out; a cop out. I doubt that these summits being named COP is really a coincidence.
Governments aren't dragging their feet. Governments simply don't work for the people. The ruling class has figured out that people are best controlled via proxy and controlled opposition.
It's a silly urban legend. Frogs absolutely jump out of water when it gets uncomfortable. Unfortunately, humans as a civilization aren't as smart as frogs.
Also, with climate change "when it gets uncomfortable" is way way too late. We're definitely not smart enough to have jumped out when it was still possible to reverse the course towards future discomfort.
We can sense from what's happening that this 'I am smart (by implication) and can see impending disaster while you don't because you're not smart' does not go down well with some rather distinguished academics intimately acquainted with the data. Since you and many others believe this is an existential crisis (and those other folk simply do not accept it as such) why not organize a truly independently hosted public forum with a massive PR buildup where the arguments can really see the light and people on your side can show everyone just how wrong the demurring folk are? But it has to be independently-hosted to have any traction with folk who say "OK show me the arguments".
"Jump" in this analogy means to stop emitting greenhouse gasses, an action that only works when coordinated throughout the species and is useless for the individual when carried out individually. Frogs can't do anything like that at all.
If by personally ceasing to emit one could obtain a personal bubble of comfortable climate, everybody would do it and the problem would be solved.
Our planet is burning while oligarchs argue over the fossil fuels that are threatening all life on our planet. Because their profits might suffer.
At this point, we know it is really over and we are probably on the way to maybe +5C. I thought I read somewhere in reality scientists are hoping we can keep it below +3.5C, but they are very worried, who listens to them anyway :(
In the US, both political parties have been trying for years to keep gas and diesel fuel prices low. They know they will loose their cushy jobs if fossil fuel prices reach a certain level. A good example of this is the US midterms, the GOP got hammered due to fossil fuel prices.
Yes you can argue it was Trump and other reasons, but I have been around for while and gas prices in the US is the # 1 reason for political change and has been since the 70s.
What should happen ? Fossil Fuel prices need to raise a lot to force a very quick move to alternate sources. Otherwise, off to +5C we go. Yes people will suffer, but suffering, even at +3.5C will be far worse than high fuel prices. Instead we keep prices low by oil subsidies and other incentives.
> both political parties have been trying for years to keep gas and diesel fuel prices low
There's no real alternative for a political party. If you push through green energy that ends up increasing the cost of living, your party will inevitably lose power. So instead you get performative green energy, which is just politicians bragging about how great their renewable program is going, while it does next to nothing. I've seen 30 years of this.
I think you just continue to burn oil and coal while heavily incentivizing alternatives, kind of like China's been doing. Without a planned economy though, the vested interests and political power in dirty energy are a pretty huge obstacle.
This is not true, we are not on our way to over +5C , we are slightly below the emissions of the track of IPCC6 scenario SSP2-4.5 , which predicts warming from 2.1 to 3.5 C .
A reevaluation from a IPCC7 lead author puts estimates that the median with current policies is 2.7 degrees C. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/29768659241304854
Thats not great, and we should put in more effort to get it lower, but it doesn't warrant unnecessary doomerism.
Daily reminder that earth is 70% oceans and that these don't warm anywhere close to as fast as land. +3c globally will be a death sentence for a lot of places.
Yeah 1.5c+ is already very bad. 3c+ is catastrophic.
Does anyone actually believe that these talks will achieve anything concrete? As another commenter has mentioned, only the cost of fossil fuels has any teeth in influencing our behavior. The other factor that will help is the declining birthrate world wide which reduces consumption.
Of course, it’s not all rainbows and butterflies. Higher energy costs results in higher costs in nearly everything including food, heating & cooling costs. Collapsing birthrates mean collapsing economic systems since both socialism and capitalism rely on constantly growing populations.