Ask HN: Do you feel developers are more "grumpy" these days?

7 points by ksajadi 1 day ago

I genuinely am questioning whether this is my perception or it's real. The whole AI coding and threats and opportunities in our industry, makes me think that I might be right, but then again that could be my bias. I wanted to see how everybody else thinks about this. Do you also feel that when you're in a developer-focused subreddit, X communities, or other places, and even on Hacker News, the developers there are harsher in their responses, less friendly, more polarized, and, I would generalize it, grumpier? I remember reading something here a few weeks ago that did a data analysis comparison between Hacker News posts in the past and recent ones, and it sort of said that sentiments have shifted more negative recently. It feels like we all feel threatened by AI, excited by the opportunities, and at the same time, sometimes I feel that as AI has made coding and creation of SaaS companies so competitive that we're also anxious at the same time at the elevated level.

elo2000 1 day ago

Yeah. Everybody is feeling the squeeze. Not just developers, in my experience either—it's designers, product managers, doctors, lawyers. Anybody who does knowledge work and who perceives their future income to be uncertain.

devilsdata 21 hours ago

My career is coming to an end, and so is my world. Not much to look forward to.

MuGlobe 12 hours ago

Putting on my asbestos underwear... The thing is you have to move up the value chain. People use to write in machine code and complained that compilers were producing slop and couldnt be trusted. They were purist who said you always had to keep an eye on the machine code. (Yes I am that old). i worked for a company where EVERTYTHING had to be in assembly language, UIs, DBMS everything. They are gone now and now we work in HLLs

Its the same thing with AI. You can leverage you invaluable systems and low level knowledge to produce more value by managing AI coding. Your unique value is keeping the slop out of AI coding, That's most the work these days. But if you want to sling lines of code forever you are going the way off those guys who insisted on keying in opcodes and using punch cards.

Your job is changing. its only going away if you don't change with it. Dev backlogs never go to zero.

mikewarot 17 hours ago

My nickname at home is "Grump" or "Mr GrumpyPants"

I'm out of the workforce, so that's not driving my disquiet. The realization that we're about to feel the way that people felt when they realized "The Great War" was, in fact, just WWI.... only about "The Great Depression" weighs heavily on me.

Trump has speedrun the end of the Dollar's reserve currency status. Jensen's bubble introduced so much distortion and mal-investment that can't be recovered, it'll be having repercussions for years. That money should have been plowed into expanding the US manufacturing infrastructure to handle our internal needs in a post globalization world.

If trends continue, the rest of the world will finally be out from under the thumb of the US, so that's a plus for them.

---

On the plus side... I've got a PC with the ability to do billions of operations per second. Lazarus/Free Pascal are amazing development IDEs. I picked up a handful of complete computers for $5 each a few years ago at micro-center. I've got SDRs to play with, ham radio, (I'm KA9DGX), and now I'm finally at the end of living week to week just barely holding on thanks to our remaining social safety net.

---

ben_w 1 day ago

We've always been grumpy, I think?

Would be interesting to see a deeper analysis than just opinions though.

Ironically, one of the first things LLMs did well, before they could chat reliably, was sentiment analysis.

  • AnimalMuppet 1 day ago

    I don't think we've always been this grumpy.

    The Berlin Wall fell, and it was (supposedly) the end of history, and freedom won. At the same time, technological progress was amazing. Going from 8086 to 80286 to 80386 to 80486, each step did not feel like Intel going from generation 16 to generation 17. The change was dramatic.

    So we were going to not die in atomic fire, and live in a better and better world. It was a great time.

    Then came 2000, and the dotcom crash. And then 9/11. And then 2008 and the real estate crash. And Covid. And Ukraine. And Trump and, worse, Trump II. And inflation, and housing out of reach. And Russia, and to a lesser degree China and Iran, manipulating online discourse to make everyone hate everyone.

    We may always have been grumpy. I don't think we were always this grumpy.

    • ben_w 1 day ago

      Mmm.

      I graduated in 2006, so I may have entirely missed your good times.

      Or rather, they happened while I was a kid, starting about when I first discovered that people (adults and other kids) can be mean, and then when I was going through a pubescent goth phase.

  • muzani 3 hours ago

    It's a contour too.

    I know objectively there has been plenty of grumpy developers. There's a grumpy one in every company. That guy tends to get fired and one of the existing devs takes the role as the grumpy one. If I'm the sole dev, then I'm the grumpy one.

    HN has always had plenty of pessimists too. People who always say no, no, no and pad estimates because there's a lot of unknown unknowns.

    It's possible that the AI culture has created more teams and projects, and thus created more grumpy people because it's just a role.

kypro 16 hours ago

Personally I think the only way I can describe how I feel these days is that it's like I and everyone I loved has been diagnosed with terminal cancer, but no one believes me.

It's frustrating and scary, and I'm mourning the loss of the life I thought I would live, which I now believe will no longer come to pass.

I've become more withdrawn socially. I can't enjoy anything anymore, and I'm not looking after myself as I probably should. I know I'm becoming less pleasant to be around and I resent that, but it's also hard to be happy given what I believe is coming.

I know many people here think I'm being too doomer, perhaps mentally ill even, and that gives me a little relief, but at the back of my mind I remember feeling the same way a couple of years ago when everyone on HN was convinced AI was BS while I thought SWE as a profession would soon be more or less gone. People here are smart and I figured maybe therefore I was wrong, but I think ultimately my predictions on AI have always been consistently extremely on point and I'm trusting myself more these days. I've been building neural networks for 2 decades at this point. I know how they scale. Now we know how to train deep networks, there is no limit to what they can do without enough data, compute and time.

Over the last couple of months I've become increasingly convinced that it's now too late to stop what's coming. I strongly suspect that the internal models frontier labs have today is plenty for RSI, and therefore an intelligence explosion in the coming years. There's almost nothing we can do to stop this now, and certainly nothing I as an individual can do. I just wish I had more time. There were so many things I wanted to do.

  • hollerith 11 hours ago

    I feel the same way. The world seems like it would be in a good place if it weren't for the lack of recognition of the dangerousness of continuing AI research.