akersten 5 days ago

Their sample prompt takes me back a year or two:

> Find unused code in our web app. Exclude generated files and test fixtures, and check for indirect references before recommending a removal.

If I "/goal remove unused code" in Claude today, I would not even think to specify "check for indirect references" and "don't consider generated code dead code," those sorts of intuitions have been "built in" to the frontier models for a while now.

So I'm pretty confused by this, what does it do that I can't with an agent swarm?

NBJack 4 days ago

Yep, we've been doing this "agenticly" at my job for a while now. I can't say the results are often impressive, particularly if you underspecify what you actually want.

Sheeny96 4 days ago

> Improve SEO

> Reduce maintenance overhead

> Make your application compile faster

> Find unused code in our web app. Exclude generated files and test fixtures, and check for indirect references before recommending a removal.

If someone came to me with these requirements, I would laugh in their face. These reek of busy work with no actual business benefit. Have these people actually built real software before?

  • mytydev 4 days ago

    I would categorize these all as grunt work, but definitely not busywork or even a lack of business value. Improving SEO has direct business value. And the fact that it's unglamorous and laborious feels like a really good reason to have agents do it.

  • ksjckejdkw 4 days ago

    Have you actually built real software before?

    In what world does improving SEO, reducing maintenance overhead and faster compile times not provide any actual business benefit?

    > If someone came to me with these requirements, I would laugh in their face.

    My god the arrogance is almost tangible. Maybe tone down the greybeard act a bit, yeah? No one’s buying it.

v3ss0n 5 days ago

just another prompt right?

  • dudus 5 days ago

    With a forloop

  • fakeBeerDrinker 5 days ago

    Yeah, but now with “agentic mapreduce”! A “talent dense” team of prompters selling to the Feds.

    • v3ss0n 4 days ago

      which ai come up with that buzzword lol