I think enthusiast computing is dying. Home users will be able to buy packaged laptops and some desktop PCs, but I think the era of enthusiasts building "gaming rigs" and such is coming to an end. I think it's being ushered out by a feedback loop of high prices driving market contraction and, in turn, driving prices even higher as demand shrinks. Gaming will move to real-time streaming and there won't be a need or a market for GPUs and high performance CPUs in the enthusiast market.
Home computing, in the context of having a marginally-powerful computer or phone / tablet with minimal storage and RAM in the home, will continue just fine. Subscriptions for storage and applications are already becoming the norm, and with the skyrocketing cost of storage the market for large capacity storage targeted at enthusiast and home users will dry up, too.
The industry wants users to rent everything.
Storage rental is particular pernicious, to me, because being able to store your personally-created works in a manner that maintains confidentiality is to cornerstone of digital sovereignty. Being forced to store your data in systems that will use your data for model training is definitely desired by the industry. If they can con users into renting that storage and giving up their data to model training so much the better.
Are we anywhere near that? GeForce Now is solid and xcloud surprisingly has excellent latency (for me), but it’s still there. FPS’s are off the table, not even in a snobby way. You can feel the delay it’s just too severe. The only shooters I’ve ever ever been able to successfully do are slower third person ones and even that’s dicey unless they have other mechanics you can lean on (Mass effect for instance).
I think people get snobby about frame rates but latency is a real thing and there is a threshold you have to cross or everyone notices it, and I’m not sure anyone’s capable of crossing it
I'm sure you're right. I'm not gamer, mobile or otherwise, but I can definitely see walled-garden mobile devices taking over for the "gaming rig" in a lot of cases.
I am what people would consider a “serious gamer” and I don’t have the natural revulsion to Mobile gaming that my peers do. However, it’s a narrower field than you would think.
When enough players don't know any different the latency won't be an issue. It'll be the norm, just like using the molasses-slow UI on today's PC is considered normal.
Play a real Atari 2600 on a CRT TV. You'll be amazed at the fluid responsiveness of the system. Use an Apple II or a Commodore 64 and you'll be amazed at the lack of input latency.
We've gotten used to crap latency on our PCs. Gamers will get used to it in games too-- especially if it obviates a four-figure hardware purchase and paying for the privilege of "buying" games you don't own and can't keep anyway.
It's obvious you've never played any shooter game. It can't be the norm, because the game becomes completely fucking unplayable with even 50-100ms of input lag.
Meanwhile GTA 6 has a total input lag north of 150ms.
In ps3/xbox360 times it wasn’t out of the ordinary to see 100-200ms (killzone 2 was on a higher end, for example).
Total input lag (a time between a button press and an animation showing on your screen) isn’t just 1000ms/fps, although they do correlate.
Outside of the competitive FPS scene, most people using a gamepad can do just fine with extra 50ms of latency.
Some genres hold better, some are worse (mouse lag in RTS games feels pretty shit, but no one plays these anymore).
Cloud gaming sucks for other reasons- it’s expensive, it’s fragmented (you can’t just play all of your pc library in geforce now), there are no mods, no real ownership and, more importantly, edge devices like smartphones becoming powerful enough to satiate the gaming appetites of the casual crowd, while the hardcore want all of these features that the cloud lacks.
It’s neither here nor there
It sucks because of the input lag (for me). Probably the worst part (for me) is that 100ms of network latency is effectively random within a band of 50ms or so, which makes it difficult to compensate for and stops you building muscle memory as easily.
I am with you on this one, but we are only a part of the people who play videogames in general, and likely the most demanding part.
Current-gent console market (ps6+switch2+xbox series) is about what, 200-250 million units?
That sounds like a lot, but compare this to smartphones. Apple alone sold 247 million iPhones last year. With, say, 3 year average upgrade cadence it's 600-700 modern devices all the time. Add the high-end models of Samsung and other Android vendors. This is still on-device gaming, much less demanding, where people are fine with worse graphics, lower framerate and uneven framepacing, let alone horrible controls most of the time.
And then add even more people with weaker phones, TVs, slow laptops and old-gen gaming consoles. This is the market I am talking about, and I bet for most of these users a bit of an extra lag is completely okay.
Hardware enthusiasts who are horrifies with GTA6's 30fps is a small bubble- most people will happily play it even on the series S, with drops to 25fps (and an input lag higher than most games deliver on GeForce Now)
Both of those games are not about precision or timing at all. With current streaming latency you can’t play Mario, you can’t play halo, you can’t play Fortnite. Anything that requires timing or precision is out of the question.
Timing works just fine with a bit of extra latency as long as framepacing is even, and there is no large packet loss. Humans adapt very well to a predictable latency. If everyone with whom they are matched with are other cloud gamers, even multiplayer can work just fine.
Mario is even better example as, again, things that are happening in the game are predictable, they just happen tens of milliseconds later than locally. If a game delivers 60-120fps, then playing it in the cloud could be comparable to playing the same game at 30-60fps, and it is FINE. Not amazing- just fine.
What's not fine is the price of the gaming hardware, and some people won't have a choice but to play in the cloud.
Also remember how in the 90s it was considered impossible to create a successful FPS on a console due to gamepad being a bad input device compared to mouse? And indeed it was a bad input device for Quake 3, but then came Halo which was built with the gamepad in mind, with aim-assist and a large change in a game design, and it turned out that you CAN make an FPS for a console, it's just going to be a different FPS.
Maybe if we go into the cloud direction we will see a similar change in a game design, who knows
> Timing works just fine with a bit of extra latency as long as framepacing is even, and there is no large packet loss. Humans adapt very well to a predictable latency.
The latency isn’t just a little extra, the frame pacing isn’t even on any service I’ve used (3), and some packet loss is common throughout. It simply doesn’t work well enough for platformers, FPS’s, etc.
A consistent minimal delay is not the same thing as what you experience on cloud gaming servers. That’s just not how it goes. Have you used them yourself? Try any FPS. Try a precision platformer like Celeste. A high speed racing game. You’ll throw the controller after a few minutes.
It’s fine for most games but the gaps are massive and excludes essentially entire genres. Strategy game? Fantastic use case for cloud gaming. Anything that doesn’t require a lot of precise timing is fine. A game like God of war would be situational and is kind of where the line is.
I have in fact tried them, starting from OnLive closed beta (Sony bought them soon after). It sucked so much I couldn't believe it would ever work.
Then, earlier this year, tried GeForce now and fininshed CP 2077 Phantom Liberty just to understand the current state of the tech. It was really good.
You started with Mario, which is very playable with a huge lag, but are now switching to Celeste that is indeed an entirely different thing, and I wouldn't want to play it in the cloud, same as N++. The thing is, these games run on a toaster, and most devices suitable to be cloud gaming thin clients can actually function as hybrids.
Steam Deck will run these ultra-fast platformers well enough locally, and for anything more demanding cloud could be the way to go (it isn't right now due to how shitty GeForce now is regarding my own games even within steam library, requiring publishers to grant approval for a game to be available).
For me personally, the main drawback is the lack of ownership and control- I can't play what I already own, I can't install any mods, the game that I bought can be modified without my approval at any time. Probably that's due to my genre preferences, so obviously for you the situation may be different
A steam deck is currently what? $800? We’re talking about cloud subscriptions, the assumption is that people will not have access to local hardware that can run what they want to play
It doesn’t have to be Celeste. Most Mario games would be very painful with shifting FPS, resolution, and latency.
Cyberpunk is definitely a borderline case. If you have good enough proximity to their servers and have everything hardline/perfectly set up, it is very much playable. But I could tell you that for a lot of people it would not be for all sorts of reasons. Cyberpunk is not a high precision/twitchy game at all, you can slow down the game at will too. CoD would be unplayable for instance.
Latency is absolutely the number one barrier right now with cloud gaming. The moment a game exceeds 50-75ms or so of latency people start dropping like flies if timing is important (lots of games)
It’s like bad audio. You don’t have to know anything about audio to be upset about bad audio. There are some things people can tolerate, such as out of focus or just poor camera work. But sound? There’s a point where nothing else matters and it’s generally way more sensitive than other considerations no matter what someone’s background or training is.
Latency is like audio when it comes to video games. If what you are doing with your hands does not feel reflected on the screen, you will become frustrated even if you can’t articulate what exactly is happening
I don't think game streaming will ever become the norm but audio is not as sacrosant as you make it out to be. Plenty of people live in blissfull ignorance with the crappy speakers built into their TVs. And hearing ability varies a lot too and goes down with age aka purchasing power so depending on what you consider "bad audio" it might not actually make sense for some people to spend for better.
If people are struggling to understand what is being said they get incredibly irritated and turn it off unless they’re down for captions filling the gap (assuming it’s available). If the music is too loud they also get irritated. Unlike things like frame rates and other issues, there isn’t really any knowledge necessary. It’s just universally irritating. Laggy, inconsistent inputs present a similar issue.
Mediocre tv speakers are still clear enough. Echo-y/distant/otherwise unclear audio is exhausting and annoying. Hell remember Nolan’s Bane in TDKR? It’s literally all anyone could talk about. People couldn’t understand what he was saying and it was no small matter. To this day Nolan‘s audio mixes are basically a meme that all sorts of people are aware of. I’ve been in camera departments for almost 2 decades and I will be the first to say that audio is more important than video on almost any production I’ve been on. People are far more tolerant of issues with video than they are with audio. No knowledge required.
> I think it's being ushered out by a feedback loop of high prices driving market contraction and, in turn, driving prices even higher as demand shrinks.
Shrinking demand makes prices go down, not up.
Demand for gaming and consumer gear is higher than ever. Gaming GPUs were expensive before the AI boom. Remember when everyone was shocked that the 4090 was $1500 or the 5090 was $2000, but they were sold out anyway? Remember the extreme competition for 30 series GPUs and scalping before that?
I have yet to hear a good explanation for these beliefs that consumer PCs and gaming are going away, because they’re all driven by incorrect economic ideas (like shrinking demand raising prices) or fear imported from some other ideas, while ignoring the ever expanding market for gaming and consumer PC gear
In a simple supply/demand scenario, yes, but when shrinking demand causes manufacturers to spread costs across a smaller market it can lead to higher prices. A good example is hard disk drives. As the market moved to SSDs the constant cost decreases that had been reliable for decades started stabilizing or even rising. I paid $15/TB for 8TB drives in 2017 and that continued to be a good price for new drives until the AI boom drove costs way up recently. Similar trends have happened with lots of other products as they moved from mainstream to niche.
> I paid $15/TB for 8TB drives in 2017 and that continued to be a good price for new drives until the AI boom drove costs way up recently.
So prices were low when demand was low, then they increased when demand increased?
For commodity items it’s expected to have some fluctuations, especially when prices are bottomed out and manufacturers are weighing the costs of competition in a cutthroat market with shrinking demand. However you don’t really escape the laws of supply and demand. That’s why you saw prices swing hard upward when demand increased, not when demand was the lowest.
It's not a simple curve. There has to be enough demand for any theoretical market effects to take place.
If there isn't enough demand for something for multiple companies to find it worth building a factory and producing at industrial scale (and vendors to bother stocking, etc.), then you're faced with either monopoly pricing from the single vendor who sticks around or the dramatically higher cost of other manufacturing methods.
My thesis is shrinking demand will cause specialty manufacturing lines to be used for more profitable hardware, driving down the supply. Why make enthusiast hardware when hyper-scalers need storage, RAM, and compute to rent to end users?
Well, you might also end up dead like SUN or SGI - they lived on expensive B2B workstations and one day, the companies just stopped buying & soon they were gone.
Unlike the B2B market, consumer stuff is usually more stable and history has shown that companies supporting the consumer marked usually last longer.
Yeah, gaming demand is definitely here - unfortunately we need to wait a bit more for the AI bubble to fully collapse.
The given the demand things could move as quickly as the AI psychosis inflated the bubble, hopefully, to satisfy the demand.
Looking forward to cheap AI chips and HBM on custom board from scrapped AI datacenters - with next day shipping from Aliexpress warehouse in the EU. :)
Non-gamers will try pitching this over and over again, without ever learning from their past mistakes.
Streaming doesn't work for gaming. Any gamer can easily feel even just 50ms of latency in the form of input lag, and it makes the controls feel terrible. Gamers won't accept worse game feel -- they want better games, not worse ones.
How many countless game streaming platforms have to fail before you guys realize it will never work?
Have you tried Pyrowave? I really think it's feasible to stream a game from a local data center over fiber using pyrowave with ~20ms latency which personally i find very hard to detect even of fast paced games.
(Don't get me wrong, I'm not excited at the prospect of being forced to stream games, but i don't think technical infeasibility will protect us for that long)
You already got used to right click menu taking several seconds to open. You'll get used to gaming lags too. Even if you don't, new generations of gamers won't even know there were games without lag in the past. They won't play them. It will feel unnatural to them just like we consider arcade games from the '80 too difficult to play because they require so short reaction times and dexterity.
> I think the era of enthusiasts building "gaming rigs" and such is coming to an end.
I've been hearing this for over two decades and yet gaming desktops are more mainstream than ever. Certainly the current market is negatively impacting pricing and availability, but those same factors are also pushing their competition just as hard. I'm not even sure cloud streamed games was a profitable idea when prices were sane, but it certainly isn't now.
I built my first PC in '94. The market today feels so much different than it ever has. We had some RAM and disk crunches in the past (and disk prices never really recovered from the Thai floods), but this market feels so different. Prices continue to spiral out of control.
On the business side I've got Customers looking to replace servers purchased in 2020 and 2021 and they're not able to get anything reasonably similar for less than 4X what they paid for the old machines. They're turning, sometimes grudgingly, to renting storage and compute. The prices for off-lease "enterprise" gear are skyrocketing, too. There's no respite.
There was also a big shift from simply getting the best performance to also making the PC look "good" as a display piece on your desk. Everything has got to have RGB unicorn barf now, including RAM, your CPU cooler and other similar mundane components that have no business putting out any light.
Gaming enthusiasts have cared about aesthetics of their machines for ages. The gaudy Alienwares, flourescent lights, glass side panes, etc all date back to the early 2000s
I think gaming desktops are mainstream but have a longer lifespan now, as AM4 and RTX10xx hardware is perfectly fine for most gamers who play Big Walk or Queen's Domain rather than 8k 240fps Forza. In contrast when I bought a $600 GPU in 2013 (outrageous price back then) it wouldn't be able to handle a medium quality 1080p game in 3 years. So I think both assessments are right: an enthusiast top end rig is more expensive but most gamers simply need less top end rigs every year.
I was using a GTX1060 up until last year, and it still played pretty much everything on decent settings. PC hardware has been long lived for a while, in fact, I think this is one of the factors in the attacks on personal computing.
Components are still available to buy, take a look at any marketplace. Yes, components are rather expensive these days, especially RAM, but perhaps I should remind you that in the '90s I paid something like £30 per megabyte. Then again I can now buy a ESP32S3 for a couple of quid.
Anyway, its horses for courses. With a small amount of imagination you do not have to rent anything.
You are completely wrong about storage costs which are now nearly negligible compared to RAM.
I still have my Commodore 64, which now sports a USB interface. I also play games on my phone and that is still working OK, without a sub. My Clash of Clans Town Hall is level 17.
How much more "enthusiast" do you need from anyone who really couldn't give a shit about gaming?
I recently bought a trio of reconditioned Supermicro boxes with enough flash to do a Ceph cluster of 80TB with 2/3 redundancy ie "RAID 5" as well as run the rest of Proxmox. I had to dial back the RAM to a mere 128GB each node to get the cost under £15,000. I also slapped a double QSFP28 NIC in each (100GB/s) and a pair of 10GB copper NICs.
Storage, CPU, and network are relatively cheap compared to RAM.
> but perhaps I should remind you that in the '90s I paid something like £30 per megabyte
That's entirely meaningless unless RAM requirements also go back to 90s levels, which they won't. The unit of RAM people are buying isn't measured in MB but in 'can it run what I want to run'.
I've never lived anywhere with low enough connection latency to accommodate real-time streaming of an action game, and my bare packet latency is 20ms to the nearest data-center (that I know of and can ping anyway). Add any latency in the input processing of the game, time to encode/transfer/decode the frame, and any local input latency on the client and you’re easily looking at an extra 50-100ms over playing locally, which is well into the range people can actually feel in anything twitchy. Turn-based or slower games would probably be fine, but I don’t see shooters or fighting games moving to streaming for anyone who doesn’t happen to live next door to a data center.
There might be some unexploited latency-masking tricks in client-side cursors and client-side reprojection (the timewarp trick some VR uses to rotate the camera without receiving a new frame), but I suspect the legacy internet connectivity of rural and suburban homes in america will be a serious barrier to widespread adoption of real-time streaming. If local hardware gets priced out of reach, it could rather mean the end of gaming as a widely accessible hobby instead of a switch to real-time streaming?
Not everything has to be high res 3D requiring the newest GPUs. For twitchy games I guess they'll just stay low quality enough to be able to run on customer local devices.
Is this true? I mean some of this biggest and most popular games like CS2 and DOTA are latency and refresh rate sensitive.
Genuinely asking I’m not sure of the state of the art here. I tried out GeForce now a couple years ago and it was fine for couch co-op platformers but I could never imagine using such a delivery method for an online FPS game.
No one can be certain anymore than anyone can time the market with certainty. Perhaps both modalities evolve independently, we went from mainframes to PCs, perhaps the cycle could repeat.
Valve's new streaming format (pyrowave? I don't remember exactly) trades bandwidth for latency--like 250mbps bandwidth but one-frame latency on my LAN. It's good enough for me to play star wars racer without feeling any problems. Obviously adding internet latency to that could tip the scale but it's not hard to imagine playing a high speed action game over fiber from a regional data center with only 1-2 frames latency (at 60fps) within the next few years.
I think the bottleneck there is consumer adoption of gigabit fiber and data center distribution. If i had to stream from a west coast server and not a Midwest server there's nothing that could bring the latency within 1 frame no matter what.
It's... so funny. One of the most debated topic among gamers is whether 180hz monitor makes any difference or it's just a placebo effect, and in the meanwhile non gamer are like:
Sure, and most people stopped buying stereo systems, but big budget audiophiles still have their tiny little niche. (And it's not all snake oil.) Same story with cameras etc.
What will prevent hobbyists from buying inexpensive but powerful Asian chips that can run Linux? Worry not, hobby computing is alive and well and will remain so.
There was always enterprise hardware priced much more expensively than consumer. They could both exist because there was enough capacity for manufacturers to produce both. In order to have all the capacity go to enterprise, enterprise has to price out consumers and that can only happen for so long because high prices will cause investment in more capacity.
Unfortunately "can only happen for so long" is measured in years or even decades due to high cost (both in money and time investment) to spin up competitiors. So it still ends up being very painful for consumers.
Gaming will never be streamed. The latency is just too high for most people. For the concept to work, you need to cover most of your user base and that’s just impossible unless you build small nearby datacenters. You still also need to make sure that all ISPs got their shit together.
Gamers can’t even tolerate bluetooth/radio lag which is why they use cables for their mouses/keyboards.
The gaming PC dying has been a thing people say every console generation. Things will eventually catch up in a few years when the AI investment and build out saturates.
Inwould actually think the consoles are done for this time around.
Like I have both Stem Deck and Steam Machine & they work so nice for gaming, have robust OS update mechanims, yet still don't limit me to use it for any tinkering, development or running of non-Steam games I want to do.
I have no idea why anyone would ever buy a locked down PoS console with overpriced games in 2026.
You might have noticed that there are less and less components. There's no memory - it's soldered to the motherboard. There's no CPU - soldered too. No network adapter - integrated. No sound cards - integrated. No GPUs - in CPU.
What remains? A SBC board + a case? Is that still called "buiding a computer"?
This is a cycle. As of now the companies with server farms are buying up everything that can be manufactured, but this is not a forever model. The companies that are in the business of making things will always want to make more in the future and they will need to come back to general consumers to soak up that supply. The only question is how long it will take. I was hoping the GPU situation to normalise after the blockchain hype started to die out, but AI picked up that demand and shot it up to the stratosphere
When all this is done, will general consumers even be interested in general purpose computers, vs say walled garden devices that can run their office apps and slack client? Will the hobbyist market of people building little linux home servers to run their containers or whatever be even large enough to justify investing in that sort of business at all? It is already a market where many people participating in it are buying hardware second hand, bevvied by the fact that enterprise has at least up till recently bought their own compute and replaced it every three years, creating plenty of constant inventory suplly of anything from capable enough clusterable i5 usff pcs to xeon powered rack servers.
But that was then, this is now. I've been realizing lately how perilous general purpose compute has been, and how much of its continued access depends on things remaining exactly as they've been for the last 25 years.
Yes, most major software companies want to trap you in services hell and rent everything from them forever at whatever rates they want to charge.
That’s a given.
What’s also a given is that there remains enough enthusiasts out there willing to donate time, energy, and resources into improving the space regardless of the intent of software companies. Linux works on Apple Silicon despite Apple’s refusal to share documentation. AI models run locally despite frontier labs refusing to take it seriously or share the fruits of the poisoned tree. Gamers reverse engineer console titles to run on anything and everything.
Software companies need billions of dollars and tens of thousands of people to create an illusion of a walled garden that one dedicated hacker can snap apart in a few weeks, tops. No DRM, no licensing scheme, and no “cloud” model has withstood the dedication of those glorious rebels demanding that compute remain accessible and available to all.
It's a dying craft, sadly. Because building a PC is so fun and I will do it with my kids, if for no other reason than to show them how it comes together.
building a computer (as nand to tetris) is fun, building a pc - like putting a cpu, an ssd and some ram into a motherboard is not, and modding is just spending $ on vibes.
Ya, I was born in 1981. It really surprised me around 8 years ago, I met someone my age who did not own a computer and did everything on her smartphone. I still don't really understand how people do this, but they exist in a wide range of ages, apparently. (Full disclosure, her computer was stolen, but she was in no rush to get a new one).
I made a dumb meme and posted it to Facebook about 8 years ago. My nephew in his teens asked what app I used. I told him I used Photoshop. He asked "Can I use that on my phone?" a less surprising question these days but I was a little taken back at the time.
Around the same time my niece was getting really into drawing anime and posting it on her Instagram. I offered her my Wacom tablet I wasn't using and she declined with "No thanks, I just draw on my iPad"
And that's when I knew I was truly out of touch with the youth.
> And that's when I knew I was truly out of touch with the youth.
I for real LOL'd at this. It's taken me a little longer but it's really hit me within he past 12 months or so of, "Oh right, I'm old." I'm sure this is because I have no children and so I don't interact with people under 30 very often.
On the other hand, I have a NeoCities account. I host my personal site there and while I never update it anymore, I log into fairly often to see what people are doing, and there are a lot of sites on there built but young people which disclaimers of "This site looks terrible on mobile, best viewed on a computer," so there are all sorts out there!
"Does the job" implies an equivalence, which couldn't be further from the truth in the case of PC vs phones.
Smartphones are what's responsible for the death of the internet as a place where knowledgeable, can-do people congregated and built a free utopia together. Once the normie hordes arrived and the marketing / advertising / propaganda / doomscrolling / mindless passive consumption people completely hijacked their brains with things like Instagram, the good old internet promptly died, and was replaced with the VC money-soaked online world we have now.
Gamers don't buy computers anymore (despite their consoles being computers, they are completely uninterested in those capabilities, same as phone users), students don't have a clue about files and directories anymore, and as for programmers... as a lifelong low-level programming enthusiast, I'd better stop there.
For many, many people in particularly low-income brackets, a phone is literally their only access to computing if they’re not in school or somehow getting a free laptop from work (all traffic monitored by HR-attracting IT department). A large number of (at least public) sites take this into consideration and have very robust mobile sites.
This comment genuinely makes me want to die, and perfectly illustrates what I was talking about.
It's not actually a change in computing, it's a change in people. Zero imagination for anything beyond their phones, zero interest to actually consider their own question, just zero anything. This world is properly cooked if that's the attitude of people commenting on HN, nevermind the swamps of other comment sections.
Don’t worry, enough people in the younger generation are moving to short video that there’s a good chance you’re just talking to a bot. In time it will be just us oldheads talking in text and nobody will even remember that text forums exist—botspam may dry up (or become really obvious and low effort).
The far darker reality is that it probably actually is a human who wrote that, and literally cannot imagine anything their phone can't do, and anyone who might want to do more than a phone is capable of is an unc whose time has passed. Utterly wild...
For 99℅ of people there really isn't anything they want to do that their phone can't do. If they need a bigger screen make they use an iPad. If they're writing a big email maybe they use a keyboard case or a Chromebook.
Normal people just simply do not care about technology.
Now are there things you and i want to to that we can't do with our phones? Of course. But we're a vanishingly small slice of the world population and always have been
It's always been about the people. People don't want computers or smart phones, they want what they provide. The vast majority of people, in general, do not want or need anything a computer can provide over a smart phone. At most, some people need to type up documents or spreadsheets.
Personal computers didn't even come first, they were just another step in the path toward smartphones.
Dude it's not that serious, the world has just moved on, you probably have friends in your generation who you can hang out with that share your opinions and play around with your old stuff. My father meets up with his friends, has dinner, laughs and talks about how imaginative they had to be to fix their cars in the 60-70s.
I for example can feel like psychologists in the phone are a complete waste of time and a stupid thing stripped of the social interaction and empathy that makes it useful, however it's the only thing that my friends daughter knows, and she is happy with it, because it's all she knows, so her neural experience from this is equal to mine in the "real" setting.
The generation after her might perhaps feel like psychologists in the phone are stupid when you can have an AI chatbot in the phone that knows everything about you and can cater your emotional needs, and so on, and they will have the same range of emotions from this as we do.
The world has moved on from most people fully owning device that unleashes unlimited creativity to getting to use a locked down Google/Apple-owned device build around consumption. That is pretty serious from my view and affects all of us, even those of us who still own their own real computers. Services and entire communities are now built around these anti-user devices and more and more require them to participate.
Again a bunch of unc arguments, no-one cares. If they did they wouldn't use it, or throw a fuss about it. Most people just want to look up some direction, watch some videos, text their friends. All that you list is some old person esoteric stuff based on values that don't matter anymore.
People who only use smartphones to consume were never the people to "unleash unlimited creativity" on a PC to begin with.
99.9℅ of people either don't give a flying fuck about tech or actively hate it, and have less than zero interest in anything more complicated than an iPhone. It has always been this way.
Most people never cared about computers in the first place. It was required for a 10-15 years period to not be left behind as an explosion of new services were online or in digital form.
Now these people moved on to their smartphones which give them access to the same world of wonders offered by new technologies without the hassle and clunkiness imposed by a personal computer.
You make a good point? If you were starting a business I would definitely not recommend you going into groceries.
Now it happens that entertainment can be delivered in any form, including the phone, that makes the cost of this entertainment incredibly low.
Phone games and apps are more like there is a grocery store that is always next to your house and has a bunch of free food that you pay for by just looking at some of the other goods.
> What can you do on a PC that you can't do on your phone?
This is "electricity just comes from the wall" levels of not understanding how things work.
Nothing that runs on a phone is developed or maintained on a phone. Everything that makes the phone work is done on a real computer. It doesn't have to be this way, but Apple and Google and various other parties want it to be this way, so it is. Maybe that will change.
But until it does, the "market share" or "ROI" of a PC is an irrelevant metric. The fact that these metrics fail to capture the value of a PC is an indictment of (your use of) the metrics, not of the PC.
Does the market reward your "value" metric for what a PC is?
If you want to eat and pay your mortgage, are you better off following your metric of "value" in regards to what a PC is?
I dont know, seems pretty relevant to me. I had a dream last night where my mortgage was paid with me tinkering with whimsical products that were grounded in happiness, pluralism, inclusivity and human connection, then I woke up to the good old neoliberal status quo and realized that I have to spend another day at the dream factory capturing peoples attention to pay off my loans and feed myself.
If you want to stick to market dynamics, then focus on that. You asked what can a PC do that a phone can't. The answer, in the context of digital infrastructure, is damn near everything. This is not a metaphysical question, it is an empirical one.
Water is essential for life and yet I can buy hundreds of gallons of it from the local utility for the price of one gallon of gasoline, which I can't even drink. Do not get so hung up on markets as the determiners of all worthiness, they are just allocators of scarce resources.
It's possible the PC will die off (probably through Apple and Microsoft's incompetence), and then the phones will be forced to open up to compensate, but for now I doubt it. They share a common ancestry but they have diverged quite substantially, and this separation has its benefits.
I think the water and gas comparison doesn't make sense here. It's more like the PC is the sparking water with pomegranate flavor and the phone is the normal water. The whole point is that you can do 99% of what you can do with the PC on your phone, if this was not the case the market would be larger
There are also many "legacy" business processes that are technically doable on a phone but are so cumbersome/limited there that the phone is only really used for things like quick review, small touch-ups, etc. "Microsoft Excel runs the world" is not a trope for nothing.
There are four main reasons for these limitations IMO, in rough order of importance:
1. The phone O/S vendors, who are happy to make most of their platform money through rents on physical-service (often extractive) companies that only pretend to be software companies (like ridesharing and food delivery), gambling, and "free-to-play" video games
2. The software ecosystem, which has largely ignored the use cases I listed above, and so remains fragmented and incomplete (at best) where they are concerned
3. The form factor, which is much more limiting than a monitor+keyboard+mouse/trackpad setup, and can't easily be adapted to compete with the latter except through a dock, but those remain clunky and a bit gimmicky, and no phone even has a Thunderbolt port or other high-bandwidth display-capable connection to properly dock with anyway
4. The hardware, which still shares a lot in common with that of PCs, but has been optimized for things like extremely low power consumption, limited external peripherals, and default-distrust of the end user
And the above is entirely focused on things that make money, this doesn't touch on hobbies, games, and other personal-interest niches.
Augmented LLMs are potent tools, but they themselves are still made on PCs, and they work best at their tasks when directed by humans on PCs. Such shallow prompts as you gave achieve little more than wasted tokens.
The home-consumer PC market is already contracting and will likely continue to contract. That is not the claim I took issue with. You keep conflating market size with importance. These "rounding errors" run the modern world and will not stop doing so anytime soon.
> If the phone works good enough, we don't need PCs.
Sure. It doesn't (yet), so that won't happen (entirely).
However, it does work "good enough" in enough other areas to help explain the contraction. Maybe it will expand into being "good enough" in more areas, and maybe younger people will cause a generational shift that this "unc" can't foresee. But I laid out a bunch of reasons why that's unlikely to happen. I think both PCs and phones are market-saturated, but the replacement treadmill for phones is much faster than for PCs, so the current price shock is hitting PC sales harder.
I think we need an out here to say that PCs will remain for the foreseeable future for businesses and hobbyists, but this won't be enough to sustain the PC market as we know it.
This touches on an issue that has been very concerning to me over the years. The market of "gamers, students, and programmers" in absolute numbers is larger now than it has ever been. But by proportion, it looks smaller and smaller every year. A company catering to such customers could be growing every year, but because the "total addressable market" looks like it's shrinking, we'll instead see contraction and homogenization. It's depressing.
Gamers, students and programmers is a huge swath of people. Students in particular describes essentially everyone at some point in their life. A quick stat I found shows that 83% of people in the US own a laptop. I kind of doubt this will change.
Anynone serious about creative endeavous or anything business-like. Smartphones and tablets continue to be pretty mediocre for anything that isn't consooooming.
> There are some hardware companies which take the opposite approach, namely the thinking that if you sell fragile products which break quickly, then you can get more business because people will buy replacements more quickly, but the same principle applies here as in other businesses selling physical products, like the car business: If you develop a reputation for selling cheap junk which breaks quickly, then you'll lose a lot of business long-term, so most hardware companies (at least those with widespread name-brand recognition) want to protect the value of their brand and sell good products which work well and last a long time.
The problem here is that it takes a long time for the reputation to catch up with the reduced quality and duing that time you profit a lot. And most individuals making the decisions (management, PE, other short-term investors) are not actually all that interested in longer-term sutainability only in maximizing short term profits before they cash out.
And its not just "some" hardware companies that seem to operate this way but almost all of them.
> Software doesn't wear out; it has no moving parts
Of course it does: The environment moves at lot and so do the requirements. Not to mention that hardly any software is actually perfect without room for improvement even with the original constraints.
> We know what kinds of programs people use and want to use, what kinds of features they use and don't use, and so there is not much room left for creativity or innovation, not much possibility remaining for creating new programs for people since all the software which the world needs has not only already been created, but in fact released as open-source software, given away for free on the Internet.
Perhaps we do know what software people need but we are definitely not creating it. Or at least it doesn't end up in front of the average worker, who is instead doomed to constant curses about the crap their are forced to used.
It's the local storage issue that bothers me the most.
I do not want to outsource my backups to a cloud provider.
I do not want my work output to be used by a hyperscaler to train their models.
For decades I've bought relatively inexpensive backup systems/disks, and now it's getting expensive - I believe this is more likely to be collusion than demand.
Even Apple is moving in this direction. They moved their professional apps that were previously one-time purchases to a new subscription. Technically, the one-time purchases still exist, and the existing licenses are being honored... however, they have started to introduce offline features (such as MotionVFX), that do not depend on a server, but require the subscription and do not apply to the one-time purchase.
Now that the subscription exists, the one-time purchases may never see a single new feature again. They may even be removed from sale one day.
I had hoped that John Ternus would not allow the subscription to gatekeep anything other than the server-side quotas. I now see that was mistaken.
It really makes the app stale too going to subscription model. With one time license (it would never be one time as you'd be version locked in practice), a company would actually have to deliver compelling new features that would justify the spend to get users off their existing old versions. With subscription, no innovation is needed at all, you get the money no matter what.
Apple's professional apps were truly one-time. A purchase of Final Cut Pro 15 years ago still applies to the very latest version today. You never had to pay for upgrades. There was no concept of renewal at all. Until the introduction of this subscription.
Many other businesses that offer one-time licenses do not offer major version upgrades or even sometimes any updates at all. Apple did. (ignoring the period of time where they had each macOS update behind a purchase)
I don't get updates anymore for CrossOver, Sketchapp, Plasticity. I have a lifetime license, but no updates.
As I understand it there's a growing desktop Linux grassroots movement in the U.S. due to the fact that consumer protections are non-existent and software companies can more or less abuse their customers as they see fit. Many've had enough of the flogging and are jumping ship towards Linux Mint and leaving Windows behind. Vendor lock-in will fail.
Hardly. Very few people are like you. Most people don't think too critically and just pay the companies. They actually like their walled gardens. It is why these companies are worth billions, trillions even, after all.
They don't just not think critically but actually become defensive and make excuses when exposed to the idea that there might be a better way. Almost seems like a form of cyber stockholm syndrome some times.
With everyone getting squeezed financially lately I'm hoping some will ask an LLM to help them cut costs and likely the result will be 'host your own, here's how'
AI is rapidly driving the cost of developing software toward zero. However, software is still creating value. In a world with local models and accessible reverse engineering, the software increasingly needs to be kept under wraps to enable monetisation. After the initial SaaSocalypse comes the SaaScension where all of compute is promoted to the cloud.
> AI is rapidly driving the cost of developing software toward zero.
Nah, you're gonna have to pay to access generative AI. At the very least the cost of energy to run even a local rig; if using AI services, you will be paying effective salaries to virtual workers.
Nah or no nah, the conclusion about local vs cloud seems to be the same?
The current perceived hardware scarcity can be related to the tech company race to capture an emerging market. It is a gold rush. If the scarcity is kept going long enough, customer will change their behavior and happily remain cloud customers even when there is plenty of hardware around in a couple of years.
I don’t get it. I don’t use anything that could be construed as software as a service unless you mean like web apps, but they run on somebody else’s machine so you know I expect google to extract some value from me somehow though I don’t think they have to be honest.
These days any sufficiently useful software uses third party and open source libraries and also it’s own code and accrues known CVE security issues over time.
I can't speak for the rest, but didn't JIRA use to be software you paid for and hosted at your business? It was Atlassian who stopped supporting this model, not the customers.
Who is the customer here? The IT department? The user subjected made to feel what the first S in SaaS really means? The management ultimately calling the shots but feeleing neither maintenance nor user pain directly themselves?
B2B SaaS came about because organisations said “we don’t want to run our own IT infrastructure, we want to pay someone else to hire people in India to run it instead.”
Well, yes, but if the vast majority had wanted to manage it themselves, they would not have — with both options developed - consolidated on the cloud version.
Note that on premise was de facto subscription, since almost everyone got updates.
no, it's not software companies, it's any company with shareholders that produce any product that can be "updated" to work just as a dumb worker... the idea is that you rent things and always pay, you never own, you rent, it's never yours...
you can see it in sony playstation discs going away, you can see it in things that doesn't work if they are not updated first... anything that needs to connect somewhere to do something is a product as a service...
And yes computers have to go away, so someone can offer "new innovative services"... a.k.a. new ways to "bolt" you.
Just imagine paying disney subscription to see ads... if people organized a little bit they could all cancel their subscription and not renovate it for a week... or a month... and see how fast disney will reverse...
You guys must not have teenagers who play Fortnite and Minecraft. Both my kids are totally hooked on their gaming rigs as are their friends and measure their egos in FPS. I had to suffer the shame of buying Fortnite e-bucks yesterday for my son when he snuck it in the grocery cart. So those kind of models do still seem to be working (I assume, is Epic doing ok?)
Or are we just dorks in a bubble out here in Seattle?
No section headings no bullet points just a giant wall of text.
Then there's the fact that most people aren't interested in home computing. Like all the people who only have a smart phone and their home computer either never existed or is 15 years old.
Home computing looked way more popular than it really was because home computers was all we had before mobile devices.
I would write a point by point rebuttal about why this is a golden age of home computing, but the points are all camouflaged in a jungle of words.
I agree with most of this article, and I think a lot of the Terry Davis points were true at the time he spoke them, but nowadays, with agentic AI, things like file permissions and virtual memory could potentially have value. Limiting what your agents can touch can prevent a lot of accidents.
Tech companies have been trying, and succeeding, to make people as tech illiterate as possible. So they will accept the slop they are given and not realise how bad it is.
This article itself doesn't really make much sense.
I understand the general anxiety about ownership of things in the modern world but this article disagrees with: File permissions? Sandboxing? Using React Native?
Games moving to Steam and therefore being licensed rather than owned is a much better point than "windows doesn't want you to own a computer because they have file permissions and use react native"
To be fair, it's only a blog entry (on LiveJournal)
But I personally found it verbose, overly personal (fine as a blog entry but not great as an HN submission) and went off on some strange tangents, as you mention
I think it's a case of the submission headline being a good starting off point for a discussion on here but where the actual body of the submission does not have much 'meat'
i’m just curious as to what OS it is that they deem is truly designed for home users, which they cannot use because of a lack of driver support. i’d like to try that OS out.
It is false that software doesn't wear out. The way it wore out in the past was through the development of new versions that worked faster and had more useful features.
What happened with software is that innovation stalled. A lot of software lost features, such as when Excel allowed users to drag and drop data into a chart to add other series.
Instead, software focused on changing the interface aesthetic, changing the way it works, forcing users to retrain for no gain in productivity, and making them lose muscle memory. It broke compatibility without offering a better replacement, like MS Office abandoning VB integration. And instead of getting faster, new software gets slower despite demanding more hardware.
In the past, you could learn to use a program by reading the help files. Today, they don't even include help files, or the help is useless.
I think enthusiast computing is dying. Home users will be able to buy packaged laptops and some desktop PCs, but I think the era of enthusiasts building "gaming rigs" and such is coming to an end. I think it's being ushered out by a feedback loop of high prices driving market contraction and, in turn, driving prices even higher as demand shrinks. Gaming will move to real-time streaming and there won't be a need or a market for GPUs and high performance CPUs in the enthusiast market.
Home computing, in the context of having a marginally-powerful computer or phone / tablet with minimal storage and RAM in the home, will continue just fine. Subscriptions for storage and applications are already becoming the norm, and with the skyrocketing cost of storage the market for large capacity storage targeted at enthusiast and home users will dry up, too.
The industry wants users to rent everything.
Storage rental is particular pernicious, to me, because being able to store your personally-created works in a manner that maintains confidentiality is to cornerstone of digital sovereignty. Being forced to store your data in systems that will use your data for model training is definitely desired by the industry. If they can con users into renting that storage and giving up their data to model training so much the better.
>real-time streaming
Are we anywhere near that? GeForce Now is solid and xcloud surprisingly has excellent latency (for me), but it’s still there. FPS’s are off the table, not even in a snobby way. You can feel the delay it’s just too severe. The only shooters I’ve ever ever been able to successfully do are slower third person ones and even that’s dicey unless they have other mechanics you can lean on (Mass effect for instance).
I think people get snobby about frame rates but latency is a real thing and there is a threshold you have to cross or everyone notices it, and I’m not sure anyone’s capable of crossing it
Yea, see above. I think mobile gaming has been going far better than cloud gaming, in that respect.
I'm sure you're right. I'm not gamer, mobile or otherwise, but I can definitely see walled-garden mobile devices taking over for the "gaming rig" in a lot of cases.
I am what people would consider a “serious gamer” and I don’t have the natural revulsion to Mobile gaming that my peers do. However, it’s a narrower field than you would think.
> Are we anywhere near that?
> ... latency is a real thing ...
When enough players don't know any different the latency won't be an issue. It'll be the norm, just like using the molasses-slow UI on today's PC is considered normal.
Play a real Atari 2600 on a CRT TV. You'll be amazed at the fluid responsiveness of the system. Use an Apple II or a Commodore 64 and you'll be amazed at the lack of input latency.
We've gotten used to crap latency on our PCs. Gamers will get used to it in games too-- especially if it obviates a four-figure hardware purchase and paying for the privilege of "buying" games you don't own and can't keep anyway.
> It'll be the norm
It's obvious you've never played any shooter game. It can't be the norm, because the game becomes completely fucking unplayable with even 50-100ms of input lag.
Meanwhile GTA 6 has a total input lag north of 150ms. In ps3/xbox360 times it wasn’t out of the ordinary to see 100-200ms (killzone 2 was on a higher end, for example).
Total input lag (a time between a button press and an animation showing on your screen) isn’t just 1000ms/fps, although they do correlate.
Outside of the competitive FPS scene, most people using a gamepad can do just fine with extra 50ms of latency. Some genres hold better, some are worse (mouse lag in RTS games feels pretty shit, but no one plays these anymore).
Cloud gaming sucks for other reasons- it’s expensive, it’s fragmented (you can’t just play all of your pc library in geforce now), there are no mods, no real ownership and, more importantly, edge devices like smartphones becoming powerful enough to satiate the gaming appetites of the casual crowd, while the hardcore want all of these features that the cloud lacks. It’s neither here nor there
It sucks because of the input lag (for me). Probably the worst part (for me) is that 100ms of network latency is effectively random within a band of 50ms or so, which makes it difficult to compensate for and stops you building muscle memory as easily.
I am with you on this one, but we are only a part of the people who play videogames in general, and likely the most demanding part.
Current-gent console market (ps6+switch2+xbox series) is about what, 200-250 million units?
That sounds like a lot, but compare this to smartphones. Apple alone sold 247 million iPhones last year. With, say, 3 year average upgrade cadence it's 600-700 modern devices all the time. Add the high-end models of Samsung and other Android vendors. This is still on-device gaming, much less demanding, where people are fine with worse graphics, lower framerate and uneven framepacing, let alone horrible controls most of the time.
And then add even more people with weaker phones, TVs, slow laptops and old-gen gaming consoles. This is the market I am talking about, and I bet for most of these users a bit of an extra lag is completely okay.
Hardware enthusiasts who are horrifies with GTA6's 30fps is a small bubble- most people will happily play it even on the series S, with drops to 25fps (and an input lag higher than most games deliver on GeForce Now)
Both of those games are not about precision or timing at all. With current streaming latency you can’t play Mario, you can’t play halo, you can’t play Fortnite. Anything that requires timing or precision is out of the question.
Timing works just fine with a bit of extra latency as long as framepacing is even, and there is no large packet loss. Humans adapt very well to a predictable latency. If everyone with whom they are matched with are other cloud gamers, even multiplayer can work just fine.
Mario is even better example as, again, things that are happening in the game are predictable, they just happen tens of milliseconds later than locally. If a game delivers 60-120fps, then playing it in the cloud could be comparable to playing the same game at 30-60fps, and it is FINE. Not amazing- just fine.
What's not fine is the price of the gaming hardware, and some people won't have a choice but to play in the cloud.
Also remember how in the 90s it was considered impossible to create a successful FPS on a console due to gamepad being a bad input device compared to mouse? And indeed it was a bad input device for Quake 3, but then came Halo which was built with the gamepad in mind, with aim-assist and a large change in a game design, and it turned out that you CAN make an FPS for a console, it's just going to be a different FPS.
Maybe if we go into the cloud direction we will see a similar change in a game design, who knows
> Timing works just fine with a bit of extra latency as long as framepacing is even, and there is no large packet loss. Humans adapt very well to a predictable latency.
The latency isn’t just a little extra, the frame pacing isn’t even on any service I’ve used (3), and some packet loss is common throughout. It simply doesn’t work well enough for platformers, FPS’s, etc.
A consistent minimal delay is not the same thing as what you experience on cloud gaming servers. That’s just not how it goes. Have you used them yourself? Try any FPS. Try a precision platformer like Celeste. A high speed racing game. You’ll throw the controller after a few minutes.
It’s fine for most games but the gaps are massive and excludes essentially entire genres. Strategy game? Fantastic use case for cloud gaming. Anything that doesn’t require a lot of precise timing is fine. A game like God of war would be situational and is kind of where the line is.
I have in fact tried them, starting from OnLive closed beta (Sony bought them soon after). It sucked so much I couldn't believe it would ever work.
Then, earlier this year, tried GeForce now and fininshed CP 2077 Phantom Liberty just to understand the current state of the tech. It was really good.
You started with Mario, which is very playable with a huge lag, but are now switching to Celeste that is indeed an entirely different thing, and I wouldn't want to play it in the cloud, same as N++. The thing is, these games run on a toaster, and most devices suitable to be cloud gaming thin clients can actually function as hybrids.
Steam Deck will run these ultra-fast platformers well enough locally, and for anything more demanding cloud could be the way to go (it isn't right now due to how shitty GeForce now is regarding my own games even within steam library, requiring publishers to grant approval for a game to be available).
For me personally, the main drawback is the lack of ownership and control- I can't play what I already own, I can't install any mods, the game that I bought can be modified without my approval at any time. Probably that's due to my genre preferences, so obviously for you the situation may be different
A steam deck is currently what? $800? We’re talking about cloud subscriptions, the assumption is that people will not have access to local hardware that can run what they want to play
It doesn’t have to be Celeste. Most Mario games would be very painful with shifting FPS, resolution, and latency.
Cyberpunk is definitely a borderline case. If you have good enough proximity to their servers and have everything hardline/perfectly set up, it is very much playable. But I could tell you that for a lot of people it would not be for all sorts of reasons. Cyberpunk is not a high precision/twitchy game at all, you can slow down the game at will too. CoD would be unplayable for instance.
Latency is absolutely the number one barrier right now with cloud gaming. The moment a game exceeds 50-75ms or so of latency people start dropping like flies if timing is important (lots of games)
It’s like bad audio. You don’t have to know anything about audio to be upset about bad audio. There are some things people can tolerate, such as out of focus or just poor camera work. But sound? There’s a point where nothing else matters and it’s generally way more sensitive than other considerations no matter what someone’s background or training is.
Latency is like audio when it comes to video games. If what you are doing with your hands does not feel reflected on the screen, you will become frustrated even if you can’t articulate what exactly is happening
I don't think game streaming will ever become the norm but audio is not as sacrosant as you make it out to be. Plenty of people live in blissfull ignorance with the crappy speakers built into their TVs. And hearing ability varies a lot too and goes down with age aka purchasing power so depending on what you consider "bad audio" it might not actually make sense for some people to spend for better.
If people are struggling to understand what is being said they get incredibly irritated and turn it off unless they’re down for captions filling the gap (assuming it’s available). If the music is too loud they also get irritated. Unlike things like frame rates and other issues, there isn’t really any knowledge necessary. It’s just universally irritating. Laggy, inconsistent inputs present a similar issue.
Mediocre tv speakers are still clear enough. Echo-y/distant/otherwise unclear audio is exhausting and annoying. Hell remember Nolan’s Bane in TDKR? It’s literally all anyone could talk about. People couldn’t understand what he was saying and it was no small matter. To this day Nolan‘s audio mixes are basically a meme that all sorts of people are aware of. I’ve been in camera departments for almost 2 decades and I will be the first to say that audio is more important than video on almost any production I’ve been on. People are far more tolerant of issues with video than they are with audio. No knowledge required.
Consoles theoretically cover this need.
> I think it's being ushered out by a feedback loop of high prices driving market contraction and, in turn, driving prices even higher as demand shrinks.
Shrinking demand makes prices go down, not up.
Demand for gaming and consumer gear is higher than ever. Gaming GPUs were expensive before the AI boom. Remember when everyone was shocked that the 4090 was $1500 or the 5090 was $2000, but they were sold out anyway? Remember the extreme competition for 30 series GPUs and scalping before that?
I have yet to hear a good explanation for these beliefs that consumer PCs and gaming are going away, because they’re all driven by incorrect economic ideas (like shrinking demand raising prices) or fear imported from some other ideas, while ignoring the ever expanding market for gaming and consumer PC gear
> Shrinking demand makes prices go down, not up.
In a simple supply/demand scenario, yes, but when shrinking demand causes manufacturers to spread costs across a smaller market it can lead to higher prices. A good example is hard disk drives. As the market moved to SSDs the constant cost decreases that had been reliable for decades started stabilizing or even rising. I paid $15/TB for 8TB drives in 2017 and that continued to be a good price for new drives until the AI boom drove costs way up recently. Similar trends have happened with lots of other products as they moved from mainstream to niche.
> I paid $15/TB for 8TB drives in 2017 and that continued to be a good price for new drives until the AI boom drove costs way up recently.
So prices were low when demand was low, then they increased when demand increased?
For commodity items it’s expected to have some fluctuations, especially when prices are bottomed out and manufacturers are weighing the costs of competition in a cutthroat market with shrinking demand. However you don’t really escape the laws of supply and demand. That’s why you saw prices swing hard upward when demand increased, not when demand was the lowest.
It's not a simple curve. There has to be enough demand for any theoretical market effects to take place.
If there isn't enough demand for something for multiple companies to find it worth building a factory and producing at industrial scale (and vendors to bother stocking, etc.), then you're faced with either monopoly pricing from the single vendor who sticks around or the dramatically higher cost of other manufacturing methods.
My thesis is shrinking demand will cause specialty manufacturing lines to be used for more profitable hardware, driving down the supply. Why make enthusiast hardware when hyper-scalers need storage, RAM, and compute to rent to end users?
Well, you might also end up dead like SUN or SGI - they lived on expensive B2B workstations and one day, the companies just stopped buying & soon they were gone.
Unlike the B2B market, consumer stuff is usually more stable and history has shown that companies supporting the consumer marked usually last longer.
Yeah, gaming demand is definitely here - unfortunately we need to wait a bit more for the AI bubble to fully collapse.
The given the demand things could move as quickly as the AI psychosis inflated the bubble, hopefully, to satisfy the demand.
Looking forward to cheap AI chips and HBM on custom board from scrapped AI datacenters - with next day shipping from Aliexpress warehouse in the EU. :)
> Gaming will move to real-time streaming
Non-gamers will try pitching this over and over again, without ever learning from their past mistakes.
Streaming doesn't work for gaming. Any gamer can easily feel even just 50ms of latency in the form of input lag, and it makes the controls feel terrible. Gamers won't accept worse game feel -- they want better games, not worse ones.
How many countless game streaming platforms have to fail before you guys realize it will never work?
Have you tried Pyrowave? I really think it's feasible to stream a game from a local data center over fiber using pyrowave with ~20ms latency which personally i find very hard to detect even of fast paced games.
(Don't get me wrong, I'm not excited at the prospect of being forced to stream games, but i don't think technical infeasibility will protect us for that long)
You already got used to right click menu taking several seconds to open. You'll get used to gaming lags too. Even if you don't, new generations of gamers won't even know there were games without lag in the past. They won't play them. It will feel unnatural to them just like we consider arcade games from the '80 too difficult to play because they require so short reaction times and dexterity.
> I think the era of enthusiasts building "gaming rigs" and such is coming to an end.
I've been hearing this for over two decades and yet gaming desktops are more mainstream than ever. Certainly the current market is negatively impacting pricing and availability, but those same factors are also pushing their competition just as hard. I'm not even sure cloud streamed games was a profitable idea when prices were sane, but it certainly isn't now.
I built my first PC in '94. The market today feels so much different than it ever has. We had some RAM and disk crunches in the past (and disk prices never really recovered from the Thai floods), but this market feels so different. Prices continue to spiral out of control.
On the business side I've got Customers looking to replace servers purchased in 2020 and 2021 and they're not able to get anything reasonably similar for less than 4X what they paid for the old machines. They're turning, sometimes grudgingly, to renting storage and compute. The prices for off-lease "enterprise" gear are skyrocketing, too. There's no respite.
Those 2021 servers should still be quite capable. Why exactly are they looking to upgrade?
Their business is growing and needs more capacity presumably.
There was also a big shift from simply getting the best performance to also making the PC look "good" as a display piece on your desk. Everything has got to have RGB unicorn barf now, including RAM, your CPU cooler and other similar mundane components that have no business putting out any light.
Gaming enthusiasts have cared about aesthetics of their machines for ages. The gaudy Alienwares, flourescent lights, glass side panes, etc all date back to the early 2000s
I think gaming desktops are mainstream but have a longer lifespan now, as AM4 and RTX10xx hardware is perfectly fine for most gamers who play Big Walk or Queen's Domain rather than 8k 240fps Forza. In contrast when I bought a $600 GPU in 2013 (outrageous price back then) it wouldn't be able to handle a medium quality 1080p game in 3 years. So I think both assessments are right: an enthusiast top end rig is more expensive but most gamers simply need less top end rigs every year.
I was using a GTX1060 up until last year, and it still played pretty much everything on decent settings. PC hardware has been long lived for a while, in fact, I think this is one of the factors in the attacks on personal computing.
Bollocks!
Components are still available to buy, take a look at any marketplace. Yes, components are rather expensive these days, especially RAM, but perhaps I should remind you that in the '90s I paid something like £30 per megabyte. Then again I can now buy a ESP32S3 for a couple of quid.
Anyway, its horses for courses. With a small amount of imagination you do not have to rent anything.
You are completely wrong about storage costs which are now nearly negligible compared to RAM.
I still have my Commodore 64, which now sports a USB interface. I also play games on my phone and that is still working OK, without a sub. My Clash of Clans Town Hall is level 17.
How much more "enthusiast" do you need from anyone who really couldn't give a shit about gaming?
> You are completely wrong about storage costs ...
That's not what I'm seeing in the pricing trends: https://pcpartpicker.com/trends/price/internal-hard-drive/
Every tracked storage device there has trended up dramatically over the last year. I see the same trends on other price-tracking sites, too.
Compared to (RAM vs persistent storage)
I recently bought a trio of reconditioned Supermicro boxes with enough flash to do a Ceph cluster of 80TB with 2/3 redundancy ie "RAID 5" as well as run the rest of Proxmox. I had to dial back the RAM to a mere 128GB each node to get the cost under £15,000. I also slapped a double QSFP28 NIC in each (100GB/s) and a pair of 10GB copper NICs.
Storage, CPU, and network are relatively cheap compared to RAM.
> but perhaps I should remind you that in the '90s I paid something like £30 per megabyte
That's entirely meaningless unless RAM requirements also go back to 90s levels, which they won't. The unit of RAM people are buying isn't measured in MB but in 'can it run what I want to run'.
I've never lived anywhere with low enough connection latency to accommodate real-time streaming of an action game, and my bare packet latency is 20ms to the nearest data-center (that I know of and can ping anyway). Add any latency in the input processing of the game, time to encode/transfer/decode the frame, and any local input latency on the client and you’re easily looking at an extra 50-100ms over playing locally, which is well into the range people can actually feel in anything twitchy. Turn-based or slower games would probably be fine, but I don’t see shooters or fighting games moving to streaming for anyone who doesn’t happen to live next door to a data center.
There might be some unexploited latency-masking tricks in client-side cursors and client-side reprojection (the timewarp trick some VR uses to rotate the camera without receiving a new frame), but I suspect the legacy internet connectivity of rural and suburban homes in america will be a serious barrier to widespread adoption of real-time streaming. If local hardware gets priced out of reach, it could rather mean the end of gaming as a widely accessible hobby instead of a switch to real-time streaming?
Not everything has to be high res 3D requiring the newest GPUs. For twitchy games I guess they'll just stay low quality enough to be able to run on customer local devices.
It can be the worst of both worlds.
It's both "local" and "in the cloud" if it's a subscription to a browser-based game.
Bonus points if it's not even within a walled garden and you have to go out of your way to a specific publisher's website to play it.
Is this true? I mean some of this biggest and most popular games like CS2 and DOTA are latency and refresh rate sensitive.
Genuinely asking I’m not sure of the state of the art here. I tried out GeForce now a couple years ago and it was fine for couch co-op platformers but I could never imagine using such a delivery method for an online FPS game.
No one can be certain anymore than anyone can time the market with certainty. Perhaps both modalities evolve independently, we went from mainframes to PCs, perhaps the cycle could repeat.
Valve's new streaming format (pyrowave? I don't remember exactly) trades bandwidth for latency--like 250mbps bandwidth but one-frame latency on my LAN. It's good enough for me to play star wars racer without feeling any problems. Obviously adding internet latency to that could tip the scale but it's not hard to imagine playing a high speed action game over fiber from a regional data center with only 1-2 frames latency (at 60fps) within the next few years.
I think the bottleneck there is consumer adoption of gigabit fiber and data center distribution. If i had to stream from a west coast server and not a Midwest server there's nothing that could bring the latency within 1 frame no matter what.
It's... so funny. One of the most debated topic among gamers is whether 180hz monitor makes any difference or it's just a placebo effect, and in the meanwhile non gamer are like:
> Gaming will move to real-time streaming
Sure, and most people stopped buying stereo systems, but big budget audiophiles still have their tiny little niche. (And it's not all snake oil.) Same story with cameras etc.
demand doesn't shrink - it moves into cheaper segment
the main problem is not existence of cheaper options - but lack of advertizement
there are 20$ gpus, ffs, nobody is simply aware of them
What will prevent hobbyists from buying inexpensive but powerful Asian chips that can run Linux? Worry not, hobby computing is alive and well and will remain so.
There was always enterprise hardware priced much more expensively than consumer. They could both exist because there was enough capacity for manufacturers to produce both. In order to have all the capacity go to enterprise, enterprise has to price out consumers and that can only happen for so long because high prices will cause investment in more capacity.
Unfortunately "can only happen for so long" is measured in years or even decades due to high cost (both in money and time investment) to spin up competitiors. So it still ends up being very painful for consumers.
Gaming will never be streamed. The latency is just too high for most people. For the concept to work, you need to cover most of your user base and that’s just impossible unless you build small nearby datacenters. You still also need to make sure that all ISPs got their shit together.
Gamers can’t even tolerate bluetooth/radio lag which is why they use cables for their mouses/keyboards.
The gaming PC dying has been a thing people say every console generation. Things will eventually catch up in a few years when the AI investment and build out saturates.
Inwould actually think the consoles are done for this time around.
Like I have both Stem Deck and Steam Machine & they work so nice for gaming, have robust OS update mechanims, yet still don't limit me to use it for any tinkering, development or running of non-Steam games I want to do.
I have no idea why anyone would ever buy a locked down PoS console with overpriced games in 2026.
Why would you think so? Building your PC is still cheaper, especially if you want the same quality hardware
You're describing the mainframe to terminal model essentially.
I would say we already have been doing that with Web 2.0 and it's going to trend the opposite
I dont get this take.
Been building computers since 15, i'm now 40.
Unless they take every physical component off the shelf and prevent it's sale, how can it die?
Then there is the second hand server market. Will old servers not be sold anymore?
As long as there is one shop selling components (or one person on a marketplace), I can build computers. ill use DDR3 if I have too.
You might have noticed that there are less and less components. There's no memory - it's soldered to the motherboard. There's no CPU - soldered too. No network adapter - integrated. No sound cards - integrated. No GPUs - in CPU.
What remains? A SBC board + a case? Is that still called "buiding a computer"?
This is a cycle. As of now the companies with server farms are buying up everything that can be manufactured, but this is not a forever model. The companies that are in the business of making things will always want to make more in the future and they will need to come back to general consumers to soak up that supply. The only question is how long it will take. I was hoping the GPU situation to normalise after the blockchain hype started to die out, but AI picked up that demand and shot it up to the stratosphere
When all this is done, will general consumers even be interested in general purpose computers, vs say walled garden devices that can run their office apps and slack client? Will the hobbyist market of people building little linux home servers to run their containers or whatever be even large enough to justify investing in that sort of business at all? It is already a market where many people participating in it are buying hardware second hand, bevvied by the fact that enterprise has at least up till recently bought their own compute and replaced it every three years, creating plenty of constant inventory suplly of anything from capable enough clusterable i5 usff pcs to xeon powered rack servers.
But that was then, this is now. I've been realizing lately how perilous general purpose compute has been, and how much of its continued access depends on things remaining exactly as they've been for the last 25 years.
The market shifted to iPad centric back to laptop centric for work in the last decade and a half, so I still have some hope for change.
The iPad never dethroned the laptop.
Maybe not, but it sure seems to have influenced the design of business SaaS. Information density is way down. Spacing between elements is cavernous.
Yes, most major software companies want to trap you in services hell and rent everything from them forever at whatever rates they want to charge.
That’s a given.
What’s also a given is that there remains enough enthusiasts out there willing to donate time, energy, and resources into improving the space regardless of the intent of software companies. Linux works on Apple Silicon despite Apple’s refusal to share documentation. AI models run locally despite frontier labs refusing to take it seriously or share the fruits of the poisoned tree. Gamers reverse engineer console titles to run on anything and everything.
Software companies need billions of dollars and tens of thousands of people to create an illusion of a walled garden that one dedicated hacker can snap apart in a few weeks, tops. No DRM, no licensing scheme, and no “cloud” model has withstood the dedication of those glorious rebels demanding that compute remain accessible and available to all.
Who is buying home computers besides gamers, students, and programmers? For general public smartphone does the job.
People that grew up in the 90s.
It's a dying craft, sadly. Because building a PC is so fun and I will do it with my kids, if for no other reason than to show them how it comes together.
> if for no other reason than to show them how it comes together.
I am team nand2tetris for life
building a computer (as nand to tetris) is fun, building a pc - like putting a cpu, an ssd and some ram into a motherboard is not, and modding is just spending $ on vibes.
> and modding is just spending $ on vibes.
As one does
Ya, I was born in 1981. It really surprised me around 8 years ago, I met someone my age who did not own a computer and did everything on her smartphone. I still don't really understand how people do this, but they exist in a wide range of ages, apparently. (Full disclosure, her computer was stolen, but she was in no rush to get a new one).
I made a dumb meme and posted it to Facebook about 8 years ago. My nephew in his teens asked what app I used. I told him I used Photoshop. He asked "Can I use that on my phone?" a less surprising question these days but I was a little taken back at the time.
Around the same time my niece was getting really into drawing anime and posting it on her Instagram. I offered her my Wacom tablet I wasn't using and she declined with "No thanks, I just draw on my iPad"
And that's when I knew I was truly out of touch with the youth.
> And that's when I knew I was truly out of touch with the youth.
I for real LOL'd at this. It's taken me a little longer but it's really hit me within he past 12 months or so of, "Oh right, I'm old." I'm sure this is because I have no children and so I don't interact with people under 30 very often.
On the other hand, I have a NeoCities account. I host my personal site there and while I never update it anymore, I log into fairly often to see what people are doing, and there are a lot of sites on there built but young people which disclaimers of "This site looks terrible on mobile, best viewed on a computer," so there are all sorts out there!
"Does the job" implies an equivalence, which couldn't be further from the truth in the case of PC vs phones.
Smartphones are what's responsible for the death of the internet as a place where knowledgeable, can-do people congregated and built a free utopia together. Once the normie hordes arrived and the marketing / advertising / propaganda / doomscrolling / mindless passive consumption people completely hijacked their brains with things like Instagram, the good old internet promptly died, and was replaced with the VC money-soaked online world we have now.
Gamers don't buy computers anymore (despite their consoles being computers, they are completely uninterested in those capabilities, same as phone users), students don't have a clue about files and directories anymore, and as for programmers... as a lifelong low-level programming enthusiast, I'd better stop there.
For many, many people in particularly low-income brackets, a phone is literally their only access to computing if they’re not in school or somehow getting a free laptop from work (all traffic monitored by HR-attracting IT department). A large number of (at least public) sites take this into consideration and have very robust mobile sites.
The PC market is a rounding error at this stage. What can you do on a PC that you can't do on your phone?
Who cares except for uncs shouting at clouds?
This comment genuinely makes me want to die, and perfectly illustrates what I was talking about.
It's not actually a change in computing, it's a change in people. Zero imagination for anything beyond their phones, zero interest to actually consider their own question, just zero anything. This world is properly cooked if that's the attitude of people commenting on HN, nevermind the swamps of other comment sections.
Don’t worry, enough people in the younger generation are moving to short video that there’s a good chance you’re just talking to a bot. In time it will be just us oldheads talking in text and nobody will even remember that text forums exist—botspam may dry up (or become really obvious and low effort).
The far darker reality is that it probably actually is a human who wrote that, and literally cannot imagine anything their phone can't do, and anyone who might want to do more than a phone is capable of is an unc whose time has passed. Utterly wild...
For 99℅ of people there really isn't anything they want to do that their phone can't do. If they need a bigger screen make they use an iPad. If they're writing a big email maybe they use a keyboard case or a Chromebook.
Normal people just simply do not care about technology.
Now are there things you and i want to to that we can't do with our phones? Of course. But we're a vanishingly small slice of the world population and always have been
It's always been about the people. People don't want computers or smart phones, they want what they provide. The vast majority of people, in general, do not want or need anything a computer can provide over a smart phone. At most, some people need to type up documents or spreadsheets.
Personal computers didn't even come first, they were just another step in the path toward smartphones.
Dude it's not that serious, the world has just moved on, you probably have friends in your generation who you can hang out with that share your opinions and play around with your old stuff. My father meets up with his friends, has dinner, laughs and talks about how imaginative they had to be to fix their cars in the 60-70s.
I for example can feel like psychologists in the phone are a complete waste of time and a stupid thing stripped of the social interaction and empathy that makes it useful, however it's the only thing that my friends daughter knows, and she is happy with it, because it's all she knows, so her neural experience from this is equal to mine in the "real" setting.
The generation after her might perhaps feel like psychologists in the phone are stupid when you can have an AI chatbot in the phone that knows everything about you and can cater your emotional needs, and so on, and they will have the same range of emotions from this as we do.
The world has moved on from most people fully owning device that unleashes unlimited creativity to getting to use a locked down Google/Apple-owned device build around consumption. That is pretty serious from my view and affects all of us, even those of us who still own their own real computers. Services and entire communities are now built around these anti-user devices and more and more require them to participate.
Again a bunch of unc arguments, no-one cares. If they did they wouldn't use it, or throw a fuss about it. Most people just want to look up some direction, watch some videos, text their friends. All that you list is some old person esoteric stuff based on values that don't matter anymore.
People who only use smartphones to consume were never the people to "unleash unlimited creativity" on a PC to begin with.
99.9℅ of people either don't give a flying fuck about tech or actively hate it, and have less than zero interest in anything more complicated than an iPhone. It has always been this way.
Most people never cared about computers in the first place. It was required for a 10-15 years period to not be left behind as an explosion of new services were online or in digital form.
Now these people moved on to their smartphones which give them access to the same world of wonders offered by new technologies without the hassle and clunkiness imposed by a personal computer.
PC gaming is ~20% of gaming revenue. That's not a rounding error.
Compare the ROI including development costs, time to making a mobile game.
Compare the ROI with using the same hardware for compute workloads and you're down to a rounding error.
Compare the margins of a tech company and a grocery store. Nobody should run grocery stores.
You make a good point? If you were starting a business I would definitely not recommend you going into groceries.
Now it happens that entertainment can be delivered in any form, including the phone, that makes the cost of this entertainment incredibly low.
Phone games and apps are more like there is a grocery store that is always next to your house and has a bunch of free food that you pay for by just looking at some of the other goods.
No, you pay with real money in the end. Or do you think companies run ads for the fun of it?
I don't pay stuff, someone else who subsidized my ad did. Either way it's besides the point of it being a shit market.
> What can you do on a PC that you can't do on your phone?
This is "electricity just comes from the wall" levels of not understanding how things work.
Nothing that runs on a phone is developed or maintained on a phone. Everything that makes the phone work is done on a real computer. It doesn't have to be this way, but Apple and Google and various other parties want it to be this way, so it is. Maybe that will change.
But until it does, the "market share" or "ROI" of a PC is an irrelevant metric. The fact that these metrics fail to capture the value of a PC is an indictment of (your use of) the metrics, not of the PC.
Does the market reward your "value" metric for what a PC is?
If you want to eat and pay your mortgage, are you better off following your metric of "value" in regards to what a PC is?
I dont know, seems pretty relevant to me. I had a dream last night where my mortgage was paid with me tinkering with whimsical products that were grounded in happiness, pluralism, inclusivity and human connection, then I woke up to the good old neoliberal status quo and realized that I have to spend another day at the dream factory capturing peoples attention to pay off my loans and feed myself.
If you want to stick to market dynamics, then focus on that. You asked what can a PC do that a phone can't. The answer, in the context of digital infrastructure, is damn near everything. This is not a metaphysical question, it is an empirical one.
Water is essential for life and yet I can buy hundreds of gallons of it from the local utility for the price of one gallon of gasoline, which I can't even drink. Do not get so hung up on markets as the determiners of all worthiness, they are just allocators of scarce resources.
It's possible the PC will die off (probably through Apple and Microsoft's incompetence), and then the phones will be forced to open up to compensate, but for now I doubt it. They share a common ancestry but they have diverged quite substantially, and this separation has its benefits.
I think the water and gas comparison doesn't make sense here. It's more like the PC is the sparking water with pomegranate flavor and the phone is the normal water. The whole point is that you can do 99% of what you can do with the PC on your phone, if this was not the case the market would be larger
Things a human can do on a PC but not on a phone:
- Software development
- DevOps/system administration
- Industrial automation
- CAD
- (Serious) image/video editing
There are also many "legacy" business processes that are technically doable on a phone but are so cumbersome/limited there that the phone is only really used for things like quick review, small touch-ups, etc. "Microsoft Excel runs the world" is not a trope for nothing.
There are four main reasons for these limitations IMO, in rough order of importance:
1. The phone O/S vendors, who are happy to make most of their platform money through rents on physical-service (often extractive) companies that only pretend to be software companies (like ridesharing and food delivery), gambling, and "free-to-play" video games
2. The software ecosystem, which has largely ignored the use cases I listed above, and so remains fragmented and incomplete (at best) where they are concerned
3. The form factor, which is much more limiting than a monitor+keyboard+mouse/trackpad setup, and can't easily be adapted to compete with the latter except through a dock, but those remain clunky and a bit gimmicky, and no phone even has a Thunderbolt port or other high-bandwidth display-capable connection to properly dock with anyway
4. The hardware, which still shares a lot in common with that of PCs, but has been optimized for things like extremely low power consumption, limited external peripherals, and default-distrust of the end user
And the above is entirely focused on things that make money, this doesn't touch on hobbies, games, and other personal-interest niches.
You can do software development just fine on the phone. Just do "@claude fix my website it's not loading" and everything is solved.
The rest of the listed stuff seems super niche and goes back to the rounding error initial comment.
Like take a step back and think from the average person in the world, not some system administrator, what can the PC do that the phone can't?
Augmented LLMs are potent tools, but they themselves are still made on PCs, and they work best at their tasks when directed by humans on PCs. Such shallow prompts as you gave achieve little more than wasted tokens.
The home-consumer PC market is already contracting and will likely continue to contract. That is not the claim I took issue with. You keep conflating market size with importance. These "rounding errors" run the modern world and will not stop doing so anytime soon.
"work best" is a subjective take, for most people "work good enough" is enough. If the phone works good enough, we don't need PCs.
If it "worked best" and actually mattered, the market would not shrink.
> If the phone works good enough, we don't need PCs.
Sure. It doesn't (yet), so that won't happen (entirely).
However, it does work "good enough" in enough other areas to help explain the contraction. Maybe it will expand into being "good enough" in more areas, and maybe younger people will cause a generational shift that this "unc" can't foresee. But I laid out a bunch of reasons why that's unlikely to happen. I think both PCs and phones are market-saturated, but the replacement treadmill for phones is much faster than for PCs, so the current price shock is hitting PC sales harder.
I think we need an out here to say that PCs will remain for the foreseeable future for businesses and hobbyists, but this won't be enough to sustain the PC market as we know it.
What you technically can do and what you can do even remotely comfortably are very different things.
Select, copy and paste text without feeling like I'm performing dental surgery through the asshole.
Why would you need to do that? You can just generate whatever you need , or ask Muse to copy it from some website
This touches on an issue that has been very concerning to me over the years. The market of "gamers, students, and programmers" in absolute numbers is larger now than it has ever been. But by proportion, it looks smaller and smaller every year. A company catering to such customers could be growing every year, but because the "total addressable market" looks like it's shrinking, we'll instead see contraction and homogenization. It's depressing.
Gamers, students and programmers is a huge swath of people. Students in particular describes essentially everyone at some point in their life. A quick stat I found shows that 83% of people in the US own a laptop. I kind of doubt this will change.
True unfortunately. I have a family member that runs their own business and they have told me that they can do it all from their phone.
They do have a laptop and use it every day as a phone isn't the best place to do all jobs, but it's usable for pretty much everything.
Anynone serious about creative endeavous or anything business-like. Smartphones and tablets continue to be pretty mediocre for anything that isn't consooooming.
> There are some hardware companies which take the opposite approach, namely the thinking that if you sell fragile products which break quickly, then you can get more business because people will buy replacements more quickly, but the same principle applies here as in other businesses selling physical products, like the car business: If you develop a reputation for selling cheap junk which breaks quickly, then you'll lose a lot of business long-term, so most hardware companies (at least those with widespread name-brand recognition) want to protect the value of their brand and sell good products which work well and last a long time.
The problem here is that it takes a long time for the reputation to catch up with the reduced quality and duing that time you profit a lot. And most individuals making the decisions (management, PE, other short-term investors) are not actually all that interested in longer-term sutainability only in maximizing short term profits before they cash out.
And its not just "some" hardware companies that seem to operate this way but almost all of them.
> Software doesn't wear out; it has no moving parts
Of course it does: The environment moves at lot and so do the requirements. Not to mention that hardly any software is actually perfect without room for improvement even with the original constraints.
> We know what kinds of programs people use and want to use, what kinds of features they use and don't use, and so there is not much room left for creativity or innovation, not much possibility remaining for creating new programs for people since all the software which the world needs has not only already been created, but in fact released as open-source software, given away for free on the Internet.
Perhaps we do know what software people need but we are definitely not creating it. Or at least it doesn't end up in front of the average worker, who is instead doomed to constant curses about the crap their are forced to used.
It's the local storage issue that bothers me the most.
I do not want to outsource my backups to a cloud provider.
I do not want my work output to be used by a hyperscaler to train their models.
For decades I've bought relatively inexpensive backup systems/disks, and now it's getting expensive - I believe this is more likely to be collusion than demand.
Google and apple are software companies that produce hardware and it always seems that the software side that wants to kill home computing is winning
They are talking more about pure SaaS companies. Apple is certainly not one.
But I'm sure any mixed hardware/software company would love to sell you the hardware and then a subscription for some SAAS that runs on their servers.
Even Apple is moving in this direction. They moved their professional apps that were previously one-time purchases to a new subscription. Technically, the one-time purchases still exist, and the existing licenses are being honored... however, they have started to introduce offline features (such as MotionVFX), that do not depend on a server, but require the subscription and do not apply to the one-time purchase.
Now that the subscription exists, the one-time purchases may never see a single new feature again. They may even be removed from sale one day.
I had hoped that John Ternus would not allow the subscription to gatekeep anything other than the server-side quotas. I now see that was mistaken.
It really makes the app stale too going to subscription model. With one time license (it would never be one time as you'd be version locked in practice), a company would actually have to deliver compelling new features that would justify the spend to get users off their existing old versions. With subscription, no innovation is needed at all, you get the money no matter what.
Apple's professional apps were truly one-time. A purchase of Final Cut Pro 15 years ago still applies to the very latest version today. You never had to pay for upgrades. There was no concept of renewal at all. Until the introduction of this subscription.
Many other businesses that offer one-time licenses do not offer major version upgrades or even sometimes any updates at all. Apple did. (ignoring the period of time where they had each macOS update behind a purchase)
I don't get updates anymore for CrossOver, Sketchapp, Plasticity. I have a lifetime license, but no updates.
As I understand it there's a growing desktop Linux grassroots movement in the U.S. due to the fact that consumer protections are non-existent and software companies can more or less abuse their customers as they see fit. Many've had enough of the flogging and are jumping ship towards Linux Mint and leaving Windows behind. Vendor lock-in will fail.
The reality is open source is killing software companies, justifiably.
I've killed most subscriptions and have a mini pc happily hosting OS versions.
Hardly. Very few people are like you. Most people don't think too critically and just pay the companies. They actually like their walled gardens. It is why these companies are worth billions, trillions even, after all.
They don't just not think critically but actually become defensive and make excuses when exposed to the idea that there might be a better way. Almost seems like a form of cyber stockholm syndrome some times.
With everyone getting squeezed financially lately I'm hoping some will ask an LLM to help them cut costs and likely the result will be 'host your own, here's how'
AI is rapidly driving the cost of developing software toward zero. However, software is still creating value. In a world with local models and accessible reverse engineering, the software increasingly needs to be kept under wraps to enable monetisation. After the initial SaaSocalypse comes the SaaScension where all of compute is promoted to the cloud.
> AI is rapidly driving the cost of developing software toward zero.
Nah, you're gonna have to pay to access generative AI. At the very least the cost of energy to run even a local rig; if using AI services, you will be paying effective salaries to virtual workers.
Nah or no nah, the conclusion about local vs cloud seems to be the same?
The current perceived hardware scarcity can be related to the tech company race to capture an emerging market. It is a gold rush. If the scarcity is kept going long enough, customer will change their behavior and happily remain cloud customers even when there is plenty of hardware around in a couple of years.
I don’t get it. I don’t use anything that could be construed as software as a service unless you mean like web apps, but they run on somebody else’s machine so you know I expect google to extract some value from me somehow though I don’t think they have to be honest.
These days any sufficiently useful software uses third party and open source libraries and also it’s own code and accrues known CVE security issues over time.
Actual title: Software companies are trying to kill home computing
HN has added a question mark
No, the reason that SaaS became so popular is that we wanted to share things.
We wanted to share personal events (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram).
We wanted to collaborate on documents (Google Docs, Drive, Dropbox).
We wanted to code with others (SourceForge, GitHub).
We wanted to work together on projects (Confluence, JIRA, Trello).
Always on, always accessible, always secure is hard. (Despite the HN "trivial curlftpfs" claims.)
> JIRA
I can't speak for the rest, but didn't JIRA use to be software you paid for and hosted at your business? It was Atlassian who stopped supporting this model, not the customers.
Customers didn’t really enjoy hosting and maintaining it themselves. We can observe the same thing with GitHub. People pay for the second S of SaaS.
Who is the customer here? The IT department? The user subjected made to feel what the first S in SaaS really means? The management ultimately calling the shots but feeleing neither maintenance nor user pain directly themselves?
That’s different.
B2B SaaS came about because organisations said “we don’t want to run our own IT infrastructure, we want to pay someone else to hire people in India to run it instead.”
Well, yes, but if the vast majority had wanted to manage it themselves, they would not have — with both options developed - consolidated on the cloud version.
Note that on premise was de facto subscription, since almost everyone got updates.
no, it's not software companies, it's any company with shareholders that produce any product that can be "updated" to work just as a dumb worker... the idea is that you rent things and always pay, you never own, you rent, it's never yours...
you can see it in sony playstation discs going away, you can see it in things that doesn't work if they are not updated first... anything that needs to connect somewhere to do something is a product as a service...
And yes computers have to go away, so someone can offer "new innovative services"... a.k.a. new ways to "bolt" you.
Just imagine paying disney subscription to see ads... if people organized a little bit they could all cancel their subscription and not renovate it for a week... or a month... and see how fast disney will reverse...
But "it's so convenient" so let's keep paying.
You guys must not have teenagers who play Fortnite and Minecraft. Both my kids are totally hooked on their gaming rigs as are their friends and measure their egos in FPS. I had to suffer the shame of buying Fortnite e-bucks yesterday for my son when he snuck it in the grocery cart. So those kind of models do still seem to be working (I assume, is Epic doing ok?)
Or are we just dorks in a bubble out here in Seattle?
>when he snuck it in the grocery cart.
Why not just tell the cashier you don't wanna buy it?
No section headings no bullet points just a giant wall of text.
Then there's the fact that most people aren't interested in home computing. Like all the people who only have a smart phone and their home computer either never existed or is 15 years old.
Home computing looked way more popular than it really was because home computers was all we had before mobile devices.
I would write a point by point rebuttal about why this is a golden age of home computing, but the points are all camouflaged in a jungle of words.
Brave new world. I can write any software I ever imagined, I just can't run it anywhere...
not yet.
maybe soon
Quantum is around the corner and google will come out with real qubit LLM models that perform x1000 what astra 6.2 can for half a trillion
just watch
I agree with most of this article, and I think a lot of the Terry Davis points were true at the time he spoke them, but nowadays, with agentic AI, things like file permissions and virtual memory could potentially have value. Limiting what your agents can touch can prevent a lot of accidents.
Tech companies have been trying, and succeeding, to make people as tech illiterate as possible. So they will accept the slop they are given and not realise how bad it is.
This article itself doesn't really make much sense.
I understand the general anxiety about ownership of things in the modern world but this article disagrees with: File permissions? Sandboxing? Using React Native?
Games moving to Steam and therefore being licensed rather than owned is a much better point than "windows doesn't want you to own a computer because they have file permissions and use react native"
To be fair, it's only a blog entry (on LiveJournal)
But I personally found it verbose, overly personal (fine as a blog entry but not great as an HN submission) and went off on some strange tangents, as you mention
I think it's a case of the submission headline being a good starting off point for a discussion on here but where the actual body of the submission does not have much 'meat'
i’m just curious as to what OS it is that they deem is truly designed for home users, which they cannot use because of a lack of driver support. i’d like to try that OS out.
"Competition is for losers"
Betteridge's law of headlines: Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word "no".
Although the OP article title does not end in a question mark (the HN title doesn't match the OP article).
The answer is still no, since the post really doesn't make the claim, or does it? I got lost somewhere in the talk about the N-word.
It is false that software doesn't wear out. The way it wore out in the past was through the development of new versions that worked faster and had more useful features.
What happened with software is that innovation stalled. A lot of software lost features, such as when Excel allowed users to drag and drop data into a chart to add other series.
Instead, software focused on changing the interface aesthetic, changing the way it works, forcing users to retrain for no gain in productivity, and making them lose muscle memory. It broke compatibility without offering a better replacement, like MS Office abandoning VB integration. And instead of getting faster, new software gets slower despite demanding more hardware.
In the past, you could learn to use a program by reading the help files. Today, they don't even include help files, or the help is useless.
"Capitalism has never been particularly kind to smart people who give a shit (or people in general... but I digress)."
Just another socialist technologist, bemoaning the "evils" of the very system that created the prosperity in which he's thrived.