Somewhat unrelated, but MacOS' behaviour in this regard infuriates me. It can start all your apps after a restart, yes, but it doesn't remember what desktop you had them in. So you get a dozen or more apps all dumped in the first desktop and you then have to try and sort through them. It's very typically Mac behaviour, this kind of half-baked, almost but not quite useful behaviour.
To head off the inevitable "why do you restart your laptop" questions, I mostly commute to work by bicycle and carry the laptop in my backpack. I always turn it off before I leave. If I'm driving I don't bother.
Because the jolting from the bike ride can wake the laptop up, and there's no ventilation. Sometimes I'm riding my mountain bike on tracks as well, which is a good bit rougher. It seems a lot safer to power it off.
I’ve taken laptops across five continents in my 4x4s, including the worst roads in the world in west Africa, remote Australia, south and Central America, etc.
Never once had a problem with them sleeping and staying asleep.
> To head off the inevitable "why do you restart your laptop" questions, I mostly commute to work by bicycle and carry the laptop in my backpack. I always turn it off before I leave. If I'm driving I don't bother.
This only raised more questions. Why does it need to be off to bicycle but not to drive?
> Why does it need to be off to bicycle but not to drive?
Not OP, but my guess would be that the machine isn't in a bag in the car. Odd, but it would explain the difference. I don't know about MacOS but in recent years Windows has taken to waking itself up, either to do updates or just apparently because it wants to, and leaves the machine that way running down the battery to operate as a space-heater in whatever bag the machine is enclosed in. Byebye battery, and perhaps even doing overheating related damage to the machine.
If you re-enable proper hibernate and suspend that way this can't happen, but proper hibernate seems disabled by default in part because on many machines these days don't reliably wake up from that state (my DayJob laptop does, my home laptop does not).
I travel with my Apple laptop in a bag regularly, I reboot it pretty much just when doing OS updates, and never actually shut it down. It travels fine and doesn't overheat. This is how I've traveled with them for 15+ years now with a couple of Intel ones and now an M3, and it has never been a problem.
If you have one that is overheating, then it's a problem with that one's hardware, or its specific configuration (something you've installed or some setting you've chosen to enable/disable).
I think the bike ride shakes the laptop more, so any open apps slide down into the first desktop (or the last one, depending which way your laptop is facing in your bag).
You joke but this actually reminds me of a problem people were having with macbooks about 10 years ago. There was a yellow discoloration in spots on the screen. Most forum posts concluded water damage but there were cases of the spots moving and it was eventually figured out that if you stored a still-warm macbook in a backpack, a layer in the LCD de-laminated. Once this happened, fluid pooled in the bottom-most edge of the screen, and you'd see a yellow area on whatever side of the screen was facing down in your backpack.
I'm a little paranoid about the jolting the laptop gets in the backpack which could wake it up and it's sitting in a padded sleeve with no ventilation.
I've been cycling with a Mac in my bag for about two decades and never had this happen. The year I tried a Surface it was constantly waking up in my bag and draining its battery. The succession of Macs (mostly Airs) that I've had have never done this.
Thing is that there are many ways applications can be setup to open on login, only one is controllable via that checkbox and the settings app - I believe the setting accessible via dock context menu is a different mechanism and so is launchd
> It can start all your apps after a restart, yes, but it doesn't remember what desktop you had them in. So you get a dozen or more apps all dumped in the first desktop
For what its worth, this is how kde on linux does it too.
Because the jolting from the bike ride can wake the laptop up, and there's no ventilation. Sometimes I'm riding my mountain bike on tracks as well, which is a good bit rougher. It seems a lot safer to power it off.
Very handy. Early Xerox machines (yes, those) had this feature. They would store the working memory to the slow-as-molasses hard drive. You'd have to wait once you want to shut down as the cursor would change to indicate a status code showing progress of writing the memory over. I forget the exact numbers, 3028 or something. Only once you see this were you to turn off the computer. It had a hibernate mode (!) of sorts that used this. Using it would allow you boot up in a few minutes rather than 10-15 minutes (yes, 10-15 minutes) that a cold boot would normally take.
I used to look after a IBM System/36. IPL (Initial Program Load) took about 40 minutes. This was in the mid '90s. We had several warm summers in the UK back then. One of the fans was a bit sticky and if it did not start (I had a long straw to prod it) then the system would overheat within about two hours and shutdown.
This was a pie factory and we had bags of dry ice for emergency cooling, which I had to use sometimes on the IBM beastie.
A S/36 is the size of a large chest freezer and there is loads of space within the cabinet to pop bags of frozen CO2 to keep it cool.
Not just Windows. I'm running CachyOS Linux nowadays, and barely a week goes past without an update which changes core files and tells me I need to reboot.
The restartable apps feature was actually enabled by default back in 2017 with a Windows Update^[1], but most people were confused and thought their computers weren't restarting properly while power users wanted to have a clean desktop on restart. (At the time, Microsoft forced this behavior, with no easy opt-out.)
I think Microsoft should try the MacOS approach here, where a prompt pops up with a checkbox for restoring everything on restart. Newer hardware has probably taken care of (or at least helped with) the slow startup times.
But then you would get folks who expected their machine to restart with no prompt and left for coffee or bed. Instead they leave their machine open and unlocked for mischief. (This is me every other time my work Mac's reboot is blocked by some process)
As much as I hate tray icon popups I think it's somewhat appropriate here.
Great tip. If you are OCD about startup apps, get Sysinternals Autoruns. Most publishers have moved startup tasks to one of the other 15 registry locations to trigger startup.
The biggest blight right now is Task Scheduler. MS Edge has 8 tasks running , just for checking & performing updates. MS 365 (office) has > 20 . And they trigger on login, or when the machine is idle.
Personally when there's a discussion about the cost/benefits of legacy software support within windows, it's aspects like this I really wish they had the ability to 'tidy up'. It feels like MS don't have the authority over how their own OS is used (despite trying to do so in... other aspects) that it has grown so esoteric, and I wouldn't be surprised if they add in other categories for third parties to hide within.
I agree. On one hand , MS deserves tremendous credit for backward compatibility, but they also deserve an F on migrating vendors to the newer interfaces. They also deserve an F on transparency and control. They added one page for startup apps to Task manager, omitting visibility into 90% of the startup apps.
MacOS has done a great job balancing compatibility with migrations. Give vendors a grace period (e.g. 5+ years for intel builds) and then cut them off.
I can think of a handful of functionality that has concurrent / redundant implementations.
1. starting things up: 5+ registry locations, scheduled tasks, services, custom triggers etc.
2. message passing : you have com+ , MS' event bus (i forget the name) , probably 2 more
3. Don't get me started on UI toolkits
4. i have apps still trying to install .net 3.5 (20+ years old now).
With thanksgiving coming up soon. I can't stop being thankful that linux has completely replaced windows for me and I never have to use windows again except for rare gaming session. Thank you open source devs!
From the article, caught my eyes and heart: "Seven of nine came back"
I wish she would come back and stay. Now that Picard has left, the chances are low she will come back another time :(
My Christmas wish: seven of nine
Have his son portray another clone...
Somewhat unrelated, but MacOS' behaviour in this regard infuriates me. It can start all your apps after a restart, yes, but it doesn't remember what desktop you had them in. So you get a dozen or more apps all dumped in the first desktop and you then have to try and sort through them. It's very typically Mac behaviour, this kind of half-baked, almost but not quite useful behaviour.
To head off the inevitable "why do you restart your laptop" questions, I mostly commute to work by bicycle and carry the laptop in my backpack. I always turn it off before I leave. If I'm driving I don't bother.
What difference does riding your bike make compared to driving?
It’s asleep, it doesn’t matter how you transport it.
Because the jolting from the bike ride can wake the laptop up, and there's no ventilation. Sometimes I'm riding my mountain bike on tracks as well, which is a good bit rougher. It seems a lot safer to power it off.
I’ve taken laptops across five continents in my 4x4s, including the worst roads in the world in west Africa, remote Australia, south and Central America, etc.
Never once had a problem with them sleeping and staying asleep.
> To head off the inevitable "why do you restart your laptop" questions, I mostly commute to work by bicycle and carry the laptop in my backpack. I always turn it off before I leave. If I'm driving I don't bother.
This only raised more questions. Why does it need to be off to bicycle but not to drive?
> Why does it need to be off to bicycle but not to drive?
Not OP, but my guess would be that the machine isn't in a bag in the car. Odd, but it would explain the difference. I don't know about MacOS but in recent years Windows has taken to waking itself up, either to do updates or just apparently because it wants to, and leaves the machine that way running down the battery to operate as a space-heater in whatever bag the machine is enclosed in. Byebye battery, and perhaps even doing overheating related damage to the machine.
If you re-enable proper hibernate and suspend that way this can't happen, but proper hibernate seems disabled by default in part because on many machines these days don't reliably wake up from that state (my DayJob laptop does, my home laptop does not).
> I don't know about MacOS
Clearly, because this is the sort of thing Windows famously does, and MacOS famously does not do.
Are we talking backwards compatibility?
No? Nobody mentioned that at all.
I travel with my Apple laptop in a bag regularly, I reboot it pretty much just when doing OS updates, and never actually shut it down. It travels fine and doesn't overheat. This is how I've traveled with them for 15+ years now with a couple of Intel ones and now an M3, and it has never been a problem.
If you have one that is overheating, then it's a problem with that one's hardware, or its specific configuration (something you've installed or some setting you've chosen to enable/disable).
Microsoft created a new standard for how PCs sleep (that simply doesn't work properly) called Modern Standby which is at fault here.
https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_Standby
I think the bike ride shakes the laptop more, so any open apps slide down into the first desktop (or the last one, depending which way your laptop is facing in your bag).
You joke but this actually reminds me of a problem people were having with macbooks about 10 years ago. There was a yellow discoloration in spots on the screen. Most forum posts concluded water damage but there were cases of the spots moving and it was eventually figured out that if you stored a still-warm macbook in a backpack, a layer in the LCD de-laminated. Once this happened, fluid pooled in the bottom-most edge of the screen, and you'd see a yellow area on whatever side of the screen was facing down in your backpack.
I'm a little paranoid about the jolting the laptop gets in the backpack which could wake it up and it's sitting in a padded sleeve with no ventilation.
I've been cycling with a Mac in my bag for about two decades and never had this happen. The year I tried a Surface it was constantly waking up in my bag and draining its battery. The succession of Macs (mostly Airs) that I've had have never done this.
Somewhat unrelated, but MacOS' behaviour in this regard infuriates me.
I have a different gripe.
I close all windows, and quit all programs. Then when I restart macOS, it all comes back anyway.
Despite un-checking "Reopen windows when logging in" on the Restart or Shut Down dialog box?
Thing is that there are many ways applications can be setup to open on login, only one is controllable via that checkbox and the settings app - I believe the setting accessible via dock context menu is a different mechanism and so is launchd
If they were already closed that checkbox shouldn't matter.
Yes, I experience this as well, mostly during software updates. I always close my apps before the restart, too!
extetnal monitors don’t wake up fast enough and cross platform apps dont use the mac native way of saving window positions.
> It can start all your apps after a restart, yes, but it doesn't remember what desktop you had them in. So you get a dozen or more apps all dumped in the first desktop
For what its worth, this is how kde on linux does it too.
FWIW: KDE is currently doing what it calls "real fake session management" on Wayland. There are plans to do it properly. It might take a while.
I only ride a bike, no driving, it's been a decade or more of that and it never required me to shutdown any MacBook.
Both my work and personal MacBooks only get restarted for updates, shutdowns are a once-a-year events.
Can you explain more why a bike ride requires a shutdown for you?
Because the jolting from the bike ride can wake the laptop up, and there's no ventilation. Sometimes I'm riding my mountain bike on tracks as well, which is a good bit rougher. It seems a lot safer to power it off.
Very handy. Early Xerox machines (yes, those) had this feature. They would store the working memory to the slow-as-molasses hard drive. You'd have to wait once you want to shut down as the cursor would change to indicate a status code showing progress of writing the memory over. I forget the exact numbers, 3028 or something. Only once you see this were you to turn off the computer. It had a hibernate mode (!) of sorts that used this. Using it would allow you boot up in a few minutes rather than 10-15 minutes (yes, 10-15 minutes) that a cold boot would normally take.
10-15 minutes? Holy guacamole
I used to look after a IBM System/36. IPL (Initial Program Load) took about 40 minutes. This was in the mid '90s. We had several warm summers in the UK back then. One of the fans was a bit sticky and if it did not start (I had a long straw to prod it) then the system would overheat within about two hours and shutdown.
This was a pie factory and we had bags of dry ice for emergency cooling, which I had to use sometimes on the IBM beastie.
A S/36 is the size of a large chest freezer and there is loads of space within the cabinet to pop bags of frozen CO2 to keep it cool.
And now I'm reading and answering this using a computer that fits in my hand, some 30 years later. That is crazy.
ElevenForum links for that, which will also tell you the registry settings:
https://www.elevenforum.com/t/turn-on-or-off-automatically-r...
https://www.elevenforum.com/t/turn-on-or-off-restore-previou...
I truly miss Sun Solaris desktop sessions. Very powerful and granular, even down to Window sizes and placement, across Workspaces too! (Desktops)
Those settings wouldn't be needed if Windows wouldn't insist on rebooting itself ...
Concur. The article gets at this, but most of the times this would be useful for me are due to windows updates forcing a restart.
Not just Windows. I'm running CachyOS Linux nowadays, and barely a week goes past without an update which changes core files and tells me I need to reboot.
The restartable apps feature was actually enabled by default back in 2017 with a Windows Update^[1], but most people were confused and thought their computers weren't restarting properly while power users wanted to have a clean desktop on restart. (At the time, Microsoft forced this behavior, with no easy opt-out.)
I think Microsoft should try the MacOS approach here, where a prompt pops up with a checkbox for restoring everything on restart. Newer hardware has probably taken care of (or at least helped with) the slow startup times.
[1]: https://windowscentral.com/windows-10-fall-creators-update-u...
But then you would get folks who expected their machine to restart with no prompt and left for coffee or bed. Instead they leave their machine open and unlocked for mischief. (This is me every other time my work Mac's reboot is blocked by some process)
As much as I hate tray icon popups I think it's somewhat appropriate here.
Great tip. If you are OCD about startup apps, get Sysinternals Autoruns. Most publishers have moved startup tasks to one of the other 15 registry locations to trigger startup.
The biggest blight right now is Task Scheduler. MS Edge has 8 tasks running , just for checking & performing updates. MS 365 (office) has > 20 . And they trigger on login, or when the machine is idle.
Personally when there's a discussion about the cost/benefits of legacy software support within windows, it's aspects like this I really wish they had the ability to 'tidy up'. It feels like MS don't have the authority over how their own OS is used (despite trying to do so in... other aspects) that it has grown so esoteric, and I wouldn't be surprised if they add in other categories for third parties to hide within.
I agree. On one hand , MS deserves tremendous credit for backward compatibility, but they also deserve an F on migrating vendors to the newer interfaces. They also deserve an F on transparency and control. They added one page for startup apps to Task manager, omitting visibility into 90% of the startup apps.
MacOS has done a great job balancing compatibility with migrations. Give vendors a grace period (e.g. 5+ years for intel builds) and then cut them off.
I can think of a handful of functionality that has concurrent / redundant implementations.
1. starting things up: 5+ registry locations, scheduled tasks, services, custom triggers etc.
2. message passing : you have com+ , MS' event bus (i forget the name) , probably 2 more
3. Don't get me started on UI toolkits
4. i have apps still trying to install .net 3.5 (20+ years old now).
With thanksgiving coming up soon. I can't stop being thankful that linux has completely replaced windows for me and I never have to use windows again except for rare gaming session. Thank you open source devs!
I hate this usually
Even with all the settings turned off it still does it sometimes. Maddening.