points by grapheneos 2 days ago

Fairphones don't provide a reasonable level of privacy and security. The updates are very poor with the devices not keeping up with those from the start and falling years behind. Fairphone 5 and earlier ship an end-of-life kernel with no plan to move on from it along with many similar issues. Their devices are much further from meeting our requirements than many mainstream devices.

/e/ is a very problematic fork of LineageOS very poor privacy and atrocious security. People would be far better off using standard LineageOS one of the better supported devices. An iPhone is far more private and drastically more secure than Murena products.

/e/ lacks crucial standard privacy and security patches. It fails to ship users standard Android, Chromium and Linux patches without enormous delays. It barely provides updates to the Linux kernel, drivers and firmware at all.

/e/ also doesn't provide important standard privacy or security protections. It lags years behind on providing the current generation protections and disables many of the most important ones. An operating system failing to protect against known privacy weaknesses does not have reasonable privacy. Lack of reasonable security also means any privacy protections can be easily bypassed.

/e/ includes their own privacy invasive services and sends user data to third parties. They spent years sending user speech data to OpenAI without obtaining consent and falsely claimed the data was anonymized when challenged over it. Despite how it's marketed, it includes many Google services with privileged integration into the OS. They have their own privacy invasive services including user tracking with unique identifiers in their update client.

/e/ and their for-profit company Murena have repeatedly pushed anti-privacy talking points from authoritarians claiming devices with strong privacy and security are for criminals and pedophiles. They've heavily targeted GrapheneOS this way making the outrageous claim that the userbase are mainly criminals and that it mainly benefits criminals. Here are 2 examples where Gaël Duval says this himself about privacy/security hardened devices in general, but there are many more examples:

https://x.com/GrapheneOS/status/2040887784253141142

https://clubic.com/actualite-604786-murena-e-os-interview.ht...

/e/ makes it far easier to remotely take over devices, violate user privacy from apps and bypass encryption to extract all the data from a device. These are exactly the kinds of devices authoritarians opposed to privacy and security want people to be using. These devices are much less private and drastically less secure than iPhones but are duping people into paying them for it with false marketing. They're regressing privacy and security instead of advancing it.

More information:

https://discuss.grapheneos.org/d/24134-devices-lacking-stand...

https://eylenburg.github.io/android_comparison.htm

https://codeberg.org/divested-mobile/divestos-website/raw/co...

https://community.e.foundation/t/voice-to-text-feature-using...