Except the explanation doesn't make any sense. A period is a period.
Earth doesn't look like its spinning half as fast if you are 1 light-day away...
The real effect is actually to do with making a graph and noticing an oscillation in the phase of the orbit. In particular the cumulative phase shifts that add up as earth moves further away and the cumulative small phase shifts that add up as earth moves closer to Jupiter. This looks like a sine wave.
Like if someone before you made a table of predicated date and times of io transits (Cassini's constant-period tables) based on the assumption that the oscillation is jitter-free, you could actually realize that there is this +-11 minute jitter in the real measurements after collecting a lot of samples.
There are lots of these textbook simplifications that make a line fitting problem look like some magic 2 point measurement impossibility.
Like the Millikan’s oil drop experiment wasn't some magic nonsense where you figure out how to balance a single drop in mid air.
The Cavendish weighing the earth wasn't a static twist on some wire where you cannot possibly measure the torsion constant precisely enough. It involved measuring a peak to peak deflection of some small oscillation.
The Foucault rotating mirror was not magically shooting a discrete laser pulse and measuring an RPM, as it came back in the second gap it was realising that you could modulate the returning intensity as you ramped angular frequency. Fitting angular velocity against harmonic number was what gives you time of flight not a single tooth.
From the comic: "Over the course of a year, Io's orbital time varied by 22 minutes".
This sentence implies that at some point in the year the time it takes for Io to do one single orbit, as viewed from earth is 22 minutes longer. That's not true. This is not a good explanation comic.
What happens is that if you have a clock that is very accurate and has a drift of less than a minute for a whole year, and you measure the exact moment that Io's eclipse happens (every 42.5 hours) over a full year, you might expect that it's every 42.5 hours all the way through the year. But what you actually see is that this moment varies over the course of a year by 22 minutes - it's later if Jupiter is far away.
Now you might ask how can somebody create such an accurate clock - in the 17th century? He used a pendulum clock which had a drift of like a second in 6 hours, and at the beginning of each night, he corrected that clock based on some other daily occurring measurement of the night sky, like when a certain star crosses a fixed point when viewed from his observatory.
Oof, "not a good explanation comic" is a bit harsh. I deliberately skipped the synodic-period / cumulative-delay framing because I worried it would add a layer of complexity that might bog down a comic aimed at people with zero physics background.
I didn't write the original comment but perhaps a suggestion that may satisfy both of you would be to say the "apparent orbital time"? You don't need to get into the details but this way no one will think that you claim that the actual orbital period varied, only its measurement from earth.
Edit: re-reading the comic I think it was pretty clear already but still maybe this helps.
Didn't intend to make you feel bad. I'm sorry if I offended you.
I think it's interesting that readers often believe "in the medium of comic, things are easier to understand". But it's not so by default. As a writer, it's all about first getting a good intuitive understanding yourself. And then breaking things down into easy to understand chunks that build on top of each other. Which can work in text just as well as a in sequential art.
If I used the form of comic to explain this, I would have shown a graph of time and when eclipses happened, that a scientist might make of this on earth. The graph would have expected eclipses as regular black dots, and there would be red dots with the time of the actual eclipses. And the actual eclipses sometimes line up with the expected time, and sometimes the actual eclipses are a bit late. That would have used the medium to make things clearer.
I'm not sure if it is "comics are easier to understand", but rather that for many, "comics are more inviting to consume than books".
I have 3 (now adult) children -- one was a bookworm and the other two were not, despite doing all the supposedly right things in their rearing (reading to them every night, a large collection of books tailored to them and lining the bookcases in their bedroom, etc.)
They just don't like to read. But Manga and other assorted graphic novels will catch their attention.
I think it is still a good explanation because the context makes it clear, although on its own the statement is wrong. Perhaps you could have written "Over the course of a year, its orbit period was late by up to 22min". Phase is too technical and you would have lost a loot of readers already.
I believe the universe sets the standard for constants science is attempting to articulate.
With that said, the observation of an orbit being late is an observation that our tracking of the orbits is not accounted for accurately.
Time is vague. If our use of base-12 is to account for 60x60x24 seconds in earths rotation and our calendar systems are based around earths orbit. They fail to align with our solar systems constants.
Likely just another counting and dating system approaching
"The museum is situated just a stone's throw from the astronomer Ole Rømer’s Observatorium Tusculanum, where the world’s first meridian circle was built—marking the beginning of a new chapter in the precise measurement of stellar positions. Ole Rømer had the observatory built on his father-in-law’s land in 1704, hoping to escape the disturbances of the big city. In 1973, the site of the observatory was rediscovered, leading to the establishment of an "Ole Rømer Museum" — the direct predecessor to the current Kroppedal Museum.
Today, Kroppedal Museum covers the entire history of Danish astronomy, from the time of Tycho Brahe to the present day."
It’s one of my favorite science fact and question to ask at parties. When I ask people when do people think humans thought for the first time light had a finite speed, the earliest date I got was 1950.
Speaking of favorite question, here’s a brain teaser. Give me a spot on earth from which you move south 30km, east 30km then north 30km and you end up in the same spot?
> Give me a spot on earth from which you move south 30km, east 30km then north 30km and you end up in the same spot?
North Pole, a good one. It's popular brain teaser on non-planar geometry for kids. I usually use: "north 100km, west 100km and south 100km", then ask kids if it's possible to end up in the same place. Most say "no". Then I tell them that it is and ask them where would that place be. If still don't know I tell them "pretend you're penguin" pretty much giving them the answer.
The other one I like to ask is if it's possible to have a triangle with all right angles. (That's called a trirectangular triangle, on earth it would starting and north/south pole, all the way to the equator then a 1/4 way east/south).
There are infinitely many such spots, almost all near the South Pole. Apart from the North Pole, any spot 30km north of a line of latitude whose length is 30km/n for integer n will do.
Oh nice ! Those two are my follow-up questions when they find the North Pole. Specifically I say:
Good job, but what if I told you there were an infinite number of such spots on earth?
They usually ask a lot of good but funny questions about the laws of what I’m asking. You can see in their eyes that they believe at first there’s a trick and my whole goal is to make them think only about the geometry of a perfect sphere.
Then when they found that the infinite number of spots is the meridian 30km north of a meridian of circumference 30km, I ask the second follow-up:
What if I told you there is an infinite number of infinite spots?
No there aren't, unless you redefine "south" "east" and "north" to mean something other than their usual meanings. Obviously from any point you can define a coordinate system with a pole at your location and move away from it, then perpendicular to it and then back to the original point, but unless you at the north pole those three directions wont be south then east then north.
There are actually an infinite number of spots on earth where you can go south 30km, east 30km and north 30km and end up in the same spot.
There are no tricks involved, it’s just pure geometry on a perfect sphere. No need to change coordinates system either. It’s not the South Pole. Also, I don’t consider starting at a different angle to go south as a different starting spot.
Seems like convincing family of points. You start on any point 30km north of a circle with a circumference that is a whole divisor of your desired travel distance.
The you walk along that circle, and end up at the same point you started. (possible walking "around the globe" multiple times)
As you are in the same spot you started walking on that circle, your north-south traveling cancels out.
It works for any combination of (a, b, a) a km south, b km east/west, a km north walking.
The circle you walk just has to have circumference c so that c*n = b, for any natural number n. (probably n≠0 as you can't really walk east/west there)
I don’t quite understand this. The length of the eclipse would be the same, right? Or was it more like that the eclipse ended 10 minutes earlier on the wall clock than expected? I guess what would surprise me about that is:
1. I didn’t know clocks were that good by then to make that reliably measurable.
2. I didn’t realize clocks of the time could measure the period of the eclipse that accurately. Like say one took 24 hours and 7 minutes. If you’re off by 30 seconds, and you’re making a prediction today of when the eclipse would happen six months from now, you could easily be off 90 minutes just based on cumulative error.
The discovery seems easy enough given today’s widespread access to atomic clocks, but extra freaking impressive with clocks from the 1600s.
Got it. I think it’s still very impressive that we could measure all that accurately enough to find a discrepancy, given the tech available then.
I think it’s the phrasing I’ve seen here and in similar articles that throws me:
> He said that on November 9, Io, one of Jupiter's moons, would emerge from the planet's shadow ten minutes later than expected.
What they meant was that the eclipse happened later than expected, both to start and to finish. From just that sentence, it reads to me like it started on time and finished later than expected. On further reading, that’s clearly not the case.
> there should be a difference of about 7 minutes between the periods of Io measured at the first quadrature and those measured at the second quadrature
You're quoting a counterfactual; that paragraphs continues
> "In practice, no difference is observed, from which Rømer concludes that the speed of light must be very much greater than one Earth-diameter per second."
(It does differ, but by a lot less than in that thought experiment cited).
Oh yes, you're right, I was quoting from the reductio ad absurdum derived from the hypothesis "If light travelled at a speed of one Earth-diameter per second", which is far too little.
But I don't know why it says "no difference is observed", as it follows up by saying a difference is observed! That's the operative part: the apparent period does differ (and, of course, you couldn't get from in phase to a phase shift without the period changing). The relevant figures are "an orbital period of 42 hours 28 minutes 31¼ seconds" and "apparent orbital period is 42 hours 29 minutes 3 seconds", a difference of 32 seconds.
Since 32 seconds is roughly 1/14th of 7 minutes, Rømer's reasoning should show that the speed of light is 14 earth diameters per seconds:
14 earth diameters per second: 110845.32 mi/s (miles per second)
speed of light: 186282 mi/s (miles per second)
(Thanks to Wolfram Alpha). So Rømer's analysis was roughly correct.
The apparent orbital period is off by up to 15 seconds, due to Doppler shift. The phase shift over half an Earth orbit is the cumulative effect of the difference between the real and apparent orbital period, which adds up to 22 minutes.
To measure longer periods count the number of days. We have a built in clock which is relatively exact: The rotation of the earth. You only need a clock that measures time correctly during one day, much easier. Which existed at a time.
The pendulum clock had been invented by Christiaan Huygens a couple of decades earlier.
It became quickly widespread, especially at astronomical observatories.
It is likely that the recent availability of accurate pendulum clocks was essential for Rømer's measurements, so such a result about the speed of light would have been impossible for the previous generation of astronomers.
Nonetheless, inside a fixed astronomical observatory, where there has been built a meridian circle with a telescope, and if there is available a good catalogue of stars, it is possible to measure the current "sidereal time" and use differences in sidereal times to compute the corresponding differences in time, even without a clock. The sidereal time is not a time, but the angle of rotation of the Earth vs. the stars. The rotation of the Earth vs. the stars is much more uniform than the apparent movement of the Sun on the sky, which determines the days.
So it would have been possible, but in a much more difficult way, to measure accurately the duration of some astronomical events even without clocks, but only with accurate instruments for measuring angles, used to determine the celestial coordinates of the stars, then compute the difference in the transit times of some stars whose transits coincided with the beginning and the end of the duration that must be measured, from the angles between them.
When good clocks are available, it is easier to measure the transit times of the stars and compute the angles between them from the times, than the reverse procedure, which would be needed without good clocks.
The "shoulders of giants" aren't just those of other scientists.
There's a whole view of history in which the major advances aren't caused by great people but rather by incremental improvements to measurement, manufacturing, and the economic base that powers them. Maybe it's less popular because asking students to memorize names and dates is easier than asking them to understand technology.
Something similar happened in end of the 1800s: searches for a luminiferous aether through which light propagated came back empty, which lead to Lorentz invariance and eventually special relativity. The whole development took a few decades. Physics wasn't just waiting around for Einstein to discover it, he just happened to be born at the right time.
Io eclipses Jupiter with a certain frequency, let's say every 42.5 hour. This is easy enough to measure and verify. So if he noticed that at some point, when Jupiter is close to earth, that eclipse happens at some point during the night, it's trivial to calculate when during the day night months in the future the eclipse should happen.
The distance between the closest and furthest away Jupiter is from earth is ca 378 million km, which light uses ca 21 minute to traverse. So if he grounded his calculations from the time it was closest and then again observed it at it's furthest away (I think that's impossible as it's then behind the sun, but for arguments sake..) it will appear 21 minutes 'to late '.
The clock does not need to be able to keep time over many months, it just needs to be able to measure that its 12:21 and not 12:00.
The eclipse is the same length. When an observer on Earth sees it will vary since our distance to Jupiter varies.
Think about lightning and thunder. The thunder happens the instant the lightning does (the lightning being the eclipse). When you hear the thunder depends on the you, the observer's, position. Imagine we know exactly where and when the lightning/eclipse happens. If hearing the thunder (seeing the eclipse) happens later than that time, we can then calculate the speed of sound based on our distance from the event, and the time we observed it. The final trick is that they didn't know when the eclipse would happen exactly, but they did know when it would be observed by an observer in a given location. If you then observe it from a second location that is farther away from the eclipse, you can determine the speed of light. They used the fact that the earth moves through space to change locations enough for the time differential to be super obvious.
Accurate clocks aren't super duper necessary. You just need one that can be accurate enough for a few hours (since you can fix your time based on celestial observations several times per day). Pendulum clocks were invented about 20 years before this discovery and were accurate to about 1 minute of drift per 24h.
No. I don’t mean for six months. A variation of a minute per day is more than accurate enough to time an event that is expected to have a 10 minute deviation.
The clock only has to keep time between times when it can be accurately reset to true time. If you know your position on earth, there are several daily events that can tell you exactly what time it is. They also knew what time the eclipses were supposed to happen in absolute time.
So I can use my 1 minute per day clock to get the correct absolute time of an eclipse in January and then ignore my clock until the next time I want to observe in June. Then I can get it accurate to true time again and make my observation.
E.g. if I give you a watch that is set today and accurate to 1 second per day, you can tell me what time something happened today within a second. If you wait a full year with the battery taken out and I set the time to be accurate again, you can tell me what time something happened to an accuracy of 1 second. You can also tell me what the difference between those two times were to an accuracy of 2 seconds.
It wasn't the absolute length of the eclipse that varied, but rather the time of day when we see the eclipse happen (i.e. when at which time does the moon enter the shadow, as observed from earth). That is what varies by an unexplained 22 minutes.
The length of a single eclipse appears the same, no matter how far away you are. (Disregarding relativistic effects at high speeds of course).
Yes. That’s what I’m saying. When I said absolute time I meant it to mean true, global time rather than a time relative to an eclipse event.
That comment was only to explain why the clock doesn’t need to be accurate on a 6 month timescale to accurately tell what time two things happening 6 months apart actually happened.
Please, please, please read all of my comments again. Don't cherry pick an out of context sentence, or at the very least read the next sentences I wrote. Strive to understand the sentences fully. All of the information you need to understand is already present. Maybe try an LLM, since I am running out of ways to simplify this
As simple as I can make it:
The data I want is "at what time does Io emerge from the shadow of Jupiter". By having a clock that I know is accurate to within a minute, I can see that Io emerges, look at my clock, and know what time it emerged with no more than one minute of error. In fact, I don't even need the same clock for a second observation, and I don't need it to run continuously. I can throw the clock from the first observation into a fire, the clock need not have continuity. As long as I have ANY accurate clock for both observations I can know what time the event happened. Luckily I live on Earth, where there are several natural daily events that allow me to accurately set a clock to the true time no matter how much it drifts. It doesn't matter that my old clock is a pile of ash because I can just buy a new clock and set the time.
E.g.
You want to know if a train is always on time so you see what time a train comes by on Monday, you see the train go by and you record what time your known accurate watch said it was, you have the first data point. Then - oh no - you lost your watch. You still want to know if the train is always on time, but the original watch is gone! Will you be able to write down what time the train goes by tomorrow after you buy a new watch and set the time?
Also, you seem to be stubbornly clinging to the idea that a clock that loses 1 minute per day is a cumulative error that means it is off by 10 minutes after 10 days. That would be true, except for the thing I keep emphasizing: they reset the clock to the correct time daily. The clock is NEVER off by more than a minute because it gets reset to the correct time before it can lose any more time. If I wait 6 months, the clock is still only off by one minute since it was just set to the correct time.
One other thing you may not have grasped is that time is not arbitrary. A clock does not dictate the time. It tells us the position of the sun in relation to Earth. That's why we can reset it daily. We take an observation of the sun's location, and as long as we know our own location, we can tell you exactly what time it is (alternatively, if we don't know our location, we can derive it based on the position of the sun and the exact time. Until we had accurate clocks at sea, ships didn't know where they were). This is why we can reset the clock to be accurate daily. The clock is not the time; our relative location to the sun is.
Lightspeed[0] is a fascinating book that documents the scientists and experiments that built up to the modern measurement of the speed of light. It's interesting to see how prevailing theories of the aether and the nature of light fall to scientific scrutiny. The author details each speed of light estimate as the book goes on, and we get to see it converging on the modern value toward the end. Highly recommend if you're into the history of science.
The "speed of light" is not a speed like the commonly understood speed of an object (eg. ball/car/etc). It is all mind-bending but worth trying to get a grasp on.
"c" is a geometric property of the "unified spacetime" fabric and is actually the conversion factor between space (3 dims) and time (1 dim). See Spacetime Diagram - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spacetime_diagram. Thus there is a "motion through time" and a "motion through space" (this is the commonly understood meaning of the term motion).
One way to understand this; when an object moves through spacetime its combined rate of motion (i.e. in space + in time) is always fixed to c. So when an object is at rest all its motion is "motion through time" but when it starts accelerating in space the "motion through time" is converted into "motion through space" and in the limit becomes c. This is why you have length contraction and time dilation at speeds close to c.
Another take would be that so-called "spacetime" is just a figment of the imagination, an abstract concept originating perhaps (I don't know) in formulaic thinking (like "time squared" in acceleration as m/s²), which is then reified and postulated to "exist" in the real world.
In addition to a propension for abstract thinking, it takes some firm belief, perhaps bordering on religious, to allow for, let's say, my coffee mug to move through "spacetime" and experience these marvelous "effects" of "length contraction" and "time dilation".
In my completely unprofessional opinion these "effects" are just shims (or adaptor factors) to gloss over the contradictions arising from making the speed of light an absolute limit that won't budge even if and when two objects race past each other at or close to that same speed of light.
It's just a paper trick to dodge the contradictions.
But I guess that is heresy, so … "YMMV" ;) – at least in imagination, as none of us will ever experience anything remotely close to the speed where those "effects" are supposed to kick in.
We can measure every one of the effects that curved spacetime has on the matter and energy in the Universe, including:
- the redshifting of radiation due to the Universe’s expansion,
- the bending of light due to the presence of foreground masses,
- the effects of frame-dragging on a rotating body,
- the additional precession of orbits due to gravitational effects that go beyond what Newton predicted,
- how light gains energy when it falls deeper into a gravitational field and loses energy when it climbs out of it,
</i>
If the above seems too esoteric, then read "Relativity and Satellite Navigation" which explains how the GPS on your phone needs time-dilation corrections based on our understanding of Relativity - https://www.einstein-online.info/en/spotlight/relativity-sat...
> In my completely unprofessional opinion
This is your fundamental problem. You can't deny/make-up something because you don't understand it; that is illogical and irrational.
Much of Modern Physics (Relativity/Quantum/etc.) is not directly perceivable by our crude senses (which are approximations over a continuum) but that does not mean they are "mere mathematical tricks". Our entire society based on Technology is direct proof of the existence of a Reality which we can mould as we see fit (within our current understanding).
In the Scientific Method a Theory is always expressed as a Mathematical Model. Measurements of observations are then matched against the predictions made by the model. If there is congruence, then that model is the best description of Reality.
From the Einstein-online article titled "Relativity and satellite navigation":
« Who simply uses the same atomic clocks as on Earth as satellite clocks, without caring about relativistic effects, makes a mistake. Under conditions on Earth, the atomic clocks in question may just show the unit of time we have chosen for our Earth-centered inertial frame. But when we shoot them upward into the orbit of the navigation satellites, they run a tiny bit faster than on Earth. This results from two opposing effects: First, the flying clocks have a much higher orbital velocity compared to clocks on the Earth’s surface, so they are somewhat slowed down due to the time dilation already described in special relativity. On the other hand, the clocks are noticeably farther away from the Earth – due to the less strong gravitational time dilation, they thus go somewhat faster than clocks of the same design on Earth. The second effect predominates, and overall, a clock on one of the navigation satellites is faster than an identical clock on Earth. »
It seems to me that these explanations pertain to the instrument which is used to measure time, the atomic clock. And that may be. However:
(1) The clock is not the same as time.
(2) The alleged relativistic "time dilation" (slowdown b/o orbital speed) is entirely cancelled out and even turned into a net speedup by gravitational "time dilation".
(3) No conclusions can be drawn about the nature of time, only about the operation of the instrument.
If that is all there is to it, then it seems to me that:
(a) The satellite example does not constitute proof for the alleged relativistic "time dilation".
(b) A gravitational influence on the measurement instrument is sufficient to explain the observation, without any need for "relativity" at all.
Your comment is one "profusion of confusion" jumbling up philosophical questions, physical models and mathematical errors ;-)
As it so happens, i had recently submitted I Do Understand Relativity by Prof. Douglas Ross here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50220891 which you need to read to understand the Physics involved. The concepts are subtle and hence must be carefully grasped.
> It seems to me that these explanations pertain to the instrument which is used to measure time, the atomic clock. And that may be. However: (1) The clock is not the same as time.
This is your 1st fundamental misunderstanding. As i had mentioned earlier, the Mathematical Model is the best description of Reality which is just another way of saying "for all intents and purposes the Model is the Reality (since we have no other visibility into it)". Anything in the universe which exhibits periodicity can be used as a clock under suitable conditions and measurements. The thing it measures is "Time" whose passage we intuitively experience as a sequence of events. Therefore the clock is the model and can be considered synonymous with time itself. To drive the point home, different kinds of atomic clocks all show time dilation by the same factor thus strengthening our confidence in our model.
In this regard take a look at the concept of "logical clocks" in a distributed system introduced by Leslie Lamport which was directly inspired by clocks in Special Relativity.
> (2) The alleged relativistic "time dilation" (slowdown b/o orbital speed) is entirely cancelled out and even turned into a net speedup by gravitational "time dilation".
This is your 2nd misunderstanding. Special Relativity pertains to relative velocities while General Relativity pertains to gravitation. For a GPS satellite they act in opposition viz. the former slows-down time while the latter speeds-up time. They are not equal with former being smaller and -ve while the latter is larger and +ve. So the net effect is that the clocks on the satellite run faster than the ones on the ground. Their exact values Google gives as -7us/day and +45us/day for a net gain of +38us/day.
> (3) No conclusions can be drawn about the nature of time, only about the operation of the instrument.
Not quite. Reality vs. Model has been explained above. When multiple different models (i.e. different types of clocks) all give the same result then that is evidence that there is an actual distinct reality with definite properties. But since Time is part of SpaceTime (i.e. cannot be separated out) that means there is no universal global clock but that each clock is specific to its frame of reference (i.e 4 dims spacetime).
> (a) The satellite example does not constitute proof for the alleged relativistic "time dilation".
Wrong, disproved above.
> (b) A gravitational influence on the measurement instrument is sufficient to explain the observation, without any need for "relativity" at all.
Wrong again. Newton's gravitational laws do not include Time at all and so cannot explain the observed time-dilation. It is only Special/General Relativity which explains it correctly.
Pleased as I am that my comment is a source of delight to you, I have to marvel at your ability to discern mathematical error where mathematics is never touched upon.
« the Model is the Reality … and can be considered synonymous with time itself »
By that logic, Immanuel Kant would have equated the most advanced pendulum or maybe Harrison's marine chronometers with time itself. And yet he didn't. He defined time and space, in Kritik der reinen Vernunft (1781), as the forms in which we perceive the world. While non-physical, that is much cleaner than scrambling both concepts into a "spacetime" omelette that is then said to physically exist, to exhibit properties such as malleability, and whose "geometry" is said to manifest as gravity.
« different kinds of atomic clocks all show time dilation by the same factor »
Maybe they all rely on the same principle. We'll have to agree to disagree wrt my "1st fundamental misunderstanding".
« This is your 2nd misunderstanding. »
No. I did understand how it is supposed to work according to both relativities. The only thing measurable, though, is the net effect, a clock speedup, which is interpreted as a "time speedup", while it is also claimed (by Chatty) that "time does not have a speed", but a clock "accumulates less (or more) proper time".
There is considerable "wiggliness" in the language used to explain the operation of relativity ("wiggletime theory"), almost reminds me of a certain "philosopher" named Derrida, whose strategy is to confuse the reader with "creative language".
Both relativities could be dispensed with by simply concluding that atomic oscillation appears to be correlated with gravity. While certainly "less subtle" than a relativistic interpretation, it would seem to much better satisfy Occam's razor.
« no universal global clock … each clock is specific to its frame of reference »
I do understand how it is supposed to work. To each their own universe.
« Newton's gravitational laws do not include Time at all »
So? Do you think you have to rely on what's given in "Newton's laws" to accept there is gravity and it is correlated with atomic oscillation?
Also, to whom it may concern, what's up with the downvotes on this thread? Childishness, pettiness, bigotry? What motivates such inane behaviour? You can post zillions of moronic one-liners on HN no problem, but once you put effort into a post, you risk downvotes, which personally I don't care about (the notion of "karma points" is somewhat hilarious), but the practical effect will be that very soon I'll have to register yet another account if I want to keep participating in the debate, because all my comments will be stillborn, invisible, and unreplyable. That's the way the HN software works.
« I Do Understand Relativity by Prof. Douglas Ross »
This is a 64 pages PDF. I didn't read the text (simply too much), but I searched the doc for what he had to say about clocks, especially atomic clocks. Clocks are mentioned quite a bit all through the text, but atomic clocks only twice, on pages 24 and 49. Without any detail, he simply suggests they observe and confirm "time dilation".
On page 24 he notes that an atomic clock aboard the so-called ISS space station "which travels at 7800 m/s (v/c ≈ 0.000026) […] gains 7 milliseconds every six months". However, to illustrate "time dilation" due to speed ("special relativity"), it would have been better for the clock to lose some milliseconds. So the example doesn't illustrate his case. He apparently didn't notice – which is no wonder as it is so easy to get confused and lost with this "relativity" business.
"time dilation" is something which can be seen relatively easy. One example is that muons can actually reach certain sensors even though they have a lifetime of only 2.2 microseconds: They shouldn't live long enough for that. However, when they move fast enough they manage to reach the detectors because of time dilation.
And if you didn't take into account both General Relativity and Special Relativity for GPS satellites then you would miscalculate the position by many kilometers.
The latest atomic clocks are so accurate that they measure time differently if two clocks are located mere centimeters (or even less) higher or lower relative to the ground, due to General Relativity (time passes more slowly in a stronger gravity field).
Okay, that muon thing sounds easy enough, will try as soon as I find my stopwatch…
Jokes aside, it seems that there is a notion that the operation of the atomic clock is time. That seems very strange to me. It's just an instrument, okay, an expensive one, but still.
So if that clock is so accurate on gravity is that what's used to measure the Earth's gravitational field to produce the Potsdam potato?
Quote:
"Optical atomic clocks at the 10-19 level are so precise they can detect the slowing of time caused by gravity over height differences of millimeters."
The logic is clearly circular. They define time as some atomic oscillation that is subject to gravity ("Cesium atoms have set the global standard for time since the 1960s"), and then they claim gravity bends time because their measurement instrument uses that atomic oscillation.
And then, on top of that, they sideload a claim this would somehow prove "relativistic time dilation" b/o the theory of "speed of light absolutism" and "spacetime", which is however unrelated to the atomic oscillation (Einstein never referred to it), and does not seem proven at all.
It is you who are claiming that atomic oscillation is subject to gravity. What is the basis for this?
Atomic clocks also show different times if you put one on an airplane and the other at the airport, then you send the airplane away and back again. This is a simple test and has been done. Since then there are many others.
The first one (gravity) matches predictions in Einstein's General Relativity, the second one Einstein's Special Relativity.
As for defining time as "some atomic oscillation", what is the problem with that? How do you measure time? In the past we have used anything and everything which will move at a regular pace, including the pendulum clock I have at a wall here. The problem has always been that these things are sensitive to external forces, so pendulum clocks, while accurate at home, are useless at sea. Thus the invention of successful chronometers by John Harrison, using a mechanism which wouldn't be sensitive to the forces experienced at sea.
Since then the technology has been constantly improved, always with the goal of less and less sensitivity to external forces. Atomic clocks are used because, among other things, they are _not_ sensitive to e.g. gravity. However, they show that time moves differently in a gravity field, which is an entirely different issue.
« you … claiming that atomic oscillation is subject to gravity. What is the basis for this? »
That's what I understood from the article rramadass linked to and and which I quoted a whole paragraph from in 50550665, here's the relevant bit again:
« the clocks [travelling in orbit aboard the satellite] are noticeably farther away from the Earth – due to the less strong gravitational time dilation, they thus go somewhat faster than clocks of the same design on Earth. »
(So by moving away from the centre of gravity, we experience "negative time dilation", or perhaps more appropriately "time constriction", to stay in the metaphor.)
Did I misinterpret anything? Chatty seems to agree with the statement I quoted, when asked whether atomic oscillation is subject to gravity it replied:
« Yes. Gravity […] can very slightly affect its [the atom's] internal oscillation or transition frequency. For example, an atomic clock runs at a slightly different rate at different heights in a gravitational field—a gravitational redshift. »
You asked: « As for defining time as "some atomic oscillation", what is the problem with that? »
It is not necessarily a practical problem (given the amazing temporal resolution that it apparently affords), but substituting the operation of the clock with Time itself and then attributing the specifics of the clock operation to Time itself seems like flawed logic to me, blurring the distinction between the concept and some particular way of measurement.
Conclusions of conceptual or even (wrt Einstein's theories) clearly philosophical (and certainly debatable) nature are drawn from the fact that the operation of the clock is sensitive to gravity. That is a great finding and very interesting but I don't understand how it would constitute proof for "spacetime" or "time dilation".
« Atomic clocks […] are _not_ sensitive to e.g. gravity. »
In a previous comment on this thread, though, you said that they are, and you ascribed that effect to "General Relativity":
« The latest atomic clocks are so accurate that they measure time differently if two clocks are located mere centimeters (or even less) higher or lower relative to the ground »
However, when Einstein conceived his relativity theories (1905–15), he didn't refer to atomic oscillation at all. Perhaps it hadn't been discovered yet (Chatty says atomic clocks started only in 1949). Instead, Einstein went in a different direction, a philosophical direction involving speculative concepts such as "spacetime" and "time dilation".
There almost seems to be like an "urge" to align and unite the more philosophical Einstein stuff with the more modern and more technical stuff of atomic clocks, but to me it looks like there is just a mismatch between the two, and understanding would be much easier by keeping them strictly apart, and by contenting oneself with the amazing fact that gravity affects atomic oscillation, and by resisting the "urge" to draw physics into the more philosophical realm of "spacetime".
No, you're mixing things. Atomic clocks (or any clock, whatever mechanism) show that time progresses differently in different gravitational fields (and also speed related, see special relativity). But they don't tick differently because the tick rate is changed by gravity (or speed), the rate stays the same but _time_ changes, relative to other frames of reference. Time changes due to gravity, the oscillation does not. That's the whole point. If you place two people with one clock each, in very different gravity fields, and they could live for a very very long time, you would see not only that their clocks differ, but their _apparence_ differ: One is older than the other. Because time changes, not the mechanism of the clock.
« Atomic clocks (or any clock, whatever mechanism) show that time progresses differently in different gravitational fields »
The operation of hour glasses and water clocks will indeed be subject to gravity but for classical reasons (that would bury any "relativistic reasons"). Mechanical clocks and quartz crystal driven clocks won't. Chatty says these would show relativistic effects just like atomic clocks. The reason given is:
« The inference that the same effect applies to every physical process comes from the equivalence principle, which has itself been tested repeatedly, and from the fact that all clocks are physical systems existing in the same spacetime. »
Inclusion of "spacetime" here seems undue and circular as that has yet to be proven to exist as a physical object (and not only as a philosophical concept). And looking up "equivalence principle" in Wikipedia, I find as summary/definition: "Hypothesis that inertial and gravitational masses are equivalent". I find the inference Chatty gives unconvincing but I won't go further down what looks like a rabbit hole.
« the rate stays the same but _time_ changes »
That's just a claim that does double duty as premise and conclusion, which is circular logic. "Time changes relativistically" because Einstein said so, and "time is atomic oscillation" (because what's wrong with that?), hence the oscillation rate may stay the same, and if it looks like a speedup or a slowdown that's because "time changes relativistically" as Einstein had said (although, while he did know about atomic oscillation, he never referred to it in his relativity theories).
« two people … very long time, you would see … older than the other »
Not practically verifiable, and would at any rate be extremely fuzzy. (Works fine for sci-fi novels, though.)
It boils down for me to the conclusion that gravity and atomic oscillation are
correlated. Previously I said that "gravity has an influence on atomic oscillation" (and maybe it does), but it turns out the situation around gravity in physics is not as clear as one might think (I just learnt it is conceptually wed to… :| "spacetime", of all things).
Gravity, after all, might not be that "weakest, by a very long shot, of the four fundamental forces, whose job it is to tie solar systems and galaxies together" as it is presented according to established science, but perhaps only an effect of electromagnetism – who knows.
« You can imagine that I look back on my life's work with calm satisfaction. But from nearby it looks quite different. There is not a single concept of which I am convinced that it will stand firm, and I feel uncertain whether I am in general on the right track. » — Albert Einstein, letter to Maurice Solovine, March 28, 1949
I remember some vsauce (i think) video about how we dont know for sure if speed of light is constant in all directions. As a limitation of measurement we can only measure its speed in a round trip.
It's not really possible to measure the time it takes light to move from point A to B. You can really only measure the time it takes for light to move from point A to B and back.
But you can do measure the difference between light going from point A to point B and light going from point A to point C to point B (and adding point C in the reverse direction as well) and I think you can use that to get reasonable confidence that light has constant speed in a given medium in all directions.
But this is totally relevant for trying to figure out asymmetric delivery delays in packet switched networks... You can't measure the delay directly, and if you use the network to synchronize your clocks, you can't use the clocks to measure the delay either, because most synchronization assumes symmetric delay. You need an externally synchronized clock, like a GPS reference etc.
Let's assume light goes faster in the "north" direction, and slower in the "south" direction.
Wouldn't the north- or south-component of the vectors to C cancel each other the same way they do when going from A–B vs. B–A? If the vector AB is on the north-south axis, and C is somewhere to the east, then the increase in speed from A–C–B would be offset by the decrease on the B–C–A return trip, giving you no information as to what direction is faster.
> It's not really possible to measure the time it takes light to move from point A to B. You can really only measure the time it takes for light to move from point A to B and back.
You absolutely can. Get two synchronized clocks, and start pulsing light at each tick. Then slowly move one clock away and observe how long it takes for the light pulse to arrive.
You don't even need crazy precision for that. A regular atomic clock would do.
Edit: if you didn't get the hint, that's exactly how GPS works.
Usually when people are introduced to the issue of measuring the one-way speed of light, one of the first ideas that comes to mind is exactly what you suggest, and it's a very good first thought, but of course it doesn't work since implicit in your approach is an assumption about what the one-way speed of light already is.
As you "slowly" move the two clocks away from one another, the two clocks will no longer be synchronized due to time dilation, and so you need to account for time dilation, but in order to account for time dilation you need to already know what the one-way speed of light is.
I put "slowly" in quotes because why would it possibly matter whether you move clocks slowly or quickly? It's the principle of the matter that is at issue, not the practicality.
> As you "slowly" move the two clocks away from one another, the two clocks will no longer be synchronized due to time dilation, and so you need to account for time dilation, but in order to account for time dilation you need to already know what the one-way speed of light is.
That's why I said "slowly" so that the effect of the time dilation can be kept negligible. If you insist that you MUST account for it, get an additional clock that you move at a different velocity. It'll provide you another data point for the system of equations that you can solve to get the "c" value.
You can measure velocity precisely without any reference to the speed of light by timing how long (according to the clock itself) it takes for it to traverse a given length.
To make it even more watertight, do the experiment in an inertial reference frame with pre-accelerated clocks. Launch two clocks with arbitrary but different velocities along a race track. At the start of the track you have the pulse source along with the reference clock, you synchronize with it as your moving clocks cross the starting line.
Then you measure how long it takes for each moving clock (according to its measurement!) to cross the finish line. This will provide you enough data to solve the equation for the time dilation.
This article has a stronger statement: that it's impossible to measure one-way the lightspeed without doing clock synchronization or assuming that the unit length stays the same regardless of the direction it's traversed.
So in my example, the measurement stick that I'm using to mark the race track, might theoretically have different lengths if traversed from south to north or from north to south.
And I believe that this experiment is still possible to do, although not in the special relativity. You need to traverse the same path in a gravity field and compare the accumulated time dilation. It will depend on the absolute distance travelled.
When you account for relativity, your idea wouldn't work. You assume that two synchronised clocks would remain synchronised after moving them apart from each other and that's almost certainly not true.
It's an interesting puzzle, but it looks to be impossible to measure the speed of light in one direction due to relativity and time/length dilation effects.
Not just light, it's impossible to know if the speed of anything is constant in all directions. The so called one-way speed of an object depends on a synchronization convention used for clocks at different locations. Different conventions can produce different one-way speeds while leaving all other observable physical phenomena unchanged.
I don't think it's just a limitation of measurement. It's a fundamental limitation of the universe, there's no absolute time so there's no accurate time delta between different frames of reference.
So your time measurement can only be valid for you.
A fun corollary of this sort of relative timing is that a dude casually walking by you when you're sitting still will observe the Andromeda Galaxy with a several day time difference.
> will observe the Andromeda Galaxy with a several day time difference.
If you measure both distance and time, the observations will be near-identical. Likewise, the events observed will be near-identical (perhaps with some miniscule differences in observed event ordering). All that's really different is which parts of the distance are labelled as in space, and which are labelled as in time.
I don't think this is quite correct, but I'm not positive myself.
You can't actually make any observations that are several days different from each other, even if you had a miraculous telescope that could see what the little aliens are doing.
You don't actually have any differing observations at all from the person walking next to you (apart from some trivial Doppler effect).
Rather, your frame of reference for what "right now" means in Andromeda differ. And this is not something that ever turns into an observable difference, even if you waited 2.5 million years for the light to get to you to see what the light looked like "right then" in Andromeda, because you'd just be arguing about when that previous "right then" was.
If I remember, Penrose uses this to talk about the nature of time and determinism.
Measurements taken from positions within gravitational fields of the same strength, by observers moving and accelerating in sync (observing no change in distance between them), will be consistent.
While we cannot observe it because we lack an absolute frame of reference, we do know that the speed of light is constant in all directions due to the principle of super-position, provided the medium doesn't change between directions.
Not sure how superposition has any role in this. Sound waves also obey the principle of superposition but sound travels faster downwind than upwind, even though the medium is the same in both directions. So superposition clearly doesn't establish that wave propagation speeds must be identical in all directions.
Sound is a longitudinal wave, the medium velocity is additive to the wave's propagation. Light radiates i.e. it does not require a medium to propagate.
Both longitudinal and transverse waves obey the principle of superposition, yet superposition alone tells us nothing about whether propagation speed is the same in every direction. You're introducing additional properties of electromagnetic waves to justify a conclusion that you originally attributed to superposition.
Superposition has nothing to do with this and does not give any insight into whether the speed of light is the same in all directions.
That's not correct as it is not possible to measure the speed of light in a single direction, but only as a round-trip.
e.g. if light travelled twice as fast to the moon and half the speed from the moon to the earth, there would be no experiment that we could do that would determine that. All clocks and measurements would be the same as if light is constant in both directions.
However, logically we have no reason to think that light does change speed in different directions, so we assume that it's constant.
By the way, what is "the principle of super-position"?
I remember that I thought the hypothesis makes little sense as we define distance as the time light takes to travel. It is the defining constant itself.
As a tangential question is there a book or resource that talks about such historical discoveries with details. Eratosthenes Measurement of Earth's circumference is another such awesome example. I'm sure history is full of such amazing discoveries but I'm unable to find a curated list of such important discoveries.
They start with Eritosthenes of course, and actually mention Rømer's discovery as an aside.
I very recently showed these videos to my father after a discussion on the topic, and while no physicist or mathematician he really enjoyed the watch! It's about an hour long from start to finish.
Eratosthenes' measurement is a great puzzle to give to a smart kid. A friend of mine set it to me when I was in my early 20s.
"With only the materials available to the ancient Greeks, you can figure out the circumference of the earth. How?", he asked me one day. I let my mind have at it – this was c.2000, pre-phone, so I had no choice but to just think about it.
Took me until early that morning, but when you get it, it's immensely satisfying. I won't spoil anything here.
That is really clever. At first reading it I'm thinking, "How could he..." then you realize... Jupiter far... Jupiter close... Orbits don't change timing... Light has speed... Of course!
Is there more about his personal life? He had two wifes, Anne Marie who was 16 when he married her at 36 (in 1780), and Else Magdalene who was 19 when he married her at 55 (in 1799). He was also the Second Chief of Police in Copenhagen. It was a very different time, and I'd like to know more.
> Other philosophers and scientists had previously theorised that light has a finite speed, including the Greek philosopher Empedocles, the Muslim scientists Ibn al-Haytham and Abu Rayhan al-Biruni, and the English philosopher and natural scientist Roger Bacon, according to Wikipedia.
Why are two Arabic scientists identified by their religion? Yet Roger Bacon is "English" rather than "Christian?" Roger Bacon was deeply involved with religion as Franciscan friar!
Anyone with an Arabic name is Muslim first now, evidently.
Readers of a Norwegian science publication will typically be more familiar with Europe than the Middle East, and where there is familiarity there is meaningfully more room for distinction. If I'm talking about where I'm from to a fellow Canadian, I'll say the name of the city I live in. If I'm having the same conversation with someone from elsewhere I'd just tell them I'm from Canada.
Some of those individuals are Persian or possibly Persian, so I think the article just says “Muslim” to hedge around uncertainty or getting too precise for the reader
Biruni wasn't Arabic, but Persian (or Khwaresmian, depending on how you set the boundaries), and he was born and lived in Central Asia. Calling him Arabic is like calling Roger Bacon "Germanic".
Al Khaytam was born in Arabic family, not Persian.
So the common denominator for them is the Islamic scientific community.
Roger Bacon live in medieval England so he is "English". If he lived before England existed as a concept, he probably would be described as a "Christian".
Though impressive, I am more impressed that they had a clock that accurate at the time and also knew the distance between the planets. To me those are intrinsically related.
The way I came to understand the speed of light, it is not so much that it is finite, but more so that time slows down the nearer you get and stops at light speed.
This means that going faster than light entails time travel into the past. While going just at the speed of light means you can travel any distance in exactly zero seconds. It's just that time passes for your surroundings.
This is a subtle misunderstanding. As you approach the speed of light, physical processes including clocks or other time measuring devices appear to slow down relative to an observer. Exceeding the speed of light, at least as a conceptual generalization, doesn't mean that you end up going back in time and experiencing past events like Back to the Future, rather it would allow for future events to influence the outcome of past events, what is called retrocausality [1].
Retrocausality is not the same as time travel. With time travel it's as if you get to go back in time and reexperience things that happened in the past, which is not what faster than light travel implies. Retrocausality is more about things happening in the present that are influenced by future events, as opposed to causality where only past events can influence the outcome of future events.
According to [0], the journal has changed names twice, so "Journal des savants" would be referencing the modern journal that used to be called "Journal des sçavans"
I created a web comic based on this measurement! https://randomlyunique.com/plancky/2018/roemers-speed-of-lig...
Thanks, this is a much clearer explanation than the article.
Except the explanation doesn't make any sense. A period is a period. Earth doesn't look like its spinning half as fast if you are 1 light-day away...
The real effect is actually to do with making a graph and noticing an oscillation in the phase of the orbit. In particular the cumulative phase shifts that add up as earth moves further away and the cumulative small phase shifts that add up as earth moves closer to Jupiter. This looks like a sine wave.
Like if someone before you made a table of predicated date and times of io transits (Cassini's constant-period tables) based on the assumption that the oscillation is jitter-free, you could actually realize that there is this +-11 minute jitter in the real measurements after collecting a lot of samples.
There are lots of these textbook simplifications that make a line fitting problem look like some magic 2 point measurement impossibility.
Like the Millikan’s oil drop experiment wasn't some magic nonsense where you figure out how to balance a single drop in mid air.
The Cavendish weighing the earth wasn't a static twist on some wire where you cannot possibly measure the torsion constant precisely enough. It involved measuring a peak to peak deflection of some small oscillation.
The Foucault rotating mirror was not magically shooting a discrete laser pulse and measuring an RPM, as it came back in the second gap it was realising that you could modulate the returning intensity as you ramped angular frequency. Fitting angular velocity against harmonic number was what gives you time of flight not a single tooth.
> oscillation in the phase of the orbit.
Ok, thanks for explaining, makes sense now.
Wow, what a wonderful little site. It never occurred to me that optical disks worked via constructive/destructive interference: https://randomlyunique.com/plancky/2018/how-optical-disks-wo...
Thanks so much, this comment made my day!
From the comic: "Over the course of a year, Io's orbital time varied by 22 minutes".
This sentence implies that at some point in the year the time it takes for Io to do one single orbit, as viewed from earth is 22 minutes longer. That's not true. This is not a good explanation comic.
What happens is that if you have a clock that is very accurate and has a drift of less than a minute for a whole year, and you measure the exact moment that Io's eclipse happens (every 42.5 hours) over a full year, you might expect that it's every 42.5 hours all the way through the year. But what you actually see is that this moment varies over the course of a year by 22 minutes - it's later if Jupiter is far away.
Now you might ask how can somebody create such an accurate clock - in the 17th century? He used a pendulum clock which had a drift of like a second in 6 hours, and at the beginning of each night, he corrected that clock based on some other daily occurring measurement of the night sky, like when a certain star crosses a fixed point when viewed from his observatory.
Ok i still don’t know whats true but at least this explanation with 0 visuals was very intuitive.
Oof, "not a good explanation comic" is a bit harsh. I deliberately skipped the synodic-period / cumulative-delay framing because I worried it would add a layer of complexity that might bog down a comic aimed at people with zero physics background.
I didn't write the original comment but perhaps a suggestion that may satisfy both of you would be to say the "apparent orbital time"? You don't need to get into the details but this way no one will think that you claim that the actual orbital period varied, only its measurement from earth.
Edit: re-reading the comic I think it was pretty clear already but still maybe this helps.
But the apparent orbital period doesn't vary by 22 minutes, the cumulative error in the orbital period reaches as much as 22 minutes.
100 laps that are all a second too long makes a cumulative error of 100 seconds but there was no lap that was 100 seconds too long.
(I actually have no idea about Io, but that's the distinction I think Coeur is trying to make).
I think you're right, the orbit is much faster than 6 months so the 22 minutes would be spread across many orbits. Excellent point, thank you.
Didn't intend to make you feel bad. I'm sorry if I offended you.
I think it's interesting that readers often believe "in the medium of comic, things are easier to understand". But it's not so by default. As a writer, it's all about first getting a good intuitive understanding yourself. And then breaking things down into easy to understand chunks that build on top of each other. Which can work in text just as well as a in sequential art.
If I used the form of comic to explain this, I would have shown a graph of time and when eclipses happened, that a scientist might make of this on earth. The graph would have expected eclipses as regular black dots, and there would be red dots with the time of the actual eclipses. And the actual eclipses sometimes line up with the expected time, and sometimes the actual eclipses are a bit late. That would have used the medium to make things clearer.
I'm not sure if it is "comics are easier to understand", but rather that for many, "comics are more inviting to consume than books".
I have 3 (now adult) children -- one was a bookworm and the other two were not, despite doing all the supposedly right things in their rearing (reading to them every night, a large collection of books tailored to them and lining the bookcases in their bedroom, etc.)
They just don't like to read. But Manga and other assorted graphic novels will catch their attention.
It is confusing, Tau usually means period but it should be more like a long duration clock time t.
Ain’t nobody got time for that nowadays
I think it is still a good explanation because the context makes it clear, although on its own the statement is wrong. Perhaps you could have written "Over the course of a year, its orbit period was late by up to 22min". Phase is too technical and you would have lost a loot of readers already.
I was very confused here, your phrasing would definitely help. Once understanding breaks down at the beginning, we may never get out of it.
Orbit period means the same thing though!
Maybe "observed orbital time" (or "apparent orbital time") would work better.
True, quite difficult to explain it correctly. Perhaps substitute "late" with "shifted".
I believe the universe sets the standard for constants science is attempting to articulate.
With that said, the observation of an orbit being late is an observation that our tracking of the orbits is not accounted for accurately.
Time is vague. If our use of base-12 is to account for 60x60x24 seconds in earths rotation and our calendar systems are based around earths orbit. They fail to align with our solar systems constants.
Likely just another counting and dating system approaching
I cant stop hitting next on this site haha. Beautifully described and concise! Thank you!
Man I ask Gemini and Claude to create infographics normally but they are always so cumbersome to understand. But your comics are so intuitive
There's a charming small museum just (west) outside Copenhagen, that used to be the Ole Rømer Museum, worth considering for a visit if you are nearby.
Site (https://kroppedal.dk/astronomi/) is only in Danish, rough translation of part:
"The museum is situated just a stone's throw from the astronomer Ole Rømer’s Observatorium Tusculanum, where the world’s first meridian circle was built—marking the beginning of a new chapter in the precise measurement of stellar positions. Ole Rømer had the observatory built on his father-in-law’s land in 1704, hoping to escape the disturbances of the big city. In 1973, the site of the observatory was rediscovered, leading to the establishment of an "Ole Rømer Museum" — the direct predecessor to the current Kroppedal Museum.
Today, Kroppedal Museum covers the entire history of Danish astronomy, from the time of Tycho Brahe to the present day."
Great if you like old astronomical instruments!
There was a much better explained video from Physics Explained about this https://youtu.be/8yhk1EZq9tY?is=2BvxUY5HKEWkk2LL
It’s one of my favorite science fact and question to ask at parties. When I ask people when do people think humans thought for the first time light had a finite speed, the earliest date I got was 1950.
Speaking of favorite question, here’s a brain teaser. Give me a spot on earth from which you move south 30km, east 30km then north 30km and you end up in the same spot?
For the brain teaser; isn’t it straight forward that it’s the North Pole or am I missing something?
There are more places than just there.
Yeah but the question was asking for one :)
> Give me a spot on earth from which you move south 30km, east 30km then north 30km and you end up in the same spot?
North Pole, a good one. It's popular brain teaser on non-planar geometry for kids. I usually use: "north 100km, west 100km and south 100km", then ask kids if it's possible to end up in the same place. Most say "no". Then I tell them that it is and ask them where would that place be. If still don't know I tell them "pretend you're penguin" pretty much giving them the answer.
The other one I like to ask is if it's possible to have a triangle with all right angles. (That's called a trirectangular triangle, on earth it would starting and north/south pole, all the way to the equator then a 1/4 way east/south).
> North Pole, a good one.
There are infinitely many such spots, almost all near the South Pole. Apart from the North Pole, any spot 30km north of a line of latitude whose length is 30km/n for integer n will do.
Exactly! It surprises me that almost nobody comes up with this one.
Oh nice ! Those two are my follow-up questions when they find the North Pole. Specifically I say:
Good job, but what if I told you there were an infinite number of such spots on earth?
They usually ask a lot of good but funny questions about the laws of what I’m asking. You can see in their eyes that they believe at first there’s a trick and my whole goal is to make them think only about the geometry of a perfect sphere.
Then when they found that the infinite number of spots is the meridian 30km north of a meridian of circumference 30km, I ask the second follow-up:
What if I told you there is an infinite number of infinite spots?
That’s where you get the /n answer.
There are more answers to this than most people think. Modelling the Earth as a sphere, there is a countable infinity of uncountably many locations.
The North Pole is just one.
No there aren't, unless you redefine "south" "east" and "north" to mean something other than their usual meanings. Obviously from any point you can define a coordinate system with a pole at your location and move away from it, then perpendicular to it and then back to the original point, but unless you at the north pole those three directions wont be south then east then north.
There are actually an infinite number of spots on earth where you can go south 30km, east 30km and north 30km and end up in the same spot.
There are no tricks involved, it’s just pure geometry on a perfect sphere. No need to change coordinates system either. It’s not the South Pole. Also, I don’t consider starting at a different angle to go south as a different starting spot.
Oh, doing whole number rotations on the earth on the eastward leg near the south pole. Fair enough I didn't consider that.
Yes exactly! So it’s technically an infinite of infinite spots on earth. M
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50538924
Seems like convincing family of points. You start on any point 30km north of a circle with a circumference that is a whole divisor of your desired travel distance.
The you walk along that circle, and end up at the same point you started. (possible walking "around the globe" multiple times)
As you are in the same spot you started walking on that circle, your north-south traveling cancels out.
It works for any combination of (a, b, a) a km south, b km east/west, a km north walking.
The circle you walk just has to have circumference c so that c*n = b, for any natural number n. (probably n≠0 as you can't really walk east/west there)
I love this, and the non-trivial answers to it:
Consider any of the circles around South pole with a circumference of 30km, 15, 10 etc. 30km above any of these circles.
I don’t quite understand this. The length of the eclipse would be the same, right? Or was it more like that the eclipse ended 10 minutes earlier on the wall clock than expected? I guess what would surprise me about that is:
1. I didn’t know clocks were that good by then to make that reliably measurable.
2. I didn’t realize clocks of the time could measure the period of the eclipse that accurately. Like say one took 24 hours and 7 minutes. If you’re off by 30 seconds, and you’re making a prediction today of when the eclipse would happen six months from now, you could easily be off 90 minutes just based on cumulative error.
The discovery seems easy enough given today’s widespread access to atomic clocks, but extra freaking impressive with clocks from the 1600s.
The orbital period is the same but there's phase drift in the occlusion times.
Got it. I think it’s still very impressive that we could measure all that accurately enough to find a discrepancy, given the tech available then.
I think it’s the phrasing I’ve seen here and in similar articles that throws me:
> He said that on November 9, Io, one of Jupiter's moons, would emerge from the planet's shadow ten minutes later than expected.
What they meant was that the eclipse happened later than expected, both to start and to finish. From just that sentence, it reads to me like it started on time and finished later than expected. On further reading, that’s clearly not the case.
No, the apparent orbital period differs:
> there should be a difference of about 7 minutes between the periods of Io measured at the first quadrature and those measured at the second quadrature
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%C3%B8mer%27s_determination_o...
You're quoting a counterfactual; that paragraphs continues
> "In practice, no difference is observed, from which Rømer concludes that the speed of light must be very much greater than one Earth-diameter per second."
(It does differ, but by a lot less than in that thought experiment cited).
Oh yes, you're right, I was quoting from the reductio ad absurdum derived from the hypothesis "If light travelled at a speed of one Earth-diameter per second", which is far too little.
But I don't know why it says "no difference is observed", as it follows up by saying a difference is observed! That's the operative part: the apparent period does differ (and, of course, you couldn't get from in phase to a phase shift without the period changing). The relevant figures are "an orbital period of 42 hours 28 minutes 31¼ seconds" and "apparent orbital period is 42 hours 29 minutes 3 seconds", a difference of 32 seconds.
Since 32 seconds is roughly 1/14th of 7 minutes, Rømer's reasoning should show that the speed of light is 14 earth diameters per seconds:
14 earth diameters per second: 110845.32 mi/s (miles per second)
speed of light: 186282 mi/s (miles per second)
(Thanks to Wolfram Alpha). So Rømer's analysis was roughly correct.
> "a difference of 32 seconds."
Oh, thank you! Shows I made a factor-of-2 error in my sibling comment.
The apparent orbital period is off by up to 15 seconds, due to Doppler shift. The phase shift over half an Earth orbit is the cumulative effect of the difference between the real and apparent orbital period, which adds up to 22 minutes.
To measure longer periods count the number of days. We have a built in clock which is relatively exact: The rotation of the earth. You only need a clock that measures time correctly during one day, much easier. Which existed at a time.
For the other point, and how he did, i guess the article is badly written. This should be better: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%C3%B8mer%27s_determination_o... (he didnt need to measure months/years)
Ooh, that’s much clearer to me, thanks!
The pendulum clock had been invented by Christiaan Huygens a couple of decades earlier.
It became quickly widespread, especially at astronomical observatories.
It is likely that the recent availability of accurate pendulum clocks was essential for Rømer's measurements, so such a result about the speed of light would have been impossible for the previous generation of astronomers.
Nonetheless, inside a fixed astronomical observatory, where there has been built a meridian circle with a telescope, and if there is available a good catalogue of stars, it is possible to measure the current "sidereal time" and use differences in sidereal times to compute the corresponding differences in time, even without a clock. The sidereal time is not a time, but the angle of rotation of the Earth vs. the stars. The rotation of the Earth vs. the stars is much more uniform than the apparent movement of the Sun on the sky, which determines the days.
So it would have been possible, but in a much more difficult way, to measure accurately the duration of some astronomical events even without clocks, but only with accurate instruments for measuring angles, used to determine the celestial coordinates of the stars, then compute the difference in the transit times of some stars whose transits coincided with the beginning and the end of the duration that must be measured, from the angles between them.
When good clocks are available, it is easier to measure the transit times of the stars and compute the angles between them from the times, than the reverse procedure, which would be needed without good clocks.
The "shoulders of giants" aren't just those of other scientists.
There's a whole view of history in which the major advances aren't caused by great people but rather by incremental improvements to measurement, manufacturing, and the economic base that powers them. Maybe it's less popular because asking students to memorize names and dates is easier than asking them to understand technology.
Something similar happened in end of the 1800s: searches for a luminiferous aether through which light propagated came back empty, which lead to Lorentz invariance and eventually special relativity. The whole development took a few decades. Physics wasn't just waiting around for Einstein to discover it, he just happened to be born at the right time.
Io eclipses Jupiter with a certain frequency, let's say every 42.5 hour. This is easy enough to measure and verify. So if he noticed that at some point, when Jupiter is close to earth, that eclipse happens at some point during the night, it's trivial to calculate when during the day night months in the future the eclipse should happen.
The distance between the closest and furthest away Jupiter is from earth is ca 378 million km, which light uses ca 21 minute to traverse. So if he grounded his calculations from the time it was closest and then again observed it at it's furthest away (I think that's impossible as it's then behind the sun, but for arguments sake..) it will appear 21 minutes 'to late '.
The clock does not need to be able to keep time over many months, it just needs to be able to measure that its 12:21 and not 12:00.
The eclipse is the same length. When an observer on Earth sees it will vary since our distance to Jupiter varies.
Think about lightning and thunder. The thunder happens the instant the lightning does (the lightning being the eclipse). When you hear the thunder depends on the you, the observer's, position. Imagine we know exactly where and when the lightning/eclipse happens. If hearing the thunder (seeing the eclipse) happens later than that time, we can then calculate the speed of sound based on our distance from the event, and the time we observed it. The final trick is that they didn't know when the eclipse would happen exactly, but they did know when it would be observed by an observer in a given location. If you then observe it from a second location that is farther away from the eclipse, you can determine the speed of light. They used the fact that the earth moves through space to change locations enough for the time differential to be super obvious.
Accurate clocks aren't super duper necessary. You just need one that can be accurate enough for a few hours (since you can fix your time based on celestial observations several times per day). Pendulum clocks were invented about 20 years before this discovery and were accurate to about 1 minute of drift per 24h.
> Accurate clocks aren't super duper necessary. You just need one that can be accurate enough for a few hours
you mean for 6 months?
I guess you can recalibrate at noon daily so that you only have to be accurate for a day at a time, not for extended periods.
No. I don’t mean for six months. A variation of a minute per day is more than accurate enough to time an event that is expected to have a 10 minute deviation.
The clock only has to keep time between times when it can be accurately reset to true time. If you know your position on earth, there are several daily events that can tell you exactly what time it is. They also knew what time the eclipses were supposed to happen in absolute time.
So I can use my 1 minute per day clock to get the correct absolute time of an eclipse in January and then ignore my clock until the next time I want to observe in June. Then I can get it accurate to true time again and make my observation.
E.g. if I give you a watch that is set today and accurate to 1 second per day, you can tell me what time something happened today within a second. If you wait a full year with the battery taken out and I set the time to be accurate again, you can tell me what time something happened to an accuracy of 1 second. You can also tell me what the difference between those two times were to an accuracy of 2 seconds.
It wasn't the absolute length of the eclipse that varied, but rather the time of day when we see the eclipse happen (i.e. when at which time does the moon enter the shadow, as observed from earth). That is what varies by an unexplained 22 minutes.
The length of a single eclipse appears the same, no matter how far away you are. (Disregarding relativistic effects at high speeds of course).
Yes. That’s what I’m saying. When I said absolute time I meant it to mean true, global time rather than a time relative to an eclipse event.
That comment was only to explain why the clock doesn’t need to be accurate on a 6 month timescale to accurately tell what time two things happening 6 months apart actually happened.
> A variation of a minute per day is more than accurate enough to time an event that is expected to have a 10 minute deviation.
so you expect to measure stuff only 10 days apart?
isn't the whole deal is that Earth was on opposite sides of its orbit?
Please, please, please read all of my comments again. Don't cherry pick an out of context sentence, or at the very least read the next sentences I wrote. Strive to understand the sentences fully. All of the information you need to understand is already present. Maybe try an LLM, since I am running out of ways to simplify this
As simple as I can make it:
The data I want is "at what time does Io emerge from the shadow of Jupiter". By having a clock that I know is accurate to within a minute, I can see that Io emerges, look at my clock, and know what time it emerged with no more than one minute of error. In fact, I don't even need the same clock for a second observation, and I don't need it to run continuously. I can throw the clock from the first observation into a fire, the clock need not have continuity. As long as I have ANY accurate clock for both observations I can know what time the event happened. Luckily I live on Earth, where there are several natural daily events that allow me to accurately set a clock to the true time no matter how much it drifts. It doesn't matter that my old clock is a pile of ash because I can just buy a new clock and set the time.
E.g. You want to know if a train is always on time so you see what time a train comes by on Monday, you see the train go by and you record what time your known accurate watch said it was, you have the first data point. Then - oh no - you lost your watch. You still want to know if the train is always on time, but the original watch is gone! Will you be able to write down what time the train goes by tomorrow after you buy a new watch and set the time?
Also, you seem to be stubbornly clinging to the idea that a clock that loses 1 minute per day is a cumulative error that means it is off by 10 minutes after 10 days. That would be true, except for the thing I keep emphasizing: they reset the clock to the correct time daily. The clock is NEVER off by more than a minute because it gets reset to the correct time before it can lose any more time. If I wait 6 months, the clock is still only off by one minute since it was just set to the correct time.
One other thing you may not have grasped is that time is not arbitrary. A clock does not dictate the time. It tells us the position of the sun in relation to Earth. That's why we can reset it daily. We take an observation of the sun's location, and as long as we know our own location, we can tell you exactly what time it is (alternatively, if we don't know our location, we can derive it based on the position of the sun and the exact time. Until we had accurate clocks at sea, ships didn't know where they were). This is why we can reset the clock to be accurate daily. The clock is not the time; our relative location to the sun is.
If you like things like this, you might like the book "Longitude" about timekeeping at sea.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Longitude_(book)
A wonderful trilogy of sci-fi books by Greg Egan where the speed of light is not constant (a function of frequency) and how that impacts society.
https://a.co/d/0fZNXGxD
I love the way Egan handled closed time-like curves in the third book. It is basically what Nolan tried to do in Tenet but failed.
I always like sci-fi where you change one law of physics and follow the consequences.
Lightspeed[0] is a fascinating book that documents the scientists and experiments that built up to the modern measurement of the speed of light. It's interesting to see how prevailing theories of the aether and the nature of light fall to scientific scrutiny. The author details each speed of light estimate as the book goes on, and we get to see it converging on the modern value toward the end. Highly recommend if you're into the history of science.
[0]: https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/46179037-lightspeed
To add an even more fascinating take;
The "speed of light" is not a speed like the commonly understood speed of an object (eg. ball/car/etc). It is all mind-bending but worth trying to get a grasp on.
"c" is a geometric property of the "unified spacetime" fabric and is actually the conversion factor between space (3 dims) and time (1 dim). See Spacetime Diagram - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spacetime_diagram. Thus there is a "motion through time" and a "motion through space" (this is the commonly understood meaning of the term motion).
This article explains it - https://www.aoc.nrao.edu/~smyers/courses/astro12/speedofligh...
One way to understand this; when an object moves through spacetime its combined rate of motion (i.e. in space + in time) is always fixed to c. So when an object is at rest all its motion is "motion through time" but when it starts accelerating in space the "motion through time" is converted into "motion through space" and in the limit becomes c. This is why you have length contraction and time dilation at speeds close to c.
« when an object moves through spacetime »
Another take would be that so-called "spacetime" is just a figment of the imagination, an abstract concept originating perhaps (I don't know) in formulaic thinking (like "time squared" in acceleration as m/s²), which is then reified and postulated to "exist" in the real world.
In addition to a propension for abstract thinking, it takes some firm belief, perhaps bordering on religious, to allow for, let's say, my coffee mug to move through "spacetime" and experience these marvelous "effects" of "length contraction" and "time dilation".
In my completely unprofessional opinion these "effects" are just shims (or adaptor factors) to gloss over the contradictions arising from making the speed of light an absolute limit that won't budge even if and when two objects race past each other at or close to that same speed of light.
It's just a paper trick to dodge the contradictions.
But I guess that is heresy, so … "YMMV" ;) – at least in imagination, as none of us will ever experience anything remotely close to the speed where those "effects" are supposed to kick in.
> "spacetime" is just a figment of the imagination,
No, Its effects (relativistic) have been measured using specific mathematical models which predict its behaviour.
Read "Spacetime: is it real and physical, or just a calculational tool?" - https://bigthink.com/starts-with-a-bang/spacetime-real-physi...
We can measure every one of the effects that curved spacetime has on the matter and energy in the Universe, including:
</i>
If the above seems too esoteric, then read "Relativity and Satellite Navigation" which explains how the GPS on your phone needs time-dilation corrections based on our understanding of Relativity - https://www.einstein-online.info/en/spotlight/relativity-sat...
> In my completely unprofessional opinion
This is your fundamental problem. You can't deny/make-up something because you don't understand it; that is illogical and irrational.
Much of Modern Physics (Relativity/Quantum/etc.) is not directly perceivable by our crude senses (which are approximations over a continuum) but that does not mean they are "mere mathematical tricks". Our entire society based on Technology is direct proof of the existence of a Reality which we can mould as we see fit (within our current understanding).
In the Scientific Method a Theory is always expressed as a Mathematical Model. Measurements of observations are then matched against the predictions made by the model. If there is congruence, then that model is the best description of Reality.
From the Einstein-online article titled "Relativity and satellite navigation":
« Who simply uses the same atomic clocks as on Earth as satellite clocks, without caring about relativistic effects, makes a mistake. Under conditions on Earth, the atomic clocks in question may just show the unit of time we have chosen for our Earth-centered inertial frame. But when we shoot them upward into the orbit of the navigation satellites, they run a tiny bit faster than on Earth. This results from two opposing effects: First, the flying clocks have a much higher orbital velocity compared to clocks on the Earth’s surface, so they are somewhat slowed down due to the time dilation already described in special relativity. On the other hand, the clocks are noticeably farther away from the Earth – due to the less strong gravitational time dilation, they thus go somewhat faster than clocks of the same design on Earth. The second effect predominates, and overall, a clock on one of the navigation satellites is faster than an identical clock on Earth. »
It seems to me that these explanations pertain to the instrument which is used to measure time, the atomic clock. And that may be. However:
(1) The clock is not the same as time.
(2) The alleged relativistic "time dilation" (slowdown b/o orbital speed) is entirely cancelled out and even turned into a net speedup by gravitational "time dilation".
(3) No conclusions can be drawn about the nature of time, only about the operation of the instrument.
If that is all there is to it, then it seems to me that:
(a) The satellite example does not constitute proof for the alleged relativistic "time dilation".
(b) A gravitational influence on the measurement instrument is sufficient to explain the observation, without any need for "relativity" at all.
Your comment is one "profusion of confusion" jumbling up philosophical questions, physical models and mathematical errors ;-)
As it so happens, i had recently submitted I Do Understand Relativity by Prof. Douglas Ross here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50220891 which you need to read to understand the Physics involved. The concepts are subtle and hence must be carefully grasped.
> It seems to me that these explanations pertain to the instrument which is used to measure time, the atomic clock. And that may be. However: (1) The clock is not the same as time.
This is your 1st fundamental misunderstanding. As i had mentioned earlier, the Mathematical Model is the best description of Reality which is just another way of saying "for all intents and purposes the Model is the Reality (since we have no other visibility into it)". Anything in the universe which exhibits periodicity can be used as a clock under suitable conditions and measurements. The thing it measures is "Time" whose passage we intuitively experience as a sequence of events. Therefore the clock is the model and can be considered synonymous with time itself. To drive the point home, different kinds of atomic clocks all show time dilation by the same factor thus strengthening our confidence in our model.
In this regard take a look at the concept of "logical clocks" in a distributed system introduced by Leslie Lamport which was directly inspired by clocks in Special Relativity.
> (2) The alleged relativistic "time dilation" (slowdown b/o orbital speed) is entirely cancelled out and even turned into a net speedup by gravitational "time dilation".
This is your 2nd misunderstanding. Special Relativity pertains to relative velocities while General Relativity pertains to gravitation. For a GPS satellite they act in opposition viz. the former slows-down time while the latter speeds-up time. They are not equal with former being smaller and -ve while the latter is larger and +ve. So the net effect is that the clocks on the satellite run faster than the ones on the ground. Their exact values Google gives as -7us/day and +45us/day for a net gain of +38us/day.
> (3) No conclusions can be drawn about the nature of time, only about the operation of the instrument.
Not quite. Reality vs. Model has been explained above. When multiple different models (i.e. different types of clocks) all give the same result then that is evidence that there is an actual distinct reality with definite properties. But since Time is part of SpaceTime (i.e. cannot be separated out) that means there is no universal global clock but that each clock is specific to its frame of reference (i.e 4 dims spacetime).
> (a) The satellite example does not constitute proof for the alleged relativistic "time dilation".
Wrong, disproved above.
> (b) A gravitational influence on the measurement instrument is sufficient to explain the observation, without any need for "relativity" at all.
Wrong again. Newton's gravitational laws do not include Time at all and so cannot explain the observed time-dilation. It is only Special/General Relativity which explains it correctly.
« Your comment … mathematical errors ;-) »
Pleased as I am that my comment is a source of delight to you, I have to marvel at your ability to discern mathematical error where mathematics is never touched upon.
« the Model is the Reality … and can be considered synonymous with time itself »
By that logic, Immanuel Kant would have equated the most advanced pendulum or maybe Harrison's marine chronometers with time itself. And yet he didn't. He defined time and space, in Kritik der reinen Vernunft (1781), as the forms in which we perceive the world. While non-physical, that is much cleaner than scrambling both concepts into a "spacetime" omelette that is then said to physically exist, to exhibit properties such as malleability, and whose "geometry" is said to manifest as gravity.
« different kinds of atomic clocks all show time dilation by the same factor »
Maybe they all rely on the same principle. We'll have to agree to disagree wrt my "1st fundamental misunderstanding".
« This is your 2nd misunderstanding. »
No. I did understand how it is supposed to work according to both relativities. The only thing measurable, though, is the net effect, a clock speedup, which is interpreted as a "time speedup", while it is also claimed (by Chatty) that "time does not have a speed", but a clock "accumulates less (or more) proper time".
There is considerable "wiggliness" in the language used to explain the operation of relativity ("wiggletime theory"), almost reminds me of a certain "philosopher" named Derrida, whose strategy is to confuse the reader with "creative language".
Both relativities could be dispensed with by simply concluding that atomic oscillation appears to be correlated with gravity. While certainly "less subtle" than a relativistic interpretation, it would seem to much better satisfy Occam's razor.
« no universal global clock … each clock is specific to its frame of reference »
I do understand how it is supposed to work. To each their own universe.
« Newton's gravitational laws do not include Time at all »
So? Do you think you have to rely on what's given in "Newton's laws" to accept there is gravity and it is correlated with atomic oscillation?
Also, to whom it may concern, what's up with the downvotes on this thread? Childishness, pettiness, bigotry? What motivates such inane behaviour? You can post zillions of moronic one-liners on HN no problem, but once you put effort into a post, you risk downvotes, which personally I don't care about (the notion of "karma points" is somewhat hilarious), but the practical effect will be that very soon I'll have to register yet another account if I want to keep participating in the debate, because all my comments will be stillborn, invisible, and unreplyable. That's the way the HN software works.
« I Do Understand Relativity by Prof. Douglas Ross »
This is a 64 pages PDF. I didn't read the text (simply too much), but I searched the doc for what he had to say about clocks, especially atomic clocks. Clocks are mentioned quite a bit all through the text, but atomic clocks only twice, on pages 24 and 49. Without any detail, he simply suggests they observe and confirm "time dilation".
On page 24 he notes that an atomic clock aboard the so-called ISS space station "which travels at 7800 m/s (v/c ≈ 0.000026) […] gains 7 milliseconds every six months". However, to illustrate "time dilation" due to speed ("special relativity"), it would have been better for the clock to lose some milliseconds. So the example doesn't illustrate his case. He apparently didn't notice – which is no wonder as it is so easy to get confused and lost with this "relativity" business.
"time dilation" is something which can be seen relatively easy. One example is that muons can actually reach certain sensors even though they have a lifetime of only 2.2 microseconds: They shouldn't live long enough for that. However, when they move fast enough they manage to reach the detectors because of time dilation.
And if you didn't take into account both General Relativity and Special Relativity for GPS satellites then you would miscalculate the position by many kilometers.
The latest atomic clocks are so accurate that they measure time differently if two clocks are located mere centimeters (or even less) higher or lower relative to the ground, due to General Relativity (time passes more slowly in a stronger gravity field).
« can be seen relatively easy »
Okay, that muon thing sounds easy enough, will try as soon as I find my stopwatch…
Jokes aside, it seems that there is a notion that the operation of the atomic clock is time. That seems very strange to me. It's just an instrument, okay, an expensive one, but still.
So if that clock is so accurate on gravity is that what's used to measure the Earth's gravitational field to produce the Potsdam potato?
I have no idea what Potsdam is, but in any case - here's an article about the currently most accurate clock: https://phys.org/news/2026-09-scientists-world-accurate-atom...
Quote: "Optical atomic clocks at the 10-19 level are so precise they can detect the slowing of time caused by gravity over height differences of millimeters."
« what Potsdam is »
https://phys.org/news/2014-12-potsdam-gravity-potato-variati...
« the slowing of time »
The logic is clearly circular. They define time as some atomic oscillation that is subject to gravity ("Cesium atoms have set the global standard for time since the 1960s"), and then they claim gravity bends time because their measurement instrument uses that atomic oscillation.
And then, on top of that, they sideload a claim this would somehow prove "relativistic time dilation" b/o the theory of "speed of light absolutism" and "spacetime", which is however unrelated to the atomic oscillation (Einstein never referred to it), and does not seem proven at all.
It is you who are claiming that atomic oscillation is subject to gravity. What is the basis for this?
Atomic clocks also show different times if you put one on an airplane and the other at the airport, then you send the airplane away and back again. This is a simple test and has been done. Since then there are many others.
The first one (gravity) matches predictions in Einstein's General Relativity, the second one Einstein's Special Relativity.
As for defining time as "some atomic oscillation", what is the problem with that? How do you measure time? In the past we have used anything and everything which will move at a regular pace, including the pendulum clock I have at a wall here. The problem has always been that these things are sensitive to external forces, so pendulum clocks, while accurate at home, are useless at sea. Thus the invention of successful chronometers by John Harrison, using a mechanism which wouldn't be sensitive to the forces experienced at sea.
Since then the technology has been constantly improved, always with the goal of less and less sensitivity to external forces. Atomic clocks are used because, among other things, they are _not_ sensitive to e.g. gravity. However, they show that time moves differently in a gravity field, which is an entirely different issue.
« you … claiming that atomic oscillation is subject to gravity. What is the basis for this? »
That's what I understood from the article rramadass linked to and and which I quoted a whole paragraph from in 50550665, here's the relevant bit again:
« the clocks [travelling in orbit aboard the satellite] are noticeably farther away from the Earth – due to the less strong gravitational time dilation, they thus go somewhat faster than clocks of the same design on Earth. »
(So by moving away from the centre of gravity, we experience "negative time dilation", or perhaps more appropriately "time constriction", to stay in the metaphor.)
Did I misinterpret anything? Chatty seems to agree with the statement I quoted, when asked whether atomic oscillation is subject to gravity it replied:
« Yes. Gravity […] can very slightly affect its [the atom's] internal oscillation or transition frequency. For example, an atomic clock runs at a slightly different rate at different heights in a gravitational field—a gravitational redshift. »
You asked: « As for defining time as "some atomic oscillation", what is the problem with that? »
It is not necessarily a practical problem (given the amazing temporal resolution that it apparently affords), but substituting the operation of the clock with Time itself and then attributing the specifics of the clock operation to Time itself seems like flawed logic to me, blurring the distinction between the concept and some particular way of measurement.
Conclusions of conceptual or even (wrt Einstein's theories) clearly philosophical (and certainly debatable) nature are drawn from the fact that the operation of the clock is sensitive to gravity. That is a great finding and very interesting but I don't understand how it would constitute proof for "spacetime" or "time dilation".
« Atomic clocks […] are _not_ sensitive to e.g. gravity. »
In a previous comment on this thread, though, you said that they are, and you ascribed that effect to "General Relativity":
« The latest atomic clocks are so accurate that they measure time differently if two clocks are located mere centimeters (or even less) higher or lower relative to the ground »
However, when Einstein conceived his relativity theories (1905–15), he didn't refer to atomic oscillation at all. Perhaps it hadn't been discovered yet (Chatty says atomic clocks started only in 1949). Instead, Einstein went in a different direction, a philosophical direction involving speculative concepts such as "spacetime" and "time dilation".
There almost seems to be like an "urge" to align and unite the more philosophical Einstein stuff with the more modern and more technical stuff of atomic clocks, but to me it looks like there is just a mismatch between the two, and understanding would be much easier by keeping them strictly apart, and by contenting oneself with the amazing fact that gravity affects atomic oscillation, and by resisting the "urge" to draw physics into the more philosophical realm of "spacetime".
No, you're mixing things. Atomic clocks (or any clock, whatever mechanism) show that time progresses differently in different gravitational fields (and also speed related, see special relativity). But they don't tick differently because the tick rate is changed by gravity (or speed), the rate stays the same but _time_ changes, relative to other frames of reference. Time changes due to gravity, the oscillation does not. That's the whole point. If you place two people with one clock each, in very different gravity fields, and they could live for a very very long time, you would see not only that their clocks differ, but their _apparence_ differ: One is older than the other. Because time changes, not the mechanism of the clock.
« Atomic clocks (or any clock, whatever mechanism) show that time progresses differently in different gravitational fields »
The operation of hour glasses and water clocks will indeed be subject to gravity but for classical reasons (that would bury any "relativistic reasons"). Mechanical clocks and quartz crystal driven clocks won't. Chatty says these would show relativistic effects just like atomic clocks. The reason given is:
« The inference that the same effect applies to every physical process comes from the equivalence principle, which has itself been tested repeatedly, and from the fact that all clocks are physical systems existing in the same spacetime. »
Inclusion of "spacetime" here seems undue and circular as that has yet to be proven to exist as a physical object (and not only as a philosophical concept). And looking up "equivalence principle" in Wikipedia, I find as summary/definition: "Hypothesis that inertial and gravitational masses are equivalent". I find the inference Chatty gives unconvincing but I won't go further down what looks like a rabbit hole.
« the rate stays the same but _time_ changes »
That's just a claim that does double duty as premise and conclusion, which is circular logic. "Time changes relativistically" because Einstein said so, and "time is atomic oscillation" (because what's wrong with that?), hence the oscillation rate may stay the same, and if it looks like a speedup or a slowdown that's because "time changes relativistically" as Einstein had said (although, while he did know about atomic oscillation, he never referred to it in his relativity theories).
« two people … very long time, you would see … older than the other »
Not practically verifiable, and would at any rate be extremely fuzzy. (Works fine for sci-fi novels, though.)
It boils down for me to the conclusion that gravity and atomic oscillation are correlated. Previously I said that "gravity has an influence on atomic oscillation" (and maybe it does), but it turns out the situation around gravity in physics is not as clear as one might think (I just learnt it is conceptually wed to… :| "spacetime", of all things).
Gravity, after all, might not be that "weakest, by a very long shot, of the four fundamental forces, whose job it is to tie solar systems and galaxies together" as it is presented according to established science, but perhaps only an effect of electromagnetism – who knows.
« You can imagine that I look back on my life's work with calm satisfaction. But from nearby it looks quite different. There is not a single concept of which I am convinced that it will stand firm, and I feel uncertain whether I am in general on the right track. » — Albert Einstein, letter to Maurice Solovine, March 28, 1949
Also see The Greatest Speed, a soviet-era Mir book - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50542662
I remember some vsauce (i think) video about how we dont know for sure if speed of light is constant in all directions. As a limitation of measurement we can only measure its speed in a round trip.
i think you will find this interesting.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_exper...
It's not really possible to measure the time it takes light to move from point A to B. You can really only measure the time it takes for light to move from point A to B and back.
But you can do measure the difference between light going from point A to point B and light going from point A to point C to point B (and adding point C in the reverse direction as well) and I think you can use that to get reasonable confidence that light has constant speed in a given medium in all directions.
But this is totally relevant for trying to figure out asymmetric delivery delays in packet switched networks... You can't measure the delay directly, and if you use the network to synchronize your clocks, you can't use the clocks to measure the delay either, because most synchronization assumes symmetric delay. You need an externally synchronized clock, like a GPS reference etc.
Let's assume light goes faster in the "north" direction, and slower in the "south" direction.
Wouldn't the north- or south-component of the vectors to C cancel each other the same way they do when going from A–B vs. B–A? If the vector AB is on the north-south axis, and C is somewhere to the east, then the increase in speed from A–C–B would be offset by the decrease on the B–C–A return trip, giving you no information as to what direction is faster.
> It's not really possible to measure the time it takes light to move from point A to B. You can really only measure the time it takes for light to move from point A to B and back.
You absolutely can. Get two synchronized clocks, and start pulsing light at each tick. Then slowly move one clock away and observe how long it takes for the light pulse to arrive.
You don't even need crazy precision for that. A regular atomic clock would do.
Edit: if you didn't get the hint, that's exactly how GPS works.
Usually when people are introduced to the issue of measuring the one-way speed of light, one of the first ideas that comes to mind is exactly what you suggest, and it's a very good first thought, but of course it doesn't work since implicit in your approach is an assumption about what the one-way speed of light already is.
As you "slowly" move the two clocks away from one another, the two clocks will no longer be synchronized due to time dilation, and so you need to account for time dilation, but in order to account for time dilation you need to already know what the one-way speed of light is.
I put "slowly" in quotes because why would it possibly matter whether you move clocks slowly or quickly? It's the principle of the matter that is at issue, not the practicality.
> As you "slowly" move the two clocks away from one another, the two clocks will no longer be synchronized due to time dilation, and so you need to account for time dilation, but in order to account for time dilation you need to already know what the one-way speed of light is.
That's why I said "slowly" so that the effect of the time dilation can be kept negligible. If you insist that you MUST account for it, get an additional clock that you move at a different velocity. It'll provide you another data point for the system of equations that you can solve to get the "c" value.
You can measure velocity precisely without any reference to the speed of light by timing how long (according to the clock itself) it takes for it to traverse a given length.
To make it even more watertight, do the experiment in an inertial reference frame with pre-accelerated clocks. Launch two clocks with arbitrary but different velocities along a race track. At the start of the track you have the pulse source along with the reference clock, you synchronize with it as your moving clocks cross the starting line.
Then you measure how long it takes for each moving clock (according to its measurement!) to cross the finish line. This will provide you enough data to solve the equation for the time dilation.
I love your enthusiasm and I hope you enjoy the rabbit hole as much as I did when I went down it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-way_speed_of_light
This article has a stronger statement: that it's impossible to measure one-way the lightspeed without doing clock synchronization or assuming that the unit length stays the same regardless of the direction it's traversed.
So in my example, the measurement stick that I'm using to mark the race track, might theoretically have different lengths if traversed from south to north or from north to south.
And I believe that this experiment is still possible to do, although not in the special relativity. You need to traverse the same path in a gravity field and compare the accumulated time dilation. It will depend on the absolute distance travelled.
When you account for relativity, your idea wouldn't work. You assume that two synchronised clocks would remain synchronised after moving them apart from each other and that's almost certainly not true.
It's an interesting puzzle, but it looks to be impossible to measure the speed of light in one direction due to relativity and time/length dilation effects.
You may be thinking of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTn6Ewhb27k
Not just light, it's impossible to know if the speed of anything is constant in all directions. The so called one-way speed of an object depends on a synchronization convention used for clocks at different locations. Different conventions can produce different one-way speeds while leaving all other observable physical phenomena unchanged.
I don't think it's just a limitation of measurement. It's a fundamental limitation of the universe, there's no absolute time so there's no accurate time delta between different frames of reference.
So your time measurement can only be valid for you.
A fun corollary of this sort of relative timing is that a dude casually walking by you when you're sitting still will observe the Andromeda Galaxy with a several day time difference.
> will observe the Andromeda Galaxy with a several day time difference.
If you measure both distance and time, the observations will be near-identical. Likewise, the events observed will be near-identical (perhaps with some miniscule differences in observed event ordering). All that's really different is which parts of the distance are labelled as in space, and which are labelled as in time.
> A fun corollary...
I don't think this is quite correct, but I'm not positive myself.
You can't actually make any observations that are several days different from each other, even if you had a miraculous telescope that could see what the little aliens are doing.
You don't actually have any differing observations at all from the person walking next to you (apart from some trivial Doppler effect).
Rather, your frame of reference for what "right now" means in Andromeda differ. And this is not something that ever turns into an observable difference, even if you waited 2.5 million years for the light to get to you to see what the light looked like "right then" in Andromeda, because you'd just be arguing about when that previous "right then" was.
If I remember, Penrose uses this to talk about the nature of time and determinism.
If I'm wrong, feel free to correct me.
> If I'm wrong, feel free to correct me.
You're wrong, GPS needed a relativistic fix for this in software.
Measurements taken from positions within gravitational fields of the same strength, by observers moving and accelerating in sync (observing no change in distance between them), will be consistent.
I think.
If I walk by you, I observe a change in distance to you
> there's no accurate time delta between different frames of reference.
Yes there is. As I stated, if the frame of reference only differs by a fixed position, measurements will be equal.
Your example trivially violates that condition.
I expect we are actually in agreement.
While we cannot observe it because we lack an absolute frame of reference, we do know that the speed of light is constant in all directions due to the principle of super-position, provided the medium doesn't change between directions.
Not sure how superposition has any role in this. Sound waves also obey the principle of superposition but sound travels faster downwind than upwind, even though the medium is the same in both directions. So superposition clearly doesn't establish that wave propagation speeds must be identical in all directions.
Sound is a longitudinal wave, the medium velocity is additive to the wave's propagation. Light radiates i.e. it does not require a medium to propagate.
Both longitudinal and transverse waves obey the principle of superposition, yet superposition alone tells us nothing about whether propagation speed is the same in every direction. You're introducing additional properties of electromagnetic waves to justify a conclusion that you originally attributed to superposition.
Superposition has nothing to do with this and does not give any insight into whether the speed of light is the same in all directions.
That's not correct as it is not possible to measure the speed of light in a single direction, but only as a round-trip.
e.g. if light travelled twice as fast to the moon and half the speed from the moon to the earth, there would be no experiment that we could do that would determine that. All clocks and measurements would be the same as if light is constant in both directions.
However, logically we have no reason to think that light does change speed in different directions, so we assume that it's constant.
By the way, what is "the principle of super-position"?
IIRC it was a Veritasium video.
I remember that I thought the hypothesis makes little sense as we define distance as the time light takes to travel. It is the defining constant itself.
That is the current way of defining the meter. It's not the definitive definition of distance.
same argument can be applied to any speed measurement, so it's not actually something profane about light
it's essentially about time zones - you never can be sure that 2 clocks in different locations are in the same time displacement
If you can read Danish, there has recently been a publication of a comic book chronicling Rømer's life and his measurement of the speed of light: https://www.eudor.dk/shop-2/tegneserier/science-tegneserier/...
Nice. Just added to my wishlist for Christmas.
As a tangential question is there a book or resource that talks about such historical discoveries with details. Eratosthenes Measurement of Earth's circumference is another such awesome example. I'm sure history is full of such amazing discoveries but I'm unable to find a curated list of such important discoveries.
Not a book, but I'd recommend the YouTube collaboration between 3Blue1Brown and Terrence Tao on "The Cosmic Distance Ladder":
Part 1: https://youtu.be/YdOXS_9_P4U
Part 2: https://youtu.be/hFMaT9oRbs4
They start with Eritosthenes of course, and actually mention Rømer's discovery as an aside.
I very recently showed these videos to my father after a discussion on the topic, and while no physicist or mathematician he really enjoyed the watch! It's about an hour long from start to finish.
Eratosthenes' measurement is a great puzzle to give to a smart kid. A friend of mine set it to me when I was in my early 20s.
"With only the materials available to the ancient Greeks, you can figure out the circumference of the earth. How?", he asked me one day. I let my mind have at it – this was c.2000, pre-phone, so I had no choice but to just think about it.
Took me until early that morning, but when you get it, it's immensely satisfying. I won't spoil anything here.
That is really clever. At first reading it I'm thinking, "How could he..." then you realize... Jupiter far... Jupiter close... Orbits don't change timing... Light has speed... Of course!
Of possible interest
Universal Physical Constants
By Spiridonov
https://archive.org/details/UniversalPhysicalConstants/
You forgot the main book;
From the Science for Everyone series;
The Greatest Speed by S.Filonovich - https://archive.org/details/thegreatestspeed
Yes, Thanks for the link!
> the Muslim scientists Ibn al-Haytham
Recently featured in a MinutePhysics video!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5qYRfCnIITk
I used to watch MinutePhysics (a lot) years ago. I didn't know it's still active even now. Gonna watch that video soon.
Is there more about his personal life? He had two wifes, Anne Marie who was 16 when he married her at 36 (in 1780), and Else Magdalene who was 19 when he married her at 55 (in 1799). He was also the Second Chief of Police in Copenhagen. It was a very different time, and I'd like to know more.
> Other philosophers and scientists had previously theorised that light has a finite speed, including the Greek philosopher Empedocles, the Muslim scientists Ibn al-Haytham and Abu Rayhan al-Biruni, and the English philosopher and natural scientist Roger Bacon, according to Wikipedia.
Why are two Arabic scientists identified by their religion? Yet Roger Bacon is "English" rather than "Christian?" Roger Bacon was deeply involved with religion as Franciscan friar!
Anyone with an Arabic name is Muslim first now, evidently.
Readers of a Norwegian science publication will typically be more familiar with Europe than the Middle East, and where there is familiarity there is meaningfully more room for distinction. If I'm talking about where I'm from to a fellow Canadian, I'll say the name of the city I live in. If I'm having the same conversation with someone from elsewhere I'd just tell them I'm from Canada.
In general you can safely assume that readers of a Norwegian science publication are quite familiar with the Middle East.
kazinator evidently isn't, he thinks al-Biruni is Arabic!
If I were authoring that, I'd dig into it more and get it right.
Some of those individuals are Persian or possibly Persian, so I think the article just says “Muslim” to hedge around uncertainty or getting too precise for the reader
Biruni wasn't Arabic, but Persian (or Khwaresmian, depending on how you set the boundaries), and he was born and lived in Central Asia. Calling him Arabic is like calling Roger Bacon "Germanic".
Al Khaytam was born in Arabic family, not Persian.
So the common denominator for them is the Islamic scientific community.
Roger Bacon live in medieval England so he is "English". If he lived before England existed as a concept, he probably would be described as a "Christian".
HN should probably just blanket ban the word "this" in submission titles
I think HN's automatic title mangling is bad enough already. Clarity and avoiding clickbait is probably enough.
Even light, which travels so fast it takes most races thousands of years to realize that it travels at all, takes time to journey between the stars.
~Douglas Adams
Bad news, however, travels far faster. Maybe instantaneously.
Ridiculons[1] travels faster than the speed of light, so not unlikely bad news does too.
[1]: https://gist.github.com/pmarreck/7092d28f3d9bf8dff99faa61d01...
Yuk, please don't sully Adam's quotes with GenAI nonsense
Oh wow, completely missed that bit. That was not the intention.
Sadly, Google has locked away the original it seems behind sign-up bars. I have the original somewhere, guess I'll have to put it somewhere public.
Back on my desktop I finally found the link I was searching for, the proper newsgroup post:
https://groups.google.com/g/sci.nanotech/c/QlsQPORilE8
Sorry about the previous sloppified link.
Terence Tao on Ole Rømer’s discovery in relation to the cosmic distance ladder in a 3blue1brown video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hFMaT9oRbs4&t=450s
Rømer is also the author of the namesake temperature scale which was a source of inspiration for Farenheit's creation.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%C3%B8mer_scale
Though impressive, I am more impressed that they had a clock that accurate at the time and also knew the distance between the planets. To me those are intrinsically related.
It always amazes me how close people like him or Eratosthenes got to the actual values.
after the third popup i just bailed
Firefox and ublock origin are life savers.
Soon (if not already) it'll be that and "is this generated slop."
I wonder if we'll see a resurgence of "web of trust" stuff.
The way I came to understand the speed of light, it is not so much that it is finite, but more so that time slows down the nearer you get and stops at light speed.
This means that going faster than light entails time travel into the past. While going just at the speed of light means you can travel any distance in exactly zero seconds. It's just that time passes for your surroundings.
This is a subtle misunderstanding. As you approach the speed of light, physical processes including clocks or other time measuring devices appear to slow down relative to an observer. Exceeding the speed of light, at least as a conceptual generalization, doesn't mean that you end up going back in time and experiencing past events like Back to the Future, rather it would allow for future events to influence the outcome of past events, what is called retrocausality [1].
Retrocausality is not the same as time travel. With time travel it's as if you get to go back in time and reexperience things that happened in the past, which is not what faster than light travel implies. Retrocausality is more about things happening in the present that are influenced by future events, as opposed to causality where only past events can influence the outcome of future events.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retrocausality
It is just we are not able to comprehend it until someone pointed it out.
>Journal des sçavans
Nowadays it's written savants.
According to [0], the journal has changed names twice, so "Journal des savants" would be referencing the modern journal that used to be called "Journal des sçavans"
[0] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journal_des_savants