klez 7 hours ago

My knowledge of physics is rather limited (especially about anything besides Newtonian dynamics), but why would an atom-sized thing, even with the extreme density it has, be disruptive to a star when its mass is still that of an asteroid? I mean, wouldn't it be like a hit from an actual asteroid?

Can someone help me understand why it is different?

  • andreareina 7 hours ago

    If the black hole just passes through the star, not much would happen. But the scenario is that (due to interactions with a third body) the black hole is "captured" and orbits inside the star, where it will feed on the star that captured it. "Atom sized" is just the event horizon, it will have gravitational effects beyond that.

    • b112 3 hours ago

      Mosquitoes are innocent bystanders, just caught in my gravity well, does the star hate the hole with the same passion?

  • gus_massa 6 hours ago

    An asteroid get heated, evaporates and "dissapears" (it actualy gets mixed, like a drop of ink in the ocean).

    But (unles it's very cold and a hard vacuum) the black holes can only grow. When one enters the star and is slow enough, it will start to absorb the gas in the star and grow.

    Due to the angular conservarion, you get a nice twirl and disk, that is the main part of the new work.

  • setopt 5 hours ago

    It’s analogous to why 1 gram of meat-eating bacteria is more dangerous to a human than 1 gram of olive oil: One of them will literally eat us from the inside, while the other will just dissolve and become part of us.

    • reactordev 3 hours ago

      Damn that’s a good analogy. Gets right to the heart of how black holes behave.

    • klez 1 hour ago

      Thanks but this doesn't really help me understand. Your answer basically boils down to "because they're different" (which I get, they behave differently, of course they're different) but it doesn't explain why or how they're different.

      • spwa4 21 minutes ago

        Stars are just gas. Stars are a very delicate balance between nuclear fusion and gravity's pull. It's easy to see that if you generate too much energy the outward force will become strong enough to just spread out the gas enough that it will take millions of years to re-collapse into a star. How much? Well the star is that fusion-gravity balance. Generate 0.1% more energy than fusion would generate and after some time (in the case of 0.1% a lot of time) you only have a gas cloud left, no more fusion, no more light, no more star.

        This is what happens with a supernova. Now because supernova's increase energy generation by millions of times at the end things happen rapidly ... and the vast majority of the star's material gets blasted off into space, and becomes planets and everything else, it does not become part of the neutron star or black hole.

        So all these black holes need to do is produce 0.1% more energy than fusion produced in the star ... and no more star (in a couple hundred thousand years). The more they exceed that power, the faster the star "vaporizes" into nothing, even while very little of the material actually goes into the black hole. It wouldn't even shine brighter ... it would just dissipate. Nothing left but a huge ball of hot orange gas, ready for the next presidential election.

  • bell-cot 5 hours ago

    If (and that is a very big if) an atom-sized black hole remains in the denser parts of a star long-term - then will be guzzling the star's guts 24x7, growing as it does. The bigger it gets, the faster it can guzzle star guts - so about like an "it started really small" fire in warehouse stuff full of kindling wood.

    • sandworm101 5 hours ago

      There are limits to the guzzle. There is still plenty of spin. Matter will spin on approach, causing intense heat and radiation that will push other matter away. There will be a balance between how much is being eaten, how much is converted into energy, and how much is held away by that energy.

      I would think that a star with a small black hole inside would evolve into a red giant, with maybe even jets forming, as more and more matter is pushed away by the sheer insanity of the energies involved.

      Like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quasi-star

      • TeMPOraL 5 hours ago

        So a bit like growing fire causing drafts and making random stuff explode, both of which will blow some of the potential fuel out of the way, but possibly on fire.

      • cowlevel 4 hours ago

        One thinks the inside of a star is already full of intense heat and radiation pushing things towards any empty space, unlike the situation in outer space

        • sandworm101 4 hours ago

          Different leagues. A star like our sun has a core that emits so strongly that the outer layers are indeed kept from the fusion furnace. Thats why our star will be so short lived. But a black hole consuming a star is the sort of thing that powers quazars, objects that shine brighter than a billion suns.

          • goda90 3 hours ago

            Would the forces of our Sun push away an asteroid-mass black hole before it had the chance to consume much?

            • sandworm101 2 hours ago

              No. A that black hole would be the size of a proton. Virtually no light/energy would/could ever push it. The light from stars can push around gas, not so much solid objects or super dense things like black holes.

              But it brings up an interesting question: how does a black hole interact with light if that black hole is smaller than the light's wavelength?

              • bell-cot 1 hour ago

                > how does a black hole interact with light if...

                While a real answer would be PhD-level physics, I'll note that 1960's-tech hand-held transistor radios were quite good at picking up AM broadcast radio waves - even though the wavelength of those is about 300 meters.

  • pfdietz 3 hours ago

    The black hole has to grow quite a bit before it disrupts the star. The interesting conclusions in this paper appear to be:

    1) PBH capture occurs by three body effects, for example due to a Jupiter-mass planet.

    2) The asteroid-mass initial PBH grows to maybe 1% of the mass of the star in a few million years.

    3) Once the enlarged hole (a few meters across) is spinning fast enough that matter cannot fall directly in, it forms an accretion disk that radiates so fiercely it disrupts the star in a minute or so.

A_D_E_P_T 7 hours ago

So, to summarize: If an atom-sized, asteroid-mass primordial black hole is trapped by a sunlike star, it will sink to the core, form a swirling accretion disk, and launch magnetic jets that explode the star in a flash of high-energy light detectable by current telescopes.

I had to laugh when I realized that's basically the plot to Stephen Baxter's 1992 novel Timelike Infinity. In it, future cultists launch a primordial atom-sized black hole into Jupiter, which after some time would force it to explode in a particular high-energy way, with that explosion itself being a message to very distant observers.

  • tomrod 3 hours ago

    Baxter is such a good novelist.

  • pfdietz 3 hours ago

    The atom-sized hole does not form the accretion disk; it has to grow for a while (millions of years) until that stage is reached.

OroPla 6 hours ago

What does it mean for a black hole to be tiny? Aren't all of them roughly the same size: a tiny little point? Possibly smaller than an atom? I don't have understanding, but to my knowledge the difference between black holes is mass, not size. So if the same little point holds a lot of mass it will have a gravitational pull on things farther away.

Or do we include the gravitational pull when speaking of their size?

  • jbotz 6 hours ago

    What is commonly meant by the "size" of a black hole is the diameter of its event horizon.

  • gus_massa 6 hours ago
    • tomrod 3 hours ago

      I'm confused. Doesn't Schwarzchild assume no rotation?

      • gus_massa 2 hours ago

        You are absolutely right, but there is a generalization for rotating black holes [let me google that] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerr_metric

        If you are not an astrophysic, you can pretend it's the same.

        • tomrod 2 hours ago

          All good. I'm also not an astrophysicist, hence my question! I have three channels I subscribe to in order to learn more about it and hopefully give some diversity and repetition so I can understand what ideas are in the hopper. (Not recommending here, just saying what I watch - Veritasium, PBS Space Time, Kurzgesagt).

  • spots_leopard 6 hours ago

    Talking about their gravitational radius, not the singularity at the center. Black holes have 3 properties ("No Hair Theorem") - Mass, Angular Momentum, Electric Charge.

    Greater mass = greater gravitational influence and radius (size).

    Also interesting: A non-rotating black hole (called a "Schwarzschild black hole") would have a "point" singularity at the center/origin, but these basically don't exist in nature because the black hole picks up angular momentum from what it "eats".

    Black holes that are rotating are called "Kerr black holes" and have much more complicated geometry like inner/outer event horizons, an "ergosphere", and they stretch out slightly equatorially, with a "ring-shaped" singularity rather than a central point.

  • willis936 6 hours ago

    Black holes smaller than the Chandrasekhar limit. The idea is that there is a lower bound of mass needed during a stellar implosion (fusion fuel spent to the point where fusion outward pressure is overcome by gravitational inward pressure) to overcome all other outward pressures we know of that would stop the implosion from continuing to an apparent singularity. The neutron degeneracy pressure (Pauli exclusion principle: subatomic particles don't want to overlap) should prevent a black home from forming and instead create a neutron star.

    I recommend Kip Thorne’s “Black Holes and Time Warps”. It's easy to follow and tells the stories of the humans making these discoveries.

  • andrewflnr 5 hours ago

    "Tiny" can just refer to the mass. We often talk about fundamental particles like that despite them not really having a size. But as others mentioned, it's usually the radius of the event horizon. The actual existence of the central singularity is somewhat disputed; personally I suspect it doesn't exist due to quantum gravitational effects.

    • tomrod 3 hours ago

      It's all related. Tiny mass means tiny event horizon means tiny gravity effect.

  • ndsipa_pomu 4 hours ago

    "Size" is typically understood to be the size of the event horizon.

    Beyond the event horizon we can't meaningfully talk about what happens as our best theories become nonsensical. It may be that all black holes shrink to a point or more likely a ring (it's likely that black holes spin and points can't spin), but we cannot get any information about whether that is true. Possibly, black holes take until the end of the universe to fully collapse and so maybe just beyond the event horizon is the still collapsing star that formed it - we just simply cannot tell.

elvisgodevelop 5 hours ago

An asteroid heats up and dissolves into plasma, whereas a captured primordial black hole can stay inside, keep accreting gas, and grow. Plus, "atom-sized" just refers to the event horizon—its gravity reaches much further out.

search_facility 7 hours ago

Interesting article, but this claim: "Primordial blackholes ... they could represent a significant component of dark matter" sounds strange. Afaik the problem of DM invisibility is that it is spread around, widely, not concentrated and hidden somewhere.

  • T-A 7 hours ago

    Dark matter is believed to exist based on observations on galactic and cosmological scales. On those scales, a cloud of small black holes separated by mere interstellar distances is practically indistinguishable from a continuum.

  • dragontamer 7 hours ago

    Primordial black holes are effectively invisible.

    They are only the size of around an atom, and have a mass around that of a typical asteroid.

    They are still black holes, so light cannot escape (and they are thus invisible). If a billion primordial black holes existed somewhere, they'd fly around kinda sorta like asteroids but unless they touched something they are otherwise completely invisible.

    Invisible to all forms of light. Too little mass for stars to move (larger black holes are found because bright stars orbit these mysterious holes in space)

    This article suggests what happens with a primordial black hole collision with a star. Maybe we can't see a primordial black hole directly but maybe there is hope for when stars and them directly interact, maybe then and only then will we ever detect one.

  • A_D_E_P_T 7 hours ago

    On galactic scales, a vast swarm of asteroid-mass primordial black holes would be spread out widely, forming the exact same kind of diffuse halo that dark matter is expected to form. Because each one is only the size of an atom, they don't emit light, rarely collide with anything, don't lens light in any way we'd detect, and interact almost exclusively through gravity.

    The assumption in general is that they'd behave just like an invisible, diffuse cloud of pure mass.

bell-cot 8 hours ago

, then here is how a few of them might show up in astronomical observations.

The "might show up" part sounds like pretty solid science. Vs. the "few" sounds like it'd be an incredibly small percentage of them.

rfgplk 7 hours ago

Electrons are black holes, black holes are electrons. Electrons aren't even fundamental but the result of the distortion of spacetime geometry. Cleanest explanation there is. There's also the likely explanation that electrons are effectively naked singularities, so if you want to explore black hole internals you can explore electrons/QED.

So where are these hypothetical primordial black holes? In your room, in your hand, in the air around you.

  • exe34 6 hours ago

    How do you get a blackhole to hold exactly -1e electric charge? Why don't two electrons merge and create a -2e object?

    • Timwi 6 hours ago

      You're asking a question that would require a theory of quantum gravity to answer, which we don't have.

      However, my gut instinct is that any such theory will also have to fully explain the Pauli exclusion principle, which then answers your question.

      • K0balt 5 hours ago

        I find the idea that matter may not “exist” at all but rather be an emergent property of spacetime itself rather more likely- it is essentially the physics manifestation of the simulation hypothesis, with data being the fundamental. That also makes it theoretically much more likely to be true.

        • Timwi 4 hours ago

          What theory does not have “data being the fundamental”? That seems to me a tautology. Anything a theory postulates to exist (e.g. an electron’s charge, spin, etc.) is data.

  • idiotsecant 3 hours ago

    God save us from HN armchair physicists.