The gap in sentiment between most tech voices on X and mainstream media coverage of Jensen Huang is pretty incredible. The mainstream media coverage of the downfall of Jensen has been remarkably consistent and negative (almost gleeful), but you wouldn't know that if you read posts from any major VCs or tech figures.
Mainstream media coverage – not unlike X – generally _has_ tended to be consistent to the point of ~parroting one another on... a wide range of things, especially tech-bashing, for years now.
With respect, the fact that it's consistent is surely unsurprising – especially with the understanding that a lot of it is straightforwardly repetitious of the first source (esp. when the first source was itself _sourced_ from interviews, etc.), and the existence of a lot of journalist<>journalist groups / group chats.
And yeah, 'gleeful' feels right - excited for the excuse to heap negativity on AI.
> and the existence of a lot of journalist<>journalist groups / group chats.
What about the group chats for organized response among VCs/tech leaders/etc? Including the highly coordinated/visible reaction to Jensen's firing trying to reinstate him we're seeing now, or the previous successful campaign to bring back Sam Altman (which included sympathetic media types like Kara Swisher)?
well if we're going in this direction, cozying up to dictators and anti-democratic forces sure is common among the current crop of billionaires and political establishment in America.
And it's pretty much the American way, suck that down. And why is it the American way? Because it's a lot easier to pay off an autocrat to back our foreign policy than it is to pay off a democratic country full of people who can vote and protest about you. You don't like that, you don't like that, too bad, that's how it's worked so far.
Try reading The Dictators Handbook. It's very enlightening. Jensen's only mistake here was not maintaining his internal coalition to maintain his power. And that part's on him. The rest is propaganda.
they are the measuring stick though? unless something actually happens to the pedophile billionaires, theyvw got the US stamp of approval as exemplary american behaviour
Dude fucked a spy[1] and enabled somewhere in the hundreds of billions of dollars of business doing literal smuggling of banned equipment. Like if that's a one, what's a two?!
I think the disconnect here isn't about severity but just about "well, OK, but China isn't actually so bad". You're making a policy point, not a crime one. The crime thing is pretty obvious. And the solution to policy disagreements is democracy, not twitter.
[1] Well, OK, not a "spy spy" like a Bond Villain. She was only working for the Chinese government to enable import of illegal goods for state-directed purposes and lying about it while successfully seducing the CEO of the target company.
I mean everyone under Trump is fine with committing treason supporting China and Russia so there is that. They do seem to be a bit concerned about being investigated in the last week or two so we'll see how that goes.
So, first: as others are pointing out the approval for these deals is extremely unclear. Some are alleging involvement by the administration, no one has evidence of any such action.
Second: the executive branch obviously does not have the authority to wave trade embargos set by congressional laws. The crime would still have happened, you just might have an argument that Huang was an accomplice or underling.
Those would be facts to be argued before a court, in any case. I mean (again, yikes) it's really obviously this was criminal behavior! It's smuggling! Literally!
And having criminals in the C suite offices of public companies is widely frowned upon, so boards tend to remove them at the first hint of involvement. Which is what happened.
That the tech community seems to feel somehow unbound by this is (yes again), a "yikes" kind of thing. If you don't like the laws we have you work to elect governments to change them. You don't just YOLO your way into the bed of a spy and figure you'll get a pardon or whatever.
It's funny that you're appropriating the langauge of last decade's social justice activists to act like I'm beyond the pale for not taking at face value the word of the national security apparatus (which, I should remind, has not done a single positive thing in the last 25 years).
> it's really obviously this was criminal behavior!
There was no doubt that there was an export ban on this stuff. There is no doubt that the material went to the PRC anyway. That is presumptively a crime. You can argue exculpatory details if you want, or point to other actors with greater guilt, etc... But that becomes an argument you need to come to with evidence and not just "Well, I don't believe it".
I've not seen any suggestion that Commerce ordered Nvidia to make these sales. Getting a government official to corruptly ratify your illegal decisions does not immunize you from responsibility.
>Getting a government official to corruptly ratify your illegal decisions does not immunize you from responsibility.
This is simply untrue and there is a well established legal defense known as "entrapment by estoppel" to protect a defendant against an act which has been explicitly sanctioned by a government official.
Indeed there is, mea culpa. (Although Congress will surely be asking Jensen questions to probe whether he really "reasonably believed" that Lutnick's permission was consistent with the law.)
That's narrower than you think it is. As it applies in US federal court:
> The defense of entrapment by estoppel requires proof (1) “that a government agent actively misled him about the state of the law defining the offense,” (2) “that the government agent was responsible for interpreting, administering, or enforcing the law defining the offense,” (3) “that the defendant actually relied on the agent's misleading pronouncement in committing the offense,” and (4) “that the defendant's reliance was reasonable in light of the identity of the agent, the point of law misrepresented, and the substance of the misrepresentation.”
In short, entrapment requires that the government explicitly tell you that what you did was legal, that you relied on that information to decide to do it, and that such a reliance was reasonable.
I don't know the precise details of what Nvidia did with regards to evading the chips sanctions, but I suspect it involves a lot more of Nvidia lobbying the government to be exempted, at which point the entrapment is less likely to apply.
It is still illegal for them to sell chips when they will be laundered to China. It would not be illegal if they were just shipped to Malaysia and Chinese companies trained models there, but those companies were just empty warehouses. It is still illegal.
You sound very confident. Are you a lawyer or at least intimately familiar with the laws in question? It seems to me that Nvidia went through all of the proper channels to get the sales approved. You may not agree with the decision. You may even think it's conceptually treasonous—a term people on this site love to throw around—but that doesn't make it illegal.
i am not a lawyer, but i can read articles by people whose jobs are for looking into things like this. are you a lawyer? have you looked into what others have been doing around this story?
I would not call it pressure yet, but the existing EU law demanding watermarks for text and images clearly has a loophole because open models could be modified to circumvent this, so I'm just waiting for some sort of announcement that tackles that "issue".
Character assasination yes, but I doubt it has anything to do with the closed vs open weights battle. Much more likely the fact that Jensen was kowtowing to Trump and was among the tech oligarchs orbiting the administration. This is pure politics, as is par for the course with the NYT.
> gap in sentiment between most tech voices on X and mainstream media coverage of Jensen Huang
About as wide as that between the former and most of New York and D.C.
There is a group of folks who have convinced themselves everyone is sleeping with subordinates, everyone is corrupt and everyone is flirting with commissions of treason. They’re wrong, but they’re wedded—through profit or sin—to those positions. Then the cult of the founder amplifies it across Silicon Valley, including with folks who aren’t doing anything wrong.
Undermining the security of the US by take your pick of: exporting over $100 billion of controlled goods to an adversarial state, likely leaking US secrets to a spy, bribing the President by "donating" to his stupid ballroom.
That seems rather subjective. I would argue that many of the decisions of the national security apparatus (the network of agencies, think tanks, media outlets, and etc. that has been reveling in Jensen's downfall) in the last 25 years have undermined the security of the United States, but few would take me seriously if I called people like Bush, Cheney, McCain, and Graham treasonous.
"Bush is a traitor" is the type of slogan you see on a Code Pink protest sign, not a mainstream view or a literal statement about a meeting a legal definition. All of those figures are relatively well-liked, unfortunately, and treated with kid gloves by the same media that uncritically publishes "leaked" rumors about Jensen Huang and Alice Huang.
The Harris campaign trotted out Liz Cheney as a top surrogate in the closing weeks the 2024 race. I'm sure they would have crowed about a Bush endorsement if they had been able to get one.
> The mainstream media coverage of the downfall of Jensen has been remarkably consistent and negative (almost gleeful)
This is especially true regarding The New York Times. Their first story was the exposé of the affair with the spy. I thought that was great work by NYT. Then they published a story on Nvidia board [1]. That story seemed to cross the line from reporting to advocacy on what the board ought to do. The board may have been influenced by it.
Since the initial story landed they have been milking the scandal for all it is worth. More recently, apparently because they are running out of material, they have started adding a form at the bottom of their stories: "Have you worked with Nvidia? We want to hear from you. What aspects of the company and its leadership do you think deserve more attention?"
The most recent story is almost gleeful [2]: "Threats, Insults, Settlements: How Jensen Huang Made Humiliation Routine". It has many Jensen Huang quotes that sound awful but they are pulled out of context.
"Threats, Insults, Settlements: How Jensen Huang Made Humiliation Routine"
This is the worst because that kind of stuff requires an extreme amount of context.
Have they ever been in a sports locker room? Some of that may be justifies or not, and certainly sports stuff can be 'toxic' and not an excuse - but - context matters.
There are all sorts of ways to be 'assertive' and also a 'terd' and 'toxic' - it requires a lot of situational information.
100%. I have said the worst things imaginable to my best friends, and they have returned. I wouldn't say those things to someone I'm uncomfortable with or unsure could take it.
All of these actions are bad in a locker room. They are arguably worse when done elsewhere. They were very bad when Steve Jobs did them. And they are very bad when other people do them. Why should we carry water for the Nvidia CEO and excuse such behaviour?
So this is your way of saying what's wrong for Jensen Huang is OK for Musk and Zuckerberg? Jensen yells at people who disappoint him whilst following the letter of trade laws while Musk fires those who disagree with him on the spot and cuts off Starlink to Ukraine, and Zuck lives in his own deluded timeline, happy to meddle in the politics of other nations to deliver shareholder value.
You're assuming an "acceptable" binary that just doesn't exist. Musk and Zuckerberg have structured their companies in such a way that they can't be removed from the top; Nvidia is structured differently than that, so its executives are subject to different standards.
Which is fine! Different companies should be free to organize themselves as they see fit. It's only scary to the gaggle of VCs and tech execs because they believe that it's unconscionable to have a powerful board of directors; in their view, anyone who founds a company and makes it really big is morally entitled to lead it for however long they'd like.
Funny, I got downvoted for pointing out exactly your assertion in another thread. But I agree with you so I guess we both need to be downvoted to demonstrate the error of our ways. I don't make the rules, I just note them.
Justin Trudeau - the Prime Minister of Canada made his adult female (and very progressive) Cabinet Members cry because they used he word 'crazy' to describe something odd.
He belittled them because they shouldn't be so 'offensive' to people with mental disabilities.
Now this is a form of 'toxic leadership' - and by the way a form of 'Woke Toxicity' - doubly degrading because the whole point would be nominally empathetic to people, but instead, he became toxic.
It's perfectly reasonable for some people to use the term 'crazy' and you don't get to destroy people because of some ridiculously high minded supposed 'social principle'.
If the word 'crazy' is offensive - then everything is offensive - and that is how toxic PC culture comes to the fore - by ignoring context.
1) dressing someone down because they are no up to a standard is perfectly legitimate - in context.
2) 'language' itself is contextual. Calling someone an 'idiot' is nominally wrong, but if anyone that I knew at work said 'oh my god you idiot, you pushed and broke he build' - that would be only technically inappropriate because I would not care. If it were done in a degrading, bullying manner - no, I would not tolerate that, but my boss - who is a good and competent person, saying that in colloquial terms ... I wouldn't care.
I don't care if people swear or use creative metaphors.
Some people are offended by use of any gendered language.
3) Humiliation is contextual. In some cultures any public disrespect is very troubling aka 'face saving culture'. In others, complete opposite.
The 'frankness' of Fins, Dutch, German would be considered toxic by some.
4) Proportionality. It's possible that some of he things hat Steve Jobs did was wrong - it doesn't mean we fire him over it. People have a lot of variation, they are going to 'cross lines'. Crossing lines itself has to be put in context. Jobs famously allowed people to 'push back on him' - and that is probably the truest test.
If Jensens was holding people up and calling them 'losers' in front of everyone aka "Ok, Amanda failed her objectives, she is the loser of the week this week - Amanda, explain to everyone why you are such a loser and how you're going to make up for it?" <- this might be considered 'tough leadership' by some - but that's just plain toxic an unnecessary.
Alternatively - Jensen highlighting 'The bottom 10% of sales performers' aka "At the bottom we have John, Chen, Suzie and Ricardo. Again Ricardo - this is two weeks in a row - this is not good ..." <- that's a bit questionable, but it's not toxic and frankly it's totally in bounds, and the kind of thing where you 'choose to work there or not'.
Trudeau did not call anyone crazy - he chastised people for using the term.
He would yell at and belittle his staff - female Cabinet Members, who were by the way ultra-progressive empathetic 'woke' types for arbitrary use of what he deemed 'inappropriate and offensive language'.
This is the 'double example': someone doing something actually 'toxic' but doing it in the name of hyper high minded PC culture, aka use of an 'insensitive term' , in this case the word 'crazy'.
As in: 'Wow, that's really crazy!'
You wouldn't put the term 'crazy' in a Public Communication - but you can say that in private language, obviously.
But the PC police can come on hard for any deemed offence.
It's very plausible - especially in government - that someone takes up the Public Sector Union and HR because 'someone somewhere used he word crazy'.
This is PC toxicity and it's real.
It does not justify calling people ugly names etc - obviously. But 'context matters'.
So Trudeau said "don't call things crazy, because it's inappropriate" and the "PC woke police" responded to that with "omg! Trudeau said 'crazy', that's inappropriate!"? Sorry, this explanation doesn't add up.
I was bored so I looked the incident up and most of the outrage was (more believably) from the Canadian right. Trudeau reprimanded said minister for saying "crazy" and (in an undeniably weird choice) offered his preferred euphemism: "bananas." That's what the right found ridiculous and objectionable.
Others dug through his record and uncovered some clip where Trudeau referred to the job of Prime Minister as "crazy."
It was not 'the right' that found it 'objectionable' - it was his very own Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland, life long progressive, former MSNBC commentator, and author of the book 'Plutocrats' a treatise questioning the concentration of powerful interests etc.
She wrote about this issue, and many other things about JT in her book 'Bad Boyfriend', a rare rebuke by senior Cabinet Member of a PM's staff, reminiscent of the deluge of negative public statements about Trump, after his first term, because this kind of public rebuke is so rare.
Does she sound 'right wing' to you?
It's ridiculous that people would think to support obvious and actually toxic behaviour by a guy belittling his own senior cabinet members to the point they were crying.
Literally this thread is a 'pile on' of 'evil Jensen Huang' because he may or may not have made done some questionable things during meeting etc ...
... but as soon as an ultra-progressive guy does something overtly bullying and ridiculous - the 'tables turn'?
So these women who were harassed are just what?
'whiny women'?
Take off the political lens and try to see things for what the are.
If anything, this example lays bare the absolute hypocrisy of political standards.
Justin Trudeau - Prime Minister of Canada - belittled adult progressive female senior staff because they used the word 'crazy' in a completely benign context, under the auspices that said term ('crazy') was 'offensive'.
These are public allegations made by the Deputy PM of Canada 'on the record' Chrystia Freeland, noted progressive.
If you don't agree that this is 'PC Policing' then ... pick your own pejorative.
It's completely crazy (pun very much intended) to harass and belittle people for arbitrary use of the effectively benign language.
You can't have it both ways:
1) Was Justin's harassment and toxic belittling of women 'bad form' - just as Jensen Huang?
2) Or were his actions justified - because using the term 'crazy' in casual language offensive and toxic deserving of admonishment.
Isn't it mostly bad when the attribution falls to the person ("you're crazy" or "you idiot") and less so, even tolerable, when the attribution falls to the action ("that's a crazy thing to do" or "that's idiotic")?
Or is this concern about where the attribution lands "toxic PC" in your view?
There's a subtle difference between the use of term as you have indicated, but in this case it was a woman using the term 'crazy' in reference to something not calling someone 'crazy'.
It's a very clear cut example of Toxic PC culture and also a 'double example' of him being 'actually abusive' in the pursuit of ostensibly cultural empathy.
I do not think his belittling in that way is justifiable as 'locker room talk' - however the use of the term 'crazy' is colloquially acceptable language aka 'locker room talk'.
> The 'frankness' of Fins, Dutch, German would be considered toxic by some.
You are attempting to explain myself and my colleagues to me. And we are absolutely not “frank” against persons, we are frank about actions and things.
Your intentional or mitt mixing of these concepts has no place among us, and it is annoying that you think direct communication on matters the same as abuse.
I used to have your viewpoint, but then I worked in a large ineffective organization. You really do want someone who is a tyrant, and who can motivate people to move quickly.
In my case, leadership encouraged a lot of toxic empathy. We didn’t make hard decisions and didn’t move fast enough. We ultimately laid off a few thousand people.
I believe in the full utilitarian calculus it’s better to have a few people get verbal lashings than have many people lose their livelihood.
A common rebuttal is that maybe you don’t need to abuse people, or cause them to be afraid. But if this is the case I haven’t seen it work in practice. People in big organizations need to be scared for their jobs to burn the midnight oil, change course, or take risk. The alternative is that the organization stagnates and dies.
> I believe in the full utilitarian calculus it’s better to have a few people get verbal lashings than have many people lose their livelihood.
But this is a false dilemma. You can have both civilized discussion instead of verbal abuse and have people keep their jobs. It's just as simple as "You risk losing your job if..." rather than "I'll rip your arms off..." etc.
I worked with both these kinds of PHBs and in general the latter had worse staff as the talent preferred to work in more civilized environment. (But these were engineers, maybe middle management doesn't care.)
>People in big organizations need to be scared for their jobs to burn the midnight oil, change course, or take risk. The alternative is that the organization stagnates and dies.
Your claim is a false dichotomy. An organisation that relies on emotional manipulation and implicit threats to keep the gears turning is a deeply dysfunctional company. The common retort is Apple and Steve Jobs but this is a case of survivorship bias more than anything else.
I used to have your viewpoint, but then I worked in a large ineffective organization into which came a tyrant, who could motivate people to move quickly.
And, guess what, then it was a large ineffective organization made worse by waves of incoherent fear-motivated action rippling down the org chart as the people with the most direct contact with the tyrant moved rapidly to sooth his most recent rage directed at them and/or prevent the next.
Abuse doesn't solve structural problem, and the quick defensive reactions it motivates don't diagnose and find and implement resolutions for complex problems spanning multiple domains within a large organization, instead it exacerbates the trends of internal competition, fiefdom building, and acting in narrow immediate local self-interest that make large organizations inefficient.
There's been plenty of actual research done on what makes organizations effective. The top factor is psychological safety: subordinates need to feel safe in reporting bad news up the chain.
If they don't, you end up with Putin invading Ukraine because everybody's told him the army is in great shape and will be welcomed with flower bouquets.
> You really do want someone who is a tyrant, and who can motivate people to move quickly. [...] I believe in the full utilitarian calculus it’s better to have a few people get verbal lashings than have many people lose their livelihood.
Speak for yourself. If you want to play bootlicker to an abusive taskmaster, be my guest, that's your personal problem; you don't even need to come up with boring false dichotomies of the most transparent kind to justify it.
“He said jokingly,” for example. For what it is worth Nvidia has really high reviews on employee review sites for the work environment which is not true of many businesses.
This is why corporate anti-harassment policies exist. Smart leaders know not to say things that could be misconstrued in a harassing context because you do not want that fight to spill into the court of public opinion.
If you find yourself saying anything in a corporate environment that you’d defend as “locker room talk”, you already F’ed up.
The arbitrary assumption that some action is offensive because someone thinks it is is promoting PC toxicity, the worst part of corporatism.
See my example of Justin Trudeau (above) belittling (making women cry!) his Cabinet members for using the term 'crazy'.
Using the term 'crazy' arbitrarily was deemed by him apparently 'offensive to people with disabilities'.
The posture you are promoting here leads us all down the path to criminalizing all language: if the word 'crazy' is a form of harassment - than all language is harassing.
This is literally the Prime Minister of a major nation - the 'Top Person' in a culture and it rolls down from there.
Similar to Trump's actually bad treatment of people in other ways.
> The posture you are promoting here leads us all down the path to criminalizing all language: if the word 'crazy' is a form of harassment - than all language is harassing.
Maybe he was in the US military. Our drill sergeants in the USAF collected insults the way others collect fine art. One of my all time favorites was "Son, you're so ugly you'd make a freight train take a dirt road!"
Ha, that's a good one. When I went through USAF boot camp it was an odd time, they weren't supposed so insulting, no cussing, etc. Somehow it was supposed to be clean. This was back in the early 90s. Reality didn't quite keep up with policy, of course, but they didn't physically abuse anyone at that point.
I’m pretty sure that the reporters at the New York Times have been employed at a company before which is all the context you need. The article showed that he was being unprofessional and had to settle legal claims with his own HR department. The frankly juvenile quotes from Huang in the article don’t need any context. Actual quote from the article said to an executive in a meeting with multiple attendees: “pee on your brain”. I would expect better of a teenager let alone a CEO of a major corporation.
When there is a big power differential, you cannot make such comments in a non-toxic way. What you're describing is banter among friends, and even there you can easily miss the mark. But in a professional context when the person throwing around insults has the power to fire the people targeted, that is always toxic.
> in a professional context when the person throwing around insults has the power to fire the people targeted, that is always toxic
Not true at all. If I messed up, and I fear I am about to be fired, I would be relieved if my boss instead says "I'd like to rip your arms off and beat you to death with it. Now get back to work."
The question at hand is whether it is abusive for a boss to say "I'd like to rip your arms off and beat you to death with it." And my answer is that the context matters. It is not necessarily always abusive.
This isn't locker room banter. The CEO of a major company had extramarital affairs with three people, two of whom were his own employees. Context doesn't make any of this look better.
Disagree - you highlighted where context matters the most.
'Power' is a troubling factor in relations, and creates huge conflict of interest - but conflict of interest doesn't inherently make something wrong.
'Consenting adults are consenting adults' and can make their own decisions, in the end.
The problem was not 'the affair' its the fact there is a 'relationship in power structure hidden from oversight'.
It's the 'no transparency' that makes it a problem.
If he were to have told the Board about it, and then indicated he was 'divorcing his wife and marrying the lady' ... then they would have probably just handled that. Probably they would have to figure out another role for he lady.
An affair is a problem because it opens the business up to huge liability if anyone believes the subordinates had different treatment due to the affair. It is also a problem because it is against the policy of the company, which has said policy for exactly that reason: liability.
'Locker Room Talk' is not an argument that 'all language should be allowed' - it's an argument that context matters.
The inability to understand that - or - purposeful misrepresentation of the issue is a problem.
Calling someone bad names is almost always bad - it really does depend a lot on the name, now doesn't it? Pointing out that someone is in the 'bottom 10% of sales performers and had better do something about it' in front of peers is somewhere in the range of acceptable or not, depending on context.
I had a boss (someone much less powerful and influential than Huang) threaten to torpedo my career once if I didn’t do what he wanted. It sure didn’t feel like I was talking shit with the guys. It made me feel angry and small and scared that he might actually be able to do it.
> This is the worst because that kind of stuff requires an extreme amount of context.
LOL, sorry, these stories were told by insiders who were actually there, amongst lots of other talk about lawsuits, people resigning, etc. The actual story has tons of context. Nothing like a "locker room". Reading the actual story being discussed is helpful here.
Agreed, "locker room banter" is not supposed to be actually aggressive or humiliating, and if anyone on your team talked like that it would instantly lead to half the team coming back at them. That's "locker room cancer" territory.
Grow some self respect. When I played sports, if someone dared treat anyone in the team like that they would be immediately be set straight. That sort of behavior wouldn't fly with opposing teams, let alone your own teammates.
You guys have a very twisted sense of how people treat themselves. None of this is ok.
What do you mean when you say that [2] is "almost gleeful"? I see this line a lot and I just have no idea what it's referring to. It seems like important and serious news if Jensen Huang made humiliation routine.
Perhaps he didn't make humiliation routine and they're not getting the full story? But you seem to also take issue with the NYT's attempt to find people with more information on Nvidia and get their opinions on how the company was run. What specific editorial choices do you feel they should make to cover this news in a way that isn't "gleeful"?
The New York Times has long been the mouthpiece of the national security apparatus. That's why they take a far less progressive position on Israel/Palestine than you might expect, given how they report on domestic social issues (which often swings too far in the other direction, like in the case of the 1619 Project).
Yes lawyers lead the whole process when you look at it. Shareholders have lost almost 50% of their value over 6 weeks or so but the board has to follow a process lawyers set to remain compliant in order to "act in the best interests of shareholders". There is insurance that ironically protects the board of directors from shareholder lawsuits which limits their own risk of making poor decisions.
Lawyers will start multiple class action lawsuits against Nvidia and Jensen and the board regardless and take a cut for themselves which will be taken from the corporation ultimately and it will do nothing to regain lost value for shareholders. The litigation will take time and money away from business processes that could be put towards recovering.
Even the hiring process of the new CEO will follow a process lawyers designed ostensibly in the name of reducing risk for shareholders that really may not be what is best for the corporation. Lawsuit aversion and legal compliance are not necessarily the same as the best business practice although we are told by lawyers it is.
I think the biggest problem is that a decent fraction of the board members have effectively no skin in the game, and they’re incentivized to be risk averse and dot their i’s rather than actually act in the holistic best long term interest of the company. A couple of them have less than $500k in shares (at the peak, now a quarter mill thanks to their bumbling). There are probably a decent number of commenters here that have more invested in the future of Nvidia than some of the directors. Certainly lots of the employees do.
The world was aware of the circular deals a year ago, the board knew or could infer even further back
Their skin in the game is not being personally investigated/ruined by playing ball with government now declining to consider bringing Jensen back being one of their obligations
AI got kind of politicized. Trump took a strong stance on Nvidia and datacenters. Trump bragged about Nvidia's success and appeared with Jensen in public. That's going to attract negative attention.
Actually something kind of stunning to me about Jensen's downfall is how reckless he was about it. Someone in his position has to consider "am I doing something that could jeopardize myself and Nvidia"? Nvidia employees were the source on the second affair. He was that brazen about it. It almost seems like he wasn't aware people would come for him.
If you own a large, politically significant company like that I would expect you would CYA.
"More recently, apparently because they are running out of material, they have started adding a form at the bottom of their stories: "Have you worked with Nvidia? We want to hear from you. What aspects of the company and its leadership do you think deserve more attention?""
Hate it when the NYT reporters do their job. So annoying!
> He told one executive that his mother should have aborted him, according to one witness. He said he would rip both arms off a subordinate and beat the person over the head to death with them. And he told another employee he would rip off the top of their head and “pee on your brain.”
> He said he would rip both arms off a subordinate and beat the person over the head to death with them.
When we were naughty as kids my mother lovingly told me or my brother that she would "rip off your arm and beat you with the bloody end". Dozens of times. This is not an exaggeration. She never did that though.
Later she would start it with "If you ever ride a motorcycle I'll..."
She was your mother and you were a kid. That this is the first comparable thing that comes to mind shows just how sick it is for an adult to say that to another adult.
Maybe his parents said some shit to him when he was a kid, too, and he just had to take it, and abusing people he has power over, and the jackets, is his way of trying to work on that.
If you messed up at work badly enough to deserve being fired, what would you accept in lieu of being fired? Would you be willing to accept a stern talking-to?
I regularly have stern talking-tos with underperforming reports. These involve statements like "you are currently not meeting expectations, here's the plan that lays out the milestones and behaviors I expect", not threats of extreme physical violence.
Seriously: your sense of what is normal and acceptable has clearly been warped by an abusive family life or workplace culture. You really don't have to accept this kind of thing, and there are high performing, well paid jobs out there that don't require you to.
Agreed. Seeing their comments elsewhere reminds me of strict / borderline abusive parents berating a child's self-esteem as if it were the only way to motivate them. Lifelong issues in those cases even when the kids become adults.
The best feedback I received after a bad half was sombre, laying out my flaws and its impact on my own progress and the people I work with and the ceiling I'll have in my current trajectory. And whether that is what I wanted out of my career in that company. That straightened me in a constructive way that no amount of "abortion" abuse would.
That language doesn't allow for gradation. If you are firing the guy it makes sense to use such formal language. If not you need more colorful words to let him know just how pissed off you are. And colorful language is acceptable if it is proportionate and you are known to be a fair manager overall.
I am not firing the guy. I am letting them know they are at risk of termination (I use those exact words later on, and they're repeated in writing in the plan), and spelling out exactly what they need to do to avoid that fate.
Rest assured, this conversation gets the message across loud and clear. Those who can shape up, those who can't leave or get fired. In neither case would it make any difference if I threatened to rip out their eyeballs and skullfuck them.
So in your opinion, threatening an employee with termination (no gradation, any shortcoming gets the same threat) is better than saying "Johnson, you have really fucked up this time. I will rip your limbs off if you make this mistake again."
I disagree completely. Being threatened with termination constantly will make me look for another job. Being threatened with dismemberment doesn't because I know to not take it literally, it is my boss's jovial way of letting me know he is really pissed.
I meet most of my reports weekly and have quarterly formal progress reviews. Rest assured, they will have received lots of feedback (in your terms, been repeatedly informed they fucked up) before we get to this stage and the word "termination" is ever uttered.
Also, you're still looking this from a weird angle, because personally blaming somebody for a fuckup is rarely useful. Sure, maybe you deleted the prod database, but what was the process failing that led you do to it? Why did you have that access turned on? Why was there no confirmation? Why didn't somebody else need to sign off? Any of these are much more useful than threats of violence.
Now if they're repeatedly failing to deliver, that's the kind of thing that will lead to the aforementioned conversation, but that's also quite different from a "fuck up".
I messed up, and my boss has scheduled a meeting with me. I go to his office and I fear I am about to be fired. I would be quite relieved if my boss instead says "Johnson, I'd like to rip your arms off and beat you to death with it. Now get back to work."
Regardless, context matters. NYT messed up by pulling the quotes out of context. Context includes tone of voice, and facial expression, among other things.
You can't have the full context in a newspaper article, but the NYT article doesn't even say what the employee did to get the invectives from Huang.
Huang grew up in the US, so I don't know if he has any Asian culture in him at all, but in Asian workplaces, particularly in Japan, employers are more inclined to retain employees and correct their mistakes, sometimes through stern criticism, whereas American employers may be quicker to dismiss them for poor performance. Asian bosses are often paternalistic, and don't be surprised if they yell at you like your parents might.
> I messed up, and my boss has scheduled a meeting with me. I go to his office and I fear I am about to be fired. I would be quite relieved if my boss instead says "Johnson, I'd like to rip your arms off and beat you to death with it. Now get back to work."
If your boss would do that, whatever you didn't warrant getting fired for. The proof is you weren't fired (because since when did "taking abuse" make up for poor performance). The violent, abusive language was egregious and unnecessary. Your boss behaved unacceptably, and it would be appropriate for him to be reprimanded for it (or even fired if it was a pattern).
> Or he is benevolent. Unlike math, there are multiple answers and which one is chosen can dependent on the human.
Not in this case. If he's benevolent he's not going to be making gratuitous violent threats to you in front of others to humiliate you.
The problem with your argument is the logic is pretty much: "he could have been worse therefore he's fine," which false and a weird bit of binary thinking and not "context." His behavior can still be unacceptably bad even if could have be worse.
> what the employee did to get the invectives from Huang.
Ah, the good old "look what you made me do", the final stage of the Narcissist's Prayer:
That didn't happen.
And if it did, it wasn't that bad.
And if it was, that's not a big deal.
And if it is, that's not my fault.
And if it was, I didn't mean it.
And if I did, you deserved it.
I would indeed prefer to be fired instead of being threatened to getting beaten to death wirh my own arms, yes. And I‘d argue this to be the more healthy position.
If it is Hannibal Lecter that made the threat you'd be justified in being alarmed because you know he means it literally. If your mom said that—as many moms do—you wouldn't be so alarmed, would you? Because you know she's just expressing disappointment in you, she doesn't mean it literally.
My sincere advise -- this is not healthy behavior between parent-child and between boss-employee. If this feels normal to you, you've internalized things from a childhood that perhaps wasn't great. I'd recommend you read up on psychological abuse by parents, how this impacts the self-esteem of children (and adults), healthier ways to motivate kids, and finally, talk to a therapist.
If my mom said that to me I'd call 911 because she was having a stroke. It'd be the only explanation for doing something something so out of character.
No, I would prefer to have competent people leadership.
You look at the problem, look at the person,talk them through it, and you are open and honest about where you think they went wrong.
And if it's not necessary an individual problem but a symptom of a larger systemic issue, that's where blameless postmortems come in to help prevent whatever happened from negatively impacting the company again.
And this would be true if I was back in foxholes getting shot at again, or in the office working through very expensive issues with C-level or engineering peers.
I wouldn't necessarily call it a flaw. I'd rather work for a boss who doesn't mince words and isn't afraid to call out shoddy work, but is just as quick to recognize and praise good work. That broad spectrum of possible feedback is motivating because you know every extra ounce of effort you put in will result in visible movement of the needle! Why do you think so many people wanted to work for Steve Jobs despite his not-so-rosy reputation? Because winning praise from a guy like that actually means something!
Grow some self respect. That's not the choice you are being faced. Being insulted and humiliated didn't saved you from being fired. Your ability to endure abuse does not make you a model employee. It just makes you a spineless doormat that everyone can walk over.
Being willing to be held accountable for failures does not make me a "spineless doormat". I would rather take some verbal heat for my failures than being pushed out the door.
Being verbally abused is not the same as being held accountable. It doesn't have to be an either / or between verbal abuse such as "your mother should have aborted you" or being fired.
> I didn't read it as a defense but rather using a hypothetical to illustrate the importance of context which we seem to wholly lack here.
That "context" is frankly bullshit: two hypothetical examples of unjustifiable and atrocious behavior, with a false choice to pick one.
Think about it: if verbal abuse and humiliation can "substitute" for being fired for a mistake, then the mistake wasn't something bad enough to be fired for. If firing was on the table for that kind of thing, that's another kind of abuse.
If that's what you truly believe then you ought to express disagreement with the point actually made (ie whether or not context is needed) in a civil manner rather than accuse the other party of bad faith.
While I'm not the same person I can't say I agree with the counterargument you present. Whether or not to fire someone for a serious slipup is fairly arbitrary. Generally these are things that all parties will agree can't be let slide (otherwise as you say it isn't necessary to fire anyone to begin with). So what to do? Certainly it's not a dichotomy - there are many options. I can accept that a nonzero number of such situations exist where I would not view verbal abuse as completely unacceptable (though I certainly wouldn't encourage it either).
I'll also note that without context it's generally difficult to know if something that looks like verbal abuse in a written record actually was at the time. I've had fairly charismatic bosses that would routinely say things in a clearly joking manner that absent context - body language, tone of voice, personal history, etc - would have come across as entirely inappropriate. As it was in reality everyone was laughing and having a good time. No one felt offended or threatened.
> While I'm not the same person I can't say I agree with the counterargument you present. Whether or not to fire someone for a serious slipup is fairly arbitrary. Generally these are things that all parties will agree can't be let slide (otherwise as you say it isn't necessary to fire anyone to begin with). So what to do? Certainly it's not a dichotomy - there are many options. I can accept that a nonzero number of such situations exist where I would not view verbal abuse as completely unacceptable (though I certainly wouldn't encourage it either).
Look, we can probably agree that we'd prefer a little verbal abuse to literally getting murdered, but that "context" says nothing about the acceptability of verbal abuse in any context.
> I'll also note that without context it's generally difficult to know if something that looks like verbal abuse in a written record actually was at the time. I've had fairly charismatic bosses that would routinely say things in a clearly joking manner that absent context - body language, tone of voice, personal history, etc - would have come across as entirely inappropriate. As it was in reality everyone was laughing and having a good time. No one felt offended or threatened.
At least in Jensen Huang's case, there are multiple reports of people interpreting is comments as abusive and unacceptable, and not as jokes. So you're talking about a hypothetical that doesn't apply to thise case.
I think the hypothetical scenario here is one where someone has screwed up badly enough to justify being fired on the spot. So it's being suggested that perhaps, in light of that context, a boss that verbally berates the employee but nonetheless retains them isn't necessarily socially unacceptable.
Contrast with a boss that verbally abuses employees who are generally in good standing which seems to not be socially acceptable in most western societies.
Given the historical stock price and performance, I wouldn't shed too many tears for them. Generational wealth is worth weathering the occasional blowup.
Depends on how much money I have. If I have "fuck you" money, it would be a pleasure to get in the boss' face and tell him to fuck off using all of the creative language that I can muster.
If I don't have "fuck you" money... well, unfortunately in the world we live in, few things are more important than getting "fuck you" money. I can suck up some humiliation if there's an expectation of getting "fuck you" money.
Now, did any of the people Huang berated have "fuck you" money and still put up with it? I'm actually pretty curious about whether or not anyone told him to eat shit. If someone did, I celebrate it. If even people with "fuck you" money didn't, then I'm curious to know why. Maybe they really really wanted to go from having "fuck you" money to having "own an island" money.
When you're at the higher levels in a company, your fate is tied to a lot of other people's. You're not just going to bat for yourself. Sure, you can burn your bridges, throw your subordinates and their projects under the bus or leave them to the wolves, and merrily dance into the sunset with your "fuck you" money or whatever. That takes a type of mindset that is antithetical to being in that position in the first place.
> I would be quite relieved if my boss instead says "Johnson, I'd like to rip your arms off and beat you to death with it. Now get back to work."
I'm amazed by the extent you try to rationalize how this form of abuse and unprofessional behavior is acceptable.
First, you fabricate this whole fictional scenario to try to distract your insinuation that the comments were made out of context. You provided no context at all, only a fabricated scenario.
Then, your choice is not between being bullied or being fired. Your choice is between being bullied and not be bullied. People prefer to be treated with respect. Do you think it's normal and ok for you to be insulted and humiliated like that?
Just because some people lack self-respect and self-esteem that doesn't make it ok to be bullied.
I wonder why you're getting downvoted. Maybe HNers nowadays are the type of people who fantasize about saying exactly such things at the workplace. Wouldn't surprise me.
> I wonder why you're getting downvoted. Maybe HNers nowadays are the type of people who fantasize about saying exactly such things at the workplace.
There seems to be a type of people who go way of their way to be stans for leading silicon valley characters. For them, their idols are unable to do any wrong or harm. They think that when they idols are acting like assholes, that must be impossible and there must be layers to that. The absolutely last layer of that fictional stack of excuses is always some rationalization of brilliance, and a show of love for the Stan. So all the wrongs their idol does always ends up being a right.
So here we are, with people claiming that a history of extreme abuse is somehow a good thing because... Because what?
It's just words. If you dont like how you are being spoken to at work: find another job.
And while at it be happy that you live in the US where free-speech (apart from anything related to a particular middle eastern country) is not being cancelled like in Europe.
All that safe space bullshit: as long as no physical violence is being done to you, you can either stay or quit.
The OpenBSD mailing list? They sure don't make 'em like they used to!
Personally, I pin the blame for horrible employment dynamics on the ever-consuming paperclip maximizing global economy that drives the foundational power imbalance to begin with. In an ideal world, it should be easy for anyone to say "I consider this communication style abusive. Stop or I am going elsewhere", right? Framing the situation in terms of pitting people against other people is a standard bought-and-paid-for pop culture narrative, encouraging us to ignore that "invisible hand" picking most of our pockets.
Thanks for posting that. I tried finding it yesterday after reading a story on it. Seeing the video, it comes across more as a bad joke than the abuse portrayed in the article.
Honestly, I was readying my pitchfork when I heard about this video and could not find it yesterday.
But watching it today, it comes across as if Jenson really wants everyone to understand what the french guy is saying (because he knows the Mistral guy has a lot of good things to say) and he knows that no one has a chance of understanding him. The little in the video I heard the french guy talk, I would tend to agree with Jenson.
The press has been very unfair using all sort of salacious headlines - and I don't think directly racist/sexist but the 'Chinese Sex Spy' thing is borderline. It's just too much for them not to use as click bait.
The result has been massive disinformation among the general public.
This happens when people commit a social harm (cheating on wife) ... the emotional stain of that just carries over into everything else.
Tech Bros are often lacking in empathy, they're not always the most civil people.
It's bad.
There are a lot of unknowns.
I see a lot of regular people jumping on the bandwagon screaming that 'circular financing' is fraudulent (it's rational but risky, not fraudulent).
Making assumptions about Jensen's culpability.
All sorts of things.
Gary Marcus and Ed Zitron make really great points, but they are also 'extremely biased in the other direction'.
2 of 3 'Godfathers of AI' are needlessly scare mongering.
That fool Kevin O'Leary is on TV all the time as the 'face of Data Centres' I can't imagine a worse representative. Trump as well.
And a lot of otherwise respectable people caught up in misinformation.
This is a result of infotainment, and ideologically driven news.
Very bad situation.
Personally, I think Jensen was not knowingly involved in spy stuff, and wasn't doing anything but trying to sell GPUs. He followed the letter and intent of the law it seems. Nvidia works with US Gov and did everything asked. The sleepign with workers is bad - but - 'conflict of interest' is not inherently wrong. Adults can be Adults. I think an investigation into both would be necessary. I also think that 35 years of building that from scratch 'counts for something'. I don't think we can live in a world were 'a mistake is career death' - this is extremely bad for innovation and turns CEO's in to mindless robots.
If Jensen was found to be actively avoiding sanctions - he must leave, and possibly face sanctions. If the 'sleeping with staff' was coercive - he has to go. But there's a lot of grey in those areas.
The Board may be acting on decisive information we do not have - or - it's entirely plausible they are fearful and just being 'very PC risk averse'.
All of the revelations (bribes and export busting) or just the spicy ones (affairs)? What else will we learn in the oversight meetings Jensen and Nvidia have agreed to?
By all accounts, he was a pretty unpleasant boss, and NVIDIA is a pretty unpleasant company. I'm also not sure why people are so hellbent on supporting him.
If you're a startup founder, aspiring startup founder, or trying to ride the AI wave in any way, you'd want to keep the circular financing accelerator going. Or a retail investor who made a lot (or even a little) on NVDA and now considers any attack on a giant corporation as a personal sleight. Motivated reasoning leads you to poke holes in superficial parts of news coverage, use whataboutism, conspiracy thinking, etc to reach a predetermined position.
It's grimly fascinating to watch examples on Reddit of someone who owns a few shares of NVDA post start posting dozens of Jensen Innocent comments in every thread they can find, accusing anyone who pushes back of being a short pushing FUD to hurt Nvidia.
With zero self awareness that they are the one doing the very thing, with the same financial incentives that they baselessly project onto random NYT journalists, Reddit users, analysts, etc because of their own financial interest.
It's telling that the market is flagging right after Jensen was ousted. My take is that Jensen personally enabled the bubble over the objections of anyone around him willing to display a modicum of defiance, and now those same people are running the company.
He seemed like a cool guy. I was looking forward to having him lead the first post-AI wave of gaming GPUs next year, I was devastated the day the news broke, and to be honest I'm still holding out hope for a good redemption arc. When it comes to non-billionaires supporting him, I don't think the story is any more complex than that.
> looking forward to having him lead the first post-AI wave of gaming GPUs next year
Seems far fetched that there will be any production room for gaming GPUs. Jensen was already signaling nvidia would not be doing those because data center GPUs are too profitable.
Frankly I think the Silicon Valley tech-types come out looking a lot worse that the "mainstream media" that is everyone's favorite bugaboo.
Jensen Huang had an affair with someone who, if not a Chinese Spy, was an exec at one Nvidia's biggest foreign customers whose obvious goal was making NVidia chips available to China, even if in a legal manner through leases. It takes an incredible amount of hubris and narcissistic rush to do that. And then he also had an affair with someone he directly managed and apparently someone else at the company.
Those are things Huang did of his own volition, and I hear so many apologists talk about "war on open source models". Get a grip, his actions are clearly untenable by themselves. And even if there are people who do have ulterior motives in Huang's downfall, he certainly gave them all the ammunition they needed. And the SV types are basically saying they don't care about his transgressions because they think he'll make them all richer. The ultimate "morality doesn't matter when you're rich" viewpoint.
I don't think Huang is the antichrist, but I also don't think anything that has happened (which is really just losing his job at Nvidia) is anything but the consequences of his own actions.
> What I’m struck by however is the mix of the omnipotence of the Silicon Valley elect — the billionaire-founder CEOs and their mostly centi-millionaire hype-men/attendants (call this the David Sacks class) — combined with the equal reality that it does not seem like any of these guys have entirely absorbed just how staggeringly unpopular they and their entire industry has become. They also don’t seem to have grasped how unpopular Trump — with whom they’ve cast their lots — has become. They and Trump are locked in this kind of superhero electro-hug in which each is making the other more unpopular, a kind of electrical transfer and mutual intensification of unpopularity.
I don't know what to think of the subject but it's been alarming to hear so many TV reporters and talking heads mispronounce "Nvidia." It's worth trillions of dollars and a lot of the people shaping public opinion of the company became aware of it only weeks ago. (The star of SNL's opening sketch managed to screw up the names of both Palantir and Nvidia in just a couple of minutes.)
The pronunciation of Nvidia seems awfully unimportant to me.
Doubly so since it's just a made-up word which leaves people to come up with their own pronunciation (Sure, Nvidia may have an "official" pronunciation, but not a lot of people are going to worry about that.)
People come up with their own pronunciation for a word when they learn it without talking to anyone who knows the correct pronunciation. If the guy next to you at the bar mispronounces chameleon that's a pretty good indicator that anything he tells you about chameleons is just something he read on the internet - which is fine for the level of trust you put into information shared by people at the bar. If someone claiming to be a herpetology professor mispronounces chameleon, then they are lying about being a herpetology professor, or at least about being a good one.
> Sure, Nvidia may have an "official" pronunciation, but not a lot of people are going to worry about that.
You should be very concerned if journalists are not among the group of people who worry about that.
I'm sure that the ends justify the means for pretty high levels of evil means for that particular group of people, it's heartening that all of society doesn't feel that way.
Everyone should be held accountable, no matter how "important" a person is. Society seems to be slowly reducing to one big cult of personality, and that's really, really bad. Taking steps in the opposite direction is a healthy thing.
Huang was constantly shouting from the rooftops about how thinking is dead, all jobs will be replaced with AI. Then when he was asked what people should do he just shrugged his shoulders and essentially said “not my problem.”
What I don’t understand is how he (or any AI booster) could possibly believe the general population wouldn’t hate him.
Well yeah, literally nothing has changed in terms of any of the NYTimes's grievances - CEOs aren't going to sleep with fewer of their subordinates, generative AI will still put journalists out of work, everything will still be expensive, something something datacenters, etc. etc. - except now number goes down instead of up, which means mom and dad can't afford to keep paying Melanie and Sarah's rents to stay in New York to write for the New York Times's travel section for basically free. Okay, so it is some kind of agonizing, self destructive thing, they are trading in New York Post style scandal, and they'll reap the rewards.
It's important to realize that "tech voices on X" are a very specific and rarefied demographic. These are people likely to work in AI or AI adjacent fields and people who are likely to own AI related stocks. Huang could have ate a baby during the Superbowl halftime show and they'd want him back in charge of Nvidia Monday morning.
The general public sees a guy who had an affair, lied about it to his own board, was immediately caught in a second affair, and who was also engaged in some shady money stuff they don't really understand that made a lot of data centres possible, which they are more likely to be against than for.
BTW, lying to your own board is actually pretty serious. It's probably why Nvidia's board wasn't willing to immediately take him back.
On reddit there's been a weird pattern of sudden Huang fans just showing up with lots of oddly vague conspiracy theories. It's weird... those folks weren't there praising him before and equally weird is their effort to push a very insinuated sort of conspiracy theory, but also they seem shy about what exactly they're insinuating.
Getting caught in the sights of things like violating sanctions or ITAR is an existential threat to your company. No matter how instrumental you think he is to the future success of Nvidia, there was immense pressure weighing on the board to remove him and he clearly understood this.
> Right now the strongest form of possible accusation is that nvidia sold chips to someone who then ferried them to someone on the blacklist.
From here there are immediately stronger forms:
1) they fully should have known, because they are a nationally significant manufacturer of export-controlled items and get advice from all across government, and "Singapore-washing" is a widely understood phenomenon, and therefore they are very significantly negligent, which probably breaks the law itself.
This is IMO completely unarguable.
2) they did know they were doing it
It seems impossible to argue then that since they didn't stop when it became obvious that Singapore-washing is a thing, they were continuing in the knowledge that they were, effectively, breaking that law.
3) therefore it is really impossible to argue against the idea that he knew because he was sleeping with one of the major beneficiaries.
4) if he knew, and didn't stop it, he personally made a choice to continue to violate the law.
You can get all the way to 4) without ever considering the possibility that there's actual evidence chips left Singapore for China. And yet there's so much circumstantial evidence that a highly plausible route from Nvidia to e.g. Century Litong (and therefore benefiting DeepSeek) actually existed.
If you were to argue that it gets no further than 1), you're essentially making the argument that Jensen Huang is just an ignorant idiot. I wouldn't make that argument.
Are you arguing that Nvidia aren't a nationally significant manufacturer of export-controlled items? That is not something that can be debunked, because it is true.
That they (and Jensen Huang) wouldn't therefore have been constantly monitored and in contact with the State and Commerce department (diplomacy, compliance, advice, all that)?
That they didn't know and weren't advised Singapore-washing is a thing? They should have known this at the very latest by May 2025, because that is when they were first asked for records about Megaspeed. That is not debunkable.
They were almost certainly advised it was being investigated well before that. Singapore police were known to be investigating Megaspeed in February 2025, and Singapore was prosecuting a smuggler then too — Dell servers with Nvidia GPUs.
Reuters first reported evidence of smuggled GPUs way earlier than that — in 2023, and then there is this, in the South China Morning Post, also from 2023:
Do you think nobody at Nvidia reads the South China Morning Post? Or are you arguing that they were not negligent even if they did know?
Or that negligence is not something export law cares about?
Any links you have about how it was debunked would I am sure be interesting. Because, come on, you should really be stipulating. And from there, we can move on to 2).
Actually there are KYC requirements in these export bans. Even selling to a distributor in the US that exports to China can create meaningful exposure if you don’t do any due diligence.
>> Right now the strongest form of possible accusation is that nvidia sold chips to someone who then ferried them to someone on the blacklist.
Based on extensive investigative journalism by NYT, WSJ and others, there appears to be strong evidence that NVIDIA was not only fully aware of what was happening, but also their sales team actively worked around US export controls in order to sell more chips, and this was sanctioned and even encouraged by Jensen.
Right now Jensen's only possible saving grace is that these chip sales to Megaspeed were approved by the Dept. of Commerce under Lutnick. Lutnick, though, seems to have his own finger in the pie and profited from NVIDIA's behavior.
The whole thing stinks to high heavens and IMO it is very unlikely that Jensen is innocent. My guess is that he will be pardoned by Trump at some point, either pre-emptively or after a conviction.
If Lutnick skates, then Jensen Huang arguably even deserves a pardon; it would be unjust, I think, to punish him for lawbreaking that the Commerce department knowingly enabled, if there are no consequences for Lutnick. I would hope that is the outcome for him in that scenario.
Not least because as a non-American who uses open weights models, my view is that Chinese open weights competition has made US open weights models better, I think this is a view Jensen Huang holds and if it were me in that position I would be making a stronger case for that than turning a blind eye.
Then again, I don't think anyone in Trump's cabinet really deserves to skate if the USA is to justifiably regain its reputation for anything other than kleptocracy, and if this is the thing that ironically finally nails Howard Lutnick then so be it.
If I ask my corrupt friend in government to give me special treatment and they do, I am absolutely not off the hook for any of that. It doesn't matter who gets away with what, if the crimes were committed, anyone that we can convict, we should, and those people should be rightly punished.
What I mean is conditional. If you are not going to censure the Commerce secretary for knowingly allowing Nvidia to break export laws, then it seems churlish to punish any individual at Nvidia for it.
If Lutnick is on the hook, so ultimately is Jensen Huang.
But if Lutnick (who is the ultimate person in charge of Commerce and BIS) decided not to enforce the law, and isn't in a difficult position as a result, then was there a violation? It's more or less his decision alone.
It's worth noting that the Commerce department isn't an abstract legal and policy shop that is only tangentially connected.
They literally have police: BIS. AFAIK it's Lutnick's police who would be arresting Jensen Huang for smuggling.
To get Jensen Huang arrested for violating export laws (which to be clear I think there is evidence of), Congress is going to have to get Lutnick or his successor to do it. As Bessent said: "Commerce has the pen".
Lutnick has pretty broad, largely unreviewable discretion under the law to not simply enforce the law in individual cases. So if Congress disapproves, Lutnick is the first person on the hook.
If Lutnick knew and decided not to punish Nvidia or Jensen Huang, and he isn't himself censured/charged with not carrying out his responsibility, there perhaps isn't anyone else who can convict Jensen Huang of smuggling.
Which is part of why Huang's testimony on the Hill is such a vulnerability: he can be charged with lying to Congress!
Not at all. Just observing that it is important for opponents of the administration to be aware where culpability lies when it comes to the smuggling; the "national security Democrat" position here should be to get Lutnick first if he gave it the nod.
Where Jensen Huang is concerned, I am much more interested in the thing that risks putting people's livelihoods and savings at risk in more than just America: the circular financing.
Companies are punished for selling to intermediaries who went on to violate laws even when the company didn't know it. I've worked for one who still got fined despite not knowing and fully complying with the investigation.
And the reporting is exactly that he has the attention of the federal government. We are talking about risk management by lawyers not standards of innocence at trial.
We simply don't know. That is why we have a legal system and the principle of 'innocent until proven guilty'.
As for the ITAR stuff, it amazes me that in the same planet when major banks routinely (routinely!) do money laundering for drug cartles, organized crime, financial fraudsters, foreign intelligence agencies, white slavers, ..., and yet never seem to suffer for it and none of their exectives were iirc given this treatment in press and business world.
What is far more concerning than a single possible instance of failing to adhere to such laws is the fact that both the free press and the government think so little of the general public's opinion and intelligence that they pursue their political fights in guise of "adhering to the laws of the land" and "patriotism", to say nothing of "family values" and "abuse of power for sexual gratificatin".
"The term accelerationism (specifically in the form of Accelerationists) first appeared in a book in Roger Zelazny’s 1967 science-fiction novel Lord of Light.
The Accelerationists are a revolutionary faction (aligned with the protagonist, Sam) that advocates for the rapid, unrestricted deployment of advanced technology to shatter the ruling pantheon's stagnant monopoly and propel society forward."[0]
It's funny - for a long time I thought Nick Land invented the word in the 1990s through the Cybernetic Culture Research Unit (CCRU) at the University of Warwick.
These organisations should be democratically run with its leadership democratically elected. Each employee should have a share of the ownership of the company.
As technology progresses, this extreme concentration of power is incredible dangerous.
I don't even know what a given CEO getting fired would have anything to do with "accelerationists".
Huang or not AI is going to develop none the less...
There's a lot of internet meta talk about AI that I think is completely disconnected from whatever will happen. You might be able to win some sort of meta war on the internet and maybe influence some politics, maybe, possibly, but actual tech wherever it goes, I don't think so.
Firstly Jensen was an accelerationist, particularly in promoting open weight and AI for all.
Secondly, he was the shot caller at Nvidia, which is the central bank of AI. Nvidia could easily sit their collecting risk free profit but they didn't. They backstopped financing and pumped up deals to push AI hard. They hardly sat on their britches like a lot of tech companies do (looking at you Intel when AMD was floundering).
There is a good reason why Sam Altman said it's hard to imagine the singularity without Jensen. Jensen had an unwavering ability to take huge bets on AI being the future.
But he didn't break the law as far as we can tell. Obeyed its letter whilst violating its spirit, probably, but that's not breaking the law. Nvidia has impeccable lawyers for this I'm sure.
Are you good with Elon Musk spending $444M to buy a state or cutting off Starlink to Ukraine? Neither of those were illegal either. I'm curious where the bar really lands.
And yes, moral relativism. Seems to be a best practice here now given the results of the 2024 election.
The most likely reason he was fired is that the company’s lawyers and Board think he broke the law, and their job is to protect the company. To continue to employ him after they came to believe he broke the law could make the penalties even worse. They won’t come outright and say so, of course, as that would violate attorney-client privilege.
You’re not an insider, and are not in possession of all the facts. (Admittedly, I’m not either, but as an attorney, I can put the pieces together.) The insiders know much more than either the press or the government. That said, there are plenty of factual and legal analyses out there that, if true, give the Government plenty of fodder to indict, if not convict, Nvidia and Huang himself.
Besides, why do you (or really, anyone here) care whether Jensen Huang got fired? What impact does it have on your life?
Or they were shown things by the same people behind this outing that they would rather no one else ever see. It was awfully sudden and now you're going to tell me there's absolutely nothing suspicious from the first revelation coming out on Saturday and his resignation on Thursday. Nope, nothing to see here. move along. Heaven forbid they put him on leave until the conclusion of a deliberative investigation after leading the company to 6 trillion in valuation over the past 33 years.
It is really interesting that Garry Tan reports that all but three members of the board already want him back. so maybe you're full of s***. Why would they want him back if they know he's violated the law and Congress is about to try and make an example of him?
> Garry Tan reports that all but three members of the board already want him back.
"Wanting someone back" may be merely a sentiment. Hearsay of statements of general support are not the same as a vote to rehire in a closed-door board meeting. If all but three members of the board truly wanted putting Jensen Huang back in the driver's seat-regardless of the legal jeopardy it could put them in-they'd have a board majority, and he'd be back. The fact that he isn't should tell you something. Most rational people think staying out of prison and avoiding a felony conviction is more valuable than the gains on one's equity, regardless of how great they are.
Because I work in AI and all the alternatives to CUDA are pretty much different forms of dreadful wrapped in cope (although if I had to, I would choose the TPU). I would like cheaper GPUs, but they don't seem to dropping in price at all over this.
None of this tells me anything other than this was a rush to judgement as the spy story has already fallen apart, deprecated to something something channel stuffing to China. Wonder what the next week will brin?. It would be pretty stupid to bring him back before he testifies to Congress, but stupidity seems to be catching these days.
I'm not sure how you've concluded that throttling Starshield was legal. We're talking about a US defense contractor restricting critical military communications infra. And if any of this was coordinated with Russia, that opens up a whole different set of potential legal issues
And you're about to watch nothing be done about it because Jensen Huang is the brand new shiny. And that blue wave which was glorious is about to become the great blue waste as they fail to do anything about the Iran war or inflation either.
Good grief, the lack of humility and the degree of hubris are equally appalling. A company is not one single person. And also, a single person is responsible for their actions. I don’t know what’s happened in SV to create this mass delusion or willful ignorance for the greater good. Granted SV has always had a technocratic libertarian tilt, but the SV discourse circa Nvidia post-Jensen is so incredibly out of touch with common human decency, just because you might make an extra buck. Shameful.
I scanned all of the NVIDIA board's public statements about Huang's resignation, and the only one with any substance was "disclosure of personal behavior inconsistent with the company’s code of conduct, standards, and cultural norms".
Could the board be held liable for retaining him, once they undeniably knew about him having an ‘undisclosed’ relationship with a subordinate, if they didn’t fire him once the press revealed it?
For that to be meaningful you'd need evidence directly showing knowledge of the affair prior to the public leaks. If you had evidence of cover ups that would also make it a much stronger case compared to having known or heard rumors and done nothing.
The board said he mislead them for over a year on the affair(s). That's more than enough to be meaningful for a company board who wants to avoid the liability he was in the process of bringing on them.
Assuming that ends up to be true, I agree. As it stands I haven't seen any real proof and am curious how said affairs could have gone on known for so long, the more simple answer in my opinion does seem to be that the affairs were known and ignored until it became politically or financially valuable.
Whether or not they were ignored is only material because the board (presumably) fired him; otherwise they would have accepted the risk of liability by retaining him. So it doesn’t necessarily matter whether they knew when evaluating if they made a corporate-correct decision: reducing liability to the controlling humans in exchange for cutting off a source of public drama seems like a double-win, no matter what degree of prior knowledge exists.
All the drama about violating export controls doesn’t put the board individually at personal risk as much as sleeping with one’s reporting managers under U.S. labor laws does, so it remains no surprise that they backed him until he was found out to have done something that could threaten them. The U.S. isn’t very likely to conduct open discovery and court trial for a natsec violation, for example, and having Jensen’s actions expose the entire company to discovery and retention risks is far more costly a threat to the company than some measly government slap on the wrist for wink-nod sales to ‘Singapore’.
Much of this would end up at the whims of a judge or jury, its hard to say what would happen.
I do expect it would go much worse if evidence were to indicate that the board knowingly hid the affairs or even the spy concerns. Similarly, with regards to violating export controls I'd expect that would hinge on showing knowing action taken by the board to violate controls. If they can push it off on Jensen or walk the line of hardware going to allowed countries and Nvidia having no control over who they lease to is yet to be seen.
You aren't in charge of a company like Nvidia without being very smart and being good at covering your ass. I won't be surprised if there are little to no crimes that were technically violated or can be proven in court.
He has admitted to and been credibly accused of gross misconduct even if you ignore the spy question and the chip smuggling. Any of these issues by themselves would have gotten him fired including his children, their unjustifiable positions, and their behavior.
He has exposed the company to liability and well-deserved reputational damage.
Nvidia is also not a stranger to dubious accounting/reporting behavior.
The most baffling thing is watching tech losers line up to defend the guy and ask for him to be reinstated.
If NVIDIA has been skirting export controls, I do not expect them to disclose that publicly and embrace the legal risk. Best to give a non-committal, "Not in line with our values" kind of statement.
Like a C-suite who who is leaving to "spend time with the family", a CEO is only ever going to be kicked out for a non-criminal, defensible reason. Unless the crime was so blatant and inexcusable they need to get in front of the legal liability.
That’s because they are not going to admit that they suspect he broke the law on the company’s behalf in a public statement. It’s an admission and would be used as a basis for a criminal conviction.
For all his faults regarding his control of his delinquent member, coupled with the obvious export smuggling ring, and now perhaps accounting fraud (new SEC investigation, may end up being just a rumor) I did appreciate that Huang was sensible in the sense that:
1. Didn't pearl clutch or make every issue around Silicon Valley an "AI issue". A lot of drivel commentary and political mileage can be had by just demonizing AI. He was rather sensible versus the pervasive hyperventilating and in my view, self-serving (oss models getting too good) talk coming out of other leaders in the space.
2. Didn't treat China as the enemy. Said openly it's good for the world if China uses AI to solve cancer, etc.
Obviously in retrospect maybe he sort of overindexed on #2. But on the flip side, it doesn't seem the US government actually wants to confront China. They essentially let this export smuggling slide and knew about the spy.
Are they alone? No Americans I know want to fight China. What throng of Americans is relishing annihilation in Taiwan? We can't even subdue one of the most backward, poorest nations on the entire globe. Americans want to follow up Afghanistan, Iraq and Iran with China?
So really, in a world of madness Huang felt quite sensible. No AI isn't going to by necessity kill us all. No we don't have to think of this as a zero sum competition with China. We can try to be sensible about this.
Then it turned out he was fucking a spy and multiple other women who were not his wife. He fell for the oldest trick in the book. Sad someone who seemed so sensible will forever be famous for being so exposed as a fool.
I am still struck that his two general points were more or less correct. But indeed it is not good now to be associated with ideas he championed. Perhaps this was the greatest success of this whole ordeal, if one takes the manner of his rise and fall to not be wholly unrelated to some species of sabotage.
No one here knows the full details of what happened but my impression of it that his fall was politically engineered by someone from the admin leaking to the press and likely leveraging important people in the industry as well.
My point with this being, can Silicon Valley really permanently entrench political power in the US?
If expensive gas was enough to shakeup things at the midterms what kind of politics would be ushered in if unemployment skyrockets to 20%+
Will all the many crazy things the tech leaders have said in the last few years come back to bite them if the masses are truly in dire straits and looking for targets to blame?
The Palace Intrigue reporting is always fraught with selective leaks and gossip, but it appears to also be part of the rift between Howard Lutnick in Commerce and Scott Bessent in treasury.
Unfortunately Jensen enabled it. Sure, the timing of the leaks is suspect. It seems like Trump ok’ed the release as a way to ensure his prediction of a market crash if the dems won. But we wouldn’t be here if Jensen could keep it in his pants.
While everyone is entitled to their beliefs on the reason everyone else voted, I think it was the gas. Those who didn't like the blatant corruption voted against it in 2018, 2020, 2024, and again in 2026. The new people who voted blue did so for a new reason. In my view, it was the gas. If it wasn't for the gas, the votes would have been again 50% +/- 0.1%
I live in a very rural, very MAGA area. At least for those around me, the primary frustrations I hear are related to not releasing the Epstein papers, starting wars rather than ending them, never draining the swamp, and spending more money rather than cutting waste.
I do hear about fuel prices occasionally, but very rarely as a complaint linked to Trump.
What those folks are trying to express is that they picked an outsider to deal with the DC establishment and the promise was never fulfilled by said outsider. This most recent election is the same sentiments that got trump.elected the first time, but trying the other side again. Dems have a chance, not sure they can make the moment tho...
I do agree in theory, though I'm hesitant to speak on behalf of a group of voters.
There seems to be something to the read that voters recognize something needs to change in DC. The jury is out whether that'll happen, the machine is pretty damn resilient and most (all?) willing and able to change fundamentals at the federal level never seem to make it all the way into office.
> something needs to change in DC. The jury is out whether that'll happen
Chuckie Schumer trying to annointimg himself king (leader) and then move a secret vote once a challenger emerged... is not a good sign. Call or email your senators to say No to Schumer, they count issue stats for pro/con and contents can be used for their story times.
It was corruption and cost of living based on exit polls. Think it was just gas prices is reductionist and missing the bigger picture. You don't see Texas go completely blue just because of gas prices, not do you see the pushback from Dems base on Schumer if this was just about gas. There is also the tariffs, housing prices, health care, corporate price gouging.
Its all connected to pervasive corruption and politicians who don't fix things.
If we had anything like a democracy, all of these guys' heads would be rotting on spikes on the White House lawn already. The fact that they're not only alive, but breathing free air in their private jets with hot and cold running champagne proves that they are in actual fact above the law. People talk about some coming Silicon Valley Reich but it's very clearly already here. The task before us is to bring it down, not prevent it.
Good news. People are more aware. My observations have been that particularly younger factions on both the left and the right realize that its them (the technocrats) or us (the people).
It's highly likely the admin were (are) complicit in selling restricted hardware to China. I wouldn't be slightly surprised if the circular financing - which was completely obvious to anyone paying attention - wasn't Huang's invention.
So why kill Nvidia now? It's going to pop a carefully inflated hyperbubble and cause a depression.
the circular financing did a job - making sure nvidia's windfall continues to expand the whole industry, rather than high compute prices starving everything
Apparently the Trump administration was divided and the side that cared about smuggling Nvidia chips to China eventually won. The leaks to the New York Times were part of how they won.
Before Nov 3 Trump could continue to cover up everything and get away with it. Now he is incredibly weak and people that have been pulling very questionable shit are getting nervous.
Jensen’s fall, based solely on what we do know, was inevitable. There were too many fuckups in too many places for him to get away with it.
The proximate cause was Bessent pot shotting Lutnick. (Barring something really weird going on at Pennsylvania Avenue, that happened with the President’s knowledge if not consent.)
But the ultimate cause is Huang being a lying, corrupt sack of shit who went all in on Team Trump only for that bet collapse with the election.
Leaks to the New York Times were important in tipping them off, but their own investigation has been in progress for months. Funneling billions in exports to China apparently leaves a fair bit of evidence!
Jensen was vulnerable due to his own actions. Yes, often billionaires get away with worse, but not always, it seems.
This was already obvious years ago GPUs were going to China. You don't need leaks for it. There are videos of data center tours with nvidia cards in them. You can just open Chinese e-commerce sites and buy 4090 and 5090 non D versions which are supposed to be banned. Also the 4090 48gb mods? Seems like nobody gives a shit about those supposedly being the "non China version". So the leaks are nothing we don't already know.
Rubio's team was close to openly saying they were the source. This is about China hawks and export controls and Jensen was a roadblock to their goals so he was eliminated as a political force.
Maybe someone choose a particular moment to let the cat out of the bag. But the circumstances are such I don't think the facts could be ignored indefinitely.
> his fall was politically engineered by someone from the admin leaking to the press
I was discussing this point with someone today who didn't even know that this was started by US intelligence leaks to journalists. I have no sympathy for Jensen, but I find myself amazed that so many lack the basic media literacy to recognize a classic hatchet job.
I would amend the notion that it's the "admin" though - it's clearly the national security apparatus who decided he was out - the particular faction within it seems hard to identify.
I'll take the other side of that bet. I'm against the Great Man theory of history. Jobs, Bezos, Gates, Huang - the companies they started are now much more than the founders themselves.
It could also be they were the right man at the right time.
I mean for example Microsoft can't milk the desktop and small server market like they did back in the day. Now we have the internet, cloud, smart phones and so on. Or who knows, maybe Bill Gates would find something very profitable today, too.
Jobs was around for the ipod/iphone which is massive society defining device but I don't see how it follows that he would have come up with something better than black rectangle which the industry has been hovering around for the last 10 years.
Apple has done well with their M series chips with out him. Just because he was an idiot and took himself out at the top of the game doesnt mean he would have piloted Apple to where it is now.
Most companies go downhill, or at least become ordinary once the founfers leave. It's not necessarily about skill, but rather that founders care in a different way about the products, while later people in charge care more about the short-term bottom line.
The odds of any startup being successful are pretty low, so it's certainly notable when the same founder has multiple successes such as Jobs Apple (x2), Next and Pixar, especially when the personality/traits of the person seems directly related to the success.
Much as I dislike him, bit I think Musk also deserves credit for his serial successes, even if most of that is more in motivating others who work for him, and being willing to put his considerable personal wealth on the line.
> I'm against the Great Man theory of history. Jobs, Bezos, Gates, Huang - the companies they started are now much more than the founders themselves.
If the Great Man theory of history wasn't true, then Europe would have a bunch of successful tech companies, because founders would pop up randomly out of the large not-wanting-to-move-to-America population there.
What? If anything this shows the contrary, that structural forces create the conditions for certain organizations to be successful, even if they then become associated with particular individuals.
Europe has a very fragmented internal market for capital and labor; there's technically a single market for products and services but language barriers complicated things; there's not nearly as much capital looking for investment, in large part due to pension savings not being invested; there's a cultural propensity for regulating technology too early.
There are more than enough founders in Europe, it's just that Europe is a much worse place for a tech company to grow very large.
> If Jensen starts a new company in same field today, one day that company will be able to buy Nvidia
I doubt it.
He seems to mostly have been in right place right time.
Remember that not too long ago Nvidia was just making graphics cards for PC gaming. Nvidia/Jensen apparently did not themselves see the potential for non-gaming use of GPUs.
The way CUDA came about was via custom shaders (for gaming), which some scientific customers began "abusing" for more general GPU compute, which Nvidia only then supported by providing CUDA.
The scientific compute market is not that large, and I don't recall Nvidia making any Intel-like push to create demand for their hardware. In fact in 2012 when Geoffrey Hinton wanted a graphics card for his student to use for neural network use, Nvidia turned him down. AlexNet was what created the demand/publicity for GPU-based neural nets, and only after that did Nvidia add neural net support to CUDA in the shape of cuDNN.
The use of graphics cards for crypto mining was another accidental NVidia success of being in the right place at the right time.
By all appearances Jensen Huang is a shitty arrogant human being who abused people at Nvidia, installed a bunch of family members in high paying jobs there, fucked at least one direct report, tried to support the Chinese AI industry at a time when the US was trying to oppose it, and finally got caught with his pants down when the FBI was phone tapping a suspected Chinese spy.
The success of Nvidia as more than a PC graphics card company would appear to be due to whoever was managing CUDA, in at least semi-competent fashion, at least keeping up with customer demand if not foreseeing it.
Not in Silicon Valley, but from my perspective we are way past the "event horizon" of the "technological singularity". I don't think anything can stop the change now.
There's at least one scenario where I see this realistically unwinding and walking back from the potential for large scale job loss, doom scenarios, etc
If this is the tipping point of a bubble pop, companies that remain won't be able to light stacks of cash on fire and demand 40x multipliers on earnings.
Infrastructure already built would still be there to use, as well as the knowledge of how to build frontier models. Companies coming in would need to build financially viable business models though, almost certainly meaning smaller models with less functionality completing busy work rather than racing to AI.
The bubble pop would be painful either way, but that's a future that at least to me seems realistic meaning it wouldn't yet be a singularity.
However as you point out, infrastructure already built would still be available to use. Present day frontier models are the same. Those are already good enough to drastically accelerate the rate of scientific research, and as ML research has progressed algorithmic efficiency has improved by leaps and bounds.
Also consider the extreme markup on hardware that nvidia has.
So lets assume an unrealistic hypothetical where the bubble pops, frontier model R&D completely ceases, hardware R&D effectively stops, but the current generation of fabs keep running and the current cutting edge hardware is sold at a much more reasonable markup. Naturally cloud providers renting out large clusters at an hourly rate would still exist. Thus ML capabilities would be expected to continue to improve.
Now consider that those same ML models have also been shown to be able to accelerate hardware design. My conclusion is that we have entered a period of rapid innovation that won't be stopped (only slowed somewhat) by the economy crashing. The only question is what technological upper bound is reachable (ie the end point might or might not be the global ceiling).
Why is it unrealistic for the bubble to pop, frontier research to cease, and hardware R&D to at least slow down if not stop? And why would we assume favs keel running as today with lower markups?
If there is a bubble and it pops, it seems obvious that frontier research almost entirely funded by outside investment would have to slow way down or stop. With that market disappearing, hardware R&D and manufacturing would have to slow down as well, and given lower demand the prices would fall and that would ripple through hardware companies as well.
Whether there is a bubble and if it is popping is anyone's guess. I don't personally see how hardware fan could possibly continue at today's pace while both demand and their markup collapse.
I'm also not personally sure what would happen to frontier models if there was a liquidity crisis. In the dotcom bubble fiber was in the ground and just didn't have a user. Today data centers would exist but may not have users. The models are just code and data though, they could be sold to the highest bidder at liquidation or they could just go away, its less obvious with software rather than hardware.
> Why is it unrealistic for the bubble to pop, frontier research to cease, and hardware R&D to at least slow down if not stop?
It's not? I think there's been some misunderstanding.
I supposed a hypothetical where exactly that happened - the bubble pops and the entire economy crashes badly, the existing frontier labs go under, no one has the financial appetite to take their place, and hardware R&D nearly completely ceases.
I then observe that existing GPUs, datacenters, and frontier models would still exist, current generation GPUs would continue to be fabricated (silicon is incredibly cheap once the mask exists), and both inference providers as well as cloud services willing to rent anyone any size cluster on an hourly basis would continue to exist.
Combine the above with the observation that current frontier models display effectiveness as tools to drastically accelerate both hardware design and machine learning research. I think the presumption is then that fairly rapid progress on the theory would continue to be made despite the collapse of commercial funding.
Crucially even as models have been getting larger they've also been getting more computationally efficient by leaps and bounds. So total capabilities given only present day GPUs should be expected to continue to increase over time while token prices stay the same or fall (unless electricity becomes scarce for some unrelated reason).
A corollary to the above is that if things don't crash I expect progress will very rapidly increase to an almost unbelievable degree in the immediate future. As basis see for example the massive dump of mathematics proofs by openai last month. Things appear to be accelerating rapidly.
> Today data centers would exist but may not have users.
Tokens are quite cheap when compared with human knowledge workers - check the API prices on openrouter.
Some fields are obviously transformed forever (e.g. math), but we don't have robots walking the streets, and training runs still require gigantic data centers full of advanced chips and a human researcher to wake up and go to the office to kick them off.
There's no shortage of human researches to "kick them off" and won't be in foreseeable future.
Even if datacenter buildout would stop entirely today, there's enough datacenters to continue research. It would be compute constrained, but it won't stop.
Sure. I guess I'm wondering if there was some rogue agent or misuse incident (e.g. an autonomous wetlab synthesizing and spreading a virus that killed lots of people) serious enough to trigger a sweeping movement against further uncontrolled development along with strict regulation on the datacenter compute users. I feel there is already a lot of political will to domestically regulate, and just yesterday Trump announced joint guardrails with China to keep super intelligence from getting "too super".
We already possess the foundation for that (and many other things). The economy is a large system with lots of inertia.
It would take extreme levels of government intervention coordinated between all the major powers to stop ML from advancing significantly, and even then we'd still be experiencing drastic changes to the economy for years to come while the dust settled.
The gap in sentiment between most tech voices on X and mainstream media coverage of Jensen Huang is pretty incredible. The mainstream media coverage of the downfall of Jensen has been remarkably consistent and negative (almost gleeful), but you wouldn't know that if you read posts from any major VCs or tech figures.
> has been remarkably consistent and negative
Mainstream media coverage – not unlike X – generally _has_ tended to be consistent to the point of ~parroting one another on... a wide range of things, especially tech-bashing, for years now.
With respect, the fact that it's consistent is surely unsurprising – especially with the understanding that a lot of it is straightforwardly repetitious of the first source (esp. when the first source was itself _sourced_ from interviews, etc.), and the existence of a lot of journalist<>journalist groups / group chats.
And yeah, 'gleeful' feels right - excited for the excuse to heap negativity on AI.
What about the group chats for organized response among VCs/tech leaders/etc? Including the highly coordinated/visible reaction to Jensen's firing trying to reinstate him we're seeing now, or the previous successful campaign to bring back Sam Altman (which included sympathetic media types like Kara Swisher)?
As far as things that billionaires do, what he did was like a one out of ten.
Light treason?
What treason did he commit? Be specific.
Let's not make pedophiles our measuring stick...
well if we're going in this direction, cozying up to dictators and anti-democratic forces sure is common among the current crop of billionaires and political establishment in America.
And it's pretty much the American way, suck that down. And why is it the American way? Because it's a lot easier to pay off an autocrat to back our foreign policy than it is to pay off a democratic country full of people who can vote and protest about you. You don't like that, you don't like that, too bad, that's how it's worked so far.
Try reading The Dictators Handbook. It's very enlightening. Jensen's only mistake here was not maintaining his internal coalition to maintain his power. And that part's on him. The rest is propaganda.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dictator%27s_Handbook
they are the measuring stick though? unless something actually happens to the pedophile billionaires, theyvw got the US stamp of approval as exemplary american behaviour
It's a CEO's fiduciary duty to commit profitable treason.. or something like that.
What treason did he commit? Be specific.
If it’s true he told employees that their mom should have aborted them I think we can put it at a three.
Dude fucked a spy[1] and enabled somewhere in the hundreds of billions of dollars of business doing literal smuggling of banned equipment. Like if that's a one, what's a two?!
I think the disconnect here isn't about severity but just about "well, OK, but China isn't actually so bad". You're making a policy point, not a crime one. The crime thing is pretty obvious. And the solution to policy disagreements is democracy, not twitter.
[1] Well, OK, not a "spy spy" like a Bond Villain. She was only working for the Chinese government to enable import of illegal goods for state-directed purposes and lying about it while successfully seducing the CEO of the target company.
I fail to see the crime. The Megaspeed sales were approved by Commerce.
It was approved? I have only seen speculation of that on social media. Can you provide proof that it was approved?
I mean everyone under Trump is fine with committing treason supporting China and Russia so there is that. They do seem to be a bit concerned about being investigated in the last week or two so we'll see how that goes.
What treason is being committed? That's an extremely serious accusation.
Yikes, as it were.
So, first: as others are pointing out the approval for these deals is extremely unclear. Some are alleging involvement by the administration, no one has evidence of any such action.
Second: the executive branch obviously does not have the authority to wave trade embargos set by congressional laws. The crime would still have happened, you just might have an argument that Huang was an accomplice or underling.
Those would be facts to be argued before a court, in any case. I mean (again, yikes) it's really obviously this was criminal behavior! It's smuggling! Literally!
And having criminals in the C suite offices of public companies is widely frowned upon, so boards tend to remove them at the first hint of involvement. Which is what happened.
That the tech community seems to feel somehow unbound by this is (yes again), a "yikes" kind of thing. If you don't like the laws we have you work to elect governments to change them. You don't just YOLO your way into the bed of a spy and figure you'll get a pardon or whatever.
> Yikes, as it were.
It's funny that you're appropriating the langauge of last decade's social justice activists to act like I'm beyond the pale for not taking at face value the word of the national security apparatus (which, I should remind, has not done a single positive thing in the last 25 years).
> it's really obviously this was criminal behavior!
This is not obvious to me at all.
> YOLO your way into the bed of a spy
This is unsubstantiated sensationalism.
> This is not obvious to me at all.
There was no doubt that there was an export ban on this stuff. There is no doubt that the material went to the PRC anyway. That is presumptively a crime. You can argue exculpatory details if you want, or point to other actors with greater guilt, etc... But that becomes an argument you need to come to with evidence and not just "Well, I don't believe it".
Obvious character assassination in favor of closed, regulated weights. Trillion dollars of profit depend on it.
Obvious criminal activity in favor of ??? and vague fud about open source.
What's the criminal activity, and how is it obvious? Is it obvious because the NYT said it was?
selling chips around export controls
The sales to Megaspeed were approved by Commerce. If there's a problem, take it up with Lutnik.
Corruption needs two parties.
that's the only one we know about so far and if it was known they were going to others, still a problem, regardless if you agree with the rules or not
I've not seen any suggestion that Commerce ordered Nvidia to make these sales. Getting a government official to corruptly ratify your illegal decisions does not immunize you from responsibility.
>Getting a government official to corruptly ratify your illegal decisions does not immunize you from responsibility.
This is simply untrue and there is a well established legal defense known as "entrapment by estoppel" to protect a defendant against an act which has been explicitly sanctioned by a government official.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entrapment#Entrapment_by_estop...
Indeed there is, mea culpa. (Although Congress will surely be asking Jensen questions to probe whether he really "reasonably believed" that Lutnick's permission was consistent with the law.)
That's narrower than you think it is. As it applies in US federal court:
> The defense of entrapment by estoppel requires proof (1) “that a government agent actively misled him about the state of the law defining the offense,” (2) “that the government agent was responsible for interpreting, administering, or enforcing the law defining the offense,” (3) “that the defendant actually relied on the agent's misleading pronouncement in committing the offense,” and (4) “that the defendant's reliance was reasonable in light of the identity of the agent, the point of law misrepresented, and the substance of the misrepresentation.”
In short, entrapment requires that the government explicitly tell you that what you did was legal, that you relied on that information to decide to do it, and that such a reliance was reasonable.
I don't know the precise details of what Nvidia did with regards to evading the chips sanctions, but I suspect it involves a lot more of Nvidia lobbying the government to be exempted, at which point the entrapment is less likely to apply.
It is still illegal for them to sell chips when they will be laundered to China. It would not be illegal if they were just shipped to Malaysia and Chinese companies trained models there, but those companies were just empty warehouses. It is still illegal.
You sound very confident. Are you a lawyer or at least intimately familiar with the laws in question? It seems to me that Nvidia went through all of the proper channels to get the sales approved. You may not agree with the decision. You may even think it's conceptually treasonous—a term people on this site love to throw around—but that doesn't make it illegal.
https://archive.li/1V17b
i am not a lawyer, but i can read articles by people whose jobs are for looking into things like this. are you a lawyer? have you looked into what others have been doing around this story?
Where in the the linked article does it say that Nvidia or Jensen Huang broke the law?
Whether it's a problem and whether it's a crime are separate questions
Sure, but this subthread literally begins the question "What's the criminal activity, and how is it obvious?"
It's very fair to indicate that Jensen is not proven to be culpable, but there is obviously material suspicion.
Ah, that finally clicked… thank you.
So will there be a pressure on other countries to stop using open weight models? Is there already?
I would not call it pressure yet, but the existing EU law demanding watermarks for text and images clearly has a loophole because open models could be modified to circumvent this, so I'm just waiting for some sort of announcement that tackles that "issue".
It's doesn't actually have to make sense as a coherent policy, unfortunately.
Character assasination yes, but I doubt it has anything to do with the closed vs open weights battle. Much more likely the fact that Jensen was kowtowing to Trump and was among the tech oligarchs orbiting the administration. This is pure politics, as is par for the course with the NYT.
Politics is often downstream of economic interests. Why else would wealthy individuals and corporations “invest” in political campaigns and lobbyists?
There are many interests at play in politics beyond the economic. Reducing all motivation to money is a gross oversimplification of human psychology.
Issues of power, morality, identity etc. very often come before those of economics.
Jensen was involved with a great many things. His advocacy for open models does not absolve him of everything else.
VCs are opportunistic muck. Why is this a surprise.
> gap in sentiment between most tech voices on X and mainstream media coverage of Jensen Huang
About as wide as that between the former and most of New York and D.C.
There is a group of folks who have convinced themselves everyone is sleeping with subordinates, everyone is corrupt and everyone is flirting with commissions of treason. They’re wrong, but they’re wedded—through profit or sin—to those positions. Then the cult of the founder amplifies it across Silicon Valley, including with folks who aren’t doing anything wrong.
What treason did he commit? Be specific.
Undermining the security of the US by take your pick of: exporting over $100 billion of controlled goods to an adversarial state, likely leaking US secrets to a spy, bribing the President by "donating" to his stupid ballroom.
> Undermining the security of the US
That seems rather subjective. I would argue that many of the decisions of the national security apparatus (the network of agencies, think tanks, media outlets, and etc. that has been reveling in Jensen's downfall) in the last 25 years have undermined the security of the United States, but few would take me seriously if I called people like Bush, Cheney, McCain, and Graham treasonous.
> likely leaking US secrets to a spy
This is an unsubstantiated claim.
> bribing the President
Unfortunately not treason.
> few would take me seriously if I called people like Bush, Cheney, McCain, and Graham treasonous.
That's never been an uncommon sentiment in the United States. Where are you from?
"Bush is a traitor" is the type of slogan you see on a Code Pink protest sign, not a mainstream view or a literal statement about a meeting a legal definition. All of those figures are relatively well-liked, unfortunately, and treated with kid gloves by the same media that uncritically publishes "leaked" rumors about Jensen Huang and Alice Huang.
The Harris campaign trotted out Liz Cheney as a top surrogate in the closing weeks the 2024 race. I'm sure they would have crowed about a Bush endorsement if they had been able to get one.
Is there any evidence of leaking secrets or knowingly importing chips to China?
The ballroom... what a joke.
> The mainstream media coverage of the downfall of Jensen has been remarkably consistent and negative (almost gleeful)
This is especially true regarding The New York Times. Their first story was the exposé of the affair with the spy. I thought that was great work by NYT. Then they published a story on Nvidia board [1]. That story seemed to cross the line from reporting to advocacy on what the board ought to do. The board may have been influenced by it.
Since the initial story landed they have been milking the scandal for all it is worth. More recently, apparently because they are running out of material, they have started adding a form at the bottom of their stories: "Have you worked with Nvidia? We want to hear from you. What aspects of the company and its leadership do you think deserve more attention?"
The most recent story is almost gleeful [2]: "Threats, Insults, Settlements: How Jensen Huang Made Humiliation Routine". It has many Jensen Huang quotes that sound awful but they are pulled out of context.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/10/technology/jensen-huang-n...
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/20/technology/jensen-huang-n...
"Threats, Insults, Settlements: How Jensen Huang Made Humiliation Routine"
This is the worst because that kind of stuff requires an extreme amount of context.
Have they ever been in a sports locker room? Some of that may be justifies or not, and certainly sports stuff can be 'toxic' and not an excuse - but - context matters.
There are all sorts of ways to be 'assertive' and also a 'terd' and 'toxic' - it requires a lot of situational information.
100%. I have said the worst things imaginable to my best friends, and they have returned. I wouldn't say those things to someone I'm uncomfortable with or unsure could take it.
Did your best friends tell the New York Times about it? Sounds like if the story got out then someone in the conversation was not comfortable with it.
Could have been an innocent bystander or he could have been actually toxic. Who knows.
> Who knows.
I think we can safely say that the toxic empire is crumbling.
History knows cases of people getting ruined thanks to "innocent bystanders" overhearing private conversations on conferences and getting offended.
First, how many of that insults between you and your friends were meant and taken seriously?
Second, do your friendships have the same kind of power imbalance like in this case between a CEO and his subordinates?
Were your friends dependent upon you for their salary and ability to pay rent?
Fun banter takes a different tone when the person doing it controls your livelihood.
What context exactly?
All of these actions are bad in a locker room. They are arguably worse when done elsewhere. They were very bad when Steve Jobs did them. And they are very bad when other people do them. Why should we carry water for the Nvidia CEO and excuse such behaviour?
Because so many have carried the water for Elon Musk and Zuckerberg? I'm not defending it, but the double standard is obvious here.
By all means, take us to a timeline where none of this is acceptable, anyone, Bueller?
The downvotes have unanimously concluded that the hypocrisy will continue until morale improves.
> I'm not defending it
Are you sure?
So this is your way of saying what's wrong for Jensen Huang is OK for Musk and Zuckerberg? Jensen yells at people who disappoint him whilst following the letter of trade laws while Musk fires those who disagree with him on the spot and cuts off Starlink to Ukraine, and Zuck lives in his own deluded timeline, happy to meddle in the politics of other nations to deliver shareholder value.
What did I miss?
They are all terrible, with Musk at the top. Undermining the US is one thing but Musk is damaging/attacking Ukraine.
And so can you grasp that watching zero consequences for Musk whilst both parties hyper focus on Jensen Huang raises questions for me?
And Zuckerberg's gotten people killed too. Just not as directly as Musk. You can look that stuff up but nobody seems to give a rat's ass about it.
WhatsApp’s episode wheee it helped organising a genocide is something that keeps me away from the platform.
You're assuming an "acceptable" binary that just doesn't exist. Musk and Zuckerberg have structured their companies in such a way that they can't be removed from the top; Nvidia is structured differently than that, so its executives are subject to different standards.
Which is fine! Different companies should be free to organize themselves as they see fit. It's only scary to the gaggle of VCs and tech execs because they believe that it's unconscionable to have a powerful board of directors; in their view, anyone who founds a company and makes it really big is morally entitled to lead it for however long they'd like.
Funny, I got downvoted for pointing out exactly your assertion in another thread. But I agree with you so I guess we both need to be downvoted to demonstrate the error of our ways. I don't make the rules, I just note them.
Disagree.
Justin Trudeau - the Prime Minister of Canada made his adult female (and very progressive) Cabinet Members cry because they used he word 'crazy' to describe something odd.
He belittled them because they shouldn't be so 'offensive' to people with mental disabilities.
Now this is a form of 'toxic leadership' - and by the way a form of 'Woke Toxicity' - doubly degrading because the whole point would be nominally empathetic to people, but instead, he became toxic.
It's perfectly reasonable for some people to use the term 'crazy' and you don't get to destroy people because of some ridiculously high minded supposed 'social principle'.
If the word 'crazy' is offensive - then everything is offensive - and that is how toxic PC culture comes to the fore - by ignoring context.
1) dressing someone down because they are no up to a standard is perfectly legitimate - in context.
2) 'language' itself is contextual. Calling someone an 'idiot' is nominally wrong, but if anyone that I knew at work said 'oh my god you idiot, you pushed and broke he build' - that would be only technically inappropriate because I would not care. If it were done in a degrading, bullying manner - no, I would not tolerate that, but my boss - who is a good and competent person, saying that in colloquial terms ... I wouldn't care.
I don't care if people swear or use creative metaphors.
Some people are offended by use of any gendered language.
3) Humiliation is contextual. In some cultures any public disrespect is very troubling aka 'face saving culture'. In others, complete opposite.
The 'frankness' of Fins, Dutch, German would be considered toxic by some.
4) Proportionality. It's possible that some of he things hat Steve Jobs did was wrong - it doesn't mean we fire him over it. People have a lot of variation, they are going to 'cross lines'. Crossing lines itself has to be put in context. Jobs famously allowed people to 'push back on him' - and that is probably the truest test.
If Jensens was holding people up and calling them 'losers' in front of everyone aka "Ok, Amanda failed her objectives, she is the loser of the week this week - Amanda, explain to everyone why you are such a loser and how you're going to make up for it?" <- this might be considered 'tough leadership' by some - but that's just plain toxic an unnecessary.
Alternatively - Jensen highlighting 'The bottom 10% of sales performers' aka "At the bottom we have John, Chen, Suzie and Ricardo. Again Ricardo - this is two weeks in a row - this is not good ..." <- that's a bit questionable, but it's not toxic and frankly it's totally in bounds, and the kind of thing where you 'choose to work there or not'.
What did he call crazy?
Trudeau did not call anyone crazy - he chastised people for using the term.
He would yell at and belittle his staff - female Cabinet Members, who were by the way ultra-progressive empathetic 'woke' types for arbitrary use of what he deemed 'inappropriate and offensive language'.
This is the 'double example': someone doing something actually 'toxic' but doing it in the name of hyper high minded PC culture, aka use of an 'insensitive term' , in this case the word 'crazy'.
As in: 'Wow, that's really crazy!'
You wouldn't put the term 'crazy' in a Public Communication - but you can say that in private language, obviously.
But the PC police can come on hard for any deemed offence.
It's very plausible - especially in government - that someone takes up the Public Sector Union and HR because 'someone somewhere used he word crazy'.
This is PC toxicity and it's real.
It does not justify calling people ugly names etc - obviously. But 'context matters'.
So Trudeau said "don't call things crazy, because it's inappropriate" and the "PC woke police" responded to that with "omg! Trudeau said 'crazy', that's inappropriate!"? Sorry, this explanation doesn't add up.
I was bored so I looked the incident up and most of the outrage was (more believably) from the Canadian right. Trudeau reprimanded said minister for saying "crazy" and (in an undeniably weird choice) offered his preferred euphemism: "bananas." That's what the right found ridiculous and objectionable.
Others dug through his record and uncovered some clip where Trudeau referred to the job of Prime Minister as "crazy."
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/chrystia-freeland-unreliabl...
It was not 'the right' that found it 'objectionable' - it was his very own Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland, life long progressive, former MSNBC commentator, and author of the book 'Plutocrats' a treatise questioning the concentration of powerful interests etc.
She wrote about this issue, and many other things about JT in her book 'Bad Boyfriend', a rare rebuke by senior Cabinet Member of a PM's staff, reminiscent of the deluge of negative public statements about Trump, after his first term, because this kind of public rebuke is so rare.
Does she sound 'right wing' to you?
It's ridiculous that people would think to support obvious and actually toxic behaviour by a guy belittling his own senior cabinet members to the point they were crying.
Literally this thread is a 'pile on' of 'evil Jensen Huang' because he may or may not have made done some questionable things during meeting etc ...
... but as soon as an ultra-progressive guy does something overtly bullying and ridiculous - the 'tables turn'?
So these women who were harassed are just what?
'whiny women'?
Take off the political lens and try to see things for what the are.
If anything, this example lays bare the absolute hypocrisy of political standards.
'Context Matters'
Justin Trudeau - Prime Minister of Canada - belittled adult progressive female senior staff because they used the word 'crazy' in a completely benign context, under the auspices that said term ('crazy') was 'offensive'.
These are public allegations made by the Deputy PM of Canada 'on the record' Chrystia Freeland, noted progressive.
If you don't agree that this is 'PC Policing' then ... pick your own pejorative.
It's completely crazy (pun very much intended) to harass and belittle people for arbitrary use of the effectively benign language.
You can't have it both ways:
1) Was Justin's harassment and toxic belittling of women 'bad form' - just as Jensen Huang?
2) Or were his actions justified - because using the term 'crazy' in casual language offensive and toxic deserving of admonishment.
Pick your side.
Isn't it mostly bad when the attribution falls to the person ("you're crazy" or "you idiot") and less so, even tolerable, when the attribution falls to the action ("that's a crazy thing to do" or "that's idiotic")?
Or is this concern about where the attribution lands "toxic PC" in your view?
There's a subtle difference between the use of term as you have indicated, but in this case it was a woman using the term 'crazy' in reference to something not calling someone 'crazy'.
It's a very clear cut example of Toxic PC culture and also a 'double example' of him being 'actually abusive' in the pursuit of ostensibly cultural empathy.
I do not think his belittling in that way is justifiable as 'locker room talk' - however the use of the term 'crazy' is colloquially acceptable language aka 'locker room talk'.
> The 'frankness' of Fins, Dutch, German would be considered toxic by some.
You are attempting to explain myself and my colleagues to me. And we are absolutely not “frank” against persons, we are frank about actions and things.
Your intentional or mitt mixing of these concepts has no place among us, and it is annoying that you think direct communication on matters the same as abuse.
> What context exactly?
The context that favors one's own favorite narcissist, sociopath, etc.
No, the context that makes a scenario more objectively discernible.
I used to have your viewpoint, but then I worked in a large ineffective organization. You really do want someone who is a tyrant, and who can motivate people to move quickly.
In my case, leadership encouraged a lot of toxic empathy. We didn’t make hard decisions and didn’t move fast enough. We ultimately laid off a few thousand people.
I believe in the full utilitarian calculus it’s better to have a few people get verbal lashings than have many people lose their livelihood.
A common rebuttal is that maybe you don’t need to abuse people, or cause them to be afraid. But if this is the case I haven’t seen it work in practice. People in big organizations need to be scared for their jobs to burn the midnight oil, change course, or take risk. The alternative is that the organization stagnates and dies.
Whatabout toxic empathy is absurd attempt to deflect from ... straight toxicity and verbal abuse.
> I believe in the full utilitarian calculus it’s better to have a few people get verbal lashings than have many people lose their livelihood.
But this is a false dilemma. You can have both civilized discussion instead of verbal abuse and have people keep their jobs. It's just as simple as "You risk losing your job if..." rather than "I'll rip your arms off..." etc.
I worked with both these kinds of PHBs and in general the latter had worse staff as the talent preferred to work in more civilized environment. (But these were engineers, maybe middle management doesn't care.)
>People in big organizations need to be scared for their jobs to burn the midnight oil, change course, or take risk. The alternative is that the organization stagnates and dies.
Your claim is a false dichotomy. An organisation that relies on emotional manipulation and implicit threats to keep the gears turning is a deeply dysfunctional company. The common retort is Apple and Steve Jobs but this is a case of survivorship bias more than anything else.
I used to have your viewpoint, but then I worked in a large ineffective organization into which came a tyrant, who could motivate people to move quickly.
And, guess what, then it was a large ineffective organization made worse by waves of incoherent fear-motivated action rippling down the org chart as the people with the most direct contact with the tyrant moved rapidly to sooth his most recent rage directed at them and/or prevent the next.
Abuse doesn't solve structural problem, and the quick defensive reactions it motivates don't diagnose and find and implement resolutions for complex problems spanning multiple domains within a large organization, instead it exacerbates the trends of internal competition, fiefdom building, and acting in narrow immediate local self-interest that make large organizations inefficient.
There's been plenty of actual research done on what makes organizations effective. The top factor is psychological safety: subordinates need to feel safe in reporting bad news up the chain.
If they don't, you end up with Putin invading Ukraine because everybody's told him the army is in great shape and will be welcomed with flower bouquets.
> You really do want someone who is a tyrant, and who can motivate people to move quickly. [...] I believe in the full utilitarian calculus it’s better to have a few people get verbal lashings than have many people lose their livelihood.
Speak for yourself. If you want to play bootlicker to an abusive taskmaster, be my guest, that's your personal problem; you don't even need to come up with boring false dichotomies of the most transparent kind to justify it.
“He said jokingly,” for example. For what it is worth Nvidia has really high reviews on employee review sites for the work environment which is not true of many businesses.
Disingenuous calls for "context" are Whitewashing 101. Part of the standard Reputation Management playbook.
It's insolent and regressive to assume that 1) others are acting disingenuously or in bad faith, or that 2) context and details don't matter.
And, "Whitewashing 101 / standard Reputation Management playbook" is Redditesque conspiratorial hyperbole.
Unless they insulted him first the context doesn’t matter.
If you think insult is a good way of motivating you definitely failed that class.
This is why corporate anti-harassment policies exist. Smart leaders know not to say things that could be misconstrued in a harassing context because you do not want that fight to spill into the court of public opinion.
If you find yourself saying anything in a corporate environment that you’d defend as “locker room talk”, you already F’ed up.
The arbitrary assumption that some action is offensive because someone thinks it is is promoting PC toxicity, the worst part of corporatism.
See my example of Justin Trudeau (above) belittling (making women cry!) his Cabinet members for using the term 'crazy'.
Using the term 'crazy' arbitrarily was deemed by him apparently 'offensive to people with disabilities'.
The posture you are promoting here leads us all down the path to criminalizing all language: if the word 'crazy' is a form of harassment - than all language is harassing.
This is literally the Prime Minister of a major nation - the 'Top Person' in a culture and it rolls down from there.
Similar to Trump's actually bad treatment of people in other ways.
These things require context
> The posture you are promoting here leads us all down the path to criminalizing all language: if the word 'crazy' is a form of harassment - than all language is harassing.
That doesn't follow. You're being hyperbolic.
Ha, skimming the article, some of the insults are comical indeed:
"And he told another employee he would rip off the top of their head and 'pee on your brain.'"
That's a new one for me. I've heard the old "rip off your head and shit down your throat" one, but pee on your brain? Creative.
Maybe he was in the US military. Our drill sergeants in the USAF collected insults the way others collect fine art. One of my all time favorites was "Son, you're so ugly you'd make a freight train take a dirt road!"
Ha, that's a good one. When I went through USAF boot camp it was an odd time, they weren't supposed so insulting, no cussing, etc. Somehow it was supposed to be clean. This was back in the early 90s. Reality didn't quite keep up with policy, of course, but they didn't physically abuse anyone at that point.
I’m pretty sure that the reporters at the New York Times have been employed at a company before which is all the context you need. The article showed that he was being unprofessional and had to settle legal claims with his own HR department. The frankly juvenile quotes from Huang in the article don’t need any context. Actual quote from the article said to an executive in a meeting with multiple attendees: “pee on your brain”. I would expect better of a teenager let alone a CEO of a major corporation.
When there is a big power differential, you cannot make such comments in a non-toxic way. What you're describing is banter among friends, and even there you can easily miss the mark. But in a professional context when the person throwing around insults has the power to fire the people targeted, that is always toxic.
> in a professional context when the person throwing around insults has the power to fire the people targeted, that is always toxic
Not true at all. If I messed up, and I fear I am about to be fired, I would be relieved if my boss instead says "I'd like to rip your arms off and beat you to death with it. Now get back to work."
Context matters!
Yea, well if you said that to your boss, do you think you'd be forgiven for saying it?
The question at hand is whether it is abusive for a boss to say "I'd like to rip your arms off and beat you to death with it." And my answer is that the context matters. It is not necessarily always abusive.
Is that really the hill you want to die on?
Maybe it’s hill upon which we can rip their arms off and beat some sense into them with.
It sounds like they would actually appreciate it
If you don't think you could say that to your boss, you are in a toxic environment.
This isn't locker room banter. The CEO of a major company had extramarital affairs with three people, two of whom were his own employees. Context doesn't make any of this look better.
Disagree - you highlighted where context matters the most.
'Power' is a troubling factor in relations, and creates huge conflict of interest - but conflict of interest doesn't inherently make something wrong.
'Consenting adults are consenting adults' and can make their own decisions, in the end.
The problem was not 'the affair' its the fact there is a 'relationship in power structure hidden from oversight'.
It's the 'no transparency' that makes it a problem.
If he were to have told the Board about it, and then indicated he was 'divorcing his wife and marrying the lady' ... then they would have probably just handled that. Probably they would have to figure out another role for he lady.
This is why 'context matters'.
Well he can't marry all three.
Marry all three?
An affair is a problem because it opens the business up to huge liability if anyone believes the subordinates had different treatment due to the affair. It is also a problem because it is against the policy of the company, which has said policy for exactly that reason: liability.
> Have they ever been in a sports locker room?
Pretty sure Nvidia doesn't have anything to do with sports.
Creating and managing the biggest company in the world is even more of an exceptionally challenging environment than a regular 'sports team'.
Are we really doing "locker room talk" again?
That was the defense used in 2016 when Donald Trump's "I grab them by the pussy" tape was released.
Now the tech industry has sunk to the same level. What a sad ten years it's been.
Yes.
'Locker Room Talk' is not an argument that 'all language should be allowed' - it's an argument that context matters.
The inability to understand that - or - purposeful misrepresentation of the issue is a problem.
Calling someone bad names is almost always bad - it really does depend a lot on the name, now doesn't it? Pointing out that someone is in the 'bottom 10% of sales performers and had better do something about it' in front of peers is somewhere in the range of acceptable or not, depending on context.
I had a boss (someone much less powerful and influential than Huang) threaten to torpedo my career once if I didn’t do what he wanted. It sure didn’t feel like I was talking shit with the guys. It made me feel angry and small and scared that he might actually be able to do it.
> Have they ever been in a sports locker room?
Are we still running this playbook, coach? Everyone knows it. It's old.
> This is the worst because that kind of stuff requires an extreme amount of context.
LOL, sorry, these stories were told by insiders who were actually there, amongst lots of other talk about lawsuits, people resigning, etc. The actual story has tons of context. Nothing like a "locker room". Reading the actual story being discussed is helpful here.
Ive been in locker rooms my whole life and thats not locker room talk my friend. There is no context where saying that stuff is okay.
Agreed, "locker room banter" is not supposed to be actually aggressive or humiliating, and if anyone on your team talked like that it would instantly lead to half the team coming back at them. That's "locker room cancer" territory.
> Have they ever been in a sports locker room?
Grow some self respect. When I played sports, if someone dared treat anyone in the team like that they would be immediately be set straight. That sort of behavior wouldn't fly with opposing teams, let alone your own teammates.
You guys have a very twisted sense of how people treat themselves. None of this is ok.
What do you mean when you say that [2] is "almost gleeful"? I see this line a lot and I just have no idea what it's referring to. It seems like important and serious news if Jensen Huang made humiliation routine.
Perhaps he didn't make humiliation routine and they're not getting the full story? But you seem to also take issue with the NYT's attempt to find people with more information on Nvidia and get their opinions on how the company was run. What specific editorial choices do you feel they should make to cover this news in a way that isn't "gleeful"?
The New York Times has long been the mouthpiece of the national security apparatus. That's why they take a far less progressive position on Israel/Palestine than you might expect, given how they report on domestic social issues (which often swings too far in the other direction, like in the case of the 1619 Project).
Yes, that sounds very spooky and impressive, but you've failed to offer any suggestion as to why tanking nvidia is a national security interest.
They don't want to sink Nvidia. They just want to make it clear that opposition to the policy of export controls won't be tolerated.
I suspect the board was influenced more by lawyers who had been informed of various investigations.
NY Times is not a meaningful institution to the sort of people who would be invited to be on the board.
WaPo and NY Times are tools of such people.
Yes lawyers lead the whole process when you look at it. Shareholders have lost almost 50% of their value over 6 weeks or so but the board has to follow a process lawyers set to remain compliant in order to "act in the best interests of shareholders". There is insurance that ironically protects the board of directors from shareholder lawsuits which limits their own risk of making poor decisions.
Lawyers will start multiple class action lawsuits against Nvidia and Jensen and the board regardless and take a cut for themselves which will be taken from the corporation ultimately and it will do nothing to regain lost value for shareholders. The litigation will take time and money away from business processes that could be put towards recovering.
Even the hiring process of the new CEO will follow a process lawyers designed ostensibly in the name of reducing risk for shareholders that really may not be what is best for the corporation. Lawsuit aversion and legal compliance are not necessarily the same as the best business practice although we are told by lawyers it is.
I think the biggest problem is that a decent fraction of the board members have effectively no skin in the game, and they’re incentivized to be risk averse and dot their i’s rather than actually act in the holistic best long term interest of the company. A couple of them have less than $500k in shares (at the peak, now a quarter mill thanks to their bumbling). There are probably a decent number of commenters here that have more invested in the future of Nvidia than some of the directors. Certainly lots of the employees do.
The world was aware of the circular deals a year ago, the board knew or could infer even further back
Their skin in the game is not being personally investigated/ruined by playing ball with government now declining to consider bringing Jensen back being one of their obligations
Totally speculation of course
AI got kind of politicized. Trump took a strong stance on Nvidia and datacenters. Trump bragged about Nvidia's success and appeared with Jensen in public. That's going to attract negative attention.
Actually something kind of stunning to me about Jensen's downfall is how reckless he was about it. Someone in his position has to consider "am I doing something that could jeopardize myself and Nvidia"? Nvidia employees were the source on the second affair. He was that brazen about it. It almost seems like he wasn't aware people would come for him.
If you own a large, politically significant company like that I would expect you would CYA.
"More recently, apparently because they are running out of material, they have started adding a form at the bottom of their stories: "Have you worked with Nvidia? We want to hear from you. What aspects of the company and its leadership do you think deserve more attention?""
Hate it when the NYT reporters do their job. So annoying!
> He told one executive that his mother should have aborted him, according to one witness. He said he would rip both arms off a subordinate and beat the person over the head to death with them. And he told another employee he would rip off the top of their head and “pee on your brain.”
In what context are these quotes acceptable?
It's a quote from Trading Places. The Huangstser has good taste in movies.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukBOeHcMH_g
I've turned a corner on this.
All these supposedly abhorrent quotes make him seem normal as shit.
Maybe he was using humor as motivation.
> He said he would rip both arms off a subordinate and beat the person over the head to death with them.
When we were naughty as kids my mother lovingly told me or my brother that she would "rip off your arm and beat you with the bloody end". Dozens of times. This is not an exaggeration. She never did that though.
Later she would start it with "If you ever ride a motorcycle I'll..."
She never really did it?
She was your mother and you were a kid. That this is the first comparable thing that comes to mind shows just how sick it is for an adult to say that to another adult.
Maybe his parents said some shit to him when he was a kid, too, and he just had to take it, and abusing people he has power over, and the jackets, is his way of trying to work on that.
If you messed up at work badly enough to deserve being fired, what would you accept in lieu of being fired? Would you be willing to accept a stern talking-to?
I regularly have stern talking-tos with underperforming reports. These involve statements like "you are currently not meeting expectations, here's the plan that lays out the milestones and behaviors I expect", not threats of extreme physical violence.
Seriously: your sense of what is normal and acceptable has clearly been warped by an abusive family life or workplace culture. You really don't have to accept this kind of thing, and there are high performing, well paid jobs out there that don't require you to.
Agreed. Seeing their comments elsewhere reminds me of strict / borderline abusive parents berating a child's self-esteem as if it were the only way to motivate them. Lifelong issues in those cases even when the kids become adults.
The best feedback I received after a bad half was sombre, laying out my flaws and its impact on my own progress and the people I work with and the ceiling I'll have in my current trajectory. And whether that is what I wanted out of my career in that company. That straightened me in a constructive way that no amount of "abortion" abuse would.
> you are currently not meeting expectations
That language doesn't allow for gradation. If you are firing the guy it makes sense to use such formal language. If not you need more colorful words to let him know just how pissed off you are. And colorful language is acceptable if it is proportionate and you are known to be a fair manager overall.
I am not firing the guy. I am letting them know they are at risk of termination (I use those exact words later on, and they're repeated in writing in the plan), and spelling out exactly what they need to do to avoid that fate.
Rest assured, this conversation gets the message across loud and clear. Those who can shape up, those who can't leave or get fired. In neither case would it make any difference if I threatened to rip out their eyeballs and skullfuck them.
So in your opinion, threatening an employee with termination (no gradation, any shortcoming gets the same threat) is better than saying "Johnson, you have really fucked up this time. I will rip your limbs off if you make this mistake again."
I disagree completely. Being threatened with termination constantly will make me look for another job. Being threatened with dismemberment doesn't because I know to not take it literally, it is my boss's jovial way of letting me know he is really pissed.
I meet most of my reports weekly and have quarterly formal progress reviews. Rest assured, they will have received lots of feedback (in your terms, been repeatedly informed they fucked up) before we get to this stage and the word "termination" is ever uttered.
Also, you're still looking this from a weird angle, because personally blaming somebody for a fuckup is rarely useful. Sure, maybe you deleted the prod database, but what was the process failing that led you do to it? Why did you have that access turned on? Why was there no confirmation? Why didn't somebody else need to sign off? Any of these are much more useful than threats of violence.
Now if they're repeatedly failing to deliver, that's the kind of thing that will lead to the aforementioned conversation, but that's also quite different from a "fuck up".
> That this is the first comparable thing that comes to mind shows just how sick it is for an adult to say that to another adult.
Excuse me? I try to talk to my kid the way I talk to adults. And I try to talk to adults the way I talk to my kid.
so you tell both adults and your kids you will rip their arm out and beat them with it?
Here's the context in which it is acceptable:
I messed up, and my boss has scheduled a meeting with me. I go to his office and I fear I am about to be fired. I would be quite relieved if my boss instead says "Johnson, I'd like to rip your arms off and beat you to death with it. Now get back to work."
Context matters!
Jensen famously didn't do 1:1s. All of these were said publicly in large meetings, occasionally in front of the target's own team.
Regardless, context matters. NYT messed up by pulling the quotes out of context. Context includes tone of voice, and facial expression, among other things.
And how do you propose they include those in a newspaper article?
You can't have the full context in a newspaper article, but the NYT article doesn't even say what the employee did to get the invectives from Huang.
Huang grew up in the US, so I don't know if he has any Asian culture in him at all, but in Asian workplaces, particularly in Japan, employers are more inclined to retain employees and correct their mistakes, sometimes through stern criticism, whereas American employers may be quicker to dismiss them for poor performance. Asian bosses are often paternalistic, and don't be surprised if they yell at you like your parents might.
You’re saying they deserved it?
No, I am saying they may have deserved worse and may have gotten off easy. We don't know the context.
Interesting. So there’s a context in which the CEO of one of the most important companies globally would be justified in acting like this?
Yes, I have given an example 7 levels up.
> Yes, I have given an example 7 levels up.
Your example is bullshit. Let me quote it:
> Here's the context in which it is acceptable:
> I messed up, and my boss has scheduled a meeting with me. I go to his office and I fear I am about to be fired. I would be quite relieved if my boss instead says "Johnson, I'd like to rip your arms off and beat you to death with it. Now get back to work."
If your boss would do that, whatever you didn't warrant getting fired for. The proof is you weren't fired (because since when did "taking abuse" make up for poor performance). The violent, abusive language was egregious and unnecessary. Your boss behaved unacceptably, and it would be appropriate for him to be reprimanded for it (or even fired if it was a pattern).
> The proof is you weren't fired
Or he is benevolent. Unlike math, there are multiple answers and which one is chosen can dependent on the human.
> Or he is benevolent. Unlike math, there are multiple answers and which one is chosen can dependent on the human.
Not in this case. If he's benevolent he's not going to be making gratuitous violent threats to you in front of others to humiliate you.
The problem with your argument is the logic is pretty much: "he could have been worse therefore he's fine," which false and a weird bit of binary thinking and not "context." His behavior can still be unacceptably bad even if could have be worse.
> what the employee did to get the invectives from Huang.
Ah, the good old "look what you made me do", the final stage of the Narcissist's Prayer:
That didn't happen. And if it did, it wasn't that bad. And if it was, that's not a big deal. And if it is, that's not my fault. And if it was, I didn't mean it. And if I did, you deserved it.
bro, that's....not...better
That just sounds abusive and narcissistic.
You would prefer to be fired for messing up?
I would indeed prefer to be fired instead of being threatened to getting beaten to death wirh my own arms, yes. And I‘d argue this to be the more healthy position.
If it is Hannibal Lecter that made the threat you'd be justified in being alarmed because you know he means it literally. If your mom said that—as many moms do—you wouldn't be so alarmed, would you? Because you know she's just expressing disappointment in you, she doesn't mean it literally.
In public, in front of my peers? I would seriously consider telling her to tone down and consult a psychologist to calm her public humiliation fetish.
My sincere advise -- this is not healthy behavior between parent-child and between boss-employee. If this feels normal to you, you've internalized things from a childhood that perhaps wasn't great. I'd recommend you read up on psychological abuse by parents, how this impacts the self-esteem of children (and adults), healthier ways to motivate kids, and finally, talk to a therapist.
Colorful language != psychological abuse.
I'm sorry, but you really need to talk to a therapist.
- this project is a shitshow, we're going to be fucked and kiss goodbye to our ratings if <VP> digs into this bullet
This is colorful language venting out frustrations
- this project is so bad that I wish you never existed
This is psychological abuse
If my mom said that to me I'd call 911 because she was having a stroke. It'd be the only explanation for doing something something so out of character.
Words can do more harm than actions.
No, I would prefer to have competent people leadership.
You look at the problem, look at the person,talk them through it, and you are open and honest about where you think they went wrong.
And if it's not necessary an individual problem but a symptom of a larger systemic issue, that's where blameless postmortems come in to help prevent whatever happened from negatively impacting the company again.
And this would be true if I was back in foxholes getting shot at again, or in the office working through very expensive issues with C-level or engineering peers.
Leaders lead by example.
Looks like Jensen has some flaws to work on.
I wouldn't necessarily call it a flaw. I'd rather work for a boss who doesn't mince words and isn't afraid to call out shoddy work, but is just as quick to recognize and praise good work. That broad spectrum of possible feedback is motivating because you know every extra ounce of effort you put in will result in visible movement of the needle! Why do you think so many people wanted to work for Steve Jobs despite his not-so-rosy reputation? Because winning praise from a guy like that actually means something!
I'd rather get kicked in the nuts than shot in the stomach. That doesn't make it okay to kick me in the nuts.
> You would prefer to be fired for messing up?
Grow some self respect. That's not the choice you are being faced. Being insulted and humiliated didn't saved you from being fired. Your ability to endure abuse does not make you a model employee. It just makes you a spineless doormat that everyone can walk over.
Being willing to be held accountable for failures does not make me a "spineless doormat". I would rather take some verbal heat for my failures than being pushed out the door.
Being verbally abused is not the same as being held accountable. It doesn't have to be an either / or between verbal abuse such as "your mother should have aborted you" or being fired.
> Being willing to be held accountable for failures (...)
Grow a spine. Telling you that your mother should have aborted you is not a form of incident response.
If you don't respect yourself, no one will.
Why are "get fired" and "get abused" the only two options?
> Why are "get fired" and "get abused" the only two options?
Because we're playing "be an apologist for Jensen Huang," and a false choice like that can be used to defend the indefensible.
I didn't read it as a defense but rather using a hypothetical to illustrate the importance of context which we seem to wholly lack here.
> I didn't read it as a defense but rather using a hypothetical to illustrate the importance of context which we seem to wholly lack here.
That "context" is frankly bullshit: two hypothetical examples of unjustifiable and atrocious behavior, with a false choice to pick one.
Think about it: if verbal abuse and humiliation can "substitute" for being fired for a mistake, then the mistake wasn't something bad enough to be fired for. If firing was on the table for that kind of thing, that's another kind of abuse.
If that's what you truly believe then you ought to express disagreement with the point actually made (ie whether or not context is needed) in a civil manner rather than accuse the other party of bad faith.
While I'm not the same person I can't say I agree with the counterargument you present. Whether or not to fire someone for a serious slipup is fairly arbitrary. Generally these are things that all parties will agree can't be let slide (otherwise as you say it isn't necessary to fire anyone to begin with). So what to do? Certainly it's not a dichotomy - there are many options. I can accept that a nonzero number of such situations exist where I would not view verbal abuse as completely unacceptable (though I certainly wouldn't encourage it either).
I'll also note that without context it's generally difficult to know if something that looks like verbal abuse in a written record actually was at the time. I've had fairly charismatic bosses that would routinely say things in a clearly joking manner that absent context - body language, tone of voice, personal history, etc - would have come across as entirely inappropriate. As it was in reality everyone was laughing and having a good time. No one felt offended or threatened.
> While I'm not the same person I can't say I agree with the counterargument you present. Whether or not to fire someone for a serious slipup is fairly arbitrary. Generally these are things that all parties will agree can't be let slide (otherwise as you say it isn't necessary to fire anyone to begin with). So what to do? Certainly it's not a dichotomy - there are many options. I can accept that a nonzero number of such situations exist where I would not view verbal abuse as completely unacceptable (though I certainly wouldn't encourage it either).
Look, we can probably agree that we'd prefer a little verbal abuse to literally getting murdered, but that "context" says nothing about the acceptability of verbal abuse in any context.
> I'll also note that without context it's generally difficult to know if something that looks like verbal abuse in a written record actually was at the time. I've had fairly charismatic bosses that would routinely say things in a clearly joking manner that absent context - body language, tone of voice, personal history, etc - would have come across as entirely inappropriate. As it was in reality everyone was laughing and having a good time. No one felt offended or threatened.
At least in Jensen Huang's case, there are multiple reports of people interpreting is comments as abusive and unacceptable, and not as jokes. So you're talking about a hypothetical that doesn't apply to thise case.
I think the hypothetical scenario here is one where someone has screwed up badly enough to justify being fired on the spot. So it's being suggested that perhaps, in light of that context, a boss that verbally berates the employee but nonetheless retains them isn't necessarily socially unacceptable.
Contrast with a boss that verbally abuses employees who are generally in good standing which seems to not be socially acceptable in most western societies.
I would prefer not to work there, plenty of other jobs out there that do not come with a weird Faustian bargain.
So, if your boss says the above to you, you’ll still continue working there?
Just checking..
Sounds more like a cult than a healthy workplace.
Given the historical stock price and performance, I wouldn't shed too many tears for them. Generational wealth is worth weathering the occasional blowup.
Instead of getting fired? Absolutely would. I’m not some wuss—I can handle a little scolding from a well-meaning boss if I messed up.
It's not "being a wuss" to expect professionalism respect and not be humiliated in a working environment. Says a lot that you believe so though.
You are such a little cuck
The lady doth protest too much, methinks
Depends on how much money I have. If I have "fuck you" money, it would be a pleasure to get in the boss' face and tell him to fuck off using all of the creative language that I can muster.
If I don't have "fuck you" money... well, unfortunately in the world we live in, few things are more important than getting "fuck you" money. I can suck up some humiliation if there's an expectation of getting "fuck you" money.
Now, did any of the people Huang berated have "fuck you" money and still put up with it? I'm actually pretty curious about whether or not anyone told him to eat shit. If someone did, I celebrate it. If even people with "fuck you" money didn't, then I'm curious to know why. Maybe they really really wanted to go from having "fuck you" money to having "own an island" money.
When you're at the higher levels in a company, your fate is tied to a lot of other people's. You're not just going to bat for yourself. Sure, you can burn your bridges, throw your subordinates and their projects under the bus or leave them to the wolves, and merrily dance into the sunset with your "fuck you" money or whatever. That takes a type of mindset that is antithetical to being in that position in the first place.
That would still not be an acceptable thing to say, even in that context.
> I would be quite relieved if my boss instead says "Johnson, I'd like to rip your arms off and beat you to death with it. Now get back to work."
I'm amazed by the extent you try to rationalize how this form of abuse and unprofessional behavior is acceptable.
First, you fabricate this whole fictional scenario to try to distract your insinuation that the comments were made out of context. You provided no context at all, only a fabricated scenario.
Then, your choice is not between being bullied or being fired. Your choice is between being bullied and not be bullied. People prefer to be treated with respect. Do you think it's normal and ok for you to be insulted and humiliated like that?
Just because some people lack self-respect and self-esteem that doesn't make it ok to be bullied.
I wonder why you're getting downvoted. Maybe HNers nowadays are the type of people who fantasize about saying exactly such things at the workplace. Wouldn't surprise me.
Temporarily Embarrassed Workplace Tyrants
> I wonder why you're getting downvoted. Maybe HNers nowadays are the type of people who fantasize about saying exactly such things at the workplace.
There seems to be a type of people who go way of their way to be stans for leading silicon valley characters. For them, their idols are unable to do any wrong or harm. They think that when they idols are acting like assholes, that must be impossible and there must be layers to that. The absolutely last layer of that fictional stack of excuses is always some rationalization of brilliance, and a show of love for the Stan. So all the wrongs their idol does always ends up being a right.
So here we are, with people claiming that a history of extreme abuse is somehow a good thing because... Because what?
> Here's the context in which it is acceptable:
That is not a context in which that is acceptable.
It's just words. If you dont like how you are being spoken to at work: find another job.
And while at it be happy that you live in the US where free-speech (apart from anything related to a particular middle eastern country) is not being cancelled like in Europe.
All that safe space bullshit: as long as no physical violence is being done to you, you can either stay or quit.
The OpenBSD mailing list? They sure don't make 'em like they used to!
Personally, I pin the blame for horrible employment dynamics on the ever-consuming paperclip maximizing global economy that drives the foundational power imbalance to begin with. In an ideal world, it should be easy for anyone to say "I consider this communication style abusive. Stop or I am going elsewhere", right? Framing the situation in terms of pitting people against other people is a standard bought-and-paid-for pop culture narrative, encouraging us to ignore that "invisible hand" picking most of our pockets.
Right? We’re calling the news outlet as milking a story and failing to acknowledge what appears to be fairly offensive language from the company lead.
If anything, it is tech voices on X who are to be criticised here for ignoring the issues. Mainstream media coverage is normal and ok.
I agree, it has become rather salacious and gossipy across even the major news sources.
I think people are tired of bad behavior from billionaires and so this is an easy pile on.
I saw a video yesterday where Jensen mocked the Mistral founder for his french accent.
This one? https://www.facebook.com/21NewsBe/videos/une-vid%C3%A9o-de-j...
P.S. Found a better more complete video at https://youtu.be/GxBrMX1NPiQ?t=3022
Thanks for posting that. I tried finding it yesterday after reading a story on it. Seeing the video, it comes across more as a bad joke than the abuse portrayed in the article.
Honestly, I was readying my pitchfork when I heard about this video and could not find it yesterday.
But watching it today, it comes across as if Jenson really wants everyone to understand what the french guy is saying (because he knows the Mistral guy has a lot of good things to say) and he knows that no one has a chance of understanding him. The little in the video I heard the french guy talk, I would tend to agree with Jenson.
The fact that Jensen was seen as the most reasonable of the AI-related companies' CEOs says very little about Jensen, and a lot about everybody else.
The press has been very unfair using all sort of salacious headlines - and I don't think directly racist/sexist but the 'Chinese Sex Spy' thing is borderline. It's just too much for them not to use as click bait.
The result has been massive disinformation among the general public.
This happens when people commit a social harm (cheating on wife) ... the emotional stain of that just carries over into everything else.
Tech Bros are often lacking in empathy, they're not always the most civil people.
It's bad.
There are a lot of unknowns.
I see a lot of regular people jumping on the bandwagon screaming that 'circular financing' is fraudulent (it's rational but risky, not fraudulent).
Making assumptions about Jensen's culpability.
All sorts of things.
Gary Marcus and Ed Zitron make really great points, but they are also 'extremely biased in the other direction'.
2 of 3 'Godfathers of AI' are needlessly scare mongering.
That fool Kevin O'Leary is on TV all the time as the 'face of Data Centres' I can't imagine a worse representative. Trump as well.
And a lot of otherwise respectable people caught up in misinformation.
This is a result of infotainment, and ideologically driven news.
Very bad situation.
Personally, I think Jensen was not knowingly involved in spy stuff, and wasn't doing anything but trying to sell GPUs. He followed the letter and intent of the law it seems. Nvidia works with US Gov and did everything asked. The sleepign with workers is bad - but - 'conflict of interest' is not inherently wrong. Adults can be Adults. I think an investigation into both would be necessary. I also think that 35 years of building that from scratch 'counts for something'. I don't think we can live in a world were 'a mistake is career death' - this is extremely bad for innovation and turns CEO's in to mindless robots.
If Jensen was found to be actively avoiding sanctions - he must leave, and possibly face sanctions. If the 'sleeping with staff' was coercive - he has to go. But there's a lot of grey in those areas.
The Board may be acting on decisive information we do not have - or - it's entirely plausible they are fearful and just being 'very PC risk averse'.
> and I don't think directly racist/sexist but the 'Chinese Sex Spy' thing is borderline
It might be salacious headline, but it's definitely not misinformation. It's literally a description of what happened.
HN and Reddit has been overall happy at his downfall.
most people are, I'm curious about the motivations for those who are supporting him regardless of the revelations
For me, the supposed revelations are just not a big deal.
All of the revelations (bribes and export busting) or just the spicy ones (affairs)? What else will we learn in the oversight meetings Jensen and Nvidia have agreed to?
Money most likely...
By all accounts, he was a pretty unpleasant boss, and NVIDIA is a pretty unpleasant company. I'm also not sure why people are so hellbent on supporting him.
Cult of the CEO founder, same story for Musk and more
(my best guess)
And money, which can be corrosive to objectivity.
If you're a startup founder, aspiring startup founder, or trying to ride the AI wave in any way, you'd want to keep the circular financing accelerator going. Or a retail investor who made a lot (or even a little) on NVDA and now considers any attack on a giant corporation as a personal sleight. Motivated reasoning leads you to poke holes in superficial parts of news coverage, use whataboutism, conspiracy thinking, etc to reach a predetermined position.
It's grimly fascinating to watch examples on Reddit of someone who owns a few shares of NVDA post start posting dozens of Jensen Innocent comments in every thread they can find, accusing anyone who pushes back of being a short pushing FUD to hurt Nvidia.
With zero self awareness that they are the one doing the very thing, with the same financial incentives that they baselessly project onto random NYT journalists, Reddit users, analysts, etc because of their own financial interest.
Those heavily invested in tech-adjacent equity.
It's telling that the market is flagging right after Jensen was ousted. My take is that Jensen personally enabled the bubble over the objections of anyone around him willing to display a modicum of defiance, and now those same people are running the company.
He seemed like a cool guy. I was looking forward to having him lead the first post-AI wave of gaming GPUs next year, I was devastated the day the news broke, and to be honest I'm still holding out hope for a good redemption arc. When it comes to non-billionaires supporting him, I don't think the story is any more complex than that.
> looking forward to having him lead the first post-AI wave of gaming GPUs next year
Seems far fetched that there will be any production room for gaming GPUs. Jensen was already signaling nvidia would not be doing those because data center GPUs are too profitable.
Frankly I think the Silicon Valley tech-types come out looking a lot worse that the "mainstream media" that is everyone's favorite bugaboo.
Jensen Huang had an affair with someone who, if not a Chinese Spy, was an exec at one Nvidia's biggest foreign customers whose obvious goal was making NVidia chips available to China, even if in a legal manner through leases. It takes an incredible amount of hubris and narcissistic rush to do that. And then he also had an affair with someone he directly managed and apparently someone else at the company.
Those are things Huang did of his own volition, and I hear so many apologists talk about "war on open source models". Get a grip, his actions are clearly untenable by themselves. And even if there are people who do have ulterior motives in Huang's downfall, he certainly gave them all the ammunition they needed. And the SV types are basically saying they don't care about his transgressions because they think he'll make them all richer. The ultimate "morality doesn't matter when you're rich" viewpoint.
I don't think Huang is the antichrist, but I also don't think anything that has happened (which is really just losing his job at Nvidia) is anything but the consequences of his own actions.
This quote struck a chord for me (from https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/jensen-resurrection-wat...)
> What I’m struck by however is the mix of the omnipotence of the Silicon Valley elect — the billionaire-founder CEOs and their mostly centi-millionaire hype-men/attendants (call this the David Sacks class) — combined with the equal reality that it does not seem like any of these guys have entirely absorbed just how staggeringly unpopular they and their entire industry has become. They also don’t seem to have grasped how unpopular Trump — with whom they’ve cast their lots — has become. They and Trump are locked in this kind of superhero electro-hug in which each is making the other more unpopular, a kind of electrical transfer and mutual intensification of unpopularity.
They belatedly have and are distancing themselves furiously. Even Musk is no longer MAGA!
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/nov/21/silicon-vall...
How come the mainstream media never talked about how bad Huang was and now it’s bullying, nepotism, infidelity, treason. It’s indeed incredible.
Jensen screwed up all responsibility is on him, nowhere else blaming the messenger is misguided…
Blaming a messenger that strategically withholds information or completely ignores it cannot be misguided. It’s either malice or malpractice.
I don't know what to think of the subject but it's been alarming to hear so many TV reporters and talking heads mispronounce "Nvidia." It's worth trillions of dollars and a lot of the people shaping public opinion of the company became aware of it only weeks ago. (The star of SNL's opening sketch managed to screw up the names of both Palantir and Nvidia in just a couple of minutes.)
The pronunciation of Nvidia seems awfully unimportant to me.
Doubly so since it's just a made-up word which leaves people to come up with their own pronunciation (Sure, Nvidia may have an "official" pronunciation, but not a lot of people are going to worry about that.)
People come up with their own pronunciation for a word when they learn it without talking to anyone who knows the correct pronunciation. If the guy next to you at the bar mispronounces chameleon that's a pretty good indicator that anything he tells you about chameleons is just something he read on the internet - which is fine for the level of trust you put into information shared by people at the bar. If someone claiming to be a herpetology professor mispronounces chameleon, then they are lying about being a herpetology professor, or at least about being a good one.
> Sure, Nvidia may have an "official" pronunciation, but not a lot of people are going to worry about that.
You should be very concerned if journalists are not among the group of people who worry about that.
Techbros on the fascosphere disagreeing with mainstream media. Are you next gonna try telling me that the sky is blue?
> major VCs
I'm sure that the ends justify the means for pretty high levels of evil means for that particular group of people, it's heartening that all of society doesn't feel that way.
Everyone should be held accountable, no matter how "important" a person is. Society seems to be slowly reducing to one big cult of personality, and that's really, really bad. Taking steps in the opposite direction is a healthy thing.
Huang was constantly shouting from the rooftops about how thinking is dead, all jobs will be replaced with AI. Then when he was asked what people should do he just shrugged his shoulders and essentially said “not my problem.”
What I don’t understand is how he (or any AI booster) could possibly believe the general population wouldn’t hate him.
That’s Dario you are talking about.
It’s both. Jensen said it many many times. Basically every interview.
I’m argue that many tech voices are subdued because SV is still a small place.
I don’t think we’re should confuse vocal minority with “most” tech voices.
Well yeah, literally nothing has changed in terms of any of the NYTimes's grievances - CEOs aren't going to sleep with fewer of their subordinates, generative AI will still put journalists out of work, everything will still be expensive, something something datacenters, etc. etc. - except now number goes down instead of up, which means mom and dad can't afford to keep paying Melanie and Sarah's rents to stay in New York to write for the New York Times's travel section for basically free. Okay, so it is some kind of agonizing, self destructive thing, they are trading in New York Post style scandal, and they'll reap the rewards.
It's important to realize that "tech voices on X" are a very specific and rarefied demographic. These are people likely to work in AI or AI adjacent fields and people who are likely to own AI related stocks. Huang could have ate a baby during the Superbowl halftime show and they'd want him back in charge of Nvidia Monday morning.
The general public sees a guy who had an affair, lied about it to his own board, was immediately caught in a second affair, and who was also engaged in some shady money stuff they don't really understand that made a lot of data centres possible, which they are more likely to be against than for.
BTW, lying to your own board is actually pretty serious. It's probably why Nvidia's board wasn't willing to immediately take him back.
On reddit there's been a weird pattern of sudden Huang fans just showing up with lots of oddly vague conspiracy theories. It's weird... those folks weren't there praising him before and equally weird is their effort to push a very insinuated sort of conspiracy theory, but also they seem shy about what exactly they're insinuating.
Getting caught in the sights of things like violating sanctions or ITAR is an existential threat to your company. No matter how instrumental you think he is to the future success of Nvidia, there was immense pressure weighing on the board to remove him and he clearly understood this.
> there was immense pressure weighing on the board to remove him
Meanwhile Trump is calling for reinstatement. The disconnect between the US government and its executive branch is large.
Is it? Instead of going to congress to change the laws, Trump can use the pardon power of the office.
ITAR, SHMITAR, As long as NVIDIA chips get in the hands of Russia.
A scimitar is on the flag of the one country you'd think would be covered by ITAR
Well the executive branch got 25 million from him so they probably see a path to more.
Except he.. didn't do those things?
Right now the strongest form of possible accusation is that nvidia sold chips to someone who then ferried them to someone on the blacklist.
Which is:
+ Not a failing of Jensen
+ Still an open accusation that may well be false (it was previously investigated and found not true)
+ Has no named accusers!
That sounds pretty weak to me.
> Right now the strongest form of possible accusation is that nvidia sold chips to someone who then ferried them to someone on the blacklist.
From here there are immediately stronger forms:
1) they fully should have known, because they are a nationally significant manufacturer of export-controlled items and get advice from all across government, and "Singapore-washing" is a widely understood phenomenon, and therefore they are very significantly negligent, which probably breaks the law itself.
This is IMO completely unarguable.
2) they did know they were doing it
It seems impossible to argue then that since they didn't stop when it became obvious that Singapore-washing is a thing, they were continuing in the knowledge that they were, effectively, breaking that law.
3) therefore it is really impossible to argue against the idea that he knew because he was sleeping with one of the major beneficiaries.
4) if he knew, and didn't stop it, he personally made a choice to continue to violate the law.
You can get all the way to 4) without ever considering the possibility that there's actual evidence chips left Singapore for China. And yet there's so much circumstantial evidence that a highly plausible route from Nvidia to e.g. Century Litong (and therefore benefiting DeepSeek) actually existed.
If you were to argue that it gets no further than 1), you're essentially making the argument that Jensen Huang is just an ignorant idiot. I wouldn't make that argument.
1) This claim is false
It was investigated already.. and debunked.
2) Treating your argument as a conclusion
Is a poor form of arguing. It betrays a lack of rigor.
3) Unverified assumptions
Are not evidence of wrongdoing.
4) Just because you want it to be true
Doesn't mean it is.
What is it about 1) that is false and debunked?
Are you arguing that Nvidia aren't a nationally significant manufacturer of export-controlled items? That is not something that can be debunked, because it is true.
That they (and Jensen Huang) wouldn't therefore have been constantly monitored and in contact with the State and Commerce department (diplomacy, compliance, advice, all that)?
That they didn't know and weren't advised Singapore-washing is a thing? They should have known this at the very latest by May 2025, because that is when they were first asked for records about Megaspeed. That is not debunkable.
They were almost certainly advised it was being investigated well before that. Singapore police were known to be investigating Megaspeed in February 2025, and Singapore was prosecuting a smuggler then too — Dell servers with Nvidia GPUs.
Reuters first reported evidence of smuggled GPUs way earlier than that — in 2023, and then there is this, in the South China Morning Post, also from 2023:
https://www.scmp.com/tech/tech-war/article/3225594/tech-war-...
Do you think nobody at Nvidia reads the South China Morning Post? Or are you arguing that they were not negligent even if they did know?
Or that negligence is not something export law cares about?
Any links you have about how it was debunked would I am sure be interesting. Because, come on, you should really be stipulating. And from there, we can move on to 2).
Actually there are KYC requirements in these export bans. Even selling to a distributor in the US that exports to China can create meaningful exposure if you don’t do any due diligence.
ITAR covers re-exports. It's your responsibility to audit the full chain.
Doesn’t everyone have to do the training on this every year?
>> Right now the strongest form of possible accusation is that nvidia sold chips to someone who then ferried them to someone on the blacklist.
Based on extensive investigative journalism by NYT, WSJ and others, there appears to be strong evidence that NVIDIA was not only fully aware of what was happening, but also their sales team actively worked around US export controls in order to sell more chips, and this was sanctioned and even encouraged by Jensen.
Right now Jensen's only possible saving grace is that these chip sales to Megaspeed were approved by the Dept. of Commerce under Lutnick. Lutnick, though, seems to have his own finger in the pie and profited from NVIDIA's behavior.
The whole thing stinks to high heavens and IMO it is very unlikely that Jensen is innocent. My guess is that he will be pardoned by Trump at some point, either pre-emptively or after a conviction.
If Lutnick skates, then Jensen Huang arguably even deserves a pardon; it would be unjust, I think, to punish him for lawbreaking that the Commerce department knowingly enabled, if there are no consequences for Lutnick. I would hope that is the outcome for him in that scenario.
Not least because as a non-American who uses open weights models, my view is that Chinese open weights competition has made US open weights models better, I think this is a view Jensen Huang holds and if it were me in that position I would be making a stronger case for that than turning a blind eye.
Then again, I don't think anyone in Trump's cabinet really deserves to skate if the USA is to justifiably regain its reputation for anything other than kleptocracy, and if this is the thing that ironically finally nails Howard Lutnick then so be it.
If I ask my corrupt friend in government to give me special treatment and they do, I am absolutely not off the hook for any of that. It doesn't matter who gets away with what, if the crimes were committed, anyone that we can convict, we should, and those people should be rightly punished.
Not quite what I mean.
What I mean is conditional. If you are not going to censure the Commerce secretary for knowingly allowing Nvidia to break export laws, then it seems churlish to punish any individual at Nvidia for it.
If Lutnick is on the hook, so ultimately is Jensen Huang.
But if Lutnick (who is the ultimate person in charge of Commerce and BIS) decided not to enforce the law, and isn't in a difficult position as a result, then was there a violation? It's more or less his decision alone.
It's worth noting that the Commerce department isn't an abstract legal and policy shop that is only tangentially connected.
They literally have police: BIS. AFAIK it's Lutnick's police who would be arresting Jensen Huang for smuggling.
To get Jensen Huang arrested for violating export laws (which to be clear I think there is evidence of), Congress is going to have to get Lutnick or his successor to do it. As Bessent said: "Commerce has the pen".
Lutnick has pretty broad, largely unreviewable discretion under the law to not simply enforce the law in individual cases. So if Congress disapproves, Lutnick is the first person on the hook.
If Lutnick knew and decided not to punish Nvidia or Jensen Huang, and he isn't himself censured/charged with not carrying out his responsibility, there perhaps isn't anyone else who can convict Jensen Huang of smuggling.
Which is part of why Huang's testimony on the Hill is such a vulnerability: he can be charged with lying to Congress!
Are you looking for moral consistency from the trump administration?
Not at all. Just observing that it is important for opponents of the administration to be aware where culpability lies when it comes to the smuggling; the "national security Democrat" position here should be to get Lutnick first if he gave it the nod.
Where Jensen Huang is concerned, I am much more interested in the thing that risks putting people's livelihoods and savings at risk in more than just America: the circular financing.
No one is getting got. Some people will be subjected to what should be embarrassing to them, but lacking any shame, won’t be. That’s about it.
Most likely.
Companies are punished for selling to intermediaries who went on to violate laws even when the company didn't know it. I've worked for one who still got fined despite not knowing and fully complying with the investigation.
And the reporting is exactly that he has the attention of the federal government. We are talking about risk management by lawyers not standards of innocence at trial.
We simply don't know. That is why we have a legal system and the principle of 'innocent until proven guilty'.
As for the ITAR stuff, it amazes me that in the same planet when major banks routinely (routinely!) do money laundering for drug cartles, organized crime, financial fraudsters, foreign intelligence agencies, white slavers, ..., and yet never seem to suffer for it and none of their exectives were iirc given this treatment in press and business world.
What is far more concerning than a single possible instance of failing to adhere to such laws is the fact that both the free press and the government think so little of the general public's opinion and intelligence that they pursue their political fights in guise of "adhering to the laws of the land" and "patriotism", to say nothing of "family values" and "abuse of power for sexual gratificatin".
That is what is critically stinky here.
"The term accelerationism (specifically in the form of Accelerationists) first appeared in a book in Roger Zelazny’s 1967 science-fiction novel Lord of Light.
The Accelerationists are a revolutionary faction (aligned with the protagonist, Sam) that advocates for the rapid, unrestricted deployment of advanced technology to shatter the ruling pantheon's stagnant monopoly and propel society forward."[0]
It's funny - for a long time I thought Nick Land invented the word in the 1990s through the Cybernetic Culture Research Unit (CCRU) at the University of Warwick.
[0]: Gemini
These organisations should be democratically run with its leadership democratically elected. Each employee should have a share of the ownership of the company.
As technology progresses, this extreme concentration of power is incredible dangerous.
https://youtu.be/LN2shXeJNz8?is=e1UebRMtpSosub9f
I don't even know what a given CEO getting fired would have anything to do with "accelerationists".
Huang or not AI is going to develop none the less...
There's a lot of internet meta talk about AI that I think is completely disconnected from whatever will happen. You might be able to win some sort of meta war on the internet and maybe influence some politics, maybe, possibly, but actual tech wherever it goes, I don't think so.
https://pastebin.com/JXG5V7jT
Decel cycle ramping up after the mid-terms, that’s the bigger picture and Jensen is just a big cog in a much larger political wheel.
I don't think you can call Jensen "just a cog".
Firstly Jensen was an accelerationist, particularly in promoting open weight and AI for all.
Secondly, he was the shot caller at Nvidia, which is the central bank of AI. Nvidia could easily sit their collecting risk free profit but they didn't. They backstopped financing and pumped up deals to push AI hard. They hardly sat on their britches like a lot of tech companies do (looking at you Intel when AMD was floundering).
There is a good reason why Sam Altman said it's hard to imagine the singularity without Jensen. Jensen had an unwavering ability to take huge bets on AI being the future.
I personally will miss someone willing to make a big bet on AI like Jensen. Like Kirk said: risk is our business.
You can make big bets without breaking the law while doing it. The two are not inextricably intertwined.
But he didn't break the law as far as we can tell. Obeyed its letter whilst violating its spirit, probably, but that's not breaking the law. Nvidia has impeccable lawyers for this I'm sure.
Are you good with Elon Musk spending $444M to buy a state or cutting off Starlink to Ukraine? Neither of those were illegal either. I'm curious where the bar really lands.
And yes, moral relativism. Seems to be a best practice here now given the results of the 2024 election.
The most likely reason he was fired is that the company’s lawyers and Board think he broke the law, and their job is to protect the company. To continue to employ him after they came to believe he broke the law could make the penalties even worse. They won’t come outright and say so, of course, as that would violate attorney-client privilege.
You’re not an insider, and are not in possession of all the facts. (Admittedly, I’m not either, but as an attorney, I can put the pieces together.) The insiders know much more than either the press or the government. That said, there are plenty of factual and legal analyses out there that, if true, give the Government plenty of fodder to indict, if not convict, Nvidia and Huang himself.
Besides, why do you (or really, anyone here) care whether Jensen Huang got fired? What impact does it have on your life?
Or they were shown things by the same people behind this outing that they would rather no one else ever see. It was awfully sudden and now you're going to tell me there's absolutely nothing suspicious from the first revelation coming out on Saturday and his resignation on Thursday. Nope, nothing to see here. move along. Heaven forbid they put him on leave until the conclusion of a deliberative investigation after leading the company to 6 trillion in valuation over the past 33 years.
It is really interesting that Garry Tan reports that all but three members of the board already want him back. so maybe you're full of s***. Why would they want him back if they know he's violated the law and Congress is about to try and make an example of him?
> Garry Tan reports that all but three members of the board already want him back.
"Wanting someone back" may be merely a sentiment. Hearsay of statements of general support are not the same as a vote to rehire in a closed-door board meeting. If all but three members of the board truly wanted putting Jensen Huang back in the driver's seat-regardless of the legal jeopardy it could put them in-they'd have a board majority, and he'd be back. The fact that he isn't should tell you something. Most rational people think staying out of prison and avoiding a felony conviction is more valuable than the gains on one's equity, regardless of how great they are.
Again I ask: why do you even care?
Because I work in AI and all the alternatives to CUDA are pretty much different forms of dreadful wrapped in cope (although if I had to, I would choose the TPU). I would like cheaper GPUs, but they don't seem to dropping in price at all over this.
None of this tells me anything other than this was a rush to judgement as the spy story has already fallen apart, deprecated to something something channel stuffing to China. Wonder what the next week will brin?. It would be pretty stupid to bring him back before he testifies to Congress, but stupidity seems to be catching these days.
It's not like Nvidia's going out of business or something. They're still going to produce and ship silicon.
Life goes on.
I'm not sure how you've concluded that throttling Starshield was legal. We're talking about a US defense contractor restricting critical military communications infra. And if any of this was coordinated with Russia, that opens up a whole different set of potential legal issues
Don’t take the distraction bait. We’re talking about Nvidia here, not SpaceX.
And you're about to watch nothing be done about it because Jensen Huang is the brand new shiny. And that blue wave which was glorious is about to become the great blue waste as they fail to do anything about the Iran war or inflation either.
Good grief, the lack of humility and the degree of hubris are equally appalling. A company is not one single person. And also, a single person is responsible for their actions. I don’t know what’s happened in SV to create this mass delusion or willful ignorance for the greater good. Granted SV has always had a technocratic libertarian tilt, but the SV discourse circa Nvidia post-Jensen is so incredibly out of touch with common human decency, just because you might make an extra buck. Shameful.
Why do you think they're trying to dismantle democracy? Normal people hate this fucking shit.
I scanned all of the NVIDIA board's public statements about Huang's resignation, and the only one with any substance was "disclosure of personal behavior inconsistent with the company’s code of conduct, standards, and cultural norms".
Could the board be held liable for retaining him, once they undeniably knew about him having an ‘undisclosed’ relationship with a subordinate, if they didn’t fire him once the press revealed it?
For that to be meaningful you'd need evidence directly showing knowledge of the affair prior to the public leaks. If you had evidence of cover ups that would also make it a much stronger case compared to having known or heard rumors and done nothing.
The board said he mislead them for over a year on the affair(s). That's more than enough to be meaningful for a company board who wants to avoid the liability he was in the process of bringing on them.
Assuming that ends up to be true, I agree. As it stands I haven't seen any real proof and am curious how said affairs could have gone on known for so long, the more simple answer in my opinion does seem to be that the affairs were known and ignored until it became politically or financially valuable.
Whether or not they were ignored is only material because the board (presumably) fired him; otherwise they would have accepted the risk of liability by retaining him. So it doesn’t necessarily matter whether they knew when evaluating if they made a corporate-correct decision: reducing liability to the controlling humans in exchange for cutting off a source of public drama seems like a double-win, no matter what degree of prior knowledge exists.
All the drama about violating export controls doesn’t put the board individually at personal risk as much as sleeping with one’s reporting managers under U.S. labor laws does, so it remains no surprise that they backed him until he was found out to have done something that could threaten them. The U.S. isn’t very likely to conduct open discovery and court trial for a natsec violation, for example, and having Jensen’s actions expose the entire company to discovery and retention risks is far more costly a threat to the company than some measly government slap on the wrist for wink-nod sales to ‘Singapore’.
Much of this would end up at the whims of a judge or jury, its hard to say what would happen.
I do expect it would go much worse if evidence were to indicate that the board knowingly hid the affairs or even the spy concerns. Similarly, with regards to violating export controls I'd expect that would hinge on showing knowing action taken by the board to violate controls. If they can push it off on Jensen or walk the line of hardware going to allowed countries and Nvidia having no control over who they lease to is yet to be seen.
You aren't in charge of a company like Nvidia without being very smart and being good at covering your ass. I won't be surprised if there are little to no crimes that were technically violated or can be proven in court.
He has admitted to and been credibly accused of gross misconduct even if you ignore the spy question and the chip smuggling. Any of these issues by themselves would have gotten him fired including his children, their unjustifiable positions, and their behavior.
He has exposed the company to liability and well-deserved reputational damage.
Nvidia is also not a stranger to dubious accounting/reporting behavior.
The most baffling thing is watching tech losers line up to defend the guy and ask for him to be reinstated.
If NVIDIA has been skirting export controls, I do not expect them to disclose that publicly and embrace the legal risk. Best to give a non-committal, "Not in line with our values" kind of statement.
Like a C-suite who who is leaving to "spend time with the family", a CEO is only ever going to be kicked out for a non-criminal, defensible reason. Unless the crime was so blatant and inexcusable they need to get in front of the legal liability.
That’s because they are not going to admit that they suspect he broke the law on the company’s behalf in a public statement. It’s an admission and would be used as a basis for a criminal conviction.
For all his faults regarding his control of his delinquent member, coupled with the obvious export smuggling ring, and now perhaps accounting fraud (new SEC investigation, may end up being just a rumor) I did appreciate that Huang was sensible in the sense that:
1. Didn't pearl clutch or make every issue around Silicon Valley an "AI issue". A lot of drivel commentary and political mileage can be had by just demonizing AI. He was rather sensible versus the pervasive hyperventilating and in my view, self-serving (oss models getting too good) talk coming out of other leaders in the space.
2. Didn't treat China as the enemy. Said openly it's good for the world if China uses AI to solve cancer, etc.
Obviously in retrospect maybe he sort of overindexed on #2. But on the flip side, it doesn't seem the US government actually wants to confront China. They essentially let this export smuggling slide and knew about the spy.
Are they alone? No Americans I know want to fight China. What throng of Americans is relishing annihilation in Taiwan? We can't even subdue one of the most backward, poorest nations on the entire globe. Americans want to follow up Afghanistan, Iraq and Iran with China?
So really, in a world of madness Huang felt quite sensible. No AI isn't going to by necessity kill us all. No we don't have to think of this as a zero sum competition with China. We can try to be sensible about this.
Then it turned out he was fucking a spy and multiple other women who were not his wife. He fell for the oldest trick in the book. Sad someone who seemed so sensible will forever be famous for being so exposed as a fool.
I am still struck that his two general points were more or less correct. But indeed it is not good now to be associated with ideas he championed. Perhaps this was the greatest success of this whole ordeal, if one takes the manner of his rise and fall to not be wholly unrelated to some species of sabotage.
As far as I am aware, there is zero public evidence huang or nvdia did anything illegal, or Huang divulged any secrets.
Megaspeed's primary business of renting out computing power from data centers outside China was completely legal under existing U.S. export rules.
What am I missing
The article is paywalled
https://pastebin.com/JXG5V7jT Until recently The Economist has been quite easy to access but they seem to have tightened up
No one here knows the full details of what happened but my impression of it that his fall was politically engineered by someone from the admin leaking to the press and likely leveraging important people in the industry as well.
My point with this being, can Silicon Valley really permanently entrench political power in the US?
If expensive gas was enough to shakeup things at the midterms what kind of politics would be ushered in if unemployment skyrockets to 20%+
Will all the many crazy things the tech leaders have said in the last few years come back to bite them if the masses are truly in dire straits and looking for targets to blame?
Sounds like it's Rubio. Possibly as a shot at Vance (Vance is in the techbro orbit).
That said Jensen has been a naughty boy: "light" treason, SEC probe into financial statements. This is not about him getting his wick wet.
The Palace Intrigue reporting is always fraught with selective leaks and gossip, but it appears to also be part of the rift between Howard Lutnick in Commerce and Scott Bessent in treasury.
Unfortunately Jensen enabled it. Sure, the timing of the leaks is suspect. It seems like Trump ok’ed the release as a way to ensure his prediction of a market crash if the dems won. But we wouldn’t be here if Jensen could keep it in his pants.
maybe wouldn't be here if they weren't side stepping export laws by bribing the president
> If expensive gas was enough to shakeup things at the midterms
It was the blatant corruption that shook things up. The Jensen Incidents are very inline with that.
While everyone is entitled to their beliefs on the reason everyone else voted, I think it was the gas. Those who didn't like the blatant corruption voted against it in 2018, 2020, 2024, and again in 2026. The new people who voted blue did so for a new reason. In my view, it was the gas. If it wasn't for the gas, the votes would have been again 50% +/- 0.1%
I live in a very rural, very MAGA area. At least for those around me, the primary frustrations I hear are related to not releasing the Epstein papers, starting wars rather than ending them, never draining the swamp, and spending more money rather than cutting waste.
I do hear about fuel prices occasionally, but very rarely as a complaint linked to Trump.
What those folks are trying to express is that they picked an outsider to deal with the DC establishment and the promise was never fulfilled by said outsider. This most recent election is the same sentiments that got trump.elected the first time, but trying the other side again. Dems have a chance, not sure they can make the moment tho...
I do agree in theory, though I'm hesitant to speak on behalf of a group of voters.
There seems to be something to the read that voters recognize something needs to change in DC. The jury is out whether that'll happen, the machine is pretty damn resilient and most (all?) willing and able to change fundamentals at the federal level never seem to make it all the way into office.
> something needs to change in DC. The jury is out whether that'll happen
Chuckie Schumer trying to annointimg himself king (leader) and then move a secret vote once a challenger emerged... is not a good sign. Call or email your senators to say No to Schumer, they count issue stats for pro/con and contents can be used for their story times.
It was corruption and cost of living based on exit polls. Think it was just gas prices is reductionist and missing the bigger picture. You don't see Texas go completely blue just because of gas prices, not do you see the pushback from Dems base on Schumer if this was just about gas. There is also the tariffs, housing prices, health care, corporate price gouging.
Its all connected to pervasive corruption and politicians who don't fix things.
If we had anything like a democracy, all of these guys' heads would be rotting on spikes on the White House lawn already. The fact that they're not only alive, but breathing free air in their private jets with hot and cold running champagne proves that they are in actual fact above the law. People talk about some coming Silicon Valley Reich but it's very clearly already here. The task before us is to bring it down, not prevent it.
Good news. People are more aware. My observations have been that particularly younger factions on both the left and the right realize that its them (the technocrats) or us (the people).
It's highly likely the admin were (are) complicit in selling restricted hardware to China. I wouldn't be slightly surprised if the circular financing - which was completely obvious to anyone paying attention - wasn't Huang's invention.
So why kill Nvidia now? It's going to pop a carefully inflated hyperbubble and cause a depression.
Cui bono?
the circular financing did a job - making sure nvidia's windfall continues to expand the whole industry, rather than high compute prices starving everything
Apparently the Trump administration was divided and the side that cared about smuggling Nvidia chips to China eventually won. The leaks to the New York Times were part of how they won.
Before Nov 3 Trump could continue to cover up everything and get away with it. Now he is incredibly weak and people that have been pulling very questionable shit are getting nervous.
> his fall was politically engineered
Jensen’s fall, based solely on what we do know, was inevitable. There were too many fuckups in too many places for him to get away with it.
The proximate cause was Bessent pot shotting Lutnick. (Barring something really weird going on at Pennsylvania Avenue, that happened with the President’s knowledge if not consent.)
But the ultimate cause is Huang being a lying, corrupt sack of shit who went all in on Team Trump only for that bet collapse with the election.
Leaks to the New York Times were important in tipping them off, but their own investigation has been in progress for months. Funneling billions in exports to China apparently leaves a fair bit of evidence!
Jensen was vulnerable due to his own actions. Yes, often billionaires get away with worse, but not always, it seems.
This was already obvious years ago GPUs were going to China. You don't need leaks for it. There are videos of data center tours with nvidia cards in them. You can just open Chinese e-commerce sites and buy 4090 and 5090 non D versions which are supposed to be banned. Also the 4090 48gb mods? Seems like nobody gives a shit about those supposedly being the "non China version". So the leaks are nothing we don't already know.
> someone from the admin
Seems like they're on the opposite side (aligned with Jensen).
Much more likely this is Anthropic pushing the story.
Rubio's team was close to openly saying they were the source. This is about China hawks and export controls and Jensen was a roadblock to their goals so he was eliminated as a political force.
Maybe someone choose a particular moment to let the cat out of the bag. But the circumstances are such I don't think the facts could be ignored indefinitely.
> his fall was politically engineered by someone from the admin leaking to the press
I was discussing this point with someone today who didn't even know that this was started by US intelligence leaks to journalists. I have no sympathy for Jensen, but I find myself amazed that so many lack the basic media literacy to recognize a classic hatchet job.
I would amend the notion that it's the "admin" though - it's clearly the national security apparatus who decided he was out - the particular faction within it seems hard to identify.
This wasn't fall of Jensen. It was fall of Nvidia.
If Jensen starts a new company in same field today, one day that company will be able to buy Nvidia.
Nvidia board should be fired.
I'll take the other side of that bet. I'm against the Great Man theory of history. Jobs, Bezos, Gates, Huang - the companies they started are now much more than the founders themselves.
Apple without Jobs (pt 1) was a trainwreck.
Apple without Jobs (pt 2) is just mediocre.
Msft without Gates (Ballmer) enough said.
Amazon without Bezos too early to tell (but cracks are starting to show)
It could also be they were the right man at the right time.
I mean for example Microsoft can't milk the desktop and small server market like they did back in the day. Now we have the internet, cloud, smart phones and so on. Or who knows, maybe Bill Gates would find something very profitable today, too.
Jobs was around for the ipod/iphone which is massive society defining device but I don't see how it follows that he would have come up with something better than black rectangle which the industry has been hovering around for the last 10 years.
Apple has done well with their M series chips with out him. Just because he was an idiot and took himself out at the top of the game doesnt mean he would have piloted Apple to where it is now.
He gave himself pancreatic cancer?
If you read Mo Tkacik's obituary it is by no means just about the cancer.
He chose to die of pancreatic cancer. He had options and his choices led directly to his early death.
No way to say that his choices made any appreciable difference. Maybe a matter of a year or less.
Jobs did it twice. Musk has done it two or three times, depending on whether you feel Tesla counts, given that he didn't start it.
Most companies go downhill, or at least become ordinary once the founfers leave. It's not necessarily about skill, but rather that founders care in a different way about the products, while later people in charge care more about the short-term bottom line.
A great leader alone can't achieve much. He needs luck and skills to surround himself with good and skilled men.
A mediocre leader surrounded even with many great men, will still produce shit. Might take awhile depending on momentum, but will happen.
Founder mode is always better regardless how big the company has grown.
The odds of any startup being successful are pretty low, so it's certainly notable when the same founder has multiple successes such as Jobs Apple (x2), Next and Pixar, especially when the personality/traits of the person seems directly related to the success.
Much as I dislike him, bit I think Musk also deserves credit for his serial successes, even if most of that is more in motivating others who work for him, and being willing to put his considerable personal wealth on the line.
> I'm against the Great Man theory of history. Jobs, Bezos, Gates, Huang - the companies they started are now much more than the founders themselves.
If the Great Man theory of history wasn't true, then Europe would have a bunch of successful tech companies, because founders would pop up randomly out of the large not-wanting-to-move-to-America population there.
What? If anything this shows the contrary, that structural forces create the conditions for certain organizations to be successful, even if they then become associated with particular individuals.
Europe has a very fragmented internal market for capital and labor; there's technically a single market for products and services but language barriers complicated things; there's not nearly as much capital looking for investment, in large part due to pension savings not being invested; there's a cultural propensity for regulating technology too early.
There are more than enough founders in Europe, it's just that Europe is a much worse place for a tech company to grow very large.
> If Jensen starts a new company in same field today, one day that company will be able to buy Nvidia
I doubt it.
He seems to mostly have been in right place right time.
Remember that not too long ago Nvidia was just making graphics cards for PC gaming. Nvidia/Jensen apparently did not themselves see the potential for non-gaming use of GPUs.
The way CUDA came about was via custom shaders (for gaming), which some scientific customers began "abusing" for more general GPU compute, which Nvidia only then supported by providing CUDA.
The scientific compute market is not that large, and I don't recall Nvidia making any Intel-like push to create demand for their hardware. In fact in 2012 when Geoffrey Hinton wanted a graphics card for his student to use for neural network use, Nvidia turned him down. AlexNet was what created the demand/publicity for GPU-based neural nets, and only after that did Nvidia add neural net support to CUDA in the shape of cuDNN.
The use of graphics cards for crypto mining was another accidental NVidia success of being in the right place at the right time.
By all appearances Jensen Huang is a shitty arrogant human being who abused people at Nvidia, installed a bunch of family members in high paying jobs there, fucked at least one direct report, tried to support the Chinese AI industry at a time when the US was trying to oppose it, and finally got caught with his pants down when the FBI was phone tapping a suspected Chinese spy.
The success of Nvidia as more than a PC graphics card company would appear to be due to whoever was managing CUDA, in at least semi-competent fashion, at least keeping up with customer demand if not foreseeing it.
Not in Silicon Valley, but from my perspective we are way past the "event horizon" of the "technological singularity". I don't think anything can stop the change now.
There's at least one scenario where I see this realistically unwinding and walking back from the potential for large scale job loss, doom scenarios, etc
If this is the tipping point of a bubble pop, companies that remain won't be able to light stacks of cash on fire and demand 40x multipliers on earnings.
Infrastructure already built would still be there to use, as well as the knowledge of how to build frontier models. Companies coming in would need to build financially viable business models though, almost certainly meaning smaller models with less functionality completing busy work rather than racing to AI.
The bubble pop would be painful either way, but that's a future that at least to me seems realistic meaning it wouldn't yet be a singularity.
However as you point out, infrastructure already built would still be available to use. Present day frontier models are the same. Those are already good enough to drastically accelerate the rate of scientific research, and as ML research has progressed algorithmic efficiency has improved by leaps and bounds.
Also consider the extreme markup on hardware that nvidia has.
So lets assume an unrealistic hypothetical where the bubble pops, frontier model R&D completely ceases, hardware R&D effectively stops, but the current generation of fabs keep running and the current cutting edge hardware is sold at a much more reasonable markup. Naturally cloud providers renting out large clusters at an hourly rate would still exist. Thus ML capabilities would be expected to continue to improve.
Now consider that those same ML models have also been shown to be able to accelerate hardware design. My conclusion is that we have entered a period of rapid innovation that won't be stopped (only slowed somewhat) by the economy crashing. The only question is what technological upper bound is reachable (ie the end point might or might not be the global ceiling).
Why is it unrealistic for the bubble to pop, frontier research to cease, and hardware R&D to at least slow down if not stop? And why would we assume favs keel running as today with lower markups?
If there is a bubble and it pops, it seems obvious that frontier research almost entirely funded by outside investment would have to slow way down or stop. With that market disappearing, hardware R&D and manufacturing would have to slow down as well, and given lower demand the prices would fall and that would ripple through hardware companies as well.
Whether there is a bubble and if it is popping is anyone's guess. I don't personally see how hardware fan could possibly continue at today's pace while both demand and their markup collapse.
I'm also not personally sure what would happen to frontier models if there was a liquidity crisis. In the dotcom bubble fiber was in the ground and just didn't have a user. Today data centers would exist but may not have users. The models are just code and data though, they could be sold to the highest bidder at liquidation or they could just go away, its less obvious with software rather than hardware.
> Why is it unrealistic for the bubble to pop, frontier research to cease, and hardware R&D to at least slow down if not stop?
It's not? I think there's been some misunderstanding.
I supposed a hypothetical where exactly that happened - the bubble pops and the entire economy crashes badly, the existing frontier labs go under, no one has the financial appetite to take their place, and hardware R&D nearly completely ceases.
I then observe that existing GPUs, datacenters, and frontier models would still exist, current generation GPUs would continue to be fabricated (silicon is incredibly cheap once the mask exists), and both inference providers as well as cloud services willing to rent anyone any size cluster on an hourly basis would continue to exist.
Combine the above with the observation that current frontier models display effectiveness as tools to drastically accelerate both hardware design and machine learning research. I think the presumption is then that fairly rapid progress on the theory would continue to be made despite the collapse of commercial funding.
Crucially even as models have been getting larger they've also been getting more computationally efficient by leaps and bounds. So total capabilities given only present day GPUs should be expected to continue to increase over time while token prices stay the same or fall (unless electricity becomes scarce for some unrelated reason).
A corollary to the above is that if things don't crash I expect progress will very rapidly increase to an almost unbelievable degree in the immediate future. As basis see for example the massive dump of mathematics proofs by openai last month. Things appear to be accelerating rapidly.
> Today data centers would exist but may not have users.
Tokens are quite cheap when compared with human knowledge workers - check the API prices on openrouter.
What makes you think that?
Some fields are obviously transformed forever (e.g. math), but we don't have robots walking the streets, and training runs still require gigantic data centers full of advanced chips and a human researcher to wake up and go to the office to kick them off.
There's no shortage of human researches to "kick them off" and won't be in foreseeable future.
Even if datacenter buildout would stop entirely today, there's enough datacenters to continue research. It would be compute constrained, but it won't stop.
Sure. I guess I'm wondering if there was some rogue agent or misuse incident (e.g. an autonomous wetlab synthesizing and spreading a virus that killed lots of people) serious enough to trigger a sweeping movement against further uncontrolled development along with strict regulation on the datacenter compute users. I feel there is already a lot of political will to domestically regulate, and just yesterday Trump announced joint guardrails with China to keep super intelligence from getting "too super".
That would not change anything as the idea of controlled development is a collective hallucination of humanity.
> but we don't have robots walking the streets
We already possess the foundation for that (and many other things). The economy is a large system with lots of inertia.
It would take extreme levels of government intervention coordinated between all the major powers to stop ML from advancing significantly, and even then we'd still be experiencing drastic changes to the economy for years to come while the dust settled.