A pacifist friend gave me a book to read to explain her point of view, Island by Aldus Huxley. It is about two islands, one a peaceful paradise and the other a martial dictatorship. She wanted to teach me the lesson of how much better it was to live on the peaceful one, and I couldn't help but agree.
But she didn't think it was relevant that in the book the martial island then easily conquers the pacifist one and destroys their way of life. I did. To me it was a lesson that "si vis pacem, para bellum".
I see her position in the demands of these tech workers. In the fullness of time it wasn't ethical for the peaceful islanders to refuse responsibility for their own defense, as it set the stage for the downfall of the society they loved, in the name of being caring people. A modern phrase for this is suicidal empathy. Short sighted works too.
If you think you live on the martial island, the ethical move is to stop helping to build their whole economy, not just their military.
To me a union is preparing for war. You have your defense set up as opposed to unilateral disarmament which is not having an organised workplace.
Suicidal empathy is often used to say we shouldn’t have immigration, foreign aid, anti genocide courts etc. I see not having that stuff as being wilfully blind to the world around you. Or just dismissing empathy and long-term fixes like creating consensus to fix the environment because you want to make money or get re-elected.
“ Saad also argues that people should start demanding reciprocity rather than asking for nothing in return, citing foreign aid that the U.S. and Canadian governments send to African countries as an example of suicidal empathy.
He also praises Musk's Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) for eliminating "a breathtaking amount of corruption, waste, and fraud."”
DOGE was a complete waste of time and resources. And the idea that the US doesn’t get reciprocity for aid or even really suffers is absurd. “Suicidal” is so absurd that I can’t believe people take it seriously.
That is a microcosm of the total use of that phrase, and only for the least controversial of the three things you're accusing the phrase of.
Even in that context though, of foreign aid, just as it wouldn't be arguing in good faith to only cite Bonnie Blue when talking about the totality of sexual liberalism, you shouldn't do the same here. There are coming up on 10 billion opinions in the world on any given topic; don't think that the one you're shown must be the usual or representative one.
Is the old thing 'kill everybody'? Rats manage to do that. They can tell by odor if another rat is an immigrant from elsewhere and kill it.
I feel like they have a better excuse for that behavior: they're rats. All of 'em, including the blood-n-soil homelander rats. They're rats, what do you expect.
In Ivanhoe by Sir Walter Scott, the serf Gurth wears a brass collar soldered around his neck inscribed with his master's name. 19th century union organizers would frequently cite this to suggest that if anti-unionists had their way, we'd all still be wearing that collar.
No, just a bit uncomfortable. There is a trend among people who are committed to ethics or religion to take on vows of poverty or forsaking material things - in some sense because that is the practical implication of taking ethics seriously. Otherwise people end up leaning in to some pretty dreadful things by implication.
But it isn't suicidal. Usually they get left alone.
> If you think you live on the martial island, the ethical move is to stop helping to build their whole economy, not just their military.
Yes, and if the "martial island" is actually a globalized system that dominates the working life of most people, what is to be done? Perhaps building institutions outside of that system, organized around shared moral values and material interests and on the basis of social trust rather than self-interested competition, is a good starting point.
Speaking of socialism. I'm not an expert in the history of the subject, but I was always confused by the emphasis on the proletariat as the working class. Surely the REAL working class were the peasants? At the time, early 1900s, the proletariat were a tiny minority. This talk about propetariat feels more a coup than a revolution.
I think in modern parlance you'd say that Lenin and others were "influencers". They promoted not the right thing, as they would themselves argue ad nauseum, but the thing that pandered to their followers and so benefited them personally.
I'm not sure when the word "ethical" was transformed into "whatever my opinion is on x is right and everyone else is unethical".
If the west can't use any surveillance or develop weapons it will leave it's citizens exposed to some very unethical attacks: terrorism and foreign invasion.
I agree with your core idea that we should abandon our rose-tinted dreams of an eternally peaceful world and make sure we are well-equipped to protect the world we value.
However, the leap from “we should be ready to defend ourselves” to “therefore, we should allow Google to enter into unethical contracts and develop hostile, superintelligent AI capable of destroying us” is much harder to justify.
The fundamental flaw in this argument is: how can we guarantee that Google or any other lab will weaponize AI in our interests? How do we control it? How do we ensure that it won’t be turned into a weapon of surveillance and control against us and domestic political opposition? We live in an era of unprecedented economic inequality, with politicians increasingly relying on oligarchic wealth and unethical practices to win votes.
Therefore, the strategic solution cannot simply be “let’s pretend we don’t need weapons.” I agree that thinking otherwise is delusional. But until we have proper guardrails in place and meaningful oversight of frontier AI labs, organizing unions and pushing for slower development and tighter controls is a better approach than simply closing our eyes and hoping that Google executives know what they’re doing.
It seems like you may be conflating multiple issues. Unionization makes a lot of sense in this economical climate. Some demands made by the union may be too idealistic, but the general direction is reasonable.
All the major blocks have nuclear weapons though, so this island situation isn't really applicable.
Things like surveillance, spying, methods that can figure out what people are thinking and doing are also something which can enable the apparent stabilization of genuinely unstable societies, such as can be created by mass immigration and the like, so it isn't clear that developing these things for intelligence or military applications will bring order or strengthen society-- it can instead become a means whereby society is able to function while operating in a manner which will eventually destroy it utterly.
Finally, if AI is to be used for warfare, and this to be beneficial to society-- i.e. strengthen the internally peaceful island which still prepares for war. Present wars have not however had this character. Nicaragua is certainly not inimical to the EU-- Iran is, but not in a manner that makes it reasonable to destabilize it, Iraq, Afghanistan, etc. certainly weren't. The one war we have is the Russian war, and there what use is AI really? I see the interesting things as increase the strike range of drones and things that have very little to do with frontier LLMs or the sort of work that DeepMind is famous for.
So I actually think your remark while perhaps true in many other contexts is absolutely wrong in this context. I think Britain is better off if DeepMind stays out of supplying weapons or surveillance technology whether to the US or anybody else.
I suppose this story alludes to the invasion of Chatham islands by two Maori tribes, right? The people of the islands, the Moriori, followed Nunuko's law and decided to not fight back. The Maori tribes proceeded to genocide and enslave them
Absolutely fascinating read. I guess number one for me was that a group of 2000 people managed to keep through oral tradition alone the story of their chief from the 16th century.
We have a responsibility to ensure our work is not used to harm society. - I applaud the effort, but it's hard to see this working out in reality. Google does so much business in defense that it's hard to see how a union could affect that.
People are being paid millions to switch labs, so maybe they can use their huge amount of leverage against those in Google who want to sell those big government contracts, or maybe it'll attract everyone else who doesn't want to contribute to AI for war making?
of course it'll affect google, llm tech is the currently the highest paid talent and also the most rarest, it's not like there's a post-bootcamp line waiting to be employed
it's just that the momentum of the technology is bigger than these engineers. Anthropic likes to say big things about humanity as well, and it seems like they're getting railroaded. Even if they manage to stand up to management will it do any good in the long run?
Anthropic basically reversed course and begged to be allowed back in to the DoD contract- despite probably what most people who work there would prefer. I'm not sure a union would have done any good in that case.
Well, it is not defence anymore. It is the department of war.
It always was, ask anyone from Libya, Syria, Afghanistan or Iraq. But now that the threat is in first world countries like Canada or Denmark, it feels different.
Recently, there has been a lot of controversy about Prospect in the UK. I am not following this subject closely, but both Reddit and trustpilot are full with the negative comments on this union.
> Recently, there has been a lot of controversy about Prospect in the UK. I am not following this subject closely, but both Reddit and trustpilot are full with the negative comments on this union.
Is that FUD? Provide details on those controversies, instead of vague negativity without even any clear links.
Also management and owners hate unions, and shown by the extreme level of propaganda and indoctrination they introduce when one is trying to organize. They want to be dictators of their fifes, with unquestioned power. I wouldn't hold it above them to flood some site with negative reviews.
Prospect is seen by many as an "employer's union".
They are the union employers bring in voluntarily to divide&conquer workers, convince workers they don't need a union representing their rights because "you already have Prospect", misinform workers etc.
Bringing in an employer-friendly union is a common union busting tactic.
There are several industry and trade associations that Big Tech and other technology companies belong to. They lobby both state and federal governments for favourable regulation, to fight restrictive policies and sometimes to stifle competition from overseas. They also lobby the government individually, since they are obscenely rich. So if employers can collectively bargain for favourable policies, why can't labour? It is actually in the employees' interest to act as a collective since it gives them more power.
This world is so bizarre. I couldn't think of a group of workers more privileged in terms of pay and perks than DeepMind employees yet this is where i'm reading about worker unions as the term shifts to be about ethical use of company products.
Software engineers should have learned this. In the 2000s-2010s tech boom, "why would I need a union?" In the 2020s AI tech crash, "damn I'm getting laid off"
Unions don’t stop layoffs, they just change who gets laid off to be less economical for the firm. Generally that means younger, more productive workers are let go ahead of senior, less productive ones.
Union can do way more than this. As an example, in France, the unions are often helping to negotiate the terms of the layoff to ensure :
- That employee can be requalified, re-trained, re-located, if possible and wanted instead of straight up laid off
- That laid off employees can benefit from paid training to help them find a job after being laid off
- The compensation for volunteers who choose to get laid off first
- And many other things
(note that unions in France are organized very differently than in the U.S and have different incentives)
A lot of time, they act as a “moderation” force between the will of the shareholders and the employees. They cannot really change the economical reality. And even if a company doing well but want to make pretty number before selling chunks of the company, there are many ways to do this. The union often ensure that they can't take measure that are too drastic with important human cost.
> Unions don’t stop layoffs, they just change who gets laid off to be less economical for the firm. Generally that means younger, more productive workers are let go ahead of senior, less productive ones. [GP]
> As an example, in France, the unions are often helping to negotiate the terms of the layoff to ensure… [OP]
The youth unemployment rate in France for 14-24 year olds is near 20%. [1]
Are you sure that unions are doing enough to help and protect young workers?
> Are you sure that unions are doing enough to help and protect young workers?
Never claimed they did :) . And this is an even longer debate to be honest. France, like every country in the world these days but especially “rich” country, is getting older. And “older” folk vote more and are likelier to be part of a union. So the unions (and the politician) have had more incentive to focus on the older part of the French population. Union also focus on worker rights, not people who never worked, which mean that youth with almost 0 job experience was always a blind spot for them (there is students unions and such, but it's another thing too). Not that they don't anything about that, but they don't defend as heavily young worker as they do for retirement benefit…
But whatever. No system is ever perfect, and I am certainly not claiming it is. But perfection is the enemy of progress. I was pointing out that the previous comment was an incomplete vision of what unions can do with layoff.
You did imply that though which is why I quoted not just you but the GP comment to keep the context front and center.
Unions don’t seem to be working well for young people in terms of employment, in France at least.
Interestingly enough the US and Germany which I’d suppose the US has fewer unions and Germany more, seem to both be providing better opportunities for their youngest. At least in terms of employment. So there seems to be something rather uniquely wrong in France in terms of youth unemployment. I wonder what that is?
I've seen this play out a few times. Older folks often go on to say it's about protecting against age discrimination but in all honesty it boils down to skill deterioration because they didn't bother to keep up.
Just because the house I'm selling is expensive, doesn't mean I'm not going to try and get a good price for it.
You should unionize and negotiate for better terms, no matter how good your terms are already. Your employer isn't going to negotiate for you against themselves.
>You should unionize and negotiate for better terms, no matter how good your terms are already
A business only has a fixed amount of money it can spend on wages. Unionizing is not going to bring it up if you're already near the top of the pay scale for your role, and if it brings the wages of your lower-paid colleagues up then that means there'll be less left to pay those at the top so the wages of top earners will come down.
If you aren't in a union, you weren't negotiating as well as you could have been, therefore you left money on the table. All a union does is level the playing field so workers can negotiate as one body, just like the company does.
"near the top of the pay scale for your role" does not mean you are anywhere near the top of the pay scale for the organisation.
This is the madness of engineers making $200k thinking their interests are more aligned with the executives on $10,000,000 pa than the people mopping the floor for 40 grand.
Yes, absolutely you want the union to negotiate more money for lower-paid staff because that is YOU, buddy.
A business has a fixed amount of money it can spend in total. It has a team whose job is to minimise the percentage of it that's wages.
Unions can't create more money than the business actually has. Many unions have made this mistake and taken themselves down with the business. Many others haven't.
Profit is value generated by workers' time and effort that is being allocated elsewhere.
A business that has operating expenses equal to revenue is not withholding anything. One option available in this case is for workers to improve their productivity, no loss of jobs are necessary if there are market opportunities available. What better incentive is there for workers to improve their productivity than to share in the benefits of that improvement.
Also, a pay scale is a policy set by the business. Individual employees working at a level subject to scales like these have no influence on what these scales are, unions however spend a lot of time negotiating these scales with businesses. The C-suite captures a lot of value (CEOs now earn +300x more than the typical worker), this is a wage, and included operating expenses, that gap could come down quite a lot without impacting on the executive's lifestyle...
If you're not earning minimum wage you already have pretty good leverage to get what you're worth. Otherwise the company would just pay the minimum wage. Unions can create a barrier to entry for new employees to push wages up [0], but employees already have enough negotiating power to negotiate a fair wage.
[0] If every industry does this, most people end up worse off because it just makes it harder for people to switch industries.
UTAW is just a branch of the CWU, and plenty of established finance / tech / media companies already recognise the CWU - it and Prospect are the two biggest white-collar private-sector unions in the UK.
The only bizarre aspect is that Deepmind are seeking to have a separate agreement rather than follow the rest of Google (where Prospect already has recognition).
Prospect don't have recognition in Google, they signed a sweetheart deal for access only (new rules in UK as of last month) but it seems like they have a "laughably low membership" in Google: https://novaramedia.com/2026/11/04/google-uk-signs-sweethear...
You’ve presupposed that the “privileged” in question are positioned as wage-earning employees in an industry in which there is a union, and you’ve chosen to presume that the only reason for resistance to your union is “privilege.” There are other possible roles in life than wage-earning employee, and even for wage-earning employees there are reasons other than “privilege” for wanting the freedom to negotiate their own terms.
you've said so many words and nothing at the same time, why not just include a list of why would your average wage employer not benefit form an union then?
So they shouldn't have a voice in how their work is used because they're paid well?
Many of them are specialists in domains where they can't get work in many other places - they can't walk around handing out resumes hoping the local coffee shop just happens to need an applied scientist with a PhD in reinforcement learning...
"Better working conditions" is not just about salary and whether you get a free lunch. It's also about agency, purpose and growth.
Those staff are arguing that at least two of those are misaligned right now. It's easy to argue they "shouldn't complain", but have some empathy and be glad that somebody, somewhere, is arguing for ethics and principles to start being baked into the tech industry because heck, we really do seem to need more it right now.
> This world is so bizarre. I couldn't think of a group of workers more privileged in terms of pay and perks than DeepMind employees yet this is where i'm reading about worker unions as the term shifts to be about ethical use of company products.
You can't unionise unless you have some minimum of power otherwise you get defeated with classic union busting techniques.
It's so funny how the HN cohort will always see themselves as temporarily embarrassed executives rather than the workers they are. For some reason management has been very effectively pulling the wool over the eyes of the workers here, right up until the slaughter begins.
> Which is exactly what the capital class wants the peasants to think.
Sorry I can only think what I’ve been told to think and can’t deviate because you’ve taken away my agency and ability to think for myself with your assertion.
> Not everyone’s world view is shaped or framed by a workers versus executives conflict
Yes it is. (In a capitalist system.) If you work for a living, and you've not consciously considered owner-worker relations in your world view, then your world view has been shaped not by your choice, but by the owner class against your interests.
No it's not - or rather, if it is, then I can only support the owner class because you've by your argument here have removed my agency. I have no choice but to support them and can't change because as you said they control what I think (and you too).
Yeah this is going to age like milk. Too little, too late, too diffused.
You don’t want to lose your job (a charitable way of saying this is that you can at least influence the decisions from within, a false sense of purpose), because you see the writing on the wall.
What makes you think that the management cabal is going to sit by idly? What’s your leverage? Domain knowledge? Zip. Experience/Taste? Nada.
They have all the compute. You’re planning on leveraging this by going to a competitor? Good luck trying to convince them that you’re going to work loyally with them.
Too little, too late, too diffuse. Should have started this 10 years ago, attention was all they needed.
A pacifist friend gave me a book to read to explain her point of view, Island by Aldus Huxley. It is about two islands, one a peaceful paradise and the other a martial dictatorship. She wanted to teach me the lesson of how much better it was to live on the peaceful one, and I couldn't help but agree.
But she didn't think it was relevant that in the book the martial island then easily conquers the pacifist one and destroys their way of life. I did. To me it was a lesson that "si vis pacem, para bellum".
I see her position in the demands of these tech workers. In the fullness of time it wasn't ethical for the peaceful islanders to refuse responsibility for their own defense, as it set the stage for the downfall of the society they loved, in the name of being caring people. A modern phrase for this is suicidal empathy. Short sighted works too.
If you think you live on the martial island, the ethical move is to stop helping to build their whole economy, not just their military.
To me a union is preparing for war. You have your defense set up as opposed to unilateral disarmament which is not having an organised workplace.
Suicidal empathy is often used to say we shouldn’t have immigration, foreign aid, anti genocide courts etc. I see not having that stuff as being wilfully blind to the world around you. Or just dismissing empathy and long-term fixes like creating consensus to fix the environment because you want to make money or get re-elected.
> Suicidal empathy is often used to say we shouldn’t have immigration, foreign aid, anti genocide courts etc.
No it's not.
From https://time.com/article/2026/05/19/suicidal-empathy-elon-mu... :
“ Saad also argues that people should start demanding reciprocity rather than asking for nothing in return, citing foreign aid that the U.S. and Canadian governments send to African countries as an example of suicidal empathy.
He also praises Musk's Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) for eliminating "a breathtaking amount of corruption, waste, and fraud."”
DOGE was a complete waste of time and resources. And the idea that the US doesn’t get reciprocity for aid or even really suffers is absurd. “Suicidal” is so absurd that I can’t believe people take it seriously.
Don't bother, this user never argues in good faith, just repeats stuff he heard elsewhere and abandons the discussion when proven incorrect
That is a microcosm of the total use of that phrase, and only for the least controversial of the three things you're accusing the phrase of.
Even in that context though, of foreign aid, just as it wouldn't be arguing in good faith to only cite Bonnie Blue when talking about the totality of sexual liberalism, you shouldn't do the same here. There are coming up on 10 billion opinions in the world on any given topic; don't think that the one you're shown must be the usual or representative one.
'suicidal empathy' is the wildest new way to say a very old thing. It doesn't get any more palatable when you use the workshopped term for it.
Is the old thing 'kill everybody'? Rats manage to do that. They can tell by odor if another rat is an immigrant from elsewhere and kill it.
I feel like they have a better excuse for that behavior: they're rats. All of 'em, including the blood-n-soil homelander rats. They're rats, what do you expect.
Aaa
Empathy that stops when it is inconvenient is not empathy.
In Ivanhoe by Sir Walter Scott, the serf Gurth wears a brass collar soldered around his neck inscribed with his master's name. 19th century union organizers would frequently cite this to suggest that if anti-unionists had their way, we'd all still be wearing that collar.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moriori_genocide for real life example
the ethical move is to stop helping to build their whole economy
Isn't that suicidal too?
No, just a bit uncomfortable. There is a trend among people who are committed to ethics or religion to take on vows of poverty or forsaking material things - in some sense because that is the practical implication of taking ethics seriously. Otherwise people end up leaning in to some pretty dreadful things by implication.
But it isn't suicidal. Usually they get left alone.
> If you think you live on the martial island, the ethical move is to stop helping to build their whole economy, not just their military.
Yes, and if the "martial island" is actually a globalized system that dominates the working life of most people, what is to be done? Perhaps building institutions outside of that system, organized around shared moral values and material interests and on the basis of social trust rather than self-interested competition, is a good starting point.
"What is to be done", indeed...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_Is_to_Be_Done%3F
Speaking of socialism. I'm not an expert in the history of the subject, but I was always confused by the emphasis on the proletariat as the working class. Surely the REAL working class were the peasants? At the time, early 1900s, the proletariat were a tiny minority. This talk about propetariat feels more a coup than a revolution.
I think in modern parlance you'd say that Lenin and others were "influencers". They promoted not the right thing, as they would themselves argue ad nauseum, but the thing that pandered to their followers and so benefited them personally.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1905/mar/23.htm this wasn't lost on Lenin
"Why is the world full of violence? Because if it were at peace, the first man to pick up a rock would become the next Genghis Khan."
(From a comment on one of Scott Aaronson's blog entries.)
I'm not sure when the word "ethical" was transformed into "whatever my opinion is on x is right and everyone else is unethical".
If the west can't use any surveillance or develop weapons it will leave it's citizens exposed to some very unethical attacks: terrorism and foreign invasion.
This is a ridiculous reason to unionize.
I agree with your core idea that we should abandon our rose-tinted dreams of an eternally peaceful world and make sure we are well-equipped to protect the world we value.
However, the leap from “we should be ready to defend ourselves” to “therefore, we should allow Google to enter into unethical contracts and develop hostile, superintelligent AI capable of destroying us” is much harder to justify.
The fundamental flaw in this argument is: how can we guarantee that Google or any other lab will weaponize AI in our interests? How do we control it? How do we ensure that it won’t be turned into a weapon of surveillance and control against us and domestic political opposition? We live in an era of unprecedented economic inequality, with politicians increasingly relying on oligarchic wealth and unethical practices to win votes.
Therefore, the strategic solution cannot simply be “let’s pretend we don’t need weapons.” I agree that thinking otherwise is delusional. But until we have proper guardrails in place and meaningful oversight of frontier AI labs, organizing unions and pushing for slower development and tighter controls is a better approach than simply closing our eyes and hoping that Google executives know what they’re doing.
It seems like you may be conflating multiple issues. Unionization makes a lot of sense in this economical climate. Some demands made by the union may be too idealistic, but the general direction is reasonable.
All the major blocks have nuclear weapons though, so this island situation isn't really applicable.
Things like surveillance, spying, methods that can figure out what people are thinking and doing are also something which can enable the apparent stabilization of genuinely unstable societies, such as can be created by mass immigration and the like, so it isn't clear that developing these things for intelligence or military applications will bring order or strengthen society-- it can instead become a means whereby society is able to function while operating in a manner which will eventually destroy it utterly.
Finally, if AI is to be used for warfare, and this to be beneficial to society-- i.e. strengthen the internally peaceful island which still prepares for war. Present wars have not however had this character. Nicaragua is certainly not inimical to the EU-- Iran is, but not in a manner that makes it reasonable to destabilize it, Iraq, Afghanistan, etc. certainly weren't. The one war we have is the Russian war, and there what use is AI really? I see the interesting things as increase the strike range of drones and things that have very little to do with frontier LLMs or the sort of work that DeepMind is famous for.
So I actually think your remark while perhaps true in many other contexts is absolutely wrong in this context. I think Britain is better off if DeepMind stays out of supplying weapons or surveillance technology whether to the US or anybody else.
I suppose this story alludes to the invasion of Chatham islands by two Maori tribes, right? The people of the islands, the Moriori, followed Nunuko's law and decided to not fight back. The Maori tribes proceeded to genocide and enslave them
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moriori_genocide
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nunuku-whenua
Absolutely fascinating read. I guess number one for me was that a group of 2000 people managed to keep through oral tradition alone the story of their chief from the 16th century.
We have a responsibility to ensure our work is not used to harm society. - I applaud the effort, but it's hard to see this working out in reality. Google does so much business in defense that it's hard to see how a union could affect that.
People are being paid millions to switch labs, so maybe they can use their huge amount of leverage against those in Google who want to sell those big government contracts, or maybe it'll attract everyone else who doesn't want to contribute to AI for war making?
of course it'll affect google, llm tech is the currently the highest paid talent and also the most rarest, it's not like there's a post-bootcamp line waiting to be employed
it's just that the momentum of the technology is bigger than these engineers. Anthropic likes to say big things about humanity as well, and it seems like they're getting railroaded. Even if they manage to stand up to management will it do any good in the long run?
my man the momentum IS because of the r&d
Anthropic basically reversed course and begged to be allowed back in to the DoD contract- despite probably what most people who work there would prefer. I'm not sure a union would have done any good in that case.
Well, it is not defence anymore. It is the department of war.
It always was, ask anyone from Libya, Syria, Afghanistan or Iraq. But now that the threat is in first world countries like Canada or Denmark, it feels different.
I wish this were open to non-DeepMind employees as well - we need a general tech workers' union in the UK.
You're in luck!
https://utaw.tech/join
https://prospect.org.uk/tech-workers/
Recently, there has been a lot of controversy about Prospect in the UK. I am not following this subject closely, but both Reddit and trustpilot are full with the negative comments on this union.
> Recently, there has been a lot of controversy about Prospect in the UK. I am not following this subject closely, but both Reddit and trustpilot are full with the negative comments on this union.
Is that FUD? Provide details on those controversies, instead of vague negativity without even any clear links.
Also management and owners hate unions, and shown by the extreme level of propaganda and indoctrination they introduce when one is trying to organize. They want to be dictators of their fifes, with unquestioned power. I wouldn't hold it above them to flood some site with negative reviews.
Prospect is seen by many as an "employer's union".
They are the union employers bring in voluntarily to divide&conquer workers, convince workers they don't need a union representing their rights because "you already have Prospect", misinform workers etc.
Bringing in an employer-friendly union is a common union busting tactic.
Also known as a "captured union".
I have never really got the point of Unions. Instead of my manager managing me, some one else will. What's the difference? More bureaucracy
Collective bargaining for wages and benefits is the point
…do you think a union becomes your manager when you join one?
Yes I think it kind of does. Am I wrong?
The difference is leverage
There are several industry and trade associations that Big Tech and other technology companies belong to. They lobby both state and federal governments for favourable regulation, to fight restrictive policies and sometimes to stifle competition from overseas. They also lobby the government individually, since they are obscenely rich. So if employers can collectively bargain for favourable policies, why can't labour? It is actually in the employees' interest to act as a collective since it gives them more power.
Incentives.
What are the incentives for a manager working for your employer, vs a "manager" working for a union?
This world is so bizarre. I couldn't think of a group of workers more privileged in terms of pay and perks than DeepMind employees yet this is where i'm reading about worker unions as the term shifts to be about ethical use of company products.
You can more easily unionize while you have power. Once you lose power, good luck.
Software engineers should have learned this. In the 2000s-2010s tech boom, "why would I need a union?" In the 2020s AI tech crash, "damn I'm getting laid off"
Unions don’t stop layoffs, they just change who gets laid off to be less economical for the firm. Generally that means younger, more productive workers are let go ahead of senior, less productive ones.
See US teachers unions, GM.
More desperate people are more productive. That's not a good thing.
What does that have to do with unions preventing layoffs?
If the goal is to maximize productivity then the goal is to maximize desperation.
Union can do way more than this. As an example, in France, the unions are often helping to negotiate the terms of the layoff to ensure :
- That employee can be requalified, re-trained, re-located, if possible and wanted instead of straight up laid off
- That laid off employees can benefit from paid training to help them find a job after being laid off
- The compensation for volunteers who choose to get laid off first
- And many other things
(note that unions in France are organized very differently than in the U.S and have different incentives)
A lot of time, they act as a “moderation” force between the will of the shareholders and the employees. They cannot really change the economical reality. And even if a company doing well but want to make pretty number before selling chunks of the company, there are many ways to do this. The union often ensure that they can't take measure that are too drastic with important human cost.
> Unions don’t stop layoffs, they just change who gets laid off to be less economical for the firm. Generally that means younger, more productive workers are let go ahead of senior, less productive ones. [GP]
> As an example, in France, the unions are often helping to negotiate the terms of the layoff to ensure… [OP]
The youth unemployment rate in France for 14-24 year olds is near 20%. [1]
Are you sure that unions are doing enough to help and protect young workers?
[1] https://www.wsj.com/economy/these-charts-show-why-young-peop...
> Are you sure that unions are doing enough to help and protect young workers?
Never claimed they did :) . And this is an even longer debate to be honest. France, like every country in the world these days but especially “rich” country, is getting older. And “older” folk vote more and are likelier to be part of a union. So the unions (and the politician) have had more incentive to focus on the older part of the French population. Union also focus on worker rights, not people who never worked, which mean that youth with almost 0 job experience was always a blind spot for them (there is students unions and such, but it's another thing too). Not that they don't anything about that, but they don't defend as heavily young worker as they do for retirement benefit…
But whatever. No system is ever perfect, and I am certainly not claiming it is. But perfection is the enemy of progress. I was pointing out that the previous comment was an incomplete vision of what unions can do with layoff.
> Never claimed they did :) .
You did imply that though which is why I quoted not just you but the GP comment to keep the context front and center.
Unions don’t seem to be working well for young people in terms of employment, in France at least.
Interestingly enough the US and Germany which I’d suppose the US has fewer unions and Germany more, seem to both be providing better opportunities for their youngest. At least in terms of employment. So there seems to be something rather uniquely wrong in France in terms of youth unemployment. I wonder what that is?
I've seen this play out a few times. Older folks often go on to say it's about protecting against age discrimination but in all honesty it boils down to skill deterioration because they didn't bother to keep up.
White collar knowledge workers are finally facing the same automation pressures as blue collar factory work. It ain't that deep.
Just because the house I'm selling is expensive, doesn't mean I'm not going to try and get a good price for it.
You should unionize and negotiate for better terms, no matter how good your terms are already. Your employer isn't going to negotiate for you against themselves.
>You should unionize and negotiate for better terms, no matter how good your terms are already
A business only has a fixed amount of money it can spend on wages. Unionizing is not going to bring it up if you're already near the top of the pay scale for your role, and if it brings the wages of your lower-paid colleagues up then that means there'll be less left to pay those at the top so the wages of top earners will come down.
If you aren't in a union, you weren't negotiating as well as you could have been, therefore you left money on the table. All a union does is level the playing field so workers can negotiate as one body, just like the company does.
"near the top of the pay scale for your role" does not mean you are anywhere near the top of the pay scale for the organisation.
This is the madness of engineers making $200k thinking their interests are more aligned with the executives on $10,000,000 pa than the people mopping the floor for 40 grand.
Yes, absolutely you want the union to negotiate more money for lower-paid staff because that is YOU, buddy.
A business has a fixed amount of money it can spend in total. It has a team whose job is to minimise the percentage of it that's wages.
Unions can't create more money than the business actually has. Many unions have made this mistake and taken themselves down with the business. Many others haven't.
Profit is value generated by workers' time and effort that is being allocated elsewhere.
A business that has operating expenses equal to revenue is not withholding anything. One option available in this case is for workers to improve their productivity, no loss of jobs are necessary if there are market opportunities available. What better incentive is there for workers to improve their productivity than to share in the benefits of that improvement.
Also, a pay scale is a policy set by the business. Individual employees working at a level subject to scales like these have no influence on what these scales are, unions however spend a lot of time negotiating these scales with businesses. The C-suite captures a lot of value (CEOs now earn +300x more than the typical worker), this is a wage, and included operating expenses, that gap could come down quite a lot without impacting on the executive's lifestyle...
If you're not earning minimum wage you already have pretty good leverage to get what you're worth. Otherwise the company would just pay the minimum wage. Unions can create a barrier to entry for new employees to push wages up [0], but employees already have enough negotiating power to negotiate a fair wage.
[0] If every industry does this, most people end up worse off because it just makes it harder for people to switch industries.
UTAW is just a branch of the CWU, and plenty of established finance / tech / media companies already recognise the CWU - it and Prospect are the two biggest white-collar private-sector unions in the UK.
The only bizarre aspect is that Deepmind are seeking to have a separate agreement rather than follow the rest of Google (where Prospect already has recognition).
Prospect don't have recognition in Google, they signed a sweetheart deal for access only (new rules in UK as of last month) but it seems like they have a "laughably low membership" in Google: https://novaramedia.com/2026/11/04/google-uk-signs-sweethear...
> privileged
That's irrelevant. Everyone should be in a union.
Everyone being in a union implies that everyone is an employee, and nobody is a freelancer or employer. Not everyone wants to support a union, either.
should the whole union then bend to the will of the few who are privileged enough to not want to support a union?
You’ve presupposed that the “privileged” in question are positioned as wage-earning employees in an industry in which there is a union, and you’ve chosen to presume that the only reason for resistance to your union is “privilege.” There are other possible roles in life than wage-earning employee, and even for wage-earning employees there are reasons other than “privilege” for wanting the freedom to negotiate their own terms.
you've said so many words and nothing at the same time, why not just include a list of why would your average wage employer not benefit form an union then?
I think that was implied in my comment - everyone who CAN be in a union (employees), should be in one.
So they shouldn't have a voice in how their work is used because they're paid well?
Many of them are specialists in domains where they can't get work in many other places - they can't walk around handing out resumes hoping the local coffee shop just happens to need an applied scientist with a PhD in reinforcement learning...
"Better working conditions" is not just about salary and whether you get a free lunch. It's also about agency, purpose and growth.
Those staff are arguing that at least two of those are misaligned right now. It's easy to argue they "shouldn't complain", but have some empathy and be glad that somebody, somewhere, is arguing for ethics and principles to start being baked into the tech industry because heck, we really do seem to need more it right now.
> This world is so bizarre. I couldn't think of a group of workers more privileged in terms of pay and perks than DeepMind employees yet this is where i'm reading about worker unions as the term shifts to be about ethical use of company products.
You can't unionise unless you have some minimum of power otherwise you get defeated with classic union busting techniques.
Being privileged in pay and perks is what allows them to expand to whether their work is being used ethically or not.
It's so funny how the HN cohort will always see themselves as temporarily embarrassed executives rather than the workers they are. For some reason management has been very effectively pulling the wool over the eyes of the workers here, right up until the slaughter begins.
You excluded, I presume?
Sounds like all you need to be excluded is understand you are a worker and not an executive
Not everyone’s world view is shaped or framed by a workers versus executives conflict. For many it’s not something that is important at all.
Which is exactly what the capital class wants the peasants to think.
It's very rude to assert your claims to a dignified life as a human being, much better to be happy with the dregs you get.
> Which is exactly what the capital class wants the peasants to think.
Sorry I can only think what I’ve been told to think and can’t deviate because you’ve taken away my agency and ability to think for myself with your assertion.
> Not everyone’s world view is shaped or framed by a workers versus executives conflict
Yes it is. (In a capitalist system.) If you work for a living, and you've not consciously considered owner-worker relations in your world view, then your world view has been shaped not by your choice, but by the owner class against your interests.
No it's not - or rather, if it is, then I can only support the owner class because you've by your argument here have removed my agency. I have no choice but to support them and can't change because as you said they control what I think (and you too).
Yeah this is going to age like milk. Too little, too late, too diffused.
You don’t want to lose your job (a charitable way of saying this is that you can at least influence the decisions from within, a false sense of purpose), because you see the writing on the wall.
What makes you think that the management cabal is going to sit by idly? What’s your leverage? Domain knowledge? Zip. Experience/Taste? Nada.
They have all the compute. You’re planning on leveraging this by going to a competitor? Good luck trying to convince them that you’re going to work loyally with them.
Too little, too late, too diffuse. Should have started this 10 years ago, attention was all they needed.
Someone's been reading ACX: https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/ai-company-employees-should...
Gosh, even ACX figured it out? Give them another 20 years and they might figure out that "AI Alignment" without socialism is a farce.
Seems like some people can be too smart to read current news.
Apart from the amount of money some elites think they will extract from this new industry, it has also become a political/geopolitical/status issue.
Think about the reasons we couldn't stop mass surveillance. What's coming is along those lines.