points by vrganj 2 days ago

I think there's a category error in a lot of these techno-optimist takes.

Abundance of productive capacity does not automatically equal abundant access to its products.

If all of this happens in a way where a few people control these new, automated means of production, all of these wonderful things do not automatically follow.

Why would they share? And worse yet, if they have this automated production capacity without reliance on labor, why would they interact positively with society at all? What's their incentive?

You're basically reduced to hoping for charity from a group of people that have repeatedly proven their lack thereof.

EvanAnderson 1 day ago

Right there with you. What's the motivation of anybody on the high end of the wealth inequality scale to share with the other end? They have nothing to gain and everything to lose.

It would be nice to hear the rationale behind those who are downvoting you.

  • jackie293746 1 day ago

    There are no downvotes on this website

  • treszkai 1 day ago

    There are people who share a significant proportion of their wealth with the significantly poorer, like Warren Buffett, Bill Gates, Dustin Moskovitz, and so on.[0] Some people choose to do good despite nothing tangible gained, whether they are poor and just putting their single dollar in a wicker basket, or literally billionaires and saving millions of lives with their money.

    Whether the owners of AI will choose to share, time will tell.

    [0]: https://impactlist.xyz/

    • vrganj 1 day ago

      > There are people who share a significant proportion of their wealth with the significantly poorer, like Warren Buffett, Bill Gates, Dustin Moskovitz, and so on.

      Yes, that is the charity one can hope for. But even in that lucky case, the issue I'm describing is structural. It's not like any of them share to the point of giving up their generationally privileged position. That poses the problem: Even if the people immediately in control of AI are pure selfless angels, over time and generations the likelihood of one not being so asymptotically approaches 100%. Sooner or later there will be a Caligula.

      • casey2 16 hours ago

        I wouldn't worry about that, structurally the government own everything and structurally we've been burning trillions of dollars on/in Africa for decades. Corporations are already like little AIs so if anyone that cares about their lot in live could have their own little group of corporations. Maybe virtual, maybe on their own planet.

        In the future inequality will look more like "my superagent's subsub-agents don't get nearly as much energy as that guy over there" while actual humans resource needs are all met

        • vrganj 8 hours ago

          > structurally the government own everything

          Clearly not everything, the most powerful AI systems and infrastructure to run them are all concentrated in private hands. And that's exactly the problem. In democratic societies, you get to vote on your government every couple of years. How do we vote out Elon, Altman or Zuck?

          > Corporations are already like little AIs so if anyone that cares about their lot in live could have their own little group of corporations

          I'm not sure what you're saying here. But not everyone can have a corporation, much less a group. It requires access to resources and capital in the first place, which makes it a self-perpetuating system of privilege and exclusion. How would the mom trying to make ends meet in, say a favela in Rio start her own megacorp?

          > In the future inequality will look more like "my superagent's subsub-agents don't get nearly as much energy as that guy over there"

          I don't think you're sufficiently engaging with the point I'm making, it feels like you're just asserting an end state without describing the way there, when precisely that is the most interesting bit. Who says you're getting any agents at all in the future? Once the owners of our centralized AI have bots that give them everything they want, what compels them to share with you? We're back to domination and relying on goodwill.

          > actual humans resource needs are all met

          Sure, we'll have the capacity to meet human needs. But will we have the structural incentives to? There's enough food production on Earth to end global hunger right now. But that was never the issue.

    • EvanAnderson 1 day ago

      I'm specifically worried about the people who use their wealth to influence political discourse to perpetuate wealth inequality. It makes sense to me that they would use technology, which fundamentally obviates their reliance on the labor of the less wealthy, to perpetuate inequality even more that they can thru political means.

      I don't feel like the generous wealthy can offset the influence of the wealthy who have the opposite goal.

      • vrganj 1 day ago

        > We could never win an election on getting certain things because we were in such a small minority, but maybe you could unilaterally change the world without having to constantly convince people and beg people and plead with people who are never going to agree with you through technological means, and this is where I think technology is this incredible alternative to politics.

        -- Peter Thiel

        It's incredible to me that was all said out loud.